Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

30 hours free childcare- means tested?!

236 replies

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 22:47

Sure I will get blasted, but I only just realised that the 30hr free childcare is means tested. I have paid full price for my child for past 2 years- at a whopping £1240 a month, but it is what it is.

Selfishly, i was so looking forward to her turning 3 and getting the free hours. Would be a massive help with mortgage going up. However I don't qualify. And it is not a sliding scale, I don't qualify for anything. So I would actually be better off reducing hours so I would qualify for the free hours- in what world should that be the case?! Makes no sense to me!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
threeisquiteenough · 17/11/2023 20:14

KateyCuckoo · 17/11/2023 19:11

You're receiving 2 children's childcare! Just because it's meanial work to you and your £156k lifestyle doesn't mean you aren't getting 'nothing to show for it'.

I am confused. In that scenario the person isn't 'getting' childcare, they are paying for childcare. So they are working more hours but not actually earning any more for it.

And, to be clear, I don't earn this money, it is simply the scenario I disagree with. I feel it disadvantages all and discourages high earners from working more (and paying more into tax system that helps us all!)

threeisquiteenough · 17/11/2023 20:10

@Teder , it isn't a win win though, that's the point

If the person cuts down their hours they pay less tax, less money in the system overall for everyone.

It is also fair to say that in many of these jobs, part time is not an option. I don't earn 156k, would be nice! However, even on my salary, the job is not suitable for part time- so I don't think it's quite as simple as just cutting hours

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 19:13

Is this like when people own horses then say "I'm so pooooooor" Grin

KateyCuckoo · 17/11/2023 19:11

You're receiving 2 children's childcare! Just because it's meanial work to you and your £156k lifestyle doesn't mean you aren't getting 'nothing to show for it'.

Teder · 17/11/2023 19:10

threeisquiteenough · 17/11/2023 18:28

Not sure you are quite grasping this. The PP was saying on paper a person earns 50k more a year and yet sees none of it.

No one on their right mind would want to do all the extra work and sacrifice that it takes to make that 'extra 50k' to have no extra money at end of month to show for it.

A system that disincentivises people to work is flawed. You really think this is fair?!

Soooooo, don’t…?! Cut down your hours. Win win.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 18:32

threeisquiteenough · 17/11/2023 18:28

Not sure you are quite grasping this. The PP was saying on paper a person earns 50k more a year and yet sees none of it.

No one on their right mind would want to do all the extra work and sacrifice that it takes to make that 'extra 50k' to have no extra money at end of month to show for it.

A system that disincentivises people to work is flawed. You really think this is fair?!

But they are "seeing none of it" because they are spending it on childcare right?

threeisquiteenough · 17/11/2023 18:28

Teder · 17/11/2023 17:31

”Loss of free hours + tax free childcare means parents with two preschoolers will be £0 better off for earning £156k vs £100k. Surely no one thinks this is ‘fair’?”

Firstly, paying for childcare for preschoolers is a very short period of time in one’s full career. Secondly, most people realise childcare is expensive and choose not to have children super close together. Thirdly, the family earning £156k could drop a third of their income and still be very wealthy so there’s no reason why one parent or both can’t go part time for a few years.

Not sure you are quite grasping this. The PP was saying on paper a person earns 50k more a year and yet sees none of it.

No one on their right mind would want to do all the extra work and sacrifice that it takes to make that 'extra 50k' to have no extra money at end of month to show for it.

A system that disincentivises people to work is flawed. You really think this is fair?!

SandandSky · 17/11/2023 17:44

But I do get frustrated when I hear very fortunate well off people complaining that they don’t get to use and benefit from the system that is really only meant to help those who absolutely need it.

this!!

SandandSky · 17/11/2023 17:42

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/11/2023 11:58

This.

It's unbelievable.

All that needs to be said tbh.

ever heard the phrase “live within your means” ???

because us lower earners hear it all the time 🙄

Teder · 17/11/2023 17:31

”Loss of free hours + tax free childcare means parents with two preschoolers will be £0 better off for earning £156k vs £100k. Surely no one thinks this is ‘fair’?”

Firstly, paying for childcare for preschoolers is a very short period of time in one’s full career. Secondly, most people realise childcare is expensive and choose not to have children super close together. Thirdly, the family earning £156k could drop a third of their income and still be very wealthy so there’s no reason why one parent or both can’t go part time for a few years.

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 16:27

Loss of free hours + tax free childcare means parents with two preschoolers will be £0 better off for earning £156k vs £100k

Surely no one thinks this is ‘fair’?

Aside from a twin/triplet situation, people are choosing to have two preschoolers.

