Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

30 hours free childcare- means tested?!

236 replies

bingbongbang23 · 14/11/2023 22:47

Sure I will get blasted, but I only just realised that the 30hr free childcare is means tested. I have paid full price for my child for past 2 years- at a whopping £1240 a month, but it is what it is.

Selfishly, i was so looking forward to her turning 3 and getting the free hours. Would be a massive help with mortgage going up. However I don't qualify. And it is not a sliding scale, I don't qualify for anything. So I would actually be better off reducing hours so I would qualify for the free hours- in what world should that be the case?! Makes no sense to me!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
7
Snowonthebeachx · 20/11/2023 14:32

Haven't read the whole thread but OP have you looked at the small print? I think it's adjusted net income so you don't include pension contributions or charitable donations. Could you put more into your pension and do some direct charity debits? I think this is what we will do (actually already do).
It is a stupid system and penalises couples like us where one of you earns just over 100k and one of you about 20k! I am public sector as well so you would have thought it would be good if I was incentivised to work!

As a side note I'd be completely fine with a cut off just should be combined income. One income seems quite sexist as its usually women who are the lower earners and take time out of work.

Bells3032 · 20/11/2023 14:03

Concannon88 · 20/11/2023 13:21

You equate working hard with earning over 100k? Plenty of people work their fingers to the bone and earn minimum wage, I think they need the free childcare more than you! Your post just proves to me that you dont have to be intelligent to garner a high salary, you've been relying on something coming into play but didnt research the eligibility.

The OP never said she thought she should get it over someone earning minimum wage. she's saying that removing it on a cliff edge rather than tapering it is ridiculous which it is. If you have two kids you suddenly lose 60 hours of free childcare and £4k tax free account money. So if you are earning between £100-150k you actually end up with take home pay lower than someone earning £99k which makes zero sense. Stop putting words in people's mouths. It may be a tad crass to complain about it but some people it can result in major issues.

Imagine you are a parent earning £100k whilst your partner earns 20k. you have two young kids. Your total take-home pay is £6900. You have two children in full time nursery at £3000 in total leaving you with a total take home of £3900. Mortgage is now probably over £2000 a month (mortgage of 450k or a 600k house), travel to work £240, council tax £250 a month, bills and gas £150 a months etc. Leave 1k a month for EVERYTHING else - food, clothes days out with the kids, tv, holidays, repairs to the home etc not exactly living the high life on that?

Compared to someone earning 90k and their partner earning 30k = same initial income. Total take home pay = £6940 (so actually a slightly higher take home pay). but they can 60 hours free childcare. so they have an additional 2k per month to spend. The design makes no sense.

You can also have both parents earning £99k and get it but one parent earning 100k and other earning 20k doesn't.

Teder · 20/11/2023 14:03

SunshineHello · 20/11/2023 12:31

@Teder

"I would be embarrassed to whine about things like this if I earned as much as some people on here do. In the same way, I wouldn’t whine about the cold weather payment. How utterly classless."

The OP will lose several thousand pounds of take home pay because she hits the £100k 'cliff edge'.

Why work to earn £101,000, if you are going to better off to the tune of several thousand pounds to earn £99,000?

This is a well known flaw in the tax system, and it is entirely reasonable for OP to ensure her family is not worse off as a result of this cliff-edge.

I’m sure if someone is intelligent enough to earn a 6 figure salary, they’re intelligent enough to ask for financial planning advice. That’s a very different tone to some of the posts on here!

Concannon88 · 20/11/2023 13:21

You equate working hard with earning over 100k? Plenty of people work their fingers to the bone and earn minimum wage, I think they need the free childcare more than you! Your post just proves to me that you dont have to be intelligent to garner a high salary, you've been relying on something coming into play but didnt research the eligibility.

SunshineHello · 20/11/2023 12:31

@Teder

"I would be embarrassed to whine about things like this if I earned as much as some people on here do. In the same way, I wouldn’t whine about the cold weather payment. How utterly classless."

The OP will lose several thousand pounds of take home pay because she hits the £100k 'cliff edge'.

Why work to earn £101,000, if you are going to better off to the tune of several thousand pounds to earn £99,000?

This is a well known flaw in the tax system, and it is entirely reasonable for OP to ensure her family is not worse off as a result of this cliff-edge.

