Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to buy - grossly unfair on private renters and private home owners

210 replies

Winterday1991 · 14/11/2023 15:57

Is it just me or is RTB grossly unfair. People that already have cheap subsidised rent and a secure tenancy can get over to £105k off the market value of their council property.

This seems so unfair to us who have to brought in the private market at full market price and private renters who often do not have secure long term tenancies. Why should the public subsidise this?

OP posts:
WiddlinDiddlin · 14/11/2023 19:04

Gets rid of stock LA's don't want to bother maintaining any longer.

When i bought mine (yes, yes I know im such a steaming cunt! But do tell me where else I was buying a 2bed semi for 48k please?)... I had lived in it 10 years.

It needed a new kitchen, bathroom, insulation, half the windows doing, the heating system ripping out and starting again, the electrics were dodgy as fuck and each job we did revealed 20 more (peel some wallpaper... all the plaster falls off. Lift a floorboard, find the rest are rotten as are some of the joists... etcetc).

I'd been a good tenant - rent on time, repairs reported, nothing needing repair beyond usual wear and tear - but what I bought was a property that had been built with all the corners cut (And none square), that had then had 30 years of abuse and bodge repairs courtesy of the councils repair contractors.

I did those jobs, I rented it out when I had to leave the area and I sold it on paper for 12k ish profit, only when you take into account the work done in the years I owned it, no profit at all really!

Do ya think the LA put the sale price back into more affordable housing? I don't, though that is what they are supposed to do. They had first dibs to buy it back at market rate, didn't want it, they never do.

So yes, it might be a stupid scheme and it might be horribly unfair on those who never got their foot on that particular ladder.

However the RTB scheme is the only reason I am home owner (my current property was bought via RTB, sold to my sister then to me) and in terms of housing costs saved ot the LA, I can't even begin to count it. If they STILL had a duty to house me, I'd be costing them THOUSANDS a week now - and if I'd stayed a council tenant, they would have and now, I am disabled.

pleasestoprainingplease · 14/11/2023 19:02

@secretvictoria I remember reading this and I really was hoping it would come through. We now pay £2k a month on a house in rent, and would love have this reflected in how we could afford mortgage repayments.

It's frustrating because I would love the stability of Council houses or HA. A close friend has a council house 5 mins up the road and only pays £750 a month. She will also get right to buy. I'm not a bitch, I'm happy for her. But I do sometimes wish I had gone down the council route instead of private, I wouldn't feel the pressure of being uprooted every couple years and the rents are so expensive. Yet it will never be mine, the kitchen is 20 years old & well we are where we are. It's frustrating & keeps me awake most nights.

TizerorFizz · 14/11/2023 19:02

@Rosmaree This is common. My DHs relatives did this. It’s a form of investment if you are lucky enough to have elderly parents in a nice council house in a good area. These houses might need modernizing but the profits are huge. I’ve seen it done repeatedly. It was also common in the 50s/60s to choose to have a council house as you didn’t want maintenance costs or to borrow. It did allow for a higher disposable income for cars and holidays! Often these houses were bought up later.

Do not forget that Thatcher helped the parents of many by Right to Buy. She recognised that many council tenants could afford a mortgage (some had cash!) and wanted to join the house ownership boom. It appealed to the upwardly mobile. The mistake was not investing the profits in more homes. So the next generation didn’t get the same advantages as far fewer houses built. But Thatcher got the votes! It was typical government short termism and effectively bought votes.

Paintballmaker · 14/11/2023 18:56

CrazyHedgehogLover · 14/11/2023 18:14

I’m in a council property, was newly built and we was facing homelessness, we are saving up for five years time to be able to do a right to buy on the property! It’s the first place we have had the stability, it’s been our first ever proper family home..

we would never be able to afford to buy if we went privately! We work our arses off in retail jobs (in our area there is literally nothing else available, even if you had the best degree going, chances of earning loads in our area is very slim”) so yeah, we will be buying the house when we are able to up our income/work our way up in work.. because we are lucky enough to have the stability.

I don’t think it’s fair to say “it’s not fair” just because it’s social housing, they wouldn’t have the system if it didn’t work, the only reason we don’t have enough social housing atm is because our country is far to overcrowded, if they tackled that situation first then more social housing would become available and more people would have the opportunity to buy there first home/get in the property ladder..

Ive always agreed with the right to buy system, even when we was the ones facing homelessness, because it gave us the a sense of something to work towards.

So it’s unfair for people to criticise a system the benefits you and immigrants are to blame for the whole situation. There, I’ve summarised it 😄

shellyleppard · 14/11/2023 18:49

Sorry should have said I've been a tenant for 10 years my bad

321user123 · 14/11/2023 18:48

Mrsjayy · 14/11/2023 17:32

I'm sure RTB isn't a thing in most councils I was a council tenant in 2010s and the RTB was scrapped, but we won't let that get in the way of a goady thread though 😃

That may well be the case, but it is still very much a thing in several London boroughs for example.

Rosmaree · 14/11/2023 18:48

YANBU. I’ve seen a man who grew up in the house actually use this ‘right’ to steal the house from his mum. Then sold it at a massive profit after she died. He didn’t ever live there as an adult.

Personally I don’t give a fuck if someone wants to buy the council property they live in so they get to stay in a lovely area and send their kids to a lovely school and make a massive profit when its sold etc. That property belongs to the taxpayer. It should either stay as a council property or be sold to the public at market price with the profit going back to the taxpayer.

321user123 · 14/11/2023 18:45

shellyleppard · 14/11/2023 17:23

Winterday1991
Right to buy is still going in my part of the UK. Have to be a social housing tenant for 10 year or more to qualify

Someone above posted what seemed and excerpt from the policy and it states clearly 3-5yrs.

I know in certain London boroughs the get access RTB after 5yrs, not 10.

edits for spelling

Coconutdragon · 14/11/2023 18:43

Macaroni46 · 14/11/2023 18:12

@HighywayToHell

"I’m in social housing my rent is neither cheap nor subsidised. The house a few doors down is up for private rent and works out at roughly £100 a month more than I am paying. Please tell me who is subsiding my rent so I can have a word with them about the piss poor job they are doing."

The fact that your rent is £100 cheaper shows that it is subsidised!

I think you need to look up the meaning of "subsidised."

Social housing is not subsidised.

It's lower than most private rentals because private landlords make a higher profit, not because anyone subsidises it by paying part of the rent for the tenant.

Coconutdragon · 14/11/2023 18:40

AboutYouTalk · 14/11/2023 18:39

YANBU. It’s not fair at all and gives the impression that you can get on the housing ladder without working for it like everyone else who has to buy their first property at a much higher price for a smaller property.

But you'd still need to work and save a deposit and pay a mortgage if you had right to buy.

Coconutdragon · 14/11/2023 18:39

TintinHadToBeMale · 14/11/2023 18:11

Well that makes everything better then doesn’t it? I worked hard coming from nothing. The folk down the road who never bothered have seen huge increases in their minimum wage, rendering all my extra work valueless, and have had a cheap house in to the bargain. People trying to work up have been taken for mugs.

Perhaps putting your efforts into creating a more equal society, helping put to right some of those societal ills, rather than working so hard to bolster an unfair system by putting yourself above others, would have led to a better outcome for you?

AboutYouTalk · 14/11/2023 18:39

YANBU. It’s not fair at all and gives the impression that you can get on the housing ladder without working for it like everyone else who has to buy their first property at a much higher price for a smaller property.

supermamio · 14/11/2023 18:38

EarlofShrewsbury · 14/11/2023 17:25

Those new kitchens every 10 years..

The kitchens are cheap and fall to bits quickly you also don't get much choice. Choose between 3 cupboard doors and 2 worktops.

Plus it's not every ten years. Mine is 15 years old and needs replacing but they say it's OK for now.

I moved into my home 2 years ago. Enquired when I moved in about the kitchen as it is very dated, was told i would be eligible for a new kitchen approximately 2025, as the kitchens and bathroom in my housing group have a 30 year life span. 😬

Els1e · 14/11/2023 18:38

I agree. I think it’s part of the reason we have a massive shortage of affordable homes. Another legacy of Margaret Thatcher but successive governments have done nothing to address this imbalance.

mummyh2016 · 14/11/2023 18:33

CrazyHedgehogLover · 14/11/2023 18:14

I’m in a council property, was newly built and we was facing homelessness, we are saving up for five years time to be able to do a right to buy on the property! It’s the first place we have had the stability, it’s been our first ever proper family home..

we would never be able to afford to buy if we went privately! We work our arses off in retail jobs (in our area there is literally nothing else available, even if you had the best degree going, chances of earning loads in our area is very slim”) so yeah, we will be buying the house when we are able to up our income/work our way up in work.. because we are lucky enough to have the stability.

I don’t think it’s fair to say “it’s not fair” just because it’s social housing, they wouldn’t have the system if it didn’t work, the only reason we don’t have enough social housing atm is because our country is far to overcrowded, if they tackled that situation first then more social housing would become available and more people would have the opportunity to buy there first home/get in the property ladder..

Ive always agreed with the right to buy system, even when we was the ones facing homelessness, because it gave us the a sense of something to work towards.

