Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

30 hours free childcare- means tested?!

236 replies

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 22:47

Sure I will get blasted, but I only just realised that the 30hr free childcare is means tested. I have paid full price for my child for past 2 years- at a whopping £1240 a month, but it is what it is.

Selfishly, i was so looking forward to her turning 3 and getting the free hours. Would be a massive help with mortgage going up. However I don't qualify. And it is not a sliding scale, I don't qualify for anything. So I would actually be better off reducing hours so I would qualify for the free hours- in what world should that be the case?! Makes no sense to me!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
ginandtonicwithlimes · 15/11/2023 17:32

thingineme · 15/11/2023 16:52

I have no real understanding of the benefits system so I have no idea how it works but from personal experience it does seem to pay well for people that have zero intentions of ever working while other are working multiple jobs to make ends meet.

But op I do agree that it is a strange set up
When you'd be 'rewarded' for working less but unfortunately I know so many who have this worked out to a tee. My neighbour is on benefits and receives pip and I swear she is rolling in it in with her lip filllers, Botox, hair extensions, never ending Uber eats and shopping trips. All I can do is get on with it. Thankfully I enjoy my job

Things have changed if you were to read up on UC.

PepeLePugh · 15/11/2023 17:31

I understand that I will get very little sympathy for my situation, however I appreciate how you are feeling OP.

My partner earns over £100k and I know we are very fortunate however I earn £30k and the sums don't work for me going back to work due to nursery costs. I wouldn't exactly say I love my job but I have worked hard all of my life to get to the position I am at work and I work in in an industry that is in desperate need of staff. I am now sacrificing my career, pension etc. due to what my partner earns. I feel like I don't matter in the eyes of the government when I could (and should!) be working hard and contributing.

What smarts for me is that we are hit by an effective 60% tax rate and now we don't have my income to support us, yet 2 people on £99k a year still get all of it. It smarts even more with the new childcare funding to be internet as we would get nothing. We pay more into the system and yet don't qualify for even the tax-free childcare which just help us enough that me working would make sense. We live in the SE where our money gets us a modest lifestyle with a two bed house and a holiday in the UK once a year. I am very grateful for the life I have but we are hardly living it large with champagne for breakfast!

thingineme · 15/11/2023 16:52

I have no real understanding of the benefits system so I have no idea how it works but from personal experience it does seem to pay well for people that have zero intentions of ever working while other are working multiple jobs to make ends meet.

But op I do agree that it is a strange set up
When you'd be 'rewarded' for working less but unfortunately I know so many who have this worked out to a tee. My neighbour is on benefits and receives pip and I swear she is rolling in it in with her lip filllers, Botox, hair extensions, never ending Uber eats and shopping trips. All I can do is get on with it. Thankfully I enjoy my job

poorlypoppet · 15/11/2023 15:59

threeisquiteenough · 15/11/2023 15:43

I think this can still be the case.

In my area, I will move my child from private nursery to state school nursery. As wrap around care is already being paid for with older child, this is not additional cost. Net, will completely remove the full time nursery fee.

Separately, when hit over 100k, you don't receive the tax free vouchers, your tax free allowance is lessened. So, by reducing hours, it can easily be that you are better off in terms of overall money. As PP mentioned, it is common for people to then plow some extra money into pension to get around this as the net adjusted incomes arrives at just under £100k (childcare vouchers back; higher personal allowance AND 30hrs funding in the state school).

This.

It isn't as simple as 'day rate must be more than nursery fees'. At £100K you tip over the cliff edge for multiple financial thresholds:

  • Tax free childcare no longer available
  • 30 hours free reduced to 15 hours only
  • Lose your tax free personal allowance (meaning you pay tax at 60% on earnings over £100K to £125k, plus NI etc.)

Together, those cliff edges actually mean the net money you recieve in your pocket (in this case, after paying childcare fees and the tax) is tiny. The marginal rate means you're actually having about 90+% 'deducted' and so for each £1 over £100K you earn, you barely see 10p from it.

This website explains it much better https://wingatefp.com/the-loss-of-free-childcare-a-97-marginal-rate-of-tax/

When people talk of being better off working less hours - its usually relating to the fact that after £100K and loss of the childcare hours and increased tax rate, you end up working 'for free'. Might as well reduce hours and get the same amount of money in your pocket, but with the benefit of more free-time (or less childcare costs, as you can then reduce childcare reliance).

Photo by Arthur Ogleznev from Pexels

The Loss Of Free Childcare: A 97% Marginal Rate Of Tax • Wingate Financial Planning

Over the years the Government have made changes to help individuals pay for childcare. The latest scheme offers up to £2,000 of Government funding on up to

https://wingatefp.com/the-loss-of-free-childcare-a-97-marginal-rate-of-tax

threeisquiteenough · 15/11/2023 15:43

Mazuslongtoenail · 15/11/2023 13:08

I don’t understand how you’re better off going part time? If you warn over 100k your daily rate must be over £400, take home £200+. How much is your nursery per day?