KateyCuckoo · 20/11/2023 11:43

Yes it's because the scheme has a minimum income threshold as well as maximum income cut off and the poorer families are less likely to be working enough hours (16x minimum wage per week) for both parents (or one in a single parent household).

TrashedSofa · 20/11/2023 11:35

PepeLePugh · 20/11/2023 10:14

What is the explanation for this out of curiosity?

Is the argument that the new 30 hours scheme is unsustainable and therefore nurseries will be more inclined to take private paying parents who are not claiming the 30 hours? Otherwise I can't see how family income would make any difference with 2 sets of parents both claiming the 30 hours from the government.

I think it's primarily because poorer households are less likely to meet the requirement for both parents to be working enough.

PepeLePugh · 20/11/2023 10:14

WarningOfGails · 20/11/2023 10:00

Article in the Guardian today reporting on research from the New Economics Foundation that says richer households will benefit from the childcare plans, only 12% of poorer families will have access to 30hours compared with 68% of families in the top 30% of earners.

What is the explanation for this out of curiosity?

Is the argument that the new 30 hours scheme is unsustainable and therefore nurseries will be more inclined to take private paying parents who are not claiming the 30 hours? Otherwise I can't see how family income would make any difference with 2 sets of parents both claiming the 30 hours from the government.

WarningOfGails · 20/11/2023 10:00

Article in the Guardian today reporting on research from the New Economics Foundation that says richer households will benefit from the childcare plans, only 12% of poorer families will have access to 30hours compared with 68% of families in the top 30% of earners.

TheSeasonalNameChange · 19/11/2023 07:42

@poorlypoppet in my experience is worse than than 11% as there's usually a bonus. For me the difference earning over £100k would be about 20% of my average monthly salary just on childcare alone and I'd get less of the bonus too which I usually use to replenish savings.

I think a lot of the issue is that 20 years ago £100k may have been a fabulous salary, but the way the cost of everything is going it doesn't stretch. Salary matters a lot less than wealth now. For example, I literally bought the cheapest family home in the local area and still have a massive mortgage but people even 10 years ahead of me could have the same home for half the money so way more disposable income. No idea what's going to happen to the people 10 years behind or what wage they'll need to have hope of a reasonable standard of living.

Teder · 18/11/2023 09:14

LaurieStrode · 18/11/2023 01:47

The fact is that the prudent, productive people are fed up with paying for the imprudent moochers. Bottom line.

Someone earning £99k isn’t an “imprudent moocher” but they’re eligible for the childcare funding. If £100k + earners are the top 5%, then not everyone (95% of the working population) earning under that is a moocher.

I do earn the golden MN ‘six figure salary’ but my income is decent and I don’t begrudge those eligible for benefits I am not. So many high earners think they’re hard working and deserving. I do work hard but I don’t think I deserve Universal Credit because I know many people on minimum wage jobs probably have it much harder than I do!

I would be embarrassed to whine about things like this if I earned as much as some people on here do. In the same way, I wouldn’t whine about the cold weather payment. How utterly classless.

poorlypoppet · 18/11/2023 09:02

LivingDeadGirlUK · 18/11/2023 04:23

You would maybe save £400-£600 a month with the 30 free hours assuming your child is in full time. If thats not a drop in the ocean for someone earning £100k then you are doing something seriously wrong.

I think £600 per month isn't considered a drop in the ocean for anyone! For someone on £100k it's around 11% of their take home, and that's assuming they don't have any other deductions except tax and NI.

But this thread isn't about that. It's about the cliff edge for £100k where people simultaneously lose 30hrs childcare, tax free childcare and their personal allowance. It literally means people take home far LESS earning £100,001 than when they earn £99,999 and don't actually start earning "more" (in take home pay) until they have a bumper Payrise (£10s of thousands later). Who would be happy with this honestly? Hence, people reduce hours or throw into pension to come under £100k. They then earn "more" in take home pay again. But the country and public purses loses out as they don't get the tax.

People would be happy to pay 40% on their over £100k earnings. But the cliff edge means it's an effective 90+% tax and understandably that's just not acceptable (or worth the bother) for high earners.

Nutellaonall · 18/11/2023 08:57

A proper fair society is one where everyone pays high taxes and everyone benefits at the right time, like when they need childcare. No means testing. Access to services for everybody. This leads to no cliff edge cut offs that disincentive people from working a certain number of hours, nobody feels resentful. Like the Nordic models. But in this country there is nothing but nasty swiping at the people that earn more. It’s sad.

