Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

30 hours free childcare- means tested?!

236 replies

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 22:47

Sure I will get blasted, but I only just realised that the 30hr free childcare is means tested. I have paid full price for my child for past 2 years- at a whopping £1240 a month, but it is what it is.

Selfishly, i was so looking forward to her turning 3 and getting the free hours. Would be a massive help with mortgage going up. However I don't qualify. And it is not a sliding scale, I don't qualify for anything. So I would actually be better off reducing hours so I would qualify for the free hours- in what world should that be the case?! Makes no sense to me!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TeaKitten · 17/11/2023 12:47

mummabubs · 17/11/2023 12:40

We're in the same situation for child benefit. My DH earns literally just over the threshold, whereas I'm on £23k pa, but because of his salary alone we no longer qualify for child benefit, which was genuinely a noticeable support for us each month. Feels like this system penalises women- who are often the ones a) claiming the child benefit and b) earning less due to career breaks/ part time working associated with having children. It does sting a bit that some of our friends who have a combined income of just under £100k can still claim full child benefit.

If it’s so close then youl still get some child benefit anyway. And he can put a bit extra into pension to take it under.

mummabubs · 17/11/2023 12:40

QueenOfWeeds · 14/11/2023 23:01

I agree that this is not the place for you to find a sympathetic audience. What I find ridiculous is that it is tested per adult, not per household. DH just edges over the threshold so, despite my poorly paid, public service job, we don’t qualify. Fine. But we have friends where both people in the couple earn just below the threshold so, despite their household income being £50-80K higher than ours, they are able to claim free hours. It absolutely should be there for people who need it, but in some of the households we know, they definitely don’t need it - it just enables them to have a slightly easier lifestyle. The government should fund childcare properly, and this in turn should encourage, facilitate, and support people returning to work.

We're in the same situation for child benefit. My DH earns literally just over the threshold, whereas I'm on £23k pa, but because of his salary alone we no longer qualify for child benefit, which was genuinely a noticeable support for us each month. Feels like this system penalises women- who are often the ones a) claiming the child benefit and b) earning less due to career breaks/ part time working associated with having children. It does sting a bit that some of our friends who have a combined income of just under £100k can still claim full child benefit.

PepeLePugh · 17/11/2023 12:40

This tweet from the Institute of Fiscal Studies explains the problem succinctly. A parent earning £130k with two children would be worse off than a parent earning £99k. The rules do not currently make sense.

30 hours free childcare- means tested?!
MargotBamborough · 17/11/2023 12:30

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 12:11

Then they need to pay a decent wage for these roles. But they don't. Why? Because they are usually the domain of women, and women's work is under valued.

So instead, the govt tops up. And the top up system doesn't actually benefit the worker on 16h to work more hours. Because all that happens is their UC reduces by the value they earn so every hour they work over 16 they essentially are doing it unpaid.

I don't think it's as simple as these roles being poorly paid because they are mostly done by women.

Care is already incredibly expensive and it would become even more expensive if carers were paid more. I'm not saying they shouldn't be paid more, by the way, I think they should be paid more.

But ultimately it comes down to who pays for it, and I think there are a lot of voters who believe on the one hand that carers should be paid more, but also on the other hand have an elderly parent in a care home which already costs a grand a week and don't particularly want to see that bill rise by 20%.

And of course for all the people who can't afford to pay their own care or who have hit the lifetime limit for care costs, the taxpayer will be making up the shortfall either way, whether that is by topping up the salaries of the low paid workers caring for that person or picking up the entire bill for their care costs, or indeed both.

TrashedSofa · 17/11/2023 12:16

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 11:52

Why does the 30k person need to stop working though?

The 100k person and the 30k person could each work 4 days - this frees up 2 days for them to cover childcare.

The 100k person could funnel more money into their pension

The couple could take the (chosen) hit on double childcare for a year in order to retain their careers, as a short term pain that they can afford. Then once the baby hits 3yo and the older one is at school they will have much more spare funds.

And yes - they do contribute more in taxes (we'll, the 100k one does) but this is a suitable set up for a sensible nation, that those who earn more contribute more.

The couples income puts them very comfortably within the top 5% of earners in the UK.