MargotBamborough · 17/11/2023 15:28

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 15:17

No skin either but acutely aware that if we lose a lot of high earners that public spending will be put under more strain. We are at a point where more than half are taking more out of the pot than putting in. If we keep pushing high earners they’ll do what it takes to reduce their wages or just leave for pastures new like Australia. Can’t blame them personally!

Childcare is also extortionate and we are suffering with a declining birth rate. Purely importing people to fill this gap is not the way forward and most likely ends up with them taking out more than they put in as we aren’t attracting many high level skills which end up with high salaries thus more tax.

I’m personally more worried about the high earning women who will decide to leave work completely as working to fund childcare won’t appeal to them. I am one of the women in a good job (not 100k) which is male dominated so I’m a small %, but I’m considering leaving as childcare doesn’t feel worth the job anymore. And frankly the childcare on offer in our area is horrific for the cost.

This takes women out of even more positions of power, independence and decision making for many industries generally. Everything is a domino effect.

Edited

I'm a high earner and I moved abroad. Not because of the cost of living in the UK, but I'm glad I moved.

I have two children in nursery full time for about 1100€ per month. And my salary is high enough that I qualify for the minimum level of help from the government. If I earned less I would pay less.

If I were in the UK and paying twice that much, being told I didn't qualify for even the shitty amount of help that the government provides for childcare despite all the taxes I was paying would be a real kick in the teeth.

IdleAnimations · 17/11/2023 15:17

WeightoftheWorld · 17/11/2023 13:09

I fully agree with this but we always to be a small minority on MN.

And I have absolutely no skin is this game as neither me nor my DH will ever earn anywhere close to £100k! Our combined household income is about £50k and the vast majority of my lower salary goes on nursery fees for our 2yo.

No skin either but acutely aware that if we lose a lot of high earners that public spending will be put under more strain. We are at a point where more than half are taking more out of the pot than putting in. If we keep pushing high earners they’ll do what it takes to reduce their wages or just leave for pastures new like Australia. Can’t blame them personally!

Childcare is also extortionate and we are suffering with a declining birth rate. Purely importing people to fill this gap is not the way forward and most likely ends up with them taking out more than they put in as we aren’t attracting many high level skills which end up with high salaries thus more tax.

I’m personally more worried about the high earning women who will decide to leave work completely as working to fund childcare won’t appeal to them. I am one of the women in a good job (not 100k) which is male dominated so I’m a small %, but I’m considering leaving as childcare doesn’t feel worth the job anymore. And frankly the childcare on offer in our area is horrific for the cost.

This takes women out of even more positions of power, independence and decision making for many industries generally. Everything is a domino effect.

TeaKitten · 17/11/2023 15:03

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/11/2023 12:58

Fair enough. Confused as we were talking about the threshold of £100k but still wonder how people are struggling on these wages. Try waiting for your child benefit so you can get a decent coat for your child....imagine that

I’m a single parent and earn well under 50k so I can imagine it perfectly well thank you. Other than your dodgy maths I haven’t disagreed with you.

WeightoftheWorld · 17/11/2023 13:09

Nutellaonall · 14/11/2023 23:03

You won’t get much sympathy here but I agree it isn’t fair. Everyone on mumsnet agree that the Nordic countries are like some kind of perfect utopia but they believe in everyone gets access to the same benefits no matter how much they earn. People are total hypocrites. Everyone should pay tax and everyone should benefit from the society they create. But this country hates people that dare to be successful.

I fully agree with this but we always to be a small minority on MN.

And I have absolutely no skin is this game as neither me nor my DH will ever earn anywhere close to £100k! Our combined household income is about £50k and the vast majority of my lower salary goes on nursery fees for our 2yo.

mummabubs · 17/11/2023 13:01

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/11/2023 12:49

Not saying the rules are fair but you have a household income of roughly £123k and you need child benefit? Something wrong with your budgeting!

The threshold for child benefit is much lower. At £50k you pay a sliding charge on claiming it, at £60k you can't claim it as all child benefit would be eaten up by the charge. So I wish our income was £123k, it definitely isn't 😂

That said, Re: your comment about our budgeting- it's just a combination of events really! We bought a fixer upper house that needed everything doing to it just before Covid hit - at which point all trades and materials rocketed in price (and still haven't come down). Then the recent mortgage rates hiking up means our mortgage is now £500 more a month than it was compared to what it was when we last locked it in. We live in a part of the UK where childcare is very expensive, so three days a week for one child is £1100 a month. Our combined wage might look decent on paper, but we couldn't have forseen the impact of a pandemic, mortgage hikes and ever-increasing childcare costs. We do budget carefully and thankfully aren't in debt, but all "luxuries" are gone and we don't have anything to put into savings at the end of the month. So believe it or not child benefit did make a difference for us. Plenty of people are in a similar position to this it seems.

starfro · 17/11/2023 12:58

The tax system in the UK is ridiculous, with all sorts of disincentives for working past arbitrary levels of pay.