PepeLePugh · 18/11/2023 08:19

TheSeasonalNameChange · 17/11/2023 23:09

Oh good, we've solved it. So for any family earning more one parent should just give up their job to provide full time childcare and not complain because they have loads of money. Remind me how that works for single parents again?

Add to this that the lower earner is more often than not the woman who will give up her career, stop paying pension contributions etc. to look after the children.

ginandtonicwithlimes · 18/11/2023 06:55

LaurieStrode · 18/11/2023 01:47

The fact is that the prudent, productive people are fed up with paying for the imprudent moochers. Bottom line.

Sounds like you have swallowed all the Tory propoganda. Most of the childcare you may or may not contribute for are for working parents and not moochers. Most people work.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 18/11/2023 04:23

You would maybe save £400-£600 a month with the 30 free hours assuming your child is in full time. If thats not a drop in the ocean for someone earning £100k then you are doing something seriously wrong.

RiderofRohan · 18/11/2023 03:59

SALWARP2023 · 15/11/2023 13:38

During the 1980s very little child care was available and it all had to be paid for in full. No free care. My area had only one nursery in 10 mile radius. No universal credit. If you needed more money you got more hours. No minimum wage or legal right to annual leave. Please stop complaining millennials!

During the 1980s my granny's house in Chelsea was worth £30k. Not sure millennials are the ones who have it easy.

RiderofRohan · 18/11/2023 03:54

LaurieStrode · 18/11/2023 01:47

The fact is that the prudent, productive people are fed up with paying for the imprudent moochers. Bottom line.

Yep.

These rules are silly as they don't incentivise people to work. I'll be working part time after mat leave and telling DH to divert a bigger portion of his income into pension. Sorted. You just have to be savvy in this country if you actually want to take home a decent proportion of the money you earn.

LaurieStrode · 18/11/2023 01:47

The fact is that the prudent, productive people are fed up with paying for the imprudent moochers. Bottom line.

TheSeasonalNameChange · 17/11/2023 23:09

Oh good, we've solved it. So for any family earning more one parent should just give up their job to provide full time childcare and not complain because they have loads of money. Remind me how that works for single parents again?

hellomi · 17/11/2023 20:52

I agree that it would be fairer if it was based on household income- but also that both parents should be working at least the minimum required hours. I don't agree that those with an income over 100k should qualify.

Sheisannoyingme · 17/11/2023 20:52

Why would you need the 30 hours if one parent didn't work?

LTBarbara · 17/11/2023 20:45

SecondUsername4me · 17/11/2023 10:45

Especially given the fact that they've chosen to have a second child at a time which means 2x nursery fees overlapping.

Hmm. What if a women, being responsible, doesn’t start her family until she feels financially ready, or at a point in her career when she’s ready and she’s late thirties? I personally wouldn’t really want to space my kids three or more years apart if I’m absolutely set on having more than one child.

KateyCuckoo · 17/11/2023 20:29

threeisquiteenough · 17/11/2023 20:14

I am confused. In that scenario the person isn't 'getting' childcare, they are paying for childcare. So they are working more hours but not actually earning any more for it.

And, to be clear, I don't earn this money, it is simply the scenario I disagree with. I feel it disadvantages all and discourages high earners from working more (and paying more into tax system that helps us all!)

You could say that about any service you receive for payment.

I don't get annoyed and feel I work 'for nothing' just because I have to pay for groceries when others get food bank vouchers...

....or pay for my energy bils when some receive winter fuel payments....

.....or miss out on any other benefit that poorer people are entitled too.

Whinging on that your £156k doesn't stretch as far as you want is pathetic.

As is complaining that you 'Work hard for that money'. Well guess what, poorer people work hard too!

Pooooochi · 17/11/2023 20:24

Are you fucking kidding?

I didn't qualify either and damn straight i shouldn't have. I fucking do not need taxpayers money funding me when i can go earn £100k.

So you could have couple each earning £80k and qualify; then have a couple where one doesn't work and the other earns £101k and they don't qualify. That for me is madness

Yes because if one doesn't work they don't fucking need state funded childcare and if they do want a bit more money in the budget there's a whole spare adult in the equation who can go get a job.