'Need' is the wrong way to look at it. People make the choices they think are best for themselves and their families, and in the scenario outlined, the incentives mean that may well look like deciding to work less for a period. Sure, it's not the only option, but it's one of the ways people respond to cliff edges and bottlenecks, and not just at 100k either. Works the same way on lower incomes too. I know, I've done it.

There are wider implications if enough people do this, because of both our current shortage of workers and because they'll end up paying less into the pot. This is why it's not a good idea to arrange things so that people can be worse off by working more, or that they don't see much benefit from it.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 12:11

MargotBamborough · 17/11/2023 12:10

What I'm saying is that there shouldn't be any feature of the system which disincentivises people from working more than 16 hours, but particularly in the case of people who are qualified to do much needed jobs.

Then they need to pay a decent wage for these roles. But they don't. Why? Because they are usually the domain of women, and women's work is under valued.

So instead, the govt tops up. And the top up system doesn't actually benefit the worker on 16h to work more hours. Because all that happens is their UC reduces by the value they earn so every hour they work over 16 they essentially are doing it unpaid.

MargotBamborough · 17/11/2023 12:10

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 12:05

Because even a FT carer would get UC top ups as the wage alone isn't sufficient to survive.

What I'm saying is that there shouldn't be any feature of the system which disincentivises people from working more than 16 hours, but particularly in the case of people who are qualified to do much needed jobs.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 12:05

MargotBamborough · 17/11/2023 12:04

Given that the care sector is massively struggling for staff, especially post Brexit, how in the world does it make sense to have a system where a qualified carer is better off only working 16 hours a week and claiming Universal Credit?

Because even a FT carer would get UC top ups as the wage alone isn't sufficient to survive.

MargotBamborough · 17/11/2023 12:04

Tryingtohelp12 · 17/11/2023 10:31

I understand your frustration (even though I do get the hours as we don’t earn the amount), we’re not entitled to child benefit. It does rather feel like the cut offs are plucked randomly out of thin air and not regularly reassessed in line with COL.

you need to sit down and do the maths to work out what is finacially better for you. Exactly the same way my cousin (and many other people I know) who have calculated that their best financial option is to work 16 hours, add universal credit and other benefits totals more than they have the potential to earn (they would only gain employment in what is considered low skilled roles. That’s not me saying they are low skilled roles -carers and admin roles are incredibly undervalued/underpaid.) once you’ve done the maths work out what makes the most sense for your family. I am about to have my third and when I return to work will just do school hours as the cost for wrap around for my older 2, plus extended long days for my 3rd I wouldn’t earn enough to cover/make working worth it. Ie I can work 6 hours and pay less childcare, or work 7.5 hours and pay more childcare. My take home would be about the same. So work out the maths and make a decision from there!

Given that the care sector is massively struggling for staff, especially post Brexit, how in the world does it make sense to have a system where a qualified carer is better off only working 16 hours a week and claiming Universal Credit?

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/11/2023 11:58

iloveherons · 17/11/2023 10:43

nobody on 100k needs subsidised childcare. check your privilege ffs

This.

It's unbelievable.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 11:52

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:58

In my example the couple are spending 60% of their income on childcare. I’d say that’s a fair chunk.

I have no issue with funding services to ensure everyone has a good quality of life, I merely object to the idea that some people should be excluded from those services while significantly funding them, and despite the fact it clearly negatively impacts those people (eg the lower earner in a relationship potentially having to stop
work).

Combined with the loss of the personal allowance at £100k, parents of preschoolers are paying effective rates of 90%+ on quite a significant % of their income. That is not good - see posters here say they may as well work less hours. This reduces the overall tax take.

Why does the 30k person need to stop working though?

The 100k person and the 30k person could each work 4 days - this frees up 2 days for them to cover childcare.

The 100k person could funnel more money into their pension

The couple could take the (chosen) hit on double childcare for a year in order to retain their careers, as a short term pain that they can afford. Then once the baby hits 3yo and the older one is at school they will have much more spare funds.

And yes - they do contribute more in taxes (we'll, the 100k one does) but this is a suitable set up for a sensible nation, that those who earn more contribute more.

The couples income puts them very comfortably within the top 5% of earners in the UK.

