Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

End of Life Message - please help me with wording

111 replies

makesmestronger · 14/11/2023 18:16

Firstly apologies for posting here, and apologies if this is triggering.

My DH and I are power of attorney for my FIL. Sadly FIL was diagnosed with Dementia and Alzheimer earlier this year, he refused to take meds and the disease has progressed quite quickly.

In May since the diagnosis where he was living independently quite happily, he is now in a care home, can't use his mobile phone, loosing weight, he can't have a conversation with someone (as engage in the conversation) he can't remember people that visited him 2 days ago. He was admitted to hospital 2 weeks ago and has now come home with a catheter, which he has pulled out on one occasion and is constantly 'tugging at it'. On the hospital discharge notes he was measured/documented as severely frail, when I looked this up on NICE they are saying he has 6 months or less to live.

He was admitted back in to hospital yesterday with blood in the urine, and he was dehydrated.

There is a family whattsapp group for his elderly sister (DH's Aunt) and the 4 other siblings of DH. The sister is in denial that her DF is poorly and I want to try and gently break to them that FIL is poorly and is deteriorating, and he is not going to get better to full on eating, walking etc.

The home are trying their best to get him to eat - but I get it he is tired, he is 88 he never wanted to be poked and prodded. They can't force him to drink we can talk about ways of encouraging him so his favourite soft drinks etc but I do feel we could be 'rinsing and repeating' what we had this week.

I am very tired and brain is not thinking - help me with some words/phrases I can use to say that he is fighting a loosing battle with the dementia and we've seen him go from independent living a few months ago to two hospital visits in as many weeks and they need to start thinking of preparing themselves to say goodbye.

I can't do it by call as - SIL and one BIL have made their feelings very clear that they don't like me, and siblings live in different parts of the world - and this isn't about their feelings towards me its about me and DH doing the right thing by FIL.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
itsmeafterall · 15/11/2023 07:57

@54isanopendoor suggestion is perfect.

When my granny was dying my dad went into complete denial. I ended up going to pick him up, manhandling him into my car and driving him to the hospital. We said our goodbyes and she died a handful of hours later. If I hadn't been so forceful he would have missed her, and he was grateful for the intervention. It's not uncommon for people to wither not realise, accept or want to acknowledge that the end is close.

Sometimes it's hard for people to accept the finality and awfulness of it all. The message above is perfect, gently and sensitively written. It gives them the facts and their chance to act if they want or need to. That's as much as you can do.

Hospitals and care homes are usually pretty good in telling you when the end is very close, so I hope that you'll have a further opportunity for all lf you to say your final farewells when the times comes.

I spoke to a dementia doctor once and he said that studies had shown that even with the minimal brain function, people with dementia still had special, measurable brain activity when hearing the voices of the people they love. So he will know who you are and that you are there, which is a huge comfort.

I'm sorry that you are losing your FIL and hope that his and your suffering isn't too awful for you all. Flowers

Angrymum22 · 14/11/2023 23:06

At this point in time I would be looking to discuss the practicalities of end of life car rather than an overly dramatic announcement.
Discuss who wants to be notified if he takes a downturn, and who wants to visit him at this stage. They need to make a clear decision regarding a DNR order. It may be like herding cats but it is so much easier to make decisions about your FIL’s care if everyone is in agreement, and before emotion takes over. You may be surprised by the relief this sort of discussion imparts.
I think your DH needs to stress that all though he is the first point of contact he understands that it should be a family decision. He can give them a few weeks to think about it but then they need formulate a plan.
Keeping it all very matter of fact and no big dramatic announcement should help.
They all know he’s 88 with dementia and deteriorating. They are probably all waiting for the subject to come up. Sometimes you just need someone to take the lead.

Birdcar · 14/11/2023 23:03

Am I right in thinking that no one in the medical profession has said that the family need to say their goodbyes and that this is all coming from a google search of the term 'severely frail'?

