Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to buy - grossly unfair on private renters and private home owners

210 replies

Winterday1991 · 14/11/2023 15:57

Is it just me or is RTB grossly unfair. People that already have cheap subsidised rent and a secure tenancy can get over to £105k off the market value of their council property.

This seems so unfair to us who have to brought in the private market at full market price and private renters who often do not have secure long term tenancies. Why should the public subsidise this?

OP posts:
Tumbleweed101 · 14/11/2023 21:03

The RTB scheme isn't as generous now as when it was first introduced. The discounts on full market value now are far less than on tenancies started more than 20 years back. As a single waged household even with RTB discounts my property is still unaffordable for me to buy and this will be there case for many others in council properties today. Even if I could afford a mortgage (if it was similar to my rent for example) then I wouldn't be able to afford repairs and upkeep on my wage.

For me, I'm likely to always be a tenant. I'm very fortunate to be a tenant with a realistic rent rather than the highly inflated private rents. I'm also fortunate that all major repairs and renovations aren't mine to afford. The counter to that is i will always have to pay rent and be at the mercy of the system until I die and I will leave no inheritance for my children, but at least they had a roof over their heads as they grew up.

WickedSerious · 14/11/2023 20:55

Tortiemiaw · 14/11/2023 17:46

It is unfair but....wouldn't we all do it if we could? Seriously?

My parents could've bought their council house for next to nothing,they didn't because they never agreed with the RTB.

Night409 · 14/11/2023 20:47

I am quite surprised at some of these responses.

There have been several threads of people benefiting off the system and the majority of posters have been supporting it.

One poster had a council home and was renting her spare rooms out as an air B&B and one poster inherited money and she was advised to stay in her council house but buy other properties to rent out for extra income.

These sorts of things get support but right to buy is somehow wrong.

Coconutdragon · 14/11/2023 20:44

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 14/11/2023 19:22

Study hard, get qualifications, go to university, start a decent career, work your way up and you could wind up earning six figures, as long as you don't mind working 70 odd hours a week of course, and you might then just be able to afford a decent house.

Or, don't bother, go on the council waiting list, get a property that way and save yourself the equivalent of five odd years salary in the discount you get through RTB!I

It's insane and unfair. No wonder Gen Z are known for their lazy work ethic. Maybe they've realised it's all a big con.

Yes, in the past it made sense to go on council housing waiting lists. These days you'd be hughly unlikely to get a home unless you were in extremely dire need, though, so you'd have to have terrible things happen to you first, not really an easy option.

vernatheraven · 14/11/2023 20:40

And by market tent I mean what they were charging me at the time

vernatheraven · 14/11/2023 20:39

I bought mine. I got £9k discount with right to aqquire.

I feel no guilt about it at all.

I had to spend a fair whack to get it decent for market rent when I moved in. And spent three years pouring money into it because the council wouldn't fix anything!

Garden was rat infested with crazy paving on the grass so couldn't even mow it.
Front and back.

No flooring in any of the rooms. This standard where I live.

Every wall in every room needed re plastering.

Kitchen was dog chewed and doors were hanging off. Worktops all scratched to actual fuck.

Bathroom had the toilet leaking for the whole time before I replaced it. I could smell the rotten wood and every time they said it was fixed. It wasn't ever fixed. Luckily it was the clean water not the waste pipe.

Every single internal door was punch or kicked in or missing.

There was not one room that was ok.

Lots of these places are like this.

These are just the things I can remember.

It was a shithole.

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/11/2023 20:38

Jbrown76 · 14/11/2023 19:57

I know of someone who bought a house for £107k (north Lancashire) but the previous owners did rtb and bought it for £7k

What does that prove though, other than house prices change.

My parents bought a house for 50k. They sold it for 90k. Those buyers sold it for 1.5m.

The difference is of course my parents bought it in 79. Sold it in 96. The people they sold it to, sold it a couple of years ago and i assume installed a non-victorian era heating and electrical system, open plan dining/kitchen/conservatory wanker extension on the back and changed all the carpets to grey.

