Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

30 hours free childcare- means tested?!

236 replies

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 22:47

Sure I will get blasted, but I only just realised that the 30hr free childcare is means tested. I have paid full price for my child for past 2 years- at a whopping £1240 a month, but it is what it is.

Selfishly, i was so looking forward to her turning 3 and getting the free hours. Would be a massive help with mortgage going up. However I don't qualify. And it is not a sliding scale, I don't qualify for anything. So I would actually be better off reducing hours so I would qualify for the free hours- in what world should that be the case?! Makes no sense to me!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:36

@SecondUsername4me

Sure, but the other parent may well be earning an average wage.

Say they earn £30,000. This is £1,915 a month take home.

This means your childcare is 206% of
that parents wage. Which, inevitably, means that parent probably stops working.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 10:32

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:16

I agree OP.

The cost of childcare is a challenge for parent on even quite high incomes - and, as you say, if you’re paying a lot of tax I think you should probably have access to the services you are funding.

For context for a three year old (15 free hours) and a one year old at my local nursery:

  • £2,200 for the baby
  • £1,750 for the three year old (Inc 15 hours)

Thats £3,950 a month.

The take home on £100k a year Inc student loan is £4,792 a month.

This means the childcare is 82% of a £100k wage.

It creates an effective 100% tax rate between about £100-150k for those with two children.

But if you need this much childcare then surely the household has 2x working parents (so the income is higher than 100k)?

Tryingtohelp12 · 17/11/2023 10:31

I understand your frustration (even though I do get the hours as we don’t earn the amount), we’re not entitled to child benefit. It does rather feel like the cut offs are plucked randomly out of thin air and not regularly reassessed in line with COL.

you need to sit down and do the maths to work out what is finacially better for you. Exactly the same way my cousin (and many other people I know) who have calculated that their best financial option is to work 16 hours, add universal credit and other benefits totals more than they have the potential to earn (they would only gain employment in what is considered low skilled roles. That’s not me saying they are low skilled roles -carers and admin roles are incredibly undervalued/underpaid.) once you’ve done the maths work out what makes the most sense for your family. I am about to have my third and when I return to work will just do school hours as the cost for wrap around for my older 2, plus extended long days for my 3rd I wouldn’t earn enough to cover/make working worth it. Ie I can work 6 hours and pay less childcare, or work 7.5 hours and pay more childcare. My take home would be about the same. So work out the maths and make a decision from there!

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:16

I agree OP.

The cost of childcare is a challenge for parent on even quite high incomes - and, as you say, if you’re paying a lot of tax I think you should probably have access to the services you are funding.

For context for a three year old (15 free hours) and a one year old at my local nursery:

  • £2,200 for the baby
  • £1,750 for the three year old (Inc 15 hours)

Thats £3,950 a month.

The take home on £100k a year Inc student loan is £4,792 a month.

This means the childcare is 82% of a £100k wage.

It creates an effective 100% tax rate between about £100-150k for those with two children.

TrashedSofa · 17/11/2023 10:07

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 09:58

If someone earns 101k then surely they just put a smidge more in their pension to bring them under the cap?

And that's from someone who earns a third of that Grin

I think it often depends whether earning the 101k involves any extra work or not. If you were going to get it regardless, maybe a cost of living raise or whatever, it would make most sense to increase pension contributions. If however it involves working an extra few shifts, that raises the question of whether it's worth bothering or not.

This is how we've dealt with it in our house when facing bottlenecks lower down the income spectrum- don't think the 100k one is ever going to be an issue for us haha! If the extra money is automatic, of course you take it and just adjust pension accordingly. If you have to do something extra to get it, you do the calculation about whether it's worth the effort. In my case I decided it wasn't.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 09:58

If someone earns 101k then surely they just put a smidge more in their pension to bring them under the cap?

And that's from someone who earns a third of that Grin

TrashedSofa · 17/11/2023 09:50

Perhaps a better way to put it would be penalised for working more, rather than working hard. Because it doesn't especially matter whether the person is working hard or swinging the lead as they do whatever it is that takes them from £99.9k to 101k. The outcome financially is still the same. And therefore it acts as a potential disincentive for someone to do a thing that leads to paying more into the system.

PepeLePugh · 17/11/2023 09:40

Beezknees · 17/11/2023 07:12

Ah, the old "penalised for working hard" tripe.

You are not being penalised for working hard. You can afford childcare without help.

The people who are penalised for working hard are the nurses, teachers, carers, labourers and so on, who get crap pay for what they actually do.

But this argument doesn't work with our tax system. Someone earning £101k takes home less (due to the 60% tax rate) in their pay packet each month than someone on £99k, yet the £99k person apparently cannot afford childcare but the £101k person can.

Add to this that you can be in a situation where a household with 2 people earning £99k are entitled to all of the support but a household where 1 person earns £101k and the other earning £25k will get nothing until the child is 3. The consequence of this is that the person earning £25k will quit work as childcare costs more than they earn. This person on £25k may well be a nurse, carer, labourer etc. and they are now out of the system and not contributing any tax.

For clarity, I am referring to the new childcare funding in this post and not the 15/30 hours entitlement at 3.

PepeLePugh · 17/11/2023 09:30

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 07:09

then have a couple where one doesn't work and the other earns £101k and they don't qualify

If one of them doesn't work, why do they need subsidised 30 hours childcare? Surely the 15hrs every one gets is enough?

The other doesn't work because the cost of sending the child to nursery is more than they would earn and therefore they give up work.

A full time nursery place for under 3's where I live is £1850 a month. Someone would need to earn £27k just to break even with childcare costs.

Beezknees · 17/11/2023 07:12

Ah, the old "penalised for working hard" tripe.

You are not being penalised for working hard. You can afford childcare without help.

The people who are penalised for working hard are the nurses, teachers, carers, labourers and so on, who get crap pay for what they actually do.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 07:09

then have a couple where one doesn't work and the other earns £101k and they don't qualify

If one of them doesn't work, why do they need subsidised 30 hours childcare? Surely the 15hrs every one gets is enough?

MargotBamborough · 17/11/2023 07:06

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 16/11/2023 22:42

Except that isn't what I said. I responded to another poster which said people should be entitled to take something back from the state for paying higher taxes. D

I don't dislike this group. I'm in this group (incidentally, nowhere near London for whoever claimed you can only earn that sort of salary in the city). I dislike the attitude of people who just do not need government support crying that they don't get it whilst other people who do need it do.

I agree that it would be more sensible to take household income as a whole. But I'll never agree that somebody earning in excess of £100k should receive government support because they chose to buy a big house.

Well then earning 100k and living nowhere near London makes you exceptionally privileged then, doesn't it? Perhaps you should walk a mile in someone else's shoes.

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 16/11/2023 22:42

threeisquiteenough · 16/11/2023 19:54

@StrictlyComeSnoozing , why do you assume high earners are 'entitled'? Don't get me wrong, of course there are many entitled people in this world, high earners or not. Just don't understand your apparent dislike of this group just because they earn.

Most people I know that earn in this bracket work exceptionally hard and make a lot of sacrifices to enable it

Except that isn't what I said. I responded to another poster which said people should be entitled to take something back from the state for paying higher taxes. D

I don't dislike this group. I'm in this group (incidentally, nowhere near London for whoever claimed you can only earn that sort of salary in the city). I dislike the attitude of people who just do not need government support crying that they don't get it whilst other people who do need it do.

I agree that it would be more sensible to take household income as a whole. But I'll never agree that somebody earning in excess of £100k should receive government support because they chose to buy a big house.

daffodilandtulip · 16/11/2023 20:44

MummyMumMumMummy · 16/11/2023 13:46

I find it more annoying that those who don’t work/work barely any hours gets 15 free hours.. but if you work full time you don’t qualify until their 3 😅 it’s all good and we’ll giving us 30 hours, but how do I afford to work and pay childcare until then? It all seems to backwards to me.

It's not about childcare, it's about education. These children often can't talk, have never seen another child, might not even have books or hot meals at home.

TheSeasonalNameChange · 16/11/2023 20:40

@MargotBamborough just for extra fun, they could all downsize to a cheaper area to reduce the mortgage and be moaned at for taking the cheaper houses from the local people who actually need them and now can't afford to live where they want to

threeisquiteenough · 16/11/2023 19:54

@StrictlyComeSnoozing , why do you assume high earners are 'entitled'? Don't get me wrong, of course there are many entitled people in this world, high earners or not. Just don't understand your apparent dislike of this group just because they earn.

Most people I know that earn in this bracket work exceptionally hard and make a lot of sacrifices to enable it

MargotBamborough · 16/11/2023 19:04

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 16/11/2023 14:54

Health care as a universal provision is not the same as childcare and wanting help because your mortgage payments are large as you've firstly chosen to have a child and secondly chosen to purchase a home for whatever price with mortgage payments to suit. You didn't choose to be born, or to need medical attention.

But as you point out, high earners can indeed fill their entitled boots with healthcare provision which is free at the point of use. I imagine they do things like drive on the motorways and if they choose to can access state schooling. So it's rather disingenuous to claim they receive nothing.

This argument about choosing a large mortgage is so dumb.

If you're earning over 100k then it's highly likely that you need to live within easy commuting distance of central London and if you have a child then you need at least two bedrooms.