Most people in my profession have gone part-time to avoid the 100k threshold where you lose your personal allowance, as well as the child-care.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/11/2023 12:58

TeaKitten · 17/11/2023 12:50

Something wrong with your maths on that one too unfortunately.

Fair enough. Confused as we were talking about the threshold of £100k but still wonder how people are struggling on these wages. Try waiting for your child benefit so you can get a decent coat for your child....imagine that

TrashedSofa · 17/11/2023 12:54

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 12:47

Great article @WonkyDonkey3

”Parents in areas where childcare is most expensive will be hit hardest, as those 30 free hours a week will cost far more. Someone in inner London, where costs are highest, who is claiming for two children will lose a benefit worth £23,300 a year just in free childcare hours*. On top of that they lose their entitlement to tax-free childcare, which is worth up to £2,000 per child each year. It means that when one parent gets a pay rise taking them over that £100,000 limit, they lose £27,300 of entitlement in an instant.

What’s even more eye-opening is just how long it takes before their disposable income will resume to their previous levels, accounting for post-tax income and the value of the childcare support. Their salary would need to increase to £156,279 before they get back to the same disposable income as when they were earning £100,000. This puts parents in the ridiculous place where they are effectively worse off earning between £100,000 and £156,000.”

Loss of free hours + tax free childcare means parents with two preschoolers will be £0 better off for earning £156k vs £100k.

Surely no one thinks this is ‘fair’?

I think it's objectively idiotic.

WYorkshireRose · 17/11/2023 12:52

But would you actually be better off reducing your hours? We weren't eligible for the 30 hours either due to DH's income, but we got the universal 15 and when we spoke to another parent at our nursery at the time whose child attended full time like ours, the difference between the 15 and 30 hours only reduced their bill from by another £300/month.

Bells3032 · 17/11/2023 12:52

I'm confused. at 100k you lose 15 of the 30 hours for 3 and 4 years not all 30 of them. for under 3s i think it will be completely lost. you also lose the tax free childcare grant which is annoying.

Also are you aware it's adjusted net income so if you are earning £101k and are paying a 5% pension (which most people probably will) then you will still be under the band limit as your adjusted net income is is 96k not 101k.

You can also add additional contributions to your pension if it's close to the limit. My husband will likely go over that band next year so we plan to invest in his (currently meagre) pension more and kill two birds really

TeaKitten · 17/11/2023 12:50

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/11/2023 12:49

Not saying the rules are fair but you have a household income of roughly £123k and you need child benefit? Something wrong with your budgeting!

Something wrong with your maths on that one too unfortunately.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 17/11/2023 12:49

mummabubs · 17/11/2023 12:40

We're in the same situation for child benefit. My DH earns literally just over the threshold, whereas I'm on £23k pa, but because of his salary alone we no longer qualify for child benefit, which was genuinely a noticeable support for us each month. Feels like this system penalises women- who are often the ones a) claiming the child benefit and b) earning less due to career breaks/ part time working associated with having children. It does sting a bit that some of our friends who have a combined income of just under £100k can still claim full child benefit.

Not saying the rules are fair but you have a household income of roughly £123k and you need child benefit? Something wrong with your budgeting!

SunshineHello · 17/11/2023 12:47

Great article @WonkyDonkey3

”Parents in areas where childcare is most expensive will be hit hardest, as those 30 free hours a week will cost far more. Someone in inner London, where costs are highest, who is claiming for two children will lose a benefit worth £23,300 a year just in free childcare hours*. On top of that they lose their entitlement to tax-free childcare, which is worth up to £2,000 per child each year. It means that when one parent gets a pay rise taking them over that £100,000 limit, they lose £27,300 of entitlement in an instant.

What’s even more eye-opening is just how long it takes before their disposable income will resume to their previous levels, accounting for post-tax income and the value of the childcare support. Their salary would need to increase to £156,279 before they get back to the same disposable income as when they were earning £100,000. This puts parents in the ridiculous place where they are effectively worse off earning between £100,000 and £156,000.”

Loss of free hours + tax free childcare means parents with two preschoolers will be £0 better off for earning £156k vs £100k.

Surely no one thinks this is ‘fair’?