You agreed with RTB when you were facing homelessness? Despite the fact that one reason there are more and more families facing homelessness is because there is a massive shortage of homes which RTB plays a part of?
It's not often I'm speechless on here Confused

Dontcallmescarface · 14/11/2023 18:31

flipent · 14/11/2023 16:12

You're right, it isn't fair.
I've privately rented for 20 years, and have just managed to buy at full market value.

My colleague is in Housing Association property with reduced rents and apparently a new kitchen and bathroom every 10 years for free (which I did not get in my private rental and will not get in my home). I don't know if they also have the right to buy.

But I'm also not sure what the alternative is.

My HA replaces the kitchens and bathrooms every 15 years. We can choose if we want it done or not......I chose to have mine done and my rent went up 5% whilst those that didn't have the work done saw a 2% rise in rent, so I certainly didn't get it "for free".

HighywayToHell · 14/11/2023 18:26

Macaroni46 · 14/11/2023 18:12

@HighywayToHell

"I’m in social housing my rent is neither cheap nor subsidised. The house a few doors down is up for private rent and works out at roughly £100 a month more than I am paying. Please tell me who is subsiding my rent so I can have a word with them about the piss poor job they are doing."

The fact that your rent is £100 cheaper shows that it is subsidised!

😂😂😂 no it just means that landlord has increased the rent since the last tenants left, but fear not my rent will increase in April too.

DragonFly98 · 14/11/2023 18:24

flipent · 14/11/2023 16:12

You're right, it isn't fair.
I've privately rented for 20 years, and have just managed to buy at full market value.

My colleague is in Housing Association property with reduced rents and apparently a new kitchen and bathroom every 10 years for free (which I did not get in my private rental and will not get in my home). I don't know if they also have the right to buy.

But I'm also not sure what the alternative is.

The kitchen and bathrooms are not free they are maintenance covered by the rent paid. It's also highly unlikely to be every ten years that rumour is always trotted out.
RTB is a good idea it gives mostly lower income the opportunity to buy. Just because everyone can't benefit doesn't mean nobody should.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 14/11/2023 18:24

The fact that your rent is £100 cheaper shows that it is subsidised!

No it absolutely does not, the LL could be increasing the rental amount by £100 over the market value, unless you know the LL mortgage payment then your “fact” is BS!

GrumpyPanda · 14/11/2023 18:21

This seems so unfair to us who have to brought in the private market at full market price and private renters who often do not have secure long term tenancies.

Then again, it's perfectly possible for a government to regulate private rentals to make them nearly as secure. Half of Europe does so, and there's still landlords willing to invest.

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 14/11/2023 18:20

@Fidgety31 Apologies. I’ve just read our policy and it’s part of the legal procedure that you have to offer the HA/Council to buy the property first at market value.

mummyh2016 · 14/11/2023 18:18

Darthwazette · 14/11/2023 16:06

I think it’s a ridiculous policy not because it’s “not fair” but because we don’t have enough council property as it is so selling some off below market value seems plain stupid to me.

This. By all means offer right to buy but tenants should not get it discounted and for every house sold through RTB a replacement should be built/purchased.

Ginmonkeyagain · 14/11/2023 18:17

What about all the people in your situation who will never get social housing? Don't they also deserve to get a foot on the housing ladder?

If you genuinely think that people whould be able to buy somewhere at a discount that they have been renting for a while - then how about we exend right to buy to private renters? Or is it just public bodies who should be forced to dispose of their assets at below market price?

There are other ways to do this - shared ownership, council backed mortgages (they used to be a thing in 1980s London)

backtowinter · 14/11/2023 18:15

Having been outbid on several houses by those who had bought cheap and sold at huge profit, therefore had more spare cash, then I think it was hugely unfair

This was back in the day. Maybe there are more restrictions on selling on for profit now

CrazyHedgehogLover · 14/11/2023 18:14

I’m in a council property, was newly built and we was facing homelessness, we are saving up for five years time to be able to do a right to buy on the property! It’s the first place we have had the stability, it’s been our first ever proper family home..

we would never be able to afford to buy if we went privately! We work our arses off in retail jobs (in our area there is literally nothing else available, even if you had the best degree going, chances of earning loads in our area is very slim”) so yeah, we will be buying the house when we are able to up our income/work our way up in work.. because we are lucky enough to have the stability.

I don’t think it’s fair to say “it’s not fair” just because it’s social housing, they wouldn’t have the system if it didn’t work, the only reason we don’t have enough social housing atm is because our country is far to overcrowded, if they tackled that situation first then more social housing would become available and more people would have the opportunity to buy there first home/get in the property ladder..

Ive always agreed with the right to buy system, even when we was the ones facing homelessness, because it gave us the a sense of something to work towards.

Swipe left for the next trending thread