I think this can still be the case.

In my area, I will move my child from private nursery to state school nursery. As wrap around care is already being paid for with older child, this is not additional cost. Net, will completely remove the full time nursery fee.

Separately, when hit over 100k, you don't receive the tax free vouchers, your tax free allowance is lessened. So, by reducing hours, it can easily be that you are better off in terms of overall money. As PP mentioned, it is common for people to then plow some extra money into pension to get around this as the net adjusted incomes arrives at just under £100k (childcare vouchers back; higher personal allowance AND 30hrs funding in the state school).

OCDmama · 15/11/2023 15:36

Load of mumsnetters not seeing beyond the end of their own noses here.

I agree OP. Let's lay out the scenario. Nuclear family, DF earns £100k, DM £20k. They consequently make the decision in light of receiving no child benefit and free hours they can't claim anywhere that the mother will give up work til the kids are older, as all her money is being spent on childcare.

She's now completely dependent on him financially. No independent income.

Say she does go back to work when youngest is in ft school, she can't get a job doing what she was previously in her field owing to fast paced nature/changes and lack of CPD, or at previous seniority. She takes a major career hit. Bugger.

Then let's say her 'D'H fucks off. She hasn't been paying into a private pension for these years, he can afford a great lawyer, and now she's on her own with the kids and no/a shit career. Completely fucked.

But yeah all these greedy bitches her? Trying to protect themselves, who do they think they are....

MargotBamborough · 15/11/2023 14:25

SALWARP2023 · 15/11/2023 13:38

During the 1980s very little child care was available and it all had to be paid for in full. No free care. My area had only one nursery in 10 mile radius. No universal credit. If you needed more money you got more hours. No minimum wage or legal right to annual leave. Please stop complaining millennials!

Do you wanna talk about house price inflation then? Or tuition fees maybe?

SALWARP2023 · 15/11/2023 13:38

During the 1980s very little child care was available and it all had to be paid for in full. No free care. My area had only one nursery in 10 mile radius. No universal credit. If you needed more money you got more hours. No minimum wage or legal right to annual leave. Please stop complaining millennials!

Fupoffyagrasshole · 15/11/2023 13:36

my kids full time nursery with 15 hours is £1,707.57

But by us working a day less each and getting the 30 hours - we only pay £654 a month to the nursery! and we can also use tax free childcare bringing the fee's down again - it's a big difference

hookiewookie29 · 15/11/2023 13:24

They're not free hours, they're funded. Most parents will HAVE to pay some sort of contribution towards the 30 hours because the funding doesn't cover the hourly rate of childcare settings.
Be grateful you're getting anything. When my kids were born, there were no funded hours or tax credits- all I got was child benefit.

nutbrownhare15 · 15/11/2023 13:13

So how rich do you think someone should be before the government stops subsidising their childcare OP? I'd say 100k is about right, especially when you can offset your pension

Mazuslongtoenail · 15/11/2023 13:08

I don’t understand how you’re better off going part time? If you warn over 100k your daily rate must be over £400, take home £200+. How much is your nursery per day?

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 13:03

We'd be financially better off on benefits but dh wants to work to help his self esteem.

Have you had a benefits check recently? If he earns an amount that is less than you'd get on benefits chances are you'd get a top up- things have changed with UC.

Fupoffyagrasshole · 15/11/2023 12:57

makes better financial sense for husband and I to both work a 4 day week and only send daughter to nursery 3 days a week and it takes us both down below the 100k - so i would just look into all options - if you can work less i'd just do that :)

MargotBamborough · 15/11/2023 12:43

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 15/11/2023 12:34

Honestly I think anybody earning over £100k who complains about not having childcare paid for has an absolute piece of cheek.
I'd rather the government focus on funding for those who NEED it, not those who just WANT it.

I don't have children, so I've got no skin in the game either.

Honestly I think anyone paying little or no taxes objecting to people who pay huge amounts of taxes and actually do subsidise everyone else being able to qualify for the free hours everyone else is getting has an absolute piece of cheek.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 15/11/2023 12:41

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 12:38

Oh my God, THIS is what I’m talking about. You have a household income of close to a quarter of a million a year, and four children in private school hit you are still groping about the fact you can’t enjoy the same “perks” as someone on £25k and much less privilege?

The social welfare system is not a “perk”.

neither is it a savings account you get to dip into just because you’ve put into it

Unbelievable

Yet doesn't even want to use any of those services all her taxes pay for all because they are all "shit".