For the people you are talking about to get a smaller mortgage they'd need to move to a cheaper part of the country which would probably involve getting a less well paid job which would mean paying less tax!

And it's probably not a great idea to disincentivise intelligent, hard working, high earning people from having children either.

PepeLePugh · 16/11/2023 15:02

Higher earners should contribute more in tax, however we should also have a tax system that ensures the more your salary is, the more you get in your bank account each month. We don't currently have this and those creeping into the £100k pay bracket have less in their pay packets than those just under £100k due to the effective 60% tax rate. This does not incentivise hard work. Add to this the cliff edge of no help with childcare costs after £100k then it seems like a double whammy.

I don't think those over £100k should get the full 30 hours, however either 15 hours or access to the tax-free childcare scheme would significantly help until you reach the £130k where tax evens out again.

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 16/11/2023 14:55

MummyMumMumMummy · 16/11/2023 13:46

I find it more annoying that those who don’t work/work barely any hours gets 15 free hours.. but if you work full time you don’t qualify until their 3 😅 it’s all good and we’ll giving us 30 hours, but how do I afford to work and pay childcare until then? It all seems to backwards to me.

Because the 15 hours provision before 3yo isn't for the benefit of the parents, it is for the benefit of the child based on countless studies into child development and how this is impacted negatively by different variables.

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 16/11/2023 14:54

MargotBamborough · 16/11/2023 13:40

It's all part of the social contract though, isn't it?

If you have high earnings and you pay a large amount of taxes, you accept that you are subsidising people who don't contribute much, if anything, to the pot.

But you shouldn't be simultaneously the person contributing the most to the pot and the person who is excluded from accessing the societal benefits that the pot pays for.

What's next? Telling high earners they're not entitled to NHS treatment because they can afford to pay to go private?

This is how you breed resentment, and this is how you cause a brain drain.

And no, I don't think "poor people" are being cheeky.

Edited

Health care as a universal provision is not the same as childcare and wanting help because your mortgage payments are large as you've firstly chosen to have a child and secondly chosen to purchase a home for whatever price with mortgage payments to suit. You didn't choose to be born, or to need medical attention.

But as you point out, high earners can indeed fill their entitled boots with healthcare provision which is free at the point of use. I imagine they do things like drive on the motorways and if they choose to can access state schooling. So it's rather disingenuous to claim they receive nothing.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 16/11/2023 14:42

MummyMumMumMummy · 16/11/2023 13:46

I find it more annoying that those who don’t work/work barely any hours gets 15 free hours.. but if you work full time you don’t qualify until their 3 😅 it’s all good and we’ll giving us 30 hours, but how do I afford to work and pay childcare until then? It all seems to backwards to me.

Jealous of those on incomes less than this?
(universal credit is less than £15,400).

30 hours free childcare- means tested?!
MummyMumMumMummy · 16/11/2023 13:46

I find it more annoying that those who don’t work/work barely any hours gets 15 free hours.. but if you work full time you don’t qualify until their 3 😅 it’s all good and we’ll giving us 30 hours, but how do I afford to work and pay childcare until then? It all seems to backwards to me.

MargotBamborough · 16/11/2023 13:40

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 16/11/2023 13:15

So you think poor people are just being cheeky?

I pay an absolute fuck tonne of tax and I'm all for a society that supports and helps those who need it. Paying tax isn't like an investment portfolio or a Christmas savings club. You don't get something just because you paid in.

It's all part of the social contract though, isn't it?

If you have high earnings and you pay a large amount of taxes, you accept that you are subsidising people who don't contribute much, if anything, to the pot.

But you shouldn't be simultaneously the person contributing the most to the pot and the person who is excluded from accessing the societal benefits that the pot pays for.

What's next? Telling high earners they're not entitled to NHS treatment because they can afford to pay to go private?

This is how you breed resentment, and this is how you cause a brain drain.

And no, I don't think "poor people" are being cheeky.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 16/11/2023 13:39

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 16/11/2023 13:15

So you think poor people are just being cheeky?

I pay an absolute fuck tonne of tax and I'm all for a society that supports and helps those who need it. Paying tax isn't like an investment portfolio or a Christmas savings club. You don't get something just because you paid in.

Obviously some sense of moral superiority complex and a sense of smugness going by posts on here. Maybe we should throw a medal in?

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 16/11/2023 13:15

MargotBamborough · 15/11/2023 12:43

Honestly I think anyone paying little or no taxes objecting to people who pay huge amounts of taxes and actually do subsidise everyone else being able to qualify for the free hours everyone else is getting has an absolute piece of cheek.

So you think poor people are just being cheeky?

I pay an absolute fuck tonne of tax and I'm all for a society that supports and helps those who need it. Paying tax isn't like an investment portfolio or a Christmas savings club. You don't get something just because you paid in.