Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I overreacting about his new friend

112 replies

Deners · 14/11/2023 21:31

My husband has recently Made friends with a new parent at the kids school. Shes only just moved to the area, and after our kids became close, he has got to know her through the school run etc.

I've been getting uncomfortable with their friendship, first it was lots of texts, talking about her constantly.Then xx started on the end of messages. Then he started collecting her kids from school for her and she'd come over to collect them, but stay for an hour, drink wine (2glasses on the side) and will always be gone before i get home from work. it's just odd

We had a halloween party, and as all the kids are friendly. she and her kids came along. My husband had a LOT to drink, and is openly flirting with her, arms around her waist, slap bum. The works. I was mortified, this was in front of our other friends. They commented on his behaviour. I went to bed pretty upset and left him to tidy up.

I woke up an hour Or so later. I can hear giggling. it's her laughing and then I hear what shes saying. it's X rated along the lines of you can do whateveryou want to me, your wife is asleep!!!

I crept out and saw husband sat on the stairs, he was very drunk, head spinning and didn't look well. I shouted at her that I'd heard everything she had said and to get out of my house. Huge argument but eventually she leaves, but not before comments about how much better in bed she'd be etc. I was beyond angry.

The next day me and husband had a long chat about it all. He felt he's been niave, trying to be friendly to her which she's misinterpreted. I felt he's been a fool at best, super disrespectful bordering on emotionally cheating at worst. He apologised, blocked all contact and told her to arrange alternative childcare. Perfect.

Until this evening when he mentions her casually and how bad she's feeling about it all and wants to go back to where things were. Wtaf? His view is she had become a good friend and he enjoyed her company. My view is she is a snake and I want nothing more to do with her. I also feel we should be united on this, but he says he was really drunk that night and doesn't really remember much.

I feel so hurt and let down. AIBU or am I in my right to ask him to avoid her?

OP posts:
Cheesecakefiend · 14/11/2023 22:49

He's shown you his intentions so do not ignore that. He is prioritising his "friendship" with this woman over your relationship. What more do you need to know.

SleepPrettyDarling · 14/11/2023 22:48

Mydahliasareshit · 14/11/2023 21:56

Sit him down, calmly, with a glass of something if need be, when you will not be disturbed. Say 'I am going to speak for the next minute or two, uninterrupted, ok'.

You understand it felt like she was giving something to him.
Friendship, chat, attention, you know. Just something slightly different.

However.

What she has now proven is that she wants to TAKE from him.
His marital stability, the respect of you, and his friends, eventually his children.
His financial footing, should she cause a divorce, family upset for years, his reputation and judgement. His standing and calibre of a man.
If he thinks she is really worth ALL that, then let's go ahead and tell the kids tomorrow and file for divorce. Tell him you gave copies of all paperwork of financials so no point trying to go off and hide anything from tonight.

Good luck op.x

This. You need your cool head. Be prepared for the outburst of how you are crazy/controlling/over-reacting, and let him have his rant. Keep the cool head, and say ‘well, this is a problem for our marriage because this relationship is intrusive, and I can’t be in a relationship with someone who thinks this is okay. So what are you going to do? Where do your loyalties lie?’

wildwestpioneer · 14/11/2023 22:45

His flirting and what she said to you, he's lucky you're still around.

To try and go back to what it was, is a huge kick in the teeth for you. Any one who truly loved and respected you wouldn't ask that. They'd block and never speak to that person again, be remorseful and do whatever possible to make it up to you

justwatchingtelly · 14/11/2023 22:42

Mumbleer · 14/11/2023 22:31

Yeah you are definitely underreacting.

I would be steaming livid at this - the texts and touching at the party would probably have been enough to kick DH out. If I'd heard what she said and the remarks afterwards I would have slung her out by her hair. And then dealt with DH after.

The fact that they have talked again after he "blocked" her? Nope. That's strike two. Out.

Unfortunately he's obviously weak and does not respect you at all to even consider her feelings. He's probably too far gone. She is awful too but this is on him to shut down.

This!!!

HaveSomeIntrospect · 14/11/2023 22:41

Your husband is a grade A idiot! Don’t blame her, he’s the one who made vows to you

1983Louise · 14/11/2023 22:37

Shag his best mate, he'll soon get the message............

Glassofwino · 14/11/2023 22:34

What part of this man’s brain thinks it’s acceptable to be her friend after all that???? I’m sure he’d love it, if the shoe was on the other foot

Mumbleer · 14/11/2023 22:31

Yeah you are definitely underreacting.

I would be steaming livid at this - the texts and touching at the party would probably have been enough to kick DH out. If I'd heard what she said and the remarks afterwards I would have slung her out by her hair. And then dealt with DH after.

The fact that they have talked again after he "blocked" her? Nope. That's strike two. Out.

Unfortunately he's obviously weak and does not respect you at all to even consider her feelings. He's probably too far gone. She is awful too but this is on him to shut down.

OnWhatGrounds · 14/11/2023 22:30

You frame this from the perspective of her being the trouble causer, but your husband knew what he was doing. He was not, I repeat, NOT, naive to this.
Flirting, arm on waist, slapping her bum, he knew exactly what he was doing and was brazen.
He has behaved disgracefully (as has she), and they both need to be ashamed. How embarrassing for your children and hers.

I would be telling him in clearly that he's been having at the very least an emotional affair. He's slowly trying to normalise and bring her back in after the drama has settled, and you are not seeing him for what he is

Emptyheadlock · 14/11/2023 22:25

The absolute pair of rats.

My marriage would be over at this, and if she were married I'd make damn sure hers was too.

And everyone around would know exactly what they had done.

Womencanlift · 14/11/2023 22:22

He has a simple choice - your marriage or their friendship. He can only have one

Not saying that husband’s can’t have female friends, my DP has plenty which I have no issue with. But when a line is crossed, and they are both so far over the line they are in a different county, that’s when there needs to be a choice

Dweetfidilove · 14/11/2023 22:22

I think you’re under-reacting to your husband’s disgusting behaviour.

So far He’s guilty of excessive texting, inappropriate holding, slapping bum and having sexual conversations with another.

I would say he is the snake.

Madam has set her stall, so you both know she wants him.

The snake, however, is gaslighting you in pretending he was naive to all this and should somehow be allowed to carry on this ‘friendship’. This is after she has made it clear she is ready to get sexually involved AND disrespected his wife, presumably in your marital home.

StephanieLampshade · 14/11/2023 22:21

Her behaviour that night surely means she can't ever be welcome in your house. I take it she hasn't even apologised!

He is out of his mind to think you'd be ok with this.

TeaGinandFags · 14/11/2023 22:19

Remind him she was offering to shag him while you were upstairs and that was the bit you objected to.

As others have noted, how can he know she's upset if he's gone no contact? 🤔

Remind him that adultery ends in divorce and you have witnesses.

FictionalCharacter · 14/11/2023 22:18

Of course he shouldn’t be seeing her, but YABU to put all the blame at HER door when he
”is openly flirting with her, arms around her waist, slap bum.”
She didn’t make him hold her and slap her bum. His behaviour is on him.

XMissPlacedX · 14/11/2023 22:13

I'm sorry op, his head has been turned by all the attention. You are not being unreasonable at all.

Dancingonaslice · 14/11/2023 22:13

He’s actually conducting an affair right in front of you and expecting your permission.

Even before the Halloween incident it sounds highly dodgy but his behaviour and then what she said that night would have had him out the house for me I’m sorry. Am affair is my line in the sand and he’s clearly not remorseful he’s just missing her and somehow expecting you to give it your blessing.

You are on the verge of being made a real fool of which is awful as you have clearly tried to give him the opportunity to wake up to what he’s about to lose. His attraction to her is clearly stronger.

Gerrataere · 14/11/2023 22:12

Your husband is a slimeball. If it’s not this woman it will be another. That’s what happens when you mix people with the morals of alley cats, they behave as such.

Onedicktoanother · 14/11/2023 22:12

I think the writing is on the wall here. Your husband had his head turned/is enjoying the attention of this women. I would tell him to run along as he has zero respect for you. I am sorry you are in this situation.

BOOTS52PollyPrissyPants · 14/11/2023 22:10

This is just disgusting behavior from the both of them and you tell him calmly and firmly that if he wants to remain friends with her he can move out. No texting, chatting nothing as their behavior is unacceptable. I would have called him out on it with the arm around her waist etc. Disrespecting you in front of everyone on Halloween would be the last straw for me. I probably would have thrown him out then.
It shows that the two of them have been talking again and tell him he can move out if he persists in wanting to have a friendship with her as we both know where this is heading.
He is a shit and him saying he cannot remember is crap and she is also a biatch.
She has made it perfectly clear what her intentions are and he is equally being so disrespectful to you.

Imagine if you were doing this with another man and having him over to your house and drinking wine and emotionally entwined and flirting openly in front of everyone and hanging onto another man, he would be furious.
I would not put up with this in any way or form and would probably have kicked him out already.

Nicole1111 · 14/11/2023 22:08

He absolutely should have no contact with her if he wants to maintain a relationship with you but honestly I think the more important question is how much you want to be in this relationship. It doesn’t sound like he respects you or holds you in mind at all when. You deserve better.

AuntMarch · 14/11/2023 21:57

One of my very best friends is a man, I'm normally quick to fight the corner of platonic mixed sex friendships.

Not this one. It really would be a me or her choice for him to make in this situation... in fact I think we'd already be beyond that by now.

My friend and I had a drunken snog once, and very quickly decided it was too weird and we were definitely just friends. We've been drunk together many, many times since and never come close to crossing that line again.. We were 15 at the time, over 20 years ago.

She has no interest in being his friend and he knows that. It sounds like she was the instigator that night, if he was just sitting on the stairs, but given that his prior behaviour was blatant enough for other guests to notice she probably thought it was a sure bet!

The very best he can be in this situation is a disrespectful wanker ranking flattery as more important than the feelings of his wife, otherwise he wouldn't even consider "going back to how things were" after the way she disrespected you, in your own home no less. That's not something I could ever quite get over I don't think, even if he did backtrack now. The fact he even thought it would be ok would have had me packing his bags!

Tbry · 14/11/2023 21:57

He slapped her bum!!!!!

I’d not even want my DH to do that to me in public, especially when drunk but to do it to someone else! Utterly disrespectful, you deserve far better.

Hairspray123 · 14/11/2023 21:57

Based on what you said I dont think he has crossed that line of an actual affair (physically anyway in his mind). I would certainly not accept the friendship again and tell him its non negotiable end of! If he chooses to persue then its marriage over, should he actually carry on he has pretty much made the decision anyway knowing the consequences.

Mydahliasareshit · 14/11/2023 21:56

Sit him down, calmly, with a glass of something if need be, when you will not be disturbed. Say 'I am going to speak for the next minute or two, uninterrupted, ok'.

You understand it felt like she was giving something to him.
Friendship, chat, attention, you know. Just something slightly different.

However.

What she has now proven is that she wants to TAKE from him.
His marital stability, the respect of you, and his friends, eventually his children.
His financial footing, should she cause a divorce, family upset for years, his reputation and judgement. His standing and calibre of a man.
If he thinks she is really worth ALL that, then let's go ahead and tell the kids tomorrow and file for divorce. Tell him you gave copies of all paperwork of financials so no point trying to go off and hide anything from tonight.

Good luck op.x