MargotBamborough · 15/11/2023 12:41

myotherkidisacassowary · 15/11/2023 12:31

It’s not that I particularly disagree with you in principle, but you earn so much money that I just don’t really care. You’re not hard up, you’re more fortunate than the overwhelming majority of people in this country, it just doesn’t bother me that this incentivises you to work less.

But if the OP reduced her hours so she both paid less tax and qualified for the 30 free hours, there would be less money in the pot for everyone. It doesn't make sense to disincentivise people from earning more money.

AnotherEmma · 15/11/2023 12:38

carpool · 15/11/2023 00:03

Also don't get 30 hours if one parent isn't working even if that is because they can't because of health problems. I know a family in this situation and those health problems also impact the ability to be a SAHP (therefore they need the 30 hours childcare) and they don't qualify for any benefits either because their partner earns too much (although nothing like the OP). There are always winners and losers in any system unfortunately not sure how it can be made to be fair to everyone.

The parent with health problems should be able to claim new-style ESA (if they don't have enough NI contributions it would be a "credits only" claim) and they should then be eligible for TFC and 30h free childcare.

If you are not currently working
You may still be eligible if your partner is working, and you get Incapacity Benefit, Severe Disablement Allowance, Carer’s Allowance, Limited Capability for Work Benefit or contribution-based Employment and Support Allowance.
(from https://www.gov.uk/30-hours-free-childcare)

30 hours free childcare

Who is eligible for 30 hours free childcare and how you can get it.

https://www.gov.uk/30-hours-free-childcare

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 12:38

DinoDaddy · 15/11/2023 09:15

We both earn over 100k so we didn't get this either. Takes the piss a bit as we pay so much tax and then our children can't even benefit from any perks we pay towards. But, we have 4 in private school now, nursery fees are a drop in the ocean compared to that.

Oh my God, THIS is what I’m talking about. You have a household income of close to a quarter of a million a year, and four children in private school hit you are still groping about the fact you can’t enjoy the same “perks” as someone on £25k and much less privilege?

The social welfare system is not a “perk”.

neither is it a savings account you get to dip into just because you’ve put into it

Unbelievable

elliejjtiny · 15/11/2023 12:35

I think it should be based on household income rather than individual income. I think it's fairer that way.

I do think complaining that you don't get 30 hours funded childcare because you earn over 100k is a bit much though. Our dc are older now but my youngest was at nursery when they introduced the 30 funded hours. We didn't qualify because my dh doesn't earn enough. Although the preschool ds went to was only open for 15 hours a week anyway. There are a lot of unfair things in the system. Like our household income is 8k a year so we earn too much for free school meals. We'd be financially better off on benefits but dh wants to work to help his self esteem.

jupitermonket · 15/11/2023 12:35

edgeware · 15/11/2023 12:04

I agree with you. Why on earth should some of us pay more into the system but get less.

Because you need it less.

Same thing for people who need to NHS more, or disability provisions, or anything else from the welfare system. Those who need it more, need it more than you.

Thanks for your service.

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 15/11/2023 12:34

Honestly I think anybody earning over £100k who complains about not having childcare paid for has an absolute piece of cheek.
I'd rather the government focus on funding for those who NEED it, not those who just WANT it.

I don't have children, so I've got no skin in the game either.

myotherkidisacassowary · 15/11/2023 12:31

It’s not that I particularly disagree with you in principle, but you earn so much money that I just don’t really care. You’re not hard up, you’re more fortunate than the overwhelming majority of people in this country, it just doesn’t bother me that this incentivises you to work less.

TrashedSofa · 15/11/2023 12:25

I wonder why the funding does have to stop at some point, really. We do have some entitlements that aren't income based anyway, so clearly its not something we qs a society avoid on principle. As as a left winger who supports broad societal provision, I worry about higher earners withdrawing their support if they don't feel they get enough out of it. Certainly I'm far from convinced that the savings are worth the risk, especially when we have people who'd literally be costing themselves money if they take that promotion or do the extra shift.

supercalifragilistic123 · 15/11/2023 12:21

I don't think it's subsidising low earners. It's just normal people with normal jobs.
We can't all earn 100k +

We have a joint income of about 60k. Which I think is actually a very standard family income. We both have key worker (I hate that term!) Jobs. Somebody has to do those roles. Neither of us were furloughed.

We were very grateful for the 30 hrs. Childcare is prohibitively expensive.

I understand the funding has to stop at some point. I couldn't even imagine earning close to salaries talked about. I know you pay a huge amount of tax, but it's still many times my salary.

I have no problem with people being successful! but I think it's a bit much expecting help with childcare when you are earning such a huge amount of money.