Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to buy - grossly unfair on private renters and private home owners

210 replies

Winterday1991 · 14/11/2023 15:57

Is it just me or is RTB grossly unfair. People that already have cheap subsidised rent and a secure tenancy can get over to £105k off the market value of their council property.

This seems so unfair to us who have to brought in the private market at full market price and private renters who often do not have secure long term tenancies. Why should the public subsidise this?

OP posts:
Issummernearlyover · 14/11/2023 16:46

My friend has been offered 10 per cent reduction to buy her house. That's £30,000. She has already paid £72,000 in rent. The mortgage would be more than twice her rent so she's not going to buy it. I don't know where OP gets her figures from.

diddl · 14/11/2023 16:44

Even with cheaper rent some will have paid a good chunk towards it before they buy.

Like other homeowners they are then responsible for the upkeep.

If houses sold were replaced then it would have been workable I think.

Riverstep · 14/11/2023 16:42

Well, going by previous threads on here the houses are on estates that a lot of people don’t want to live on anyway 🤷‍♀️. Should more social housing have been built to counteract the losses? Perhaps but then people wouldn’t be happy that those on a low income/ unemployed etc were getting a brand new house at discounted rates. It really is a no win situation. I believe some councils have an open market purchase scheme to help address the shortage of social housing. To be honest I found the help to buy policy worse. Encouraging first time buyers to buy expensive houses on new build estates that they just could not afford without a large loan from the govt. I think ‘right to buy’ and ‘help to buy’ have both ceased in England now anyway.

UsernameCreater · 14/11/2023 16:38

VickyEadieofThigh · 14/11/2023 16:04

It's stripped the country of social housing, driving rental prices sky high and leaving many families and individuals with no choice and inadequate housing.

It was an awful policy when Thatcher invented it and it still is.

This is the issue for me. We are at a loss for social housing and selling them on cheaply means more and more people on the list for council housing who are stuck waiting.

Of we had more social and affordable housing being built and fewer people languishing on lists desperate for homes I don’t think I’d feel the same way.

NeedToChangeName · 14/11/2023 16:36

RudsyFarmer · 14/11/2023 16:12

I never understood it as a policy. I remember my father absolutely furious that our neighbour bought his identical next door semi for about £4K when he had a £200k mortgage on ours.

@RudsyFarmer Margaret Thatcher introduced right to buy, assuming that it would convert council tenants into home-owning Tory voters

Is right to buy still an option in England? I assumed it had been abolished years ago (as in Scotland)

Foxesandsquirrels · 14/11/2023 16:28

It was a very very short sighted policy as it never really planned for how these lost homes will be replaced. It was all because traditionally the conservative voter was a home owner so thatcher wanted as many of those as possible.

Teapot32 · 14/11/2023 16:28

OhmygodDont · 14/11/2023 16:22

It could work amazingly if it was done correctly.

Only sold off houses over X years old so basically the harder to maintain older homes. All monies from the sale had to go into building new houses so for every 1 sold a new 1 must be created. Anyone who purchased their council house should they become a council tenant again never got the right to buy again, all funds for the deposit should of been proven to be saved via the tenant not a friend or family member “gifting” them the deposit when what was really happening was a non tenant was buying their mums or aunties house for themselves really.

I think there might be a rule that if you sell your council house within 10 years of using the RTB scheme then you first have to offer to sell it back to the council at a reduced rate or something to that effect. Could be wrong though

G3t88 · 14/11/2023 16:26

Teapot32 · 14/11/2023 16:16

@G3t88 that’s because everyone else is paying something that’s stupidly over inflated. I’m just amazed that people can be so bitter about people in social housing 🤷‍♀️ it’s not that big a deal

You're wrong. Take Lincoln for example (just because it came first in a Google search).

The council charge just £88 per week for a 3 bed property under their social housing rent bracket, and £129.85 per week for their affordable rent bracket.

They have 7396 properties on their social rent, and just 375 properties on their affordable rent. They even specify that their affordable rent is set at 80% market value.

I'd imagine that most councils operate a similar policy.

Source: https://www.lincoln.gov.uk/downloads/file/49/council-house-and-garage-rents-2023-to-2024

https://www.lincoln.gov.uk/downloads/file/49/council-house-and-garage-rents-2023-to-2024

HighywayToHell · 14/11/2023 16:25

Winterday1991 · 14/11/2023 15:57

Is it just me or is RTB grossly unfair. People that already have cheap subsidised rent and a secure tenancy can get over to £105k off the market value of their council property.

This seems so unfair to us who have to brought in the private market at full market price and private renters who often do not have secure long term tenancies. Why should the public subsidise this?

I’m in social housing my rent is neither cheap nor subsidised. The house a few doors down is up for private rent and works out at roughly £100 a month more than I am paying. Please tell me who is subsiding my rent so I can have a word with them about the piss poor job they are doing.

CranfordScones · 14/11/2023 16:24

It fulfills an ideological aim: that people 'should' somehow aspire to home ownership. In some ways it reduces the class divide between homeowners and social housing renters. In theory most parties would support the aim, if not the actual policy.

But it's a lot of money to serve that aim which is allocated solely to those who already have a social housing tenancy and are able and willing to buy the property. The allocation of the funds is very arbitrary. It's politically enticing because the 'subsidy' doesn't show up on anyone's accounts so the immediate budgetary cost appears to be nothing. If you had to subsidise people to buy a privately owned property, you'd have to write out a big cheque. It's a jam-today policy, but with an unseen long term cost.

And it's left local authorities critically short of housing. The real problem is: we haven't allowed house building to keep up with the increase in population.

