Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

End of Life Message - please help me with wording

111 replies

makesmestronger · 14/11/2023 18:16

Firstly apologies for posting here, and apologies if this is triggering.

My DH and I are power of attorney for my FIL. Sadly FIL was diagnosed with Dementia and Alzheimer earlier this year, he refused to take meds and the disease has progressed quite quickly.

In May since the diagnosis where he was living independently quite happily, he is now in a care home, can't use his mobile phone, loosing weight, he can't have a conversation with someone (as engage in the conversation) he can't remember people that visited him 2 days ago. He was admitted to hospital 2 weeks ago and has now come home with a catheter, which he has pulled out on one occasion and is constantly 'tugging at it'. On the hospital discharge notes he was measured/documented as severely frail, when I looked this up on NICE they are saying he has 6 months or less to live.

He was admitted back in to hospital yesterday with blood in the urine, and he was dehydrated.

There is a family whattsapp group for his elderly sister (DH's Aunt) and the 4 other siblings of DH. The sister is in denial that her DF is poorly and I want to try and gently break to them that FIL is poorly and is deteriorating, and he is not going to get better to full on eating, walking etc.

The home are trying their best to get him to eat - but I get it he is tired, he is 88 he never wanted to be poked and prodded. They can't force him to drink we can talk about ways of encouraging him so his favourite soft drinks etc but I do feel we could be 'rinsing and repeating' what we had this week.

I am very tired and brain is not thinking - help me with some words/phrases I can use to say that he is fighting a loosing battle with the dementia and we've seen him go from independent living a few months ago to two hospital visits in as many weeks and they need to start thinking of preparing themselves to say goodbye.

I can't do it by call as - SIL and one BIL have made their feelings very clear that they don't like me, and siblings live in different parts of the world - and this isn't about their feelings towards me its about me and DH doing the right thing by FIL.

OP posts:
wited · 14/11/2023 21:42

I think you've misunderstood the guidelines too.

I would just say FIL has taken a turn for the worse and it's not looking good. Please get in touch with DH for a full update or go and see him in x hospital ward x.

GRex · 14/11/2023 21:42

It needs to come from your DH, but it doesn't matter what your DH says, that won't change anything nor make it easier. Suggest that he just keep it simple and let them bring questions, that's easier. "Sorry to tell you bad news, but Dad is very unwell and frail, his memory is also very poor now. Let me know if you want me to help with any video calls, or if you are coming here to see him."

Silvers11 · 14/11/2023 21:38

@makesmestronger - I think you have misread the NICE guidelines. I think severely frail means that he is NOT expected to die within the next 6 months.

I think it would be better before you do anything, if you ask the hospital/his GP whatever to clarify. The last thing that the wider family need is to be told oh you need to come quick because he's likely to be gone in the next 6 months - and then he's still here in a year. He is likely to be in and out of hospital for a while. My late Mother was in and then out and home again for a while - and then back in again. And that went on for more than 3 years! It's very common

Definitely a good idea to let them know exactly how much he has deteriorated, and they may want to visit him before he no longer recognises them etc. but not put a complete 'this is nearly the end message on it' until the hospital tell you that. But I also agree with others - it should be your DH who tells them that and not you, when you know some of them don't like you. And if not all the family get on with all the others, ask those you speak to to let the others know?

Very hard for you and DH and I feel for you

Birdcar · 14/11/2023 21:37

I don't think your dh needs to say anything beyond stating the facts of what the hospital has said. Let them interpret it how they may.

At 88, with dementia and regular hospitalisations anyone who is denial is choosing to be in denial and that's their prerogative. They won't take kindly to being told otherwise. They will shoot the messenger.

WaWaWaWaaaaaa · 14/11/2023 21:34

Isn't it better to avoid making it like some grand formal announcement. Why not a short update and then see what other people on the group chat respond with.

misshersoup · 14/11/2023 21:34

I get your intention, and I've seen the denial from people who aren't primarily involved/responsible for the person.

But I think start preparing to say goodbye soon is a bit alarmist if taken literally. I think you could say "he could go anytime" or something like that.

This sounds like the start (which wasn't really a beginning, more like a sharp fall of a cliff in graph terms, though she'd been going downhill for a while before that) of my grandma's incidences / crazy deterioration. We all thought she was going to die soon – shocking to see someone so full of life become a shell of their former self. Dementia worsening, the futile going in and out of hospital (where she had to be tied up to not pull any tubes out), incontinence, refusal to eat food and drink, in dreadful pain all the time, etc... And then it was an almost awful 5 years of her being basically immobile, going and coming into hospital from various incidences for various attempted patchwork by doctors and nurses, etc etc, until the doctors actually literally told us it was time to say goodbye and it was (but they only can in very specific predictable instances of course). But it could equally have been 5 months or 5 weeks, because every incident was touch and go in someone so severely frail.