(Ok yes I looked).

House prices change. My mums first house cost 2k. Last i looked it sold for 350k. A mere difference of some 50 years.

CrazyHedgehogLover · 14/11/2023 20:29

@Paintballmaker i agreed with the system even before I had this property 🤣🤣 I was facing homelessness with 3 small children and I STILL agreed with it.. also no it’s not the immigrants fault, it’s the government’s fault.. yawn when people try to summarise shit on here and fail badly😅

Grapewrath · 14/11/2023 20:25

Well life isn’t fair but it’s rare the poorer and more financially vulnerable people get a leg up so I can’t get excited about it tbh
The housing market isn’t a level playing field when you look at societal advantages and disadvantages overall so on that basis, yabu.

notbindingbahy · 14/11/2023 20:20

StuartSheehyisBack · 14/11/2023 20:17

Well I would rather you feel sorry for ME please OP! My house would be sold on the open market at about £400k, but with the RTB all I can get as a discount is £96k. So I need a £300k mortgage. Which is never going to happen.

Yet if I lived the the north, that £96k discount would be enough for 50% off a nice house, as houses are so much cheaper there.

How unfair is THAT??! So unfair, I think I will have a tantrum like you are and stamp my feet! Or maybe not, because I am a grown up and take things on the chin and try to be happy for others.

Just out of interest, how much is your rent and how many bedrooms?

StuartSheehyisBack · 14/11/2023 20:17

Well I would rather you feel sorry for ME please OP! My house would be sold on the open market at about £400k, but with the RTB all I can get as a discount is £96k. So I need a £300k mortgage. Which is never going to happen.

Yet if I lived the the north, that £96k discount would be enough for 50% off a nice house, as houses are so much cheaper there.

How unfair is THAT??! So unfair, I think I will have a tantrum like you are and stamp my feet! Or maybe not, because I am a grown up and take things on the chin and try to be happy for others.

Jbrown76 · 14/11/2023 19:57

I know of someone who bought a house for £107k (north Lancashire) but the previous owners did rtb and bought it for £7k

Macaroni46 · 14/11/2023 19:53

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 14/11/2023 19:22

Study hard, get qualifications, go to university, start a decent career, work your way up and you could wind up earning six figures, as long as you don't mind working 70 odd hours a week of course, and you might then just be able to afford a decent house.

Or, don't bother, go on the council waiting list, get a property that way and save yourself the equivalent of five odd years salary in the discount you get through RTB!I

It's insane and unfair. No wonder Gen Z are known for their lazy work ethic. Maybe they've realised it's all a big con.

Or do all of those things but become a public sector professional like a teacher or nurse and earn 40k if you're lucky.

DeathMetalMum · 14/11/2023 19:50

Many of these houses are no longer classed as 'Council housing' though. So the link provided will only be for pure council hosting. In our county a while back it was all changed over to housing associations. Our housing association offers a 10k discount for tenants on right to buy, not everyone will be receiving over £50k if they choose right to buy.

TintinHadToBeMale · 14/11/2023 19:42

Coconutdragon · 14/11/2023 18:39

Perhaps putting your efforts into creating a more equal society, helping put to right some of those societal ills, rather than working so hard to bolster an unfair system by putting yourself above others, would have led to a better outcome for you?

What the hell??

So anyone who comes from a poor background should not, in fact, be bothering to work towards a socially useful job?

I certainly agree that I shouldn't have bothered, not to help provide services for people like you.

notbindingbahy · 14/11/2023 19:41

VerityUnreasonble · 14/11/2023 19:39

Someone I work with bought their home under RTB with a substantial discount and now rent it out (for considerably more than they paid in rent or similar houses would now rent as social housing). They have bought a second home with their partner. The thing that made me sad (although is possibly a mortgage condition?) is that when looking for potential renters they wouldn't consider anyone in receipt of benefits.