In my experience the palliative care team are the ones who, if asked directly, will tell it like it is. Your Dh needs to talk to them before either of you start acting on the results of your Google search.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 14/11/2023 22:47

As for those AI messages: fucking hell.

They are absolute mawkish shite.

"In these challenging times", "these trying times" ... it's like a government minister trying to justify lockdown.

The grammar is rubbish in places, too.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 14/11/2023 22:43

Oh dear - as a million other PP have said, OP, your husband is the one who should be contacting his family (if he feels it appropriate at this stage).

The messages some people have suggested on here would be akin to throwing a hand grenade into his already fractured family relations.

Step away. Support him in whatever he wants to do or say about his father's illness, but don't overstep.

FWIW, I am a Luddite so don't have Whatsapp etc, but I can't imagine that a group chat is an appropriate method to communicate. I would ring the people concerned (and wouldn't ask my DP to do it for me).

misshersoup · 14/11/2023 22:38

@Runnerinthenight ok firstly, calm down 😅 secondly, they might have in your mother's case, but from experience, they won't be able to in the case of many old people (especially similar to what OP describes). Also, no one is suggesting Google – certainly not me.

Runnerinthenight · 14/11/2023 22:34

misshersoup · 14/11/2023 21:47

I think the hospital won't be able to provide an actual prognosis (or well, death date, like the Grim Reaper)!

From experience, if death is really imminent and almost completely inevitable in an old frail person (eg something catastrophic has happened like sepsis or organ bursting or organ failure), they will tell you explicitly and strongly urge you to get everyone to say goodbye.

Most other times, they probably know the old person could go anytime but equally might hang on for years in that limbo. Or they may wrongly gauge an incidence's severity and then death unexpectedly happens.

It's probably good to say goodbye and make peace, whether to avoid regrets for impending death, or in preparation for the long uphill battle if FIL stays alive.

But I agree that OP shouldn't put words in the doctors' mouth re: FIL's prognosis.

Edited

Well it's not like they're going to give a precise ETA is it!

But they can predict a potential timescale, for example, a week or so before my mum died in late November, the doctor told us she was unlikely to see Christmas.

More realistic than Dr Google, I would think!!

Howdoesitworkagain · 14/11/2023 22:29

Sweet Jesus at the ChatGPT suggestion 😳 wow

What were you thinking?!

NotStartedChristmasShoppingYet · 14/11/2023 22:27

YeahIsaidit · 14/11/2023 18:40

There's a difference between being supportive and muscling in on everything and feeling it's your duty to inform others of what's going on

Succinctly put.
I don’t get why op is so keen to rush and tell family in this way.

porridgeisbae · 14/11/2023 22:26

it's evident that he's facing a losing battle with this relentless disease.

Who TAF would send that whole morbid chat GPT thing? It's a sad situation enough without adding an extra dose of clinically depressing longwindedness.

Selenitetower · 14/11/2023 22:25

I work in a nursing home and as it’s been mentioned in the thread people with dementia and in your FILs condition can hold on for quite some time. I wouldn’t be writing up any messages that indicate that he may pass soon as he may not. I’m sure this all feels very fast (the decline) and that death is not to far away but in my experience people can remain immobile and bed bound with little to no food and water intake for a very long time. I would send a factual message updating them about the recent hospitalisations and the catheter and they can do with that information as they wish, if they want to visit they will. Keep visiting him regularly and follow the advice of the nurses in the care home and advise the family of any future changes.

porridgeisbae · 14/11/2023 22:22

I don't think anyone is saying OP shouldn't support her DH of course. Just that any message should come from him, because OP isn't that close to the recipients.

I don't think anything should be written without speaking to the doctors and getting them to give their view on what's going on. What we have here is OP has got herself worried, plus read something wrong on the internet (internet health searches are notorious for giving people the horrors.)

Don't get me wrong, she might be right but the people to tell her that are FiL's doctors.