Heronwatcher · 14/11/2023 21:32

Very sorry to hear about your FIL but yes, if his family already don’t like you then keep out of it (apart from supporting your DH). Nothing you do will be right and for them having a difficult message delivered by someone they don’t like will make it worse. If I was your DH I’d send something very simple and encourage them to visit for themselves and speak to his care team.

Screamingabdabz · 14/11/2023 21:24

Consideringachange2023 · 14/11/2023 21:07

No it isn’t coming off overbearing

WTAF is wrong with half the ppl on this thread. OP has said she wouldn’t be sending it but wants to help DH to word the message appropriately.

It is very clear that a lot of people on here have either never had a loved one at end of life or never supported a partner through the loss of a loved one. Or possibly don’t even have a partner because who would just say
to their partner, who was facing the death of their parent “nowt to do with me love, write your own message”

ffs

It’s you that lacks empathy. My DF died in similar circumstances last year and if my SIL (who I get along with actually) had taken it upon herself to send me a message like that I would’ve been angry and hurt. And yes, I get that op wants to ‘find words’ for her husband, but I would know straight away if a text that came from my brother was actually written by him or not.

This is a situation where as hard as it is, OP’s husband needs to go it alone and do the right thing. He needs to find the inner resource and pick up the phone and talk to his siblings.

ilovemyspace · 14/11/2023 21:22

@JudgeJ It seems to be the MN way that only the biological child has any responsibility regarding parents but if a couple have been together for a long time and the relationship has been generally good then it's not unknown for both to care and be involved.

The MN universe is a weird and wonderful place indeed! 😂

RusemaneGanche · 14/11/2023 21:12

Putting myself in the siblings shoes:

I don't like one of my BIL's. And neither do my other two siblings. I won't derail by explaining why, but we don't speak to him.

If my DF was dying, and my BIL took it upon himself to tell us such sensitive emotional information about MY DF via a group WhatsApp, I'd not be happy. Not happy at all.

I appreciate the reason your DHs siblings not liking you are probably nothing close to the reason why me and my siblings don't like my BIL, but I can't see it going down well with them.

If your DH is just too drained to be making several phonecalls, then I can totally get behind a WhatsApp message, as it only needs doing once to reach everyone. But it really should come from your DH. Whatever the reasons are for your DHs siblings not liking you are (and are justified or not), I'd still recommend treading carefully with this.

Maybe you and DH can discuss the wording together, and writing it down. That'd be giving him the support he needs without riling up the siblings and creating any unnecessary and unwanted extra tension and drama.

Maybe your DH could do a WhatsApp voice note instead, so its at least more personal and doesn't come across as cold?

ETA please don't you an AI chat bot to do this!!!

YeahIsaidit · 14/11/2023 21:09

Cress42 · 14/11/2023 20:43

You need to use chat gpt for this @makesmestronger

i just pasted in your OP and it gave me this:

Family, it's been a challenging time for FIL, and we've witnessed a significant decline in his health. The recent hospital visits have shown that he's facing severe challenges due to his dementia. It's a tough reality, and we should be prepared for what may come. We're here to support each other during this difficult journey.

Then I asked for a little more detail and to focus on the key words etc that you noted and it wrote this:

Dear Family,

I hope this message finds you all as well as can be expected during these challenging times. I wanted to take a moment to share some heartfelt concerns about FIL's current health situation.

Over the past few months, we've witnessed a profound change in FIL's condition. From his once independent and lively self, the grip of dementia has tightened its hold, and it's evident that he's facing a losing battle with this relentless disease. The recent hospital visits, especially the ones in the last couple of weeks, have been eye-opening for us.

It's difficult to see someone we love go through such a rapid decline. FIL's struggle with dementia has taken a toll, and it's heart-wrenching to acknowledge the challenges he faces daily. From his independent living just a few months ago to now grappling with two hospital visits within such a short span, it's clear that his situation is becoming increasingly fragile.

I believe it's important for us, as a family, to face the reality of this situation. The impact of dementia on FIL's well-being is profound, and it's crucial that we start preparing ourselves emotionally for what may lie ahead. It's a difficult conversation to have, but acknowledging the gravity of the situation allows us to better support each other during these trying times.