Often can't get insurance if people are in receipt in benefits.

RRB shouldn't be allowed to rent out.

VerityUnreasonble · 14/11/2023 19:39

Someone I work with bought their home under RTB with a substantial discount and now rent it out (for considerably more than they paid in rent or similar houses would now rent as social housing). They have bought a second home with their partner. The thing that made me sad (although is possibly a mortgage condition?) is that when looking for potential renters they wouldn't consider anyone in receipt of benefits.

Cheesecakefiend · 14/11/2023 19:31

Riverstep · 14/11/2023 19:22

In many cases , the right to buy discount was the deposit. People didn’t save up 10 or 20k.

Oh that's interesting, I didn't realise that.

notbindingbahy · 14/11/2023 19:28

Yes. I dated a guy who's grandparent had RTB. He was a proper lefty and didn't understand that it contributed to the lack of housing.

Nomnomnom66 · 14/11/2023 19:25

Why do tenants get a discount? Why don't they have to pay full price?

Riverstep · 14/11/2023 19:22

Cheesecakefiend · 14/11/2023 19:13

It says everything we need to know about how broken the system is. If you can afford to save 10 or 20k for a deposit for a mortgage of 100k ( surely most houses cost at least 100k these days), you do not need council housing. Hundreds of thousands of desperately poor people are waiting on social housing lists while people in well paid jobs sit in their council homes, buy them and then sell them for a profit.

Edited

In many cases , the right to buy discount was the deposit. People didn’t save up 10 or 20k.

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 14/11/2023 19:22

Study hard, get qualifications, go to university, start a decent career, work your way up and you could wind up earning six figures, as long as you don't mind working 70 odd hours a week of course, and you might then just be able to afford a decent house.

Or, don't bother, go on the council waiting list, get a property that way and save yourself the equivalent of five odd years salary in the discount you get through RTB!I

It's insane and unfair. No wonder Gen Z are known for their lazy work ethic. Maybe they've realised it's all a big con.

Cheesecakefiend · 14/11/2023 19:18

Fawbs89 · 14/11/2023 16:23

My mum used right to buy around 21 years ago to buy a lovely house she would not have otherwise had thw opportunity to buy (single mum of 4 children) it gave us the opportunity to grow up in a lovely area at a good school and feel secure. Myself now as an adult (34) is unfortunately not in a position to buy a property presently but I don't sit her envious or jealous of my mums situation (she was lucky and obtained a Council house in an affluent area of Cheshore). My motto in life is always concentrate on your own life and not how others live theirs.

Now I might be missing something but surely your mum did not need to buy the house in order to stay in the area ? Was she at risk of being evicted from her social housing ? I always thought social housing was the most secure housing to have. Private rent and mortgages do not feel more secure than social housing.

Cheesecakefiend · 14/11/2023 19:13

It says everything we need to know about how broken the system is. If you can afford to save 10 or 20k for a deposit for a mortgage of 100k ( surely most houses cost at least 100k these days), you do not need council housing. Hundreds of thousands of desperately poor people are waiting on social housing lists while people in well paid jobs sit in their council homes, buy them and then sell them for a profit.

CoffeeCup14 · 14/11/2023 19:11

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 14/11/2023 18:24

The fact that your rent is £100 cheaper shows that it is subsidised!

No it absolutely does not, the LL could be increasing the rental amount by £100 over the market value, unless you know the LL mortgage payment then your “fact” is BS!

My recollection from studying social housing a long time ago is that the subsidy comes from government grants towards the original building costs. It's a capital subsidy rather than revenue. So if you were just charging rent to pay back the cost of the house-build, you could afford to charge less. But as far as I'm aware, that's not what the rent is based on.

Social rents are cheaper partly because they organisations which own them are not-for-profit. They also have housing stock from long before the huge price increases - BTL landlords have a much higher mortgage per propery than a housing association, so they have to charge much more. This is the benefit of social housing - it's a public good.