JoanOfAllTrades · 14/11/2023 22:17

@JudgeJ @ilovemyspace

OP has already said that her BIL and SIL’s don’t like her. Hence it’s better coming from DP. Nothing to do with the Mumsnet way. Purely family dynamics!

AcrossthePond55 · 14/11/2023 22:13

DH and I have been in this situation with both sets of parents, years ago way before social media. We called family members directly. There were no 'rifts' on my side so it was easy. But my DH and his DB were not on speaking terms when his mother was 'failing badly' so he asked an uncle to relay the information and gave him the nurse's station phone number to give to his brother.

I believe that DH should call the ones he can call and deliver the information personally by phone. Then advise them that he will shortly be posting a group message.

Yellownotblue · 14/11/2023 22:09

Cress42 · 14/11/2023 20:43

You need to use chat gpt for this @makesmestronger

i just pasted in your OP and it gave me this:

Family, it's been a challenging time for FIL, and we've witnessed a significant decline in his health. The recent hospital visits have shown that he's facing severe challenges due to his dementia. It's a tough reality, and we should be prepared for what may come. We're here to support each other during this difficult journey.

Then I asked for a little more detail and to focus on the key words etc that you noted and it wrote this:

Dear Family,

I hope this message finds you all as well as can be expected during these challenging times. I wanted to take a moment to share some heartfelt concerns about FIL's current health situation.

Over the past few months, we've witnessed a profound change in FIL's condition. From his once independent and lively self, the grip of dementia has tightened its hold, and it's evident that he's facing a losing battle with this relentless disease. The recent hospital visits, especially the ones in the last couple of weeks, have been eye-opening for us.

It's difficult to see someone we love go through such a rapid decline. FIL's struggle with dementia has taken a toll, and it's heart-wrenching to acknowledge the challenges he faces daily. From his independent living just a few months ago to now grappling with two hospital visits within such a short span, it's clear that his situation is becoming increasingly fragile.

I believe it's important for us, as a family, to face the reality of this situation. The impact of dementia on FIL's well-being is profound, and it's crucial that we start preparing ourselves emotionally for what may lie ahead. It's a difficult conversation to have, but acknowledging the gravity of the situation allows us to better support each other during these trying times.

I understand that distance and individual circumstances make it challenging for everyone to be physically present, but our collective emotional support can make a significant difference. Let's come together, not just for FIL but for each other, as we navigate these uncertain waters.

Sending love and strength to you all.

[Your Name]

Chat GPT literally takes seconds and you can go back and forth with it adding more detail or asking for more or less as needed

I find this beyond creepy, but I recognise that some people who struggle with words might find this better than anything they could write themselves.

Still, it’s nauseating and I hope that’s not the future of humanity. 😔

GettinChillyHereFFS · 14/11/2023 22:07

RunningFromInsanity · 14/11/2023 18:37

Supporting her husband at a devastating time is not really involving herself too much.

She could send the message from his phone so it looks like it's from him, if he can't do it.

Yellownotblue · 14/11/2023 22:02

We had this situation with my mother. I have 3 sisters, 2 I’m close with and the third one (let’s call her Eva) is really odd and we are very low contact.

I was alone with DM when she was told by the consultant there was no treatment avenue left for her terminal cancer, and she needed to prepare for the end. I tried to share that information as gently as I could with my sisters, but Eva took it very badly, like I was wishing DM dead and wanted to withdraw care from her. She was adamant DM shouldn’t be moved to a hospice, even though that was the only alternative to a hospital death.

In the end DM died two weeks later in hospital, having refused (on Eva’s insistence) a hospice place. For context, this was in Canada where hospices can provide very significantly better conditions at end of life.

The reality is that people have all sorts of weird reactions to pain and grief. If people feel, for whatever reason, that you are “against” them, they will put that interpretation on whatever news you give them.

If your SIL and BIL already don’t like or trust you, then I’m afraid there’s nothing you can do to help them prepare for this. They will not thank you and they will resent you. It’s not worth your effort and heartache.