I understand that distance and individual circumstances make it challenging for everyone to be physically present, but our collective emotional support can make a significant difference. Let's come together, not just for FIL but for each other, as we navigate these uncertain waters.

Sending love and strength to you all.

[Your Name]

Chat GPT literally takes seconds and you can go back and forth with it adding more detail or asking for more or less as needed

No, no no did you really suggest using an AI bot to draft a group text with that sort of news?! What on earth is wrong with people?!

Consideringachange2023 · 14/11/2023 21:07

No it isn’t coming off overbearing

WTAF is wrong with half the ppl on this thread. OP has said she wouldn’t be sending it but wants to help DH to word the message appropriately.

It is very clear that a lot of people on here have either never had a loved one at end of life or never supported a partner through the loss of a loved one. Or possibly don’t even have a partner because who would just say
to their partner, who was facing the death of their parent “nowt to do with me love, write your own message”

ffs

HikingforScenery · 14/11/2023 21:04

That sounds really hard for you😍two, OP💐

parietal · 14/11/2023 21:02

can you tell the relatives what hospital your FIL is in and give a phone no for the hospital? that way, they can call the ward and get information without having to go through you, if they prefer that

Traceyislivid · 14/11/2023 20:58

YABU. This is absolutely not for a whats app group message. Each relative needs to be called individually and open discussions had. If they still choose to be in denial then there’s not much more you can do. They need to make informed decisions by hearing all the facts.
the group dynamic is irrelevant at this point too.

JudgeJ · 14/11/2023 20:52

ilovemyspace · 14/11/2023 18:44

I'm not sure why people are insisting that it's nothing to do with you and it's all down to your husband?
You both have POA and presumably you want to work together and support each other at this time ..........

It seems to be the MN way that only the biological child has any responsibility regarding parents but if a couple have been together for a long time and the relationship has been generally good then it's not unknown for both to care and be involved.

Cress42 · 14/11/2023 20:43

You need to use chat gpt for this @makesmestronger

i just pasted in your OP and it gave me this:

Family, it's been a challenging time for FIL, and we've witnessed a significant decline in his health. The recent hospital visits have shown that he's facing severe challenges due to his dementia. It's a tough reality, and we should be prepared for what may come. We're here to support each other during this difficult journey.

Then I asked for a little more detail and to focus on the key words etc that you noted and it wrote this:

Dear Family,

I hope this message finds you all as well as can be expected during these challenging times. I wanted to take a moment to share some heartfelt concerns about FIL's current health situation.

Over the past few months, we've witnessed a profound change in FIL's condition. From his once independent and lively self, the grip of dementia has tightened its hold, and it's evident that he's facing a losing battle with this relentless disease. The recent hospital visits, especially the ones in the last couple of weeks, have been eye-opening for us.

It's difficult to see someone we love go through such a rapid decline. FIL's struggle with dementia has taken a toll, and it's heart-wrenching to acknowledge the challenges he faces daily. From his independent living just a few months ago to now grappling with two hospital visits within such a short span, it's clear that his situation is becoming increasingly fragile.

I believe it's important for us, as a family, to face the reality of this situation. The impact of dementia on FIL's well-being is profound, and it's crucial that we start preparing ourselves emotionally for what may lie ahead. It's a difficult conversation to have, but acknowledging the gravity of the situation allows us to better support each other during these trying times.

I understand that distance and individual circumstances make it challenging for everyone to be physically present, but our collective emotional support can make a significant difference. Let's come together, not just for FIL but for each other, as we navigate these uncertain waters.

Sending love and strength to you all.

[Your Name]

Chat GPT literally takes seconds and you can go back and forth with it adding more detail or asking for more or less as needed

JoanOfAllTrades · 14/11/2023 20:42

@makesmestronger

Please don’t do this. Wait until he’s on palliative measures. If he has seen a palliative consultant, then you should ask them, or the palliative care nurses for help with wording for the conversations that must be had.

I worked in palliative care and used to help the next of kin with wording for their families.

But the time to do that isn’t now. You haven’t been told that he’s got 6 months to live. And severely frail could be that he needs care plans to be implemented so that once he does become palliative, everyone is on the same page!

Once his UTI has cleared, you may find that it’s easier to engage him, since UTI’s make older adults confused anyway.

Also, you can’t tell people this sort of news in a mass text over WhatsApp.

You need to either personalise it for each person, or even better, have what you want to say written down and call them.

Your DH can do this with your support. You also need to make sure that you have the contact details of the treating gerontologist or palliative consultant so that they can call them directly, as they may be in denial.

Gerwurtztraminer · 14/11/2023 20:41

makesmestronger · 14/11/2023 19:11

Thank you for your replies, I think you are right the message needs to come from DH, but I need to help him with the wording - I lost my Dad a few years ago and its a hell of a roller coaster ride to see them in hospital, then sitting up and talking to you, then take a turn for the worse.

DH is also struggling with his feelings too and I want to support him to find the right words so the family are informed and can they can make an informed decision to visit FIL or not.

Unfortunately the family are fractured, some siblings talk to some siblings but not one of them talk to all of their brothers or sister - just to add to the challenge

We had a similar situation with my mother, also similar age. Like your family some of us live abroad, including me, and one sibling is very low contact and only communicates with me. Another sibling had POA and she posted regular updates for us on each visit to the care home Fairly factual and not being too alarmist but it flagged the decline. By this stage she didn't recognise anyone, was virtually non verbal, incontinent and only able to walk with help,. We'd agreed with sister that there would be no hospital admissions just 'keep her comfortable" in her bed. So message were like this e.g
"Saw Mum today, she was too tired & weak to get out of bed and quite distressed & upset, so I sat with her for a while chatting until she went back to sleep.
"Hi All, Mum had a good day today, drank some tea and ate a bit of cake though care staff said her weight has dropped a lot to XX as she's refusing to eat much and they struggle to get her to drink fluids too."
"Hi everyone, mum has a chest infection and it isn't responding to antibiotics. She's sleeping a lot and breathing is very laboured. Care home said they are very concerned and will monitor her overnight. I'll let you know how things are in the morning".

Basically all this gave us a picture of what was going on and prepared us for it when she did pass away. She actually got pneumonia three times over about 8 months and every time we thought her time was up but we'd then get a message she'd perked up again. So it's really hard to predict.

Soontobe60 · 14/11/2023 20:36

54isanopendoor · 14/11/2023 18:35

Dear Family WhatsApp Group,

I am sorry to have to tell you that FIL condition has deteriorated considerably.
I realise that it was not long ago that he was doing quite well, but H & I are seeing him daily & he is now going downhill rapidly. On his Hospital Discharge papers 2 weeks ago he was described as 'severely frail'. He is now back in hospital - dehydrated, struggling to eat & sadly struggling to focus at all. He cannot use his phone now & can't remember people for any length of time.
We understand you care about him & so we wanted you to be aware of how things are for him now. Please know we are doing all we can to support him but you may wish to start thinking about any conversations you want to have NOW.

This is probably not great but it might help you iterate what you do want to say?

This is perfect!

porridgeisbae · 14/11/2023 20:34

@makesmestronger I wouldn't put it as 'they need to get ready to say goodbye.' Severe frailty can be somewhat reversed, and I don't think the six months thing is necessarily right- I mean you could be right but you need to get the facts about your FiL and the outlook for him from his doctors. You could ask the doctors what you should say to family.

Your husband needs to be the one to speak to his family about it.

I would suggest you have a serious conversation with the doctors about what they think, then your DH can relay that info to his family.

loreau · 14/11/2023 20:33

It’s not an easy one to send. And even if you got the wording and timing just right, they’d still hold it against you because they don’t particularly like you and will hold you responsible for the substance of the message. They will respond better to a message from your husband.

Shit, I know. But I have always often found the “who” is the most important elements of communication.

Eleanor6 · 14/11/2023 20:28

It is very difficult, I agree that your dh needs to be the one sending messages re your fil, I would ask for a meeting with his dr or nurse and get their opinion. The group message can be their words not your opinion. My mum is very similar to your fil, she is very unwell and yet she is still here, she survives on very little food and fluids. She has been classed as severely frail for over a year, it’s a cruel disease.

HoraceGoesBonkers · 14/11/2023 20:24

My DF has had three situations where he was possibly EOL and we were told to say goodbye. Doctors tend to err on the side of caution about EOL anyway. Three years after the first of them he is still hanging in a care home he was admitted to 18 months ago.

I'd steer well clear of saying anything.

You also might find the Elderly Parents board helpful.

SoSad44 · 14/11/2023 20:20

FuckingHellAdele · 14/11/2023 18:35

If they wouldn't welcome a phone call from you, you shouldn't message. This is one for your husband.

Exactly this!

Swipe left for the next trending thread