I know of one housing association (in Scotland) that actively tries to buy back any suitable houses that come on the market, especially 3 beds, of which it's critically short.

Fawbs89 · 14/11/2023 16:23

My mum used right to buy around 21 years ago to buy a lovely house she would not have otherwise had thw opportunity to buy (single mum of 4 children) it gave us the opportunity to grow up in a lovely area at a good school and feel secure. Myself now as an adult (34) is unfortunately not in a position to buy a property presently but I don't sit her envious or jealous of my mums situation (she was lucky and obtained a Council house in an affluent area of Cheshore). My motto in life is always concentrate on your own life and not how others live theirs.

BIossomtoes · 14/11/2023 16:23

But I'm also not sure what the alternative is.

Stop doing it and build lots more social housing. It’s not rocket science.

OhmygodDont · 14/11/2023 16:22

It could work amazingly if it was done correctly.

Only sold off houses over X years old so basically the harder to maintain older homes. All monies from the sale had to go into building new houses so for every 1 sold a new 1 must be created. Anyone who purchased their council house should they become a council tenant again never got the right to buy again, all funds for the deposit should of been proven to be saved via the tenant not a friend or family member “gifting” them the deposit when what was really happening was a non tenant was buying their mums or aunties house for themselves really.

candywoo · 14/11/2023 16:20

I don't agree with the policy as it has created a shortage of social housing and a reason for an increase in homelessness.

But I wouldn't say its unfair to people who can private rent or buy their own home. It gives lower income families a chance to buy a home when they otherwise wouldn't be able to.

PinkflowersWhiteBerries · 14/11/2023 16:19

God knows where the money went…

Exactly this. I have vague memories of it being touted as an answer to funding care - as in let people buy their council built homes and then sell them to fund care. Well that’s worked a treat.

But really, as a business model, selling capital assets and using the money to subsidise current expenditure is a race to the bottom. Unless they actively reinvest the sales returns in more housing stock, the councils will run out of homes to rent,,, oh, wait ..

Locally, (Scotland) our council has been taking on private rentals as emergency housing stock. Helluva deal for the landlords. Guaranteed rent , Council maintains to the standard they take over, council tax paid if empty.
You cannot make this stuff up.

LemonLimeDivine · 14/11/2023 16:18

Of course it’s hugely unfair.

Teapot32 · 14/11/2023 16:16

@G3t88 that’s because everyone else is paying something that’s stupidly over inflated. I’m just amazed that people can be so bitter about people in social housing 🤷‍♀️ it’s not that big a deal

Teapot32 · 14/11/2023 16:15

flipent · 14/11/2023 16:12

You're right, it isn't fair.
I've privately rented for 20 years, and have just managed to buy at full market value.

My colleague is in Housing Association property with reduced rents and apparently a new kitchen and bathroom every 10 years for free (which I did not get in my private rental and will not get in my home). I don't know if they also have the right to buy.

But I'm also not sure what the alternative is.

You don’t get a new kitchen and bathroom every 10 years. This is a misconception (I worked for a HA). Also that stops if you buy the property but typically with HA homes it’s not right to buy, it’s right to acquire and has a lot less advantages/discount.

G3t88 · 14/11/2023 16:14

Teapot32 · 14/11/2023 16:13

society isn’t fair though 🤷‍♀️ it’s just how it is. I know people who have used the RTB scheme who otherwise would never have been able to buy. I don’t begrudge people who benefit from it. It’s better everyone has a chance. You’re looking at it from a really bitter point of view. It’s not that we have to pay “tax” to cover their rent etc, they (people in RTB housing) are paying the actual market rate for rent where as people in the private sector are paying the landlords overinflated costs. Covering their mortgage and their income. It’s the greedy landlords who should be punished not the people just trying to secure a future.

They're not paying market rate for rent. In a lot of cases it's about half the market rate.

MrsPinkL · 14/11/2023 16:13

It should have been scrapped a long time ago. The need for social housing is never going to reduce we need the properties.

Teapot32 · 14/11/2023 16:13

society isn’t fair though 🤷‍♀️ it’s just how it is. I know people who have used the RTB scheme who otherwise would never have been able to buy. I don’t begrudge people who benefit from it. It’s better everyone has a chance. You’re looking at it from a really bitter point of view. It’s not that we have to pay “tax” to cover their rent etc, they (people in RTB housing) are paying the actual market rate for rent where as people in the private sector are paying the landlords overinflated costs. Covering their mortgage and their income. It’s the greedy landlords who should be punished not the people just trying to secure a future.

flipent · 14/11/2023 16:12

You're right, it isn't fair.
I've privately rented for 20 years, and have just managed to buy at full market value.

My colleague is in Housing Association property with reduced rents and apparently a new kitchen and bathroom every 10 years for free (which I did not get in my private rental and will not get in my home). I don't know if they also have the right to buy.

But I'm also not sure what the alternative is.

RudsyFarmer · 14/11/2023 16:12

I never understood it as a policy. I remember my father absolutely furious that our neighbour bought his identical next door semi for about £4K when he had a £200k mortgage on ours.

user1471538283 · 14/11/2023 16:11

None of it was ever fair. It takes stock away particularly in good areas and they were never replaced

It also encourages the mindset that by paying rent you are entitled to get something back.

I was always against it. God knows where the money went ...

Dowhadiddydiddydum · 14/11/2023 16:11

Darthwazette · 14/11/2023 16:06

I think it’s a ridiculous policy not because it’s “not fair” but because we don’t have enough council property as it is so selling some off below market value seems plain stupid to me.

This^
we should be getting more not selling off what little HA and council properties we do have.

Swipe left for the next trending thread