WonkyDonkey3 · 17/11/2023 11:43

This is an interesting article that explains far better than I could the cliff edge of earning over £100k and the impact of the cost of childcare.

ifamagazine.com/hunts-new-childcare-plans-make-punitive-100000-earnings-cliff-edge-eye-watering/

PepeLePugh · 17/11/2023 11:02

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:59

@PepeLePugh are £100k+ earners not eligible for the 15 hours? I believed they were.

If so this makes it even more extreme - a parent with two preschoolers will be looking at a 100% effective tax rate from £100-150k.

Everything I have read suggests this is the case.

The current 15hours at 3 years old is universal - this is for working parents, parents earning over £100k and parents not working at all. The new childcare funding is for those currently eligible for 30 hours which is for working parents and would therefore exclude those either not working or where a parent earns over £100k.

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:59

@PepeLePugh are £100k+ earners not eligible for the 15 hours? I believed they were.

If so this makes it even more extreme - a parent with two preschoolers will be looking at a 100% effective tax rate from £100-150k.

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:58

In my example the couple are spending 60% of their income on childcare. I’d say that’s a fair chunk.

I have no issue with funding services to ensure everyone has a good quality of life, I merely object to the idea that some people should be excluded from those services while significantly funding them, and despite the fact it clearly negatively impacts those people (eg the lower earner in a relationship potentially having to stop
work).

Combined with the loss of the personal allowance at £100k, parents of preschoolers are paying effective rates of 90%+ on quite a significant % of their income. That is not good - see posters here say they may as well work less hours. This reduces the overall tax take.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 10:56

Why?

PepeLePugh · 17/11/2023 10:56

This is not just about the current 15/30 hours at 3 years old.

The gap widens with the new childcare funding. Children under 3 with parents who work will be entitled to 30 hours however those with 1 parent earning over £100k get nothing. No 15 hours. No tax-free childcare. Nothing.

I appreciate there needs to be a cut-off somewhere and the current 15/30 for 3 year olds is probably fair enough but this should continue with the new funding arrangements for the under 3's too.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 10:50

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:47

So…. Should people on lower incomes not be eligible for childcare support if they have two in nursery at the same time to then?

People should have families they can afford within what they can pay for and what the state has decided they can have support with. Believe me, even those on much lower incomes aren't having multiple kids back to back just because of the 30 free hours for their 3yos. Because the amount they pay on top for full time year round childcare is a fair chunk of their take home pay.

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:47

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 10:45

Especially given the fact that they've chosen to have a second child at a time which means 2x nursery fees overlapping.

So…. Should people on lower incomes not be eligible for childcare support if they have two in nursery at the same time to then?

SunshineAndFizz · 17/11/2023 10:46

Oh come on.

EsmeSusanOgg · 17/11/2023 10:46

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 23:16

I am not saying that. PI find it so odd that government would set a system whereby it is more beneficial for me to reduce hours to get these hours. That's absolute madness to me- we shouldn't be making it easier for people to work less 🤷‍♀️

Feels being penalised for working hard

Or increase your pension contributions if you are only just over the threshold? It is about taxable income.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 10:45

iloveherons · 17/11/2023 10:43

nobody on 100k needs subsidised childcare. check your privilege ffs

Especially given the fact that they've chosen to have a second child at a time which means 2x nursery fees overlapping.

iloveherons · 17/11/2023 10:43

nobody on 100k needs subsidised childcare. check your privilege ffs

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 10:43

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:36

@SecondUsername4me

Sure, but the other parent may well be earning an average wage.

Say they earn £30,000. This is £1,915 a month take home.

This means your childcare is 206% of
that parents wage. Which, inevitably, means that parent probably stops working.

Why are you measuring nursery fees against one wage? The figures you supply for your couple example is £6700 take home per month. Too bloody right they don't need 30 hours free. They get 15 as does everyone. And tbh if the 100k earner upped their pensions a small amount they would then get the full 30 for free.

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 10:41

@SecondUsername4me

It also means that in this ‘very high earning’ household with £130k income.

post tax income - £4,792 + £1,915 = £6,707

Less £3,950 on nursery = £2,757

So they have £2,757 to cover a mortgage on a family home, commuting, bills etc.

I’d argue that yes, they should be able to access the same childcare support as those on lower incomes.