I’m sorry OP, this sucks. I hope your FIL has a peaceful and pain free end. 💐

YeahIsaidit · 14/11/2023 21:59

Silvers11 · 14/11/2023 21:53

I too would be appalled if I received that AI created message. It is awful and so stilted. I too would be going wtf? If I received it in similar circumstances

Yeah, it reads like a god awful BBC radio 4 monologue or some shit. Regardless, suggesting using a fucking robot to draft a message about such an emotive and personal thing is mental

rwalker · 14/11/2023 21:57

I’d keep it simple just say there’s been a steep decline in his health

it make them awar the sit has changed and they can follow up if they want with you or care home and doctors

Silvers11 · 14/11/2023 21:53

YeahIsaidit · 14/11/2023 21:09

No, no no did you really suggest using an AI bot to draft a group text with that sort of news?! What on earth is wrong with people?!

I too would be appalled if I received that AI created message. It is awful and so stilted. I too would be going wtf? If I received it in similar circumstances

Lovemychair · 14/11/2023 21:49

Do they know that he's been in and out of hospital? I'd expect them to be asking for updates tbh .

SwirlyWhirls · 14/11/2023 21:48

Sorry, but if you know already that they don’t like you then it’ll clearly not help for you to say anything. It will only annoy them, probably. This is for your DH to deal with.

misshersoup · 14/11/2023 21:47

I think the hospital won't be able to provide an actual prognosis (or well, death date, like the Grim Reaper)!

From experience, if death is really imminent and almost completely inevitable in an old frail person (eg something catastrophic has happened like sepsis or organ bursting or organ failure), they will tell you explicitly and strongly urge you to get everyone to say goodbye.

Most other times, they probably know the old person could go anytime but equally might hang on for years in that limbo. Or they may wrongly gauge an incidence's severity and then death unexpectedly happens.

It's probably good to say goodbye and make peace, whether to avoid regrets for impending death, or in preparation for the long uphill battle if FIL stays alive.

But I agree that OP shouldn't put words in the doctors' mouth re: FIL's prognosis.

Runnerinthenight · 14/11/2023 21:43

YeahIsaidit · 14/11/2023 21:09

No, no no did you really suggest using an AI bot to draft a group text with that sort of news?! What on earth is wrong with people?!

If someone had sent me that, I'd be wondering WTAF was wrong with them!!!

Having been in this situation, I think you need to take a step back. By all means support your DH but do it behind the scenes.

Clearly there is already a lot of bad feeling. Your intervention however well-intentioned is likely to add to that.

This is not a matter for a WhatsApp group chat. Your DH will need to lift the phone and have an actual conversation.

Before he does though, you should make an appointment with your FIL's hospital consultant and ask about the prognosis instead of googling it. That way, your DH will have actual information to pass on, and family members can decide what they do with it.

misshersoup · 14/11/2023 21:42

SkyFullofStars1975 · 14/11/2023 18:45

I've worked in care, OP, and you'd be amazed how long people can hold on for without much in terms of food/drink. The body can take a long time to shut down, and he could be like this for a considerable period of time. It's common to be bouncing in and out of hospital, and he may need to be in a nursing home as opposed to a care home where his care can be managed more effectively to avoid this.

I would send a simple message that his health has sadly taken a downward turn from which there isn't a prospect of recovery, and if anyone wishes to visit, it's an idea to do so before he is too poorly for visitors.

Ah thank you this is what I was saying, and nicely describes the last 5 years of my grandma's life, and come to think of it the last 10+ years of my other grandma (in a nursing home – dementia, had to be force fed or drip fed, had every single symptom/incident OP describes, was hospitalised for the same reasons as in the OP among many, eventually only died from Covid).

He could really be gone soon, but sometimes dying takes a really long time even where they're in absolutely no state to live, going in and out of hospital lots too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread