Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to buy - grossly unfair on private renters and private home owners

210 replies

Winterday1991 · 14/11/2023 15:57

Is it just me or is RTB grossly unfair. People that already have cheap subsidised rent and a secure tenancy can get over to £105k off the market value of their council property.

This seems so unfair to us who have to brought in the private market at full market price and private renters who often do not have secure long term tenancies. Why should the public subsidise this?

OP posts:
Dulra · 15/11/2023 09:11

Fawbs89 · 14/11/2023 16:23

My mum used right to buy around 21 years ago to buy a lovely house she would not have otherwise had thw opportunity to buy (single mum of 4 children) it gave us the opportunity to grow up in a lovely area at a good school and feel secure. Myself now as an adult (34) is unfortunately not in a position to buy a property presently but I don't sit her envious or jealous of my mums situation (she was lucky and obtained a Council house in an affluent area of Cheshore). My motto in life is always concentrate on your own life and not how others live theirs.

Your mum, a single woman with 4 kids was lucky to have got a council house in a nice area, but the fact that she was able to buy it means it was lost to the social housing stock and not replaced. Many single mums are now being housed in hotels, emergency accommodation, unsuitable overcrowded accommodation because there is no where to house people. The stock is gone and not replaced. I have no issue with people having aspirations for home ownership and there should have been different supports to help people achieve this which didn't include buying their council property. The whole point of social housing was to provide affordable accommodation for people who were unable to buy their own home or afford some of the private sector rents. It was to get people out of overcrowded poorly maintained dangerous tenements. The loss of stock has meant people are going back to living in overcrowded unsuitable accommodation.
It was a vote winner for Thatcher and has been criticised for years but it is part of many tenancy agreements. Now with Housing Associations taking over much of the Council's stuck RTB is no longer part of new tenancy agreements. I am in Ireland and we ran a similar scheme here (mainly copying what was happening in the UK at the time). Ironically I bought my first house off an owner who had bought it from the Council. The only rule they had was that they were only allowed sell to first time buyers. I bought it during the boom and the profit they made was eye watering

user701 · 15/11/2023 09:10

It isn’t fair. DHs relative lived in a spacious three bedroom council house with a garden all his life. He was a single man and didn’t need the space. He was a head teacher and could afford to buy. He then bought the house for less than £50k a few years ago. He also died with almost a million quid in the bank.

Completely ridiculous system.

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2023 09:07

TizerorFizz · 15/11/2023 08:27

One of the other issues is people who earn very good money clinging on to social housing which denies others the chance. It clearly gives money for holidays, cars and going out, but morally it’s not right. A family member inherited enough to buy 3 houses but decided to stay in their council flat that the council made bigger by knocking it into the adjacent flat. Two people with well paid jobs and no children. There needs to be periodic reviews of tenancy agreements and huge savings should be a bar to continuing to have social housing.

Maybe you’d like people with relatively high incomes and small mortgages to be forced out of their homes and made to pay more?

Beezknees · 15/11/2023 08:32

TizerorFizz · 15/11/2023 08:27

One of the other issues is people who earn very good money clinging on to social housing which denies others the chance. It clearly gives money for holidays, cars and going out, but morally it’s not right. A family member inherited enough to buy 3 houses but decided to stay in their council flat that the council made bigger by knocking it into the adjacent flat. Two people with well paid jobs and no children. There needs to be periodic reviews of tenancy agreements and huge savings should be a bar to continuing to have social housing.

See, while I don't agree with RTB I don't agree with this. I don't think forcing people to leave their homes just because they've managed to turn their lives around and become good earners is the way forward. As a HA tenant, I just wouldn't bother trying to get a better job or save if I knew I would lose my home because of it, and many others would do the same.

I do think that people should be downsized where appropriate though, for example when all children have left home.

TizerorFizz · 15/11/2023 08:27

One of the other issues is people who earn very good money clinging on to social housing which denies others the chance. It clearly gives money for holidays, cars and going out, but morally it’s not right. A family member inherited enough to buy 3 houses but decided to stay in their council flat that the council made bigger by knocking it into the adjacent flat. Two people with well paid jobs and no children. There needs to be periodic reviews of tenancy agreements and huge savings should be a bar to continuing to have social housing.

Spidey66 · 15/11/2023 01:13

VickyEadieofThigh · 14/11/2023 16:04

It's stripped the country of social housing, driving rental prices sky high and leaving many families and individuals with no choice and inadequate housing.

It was an awful policy when Thatcher invented it and it still is.

This x1000000000. Awful, awful policy. The only way it could possibly have worked wonders if money raised was used to build more council or HA stock, but the RTB legislation forbade it.

AllWeWantToDo · 15/11/2023 00:21

TintinHadToBeMale · 14/11/2023 19:42

What the hell??

So anyone who comes from a poor background should not, in fact, be bothering to work towards a socially useful job?

I certainly agree that I shouldn't have bothered, not to help provide services for people like you.

What exactly do you think those of us who live in social housing do for a living? Are we not allowed to have socially useful jobs or something 🤣

daffodilandtulip · 14/11/2023 23:21

I'm a home owner and couldn't care less if people can buy cheaper housing.

What I disagree with, is the resulting mess the country is now in, with not enough social housing and people forced into B&Bs and other such shit circumstances.

BIossomtoes · 14/11/2023 23:01

dumpkin · 14/11/2023 22:39

You also don’t contribute as a tax payer unless you earn in excess of £100k per annum. Under that amount you take out what you put in.

Where have you read this @Princessbananahamock

Utter bollocks. Nobody of working age in reasonable health who hasn’t got children is taking out more than they put in. We put the greatest demand on services during childhood and after pensionable age. From the time my son left school until I claimed my pension I took nothing out at all.

dumpkin · 14/11/2023 22:39

You also don’t contribute as a tax payer unless you earn in excess of £100k per annum. Under that amount you take out what you put in.

Where have you read this @Princessbananahamock

5foot5 · 14/11/2023 22:20

RudsyFarmer · 14/11/2023 22:02

It was an ex council house but interestingly the time lines don’t add up from memory. I need to go check if there was phases of it as we had lived there quite a while before the neighbour had the right to buy.

That might be the case.

I was born and brought up in a council house. My parents would have loved to own it because my Dad, who was in the building trade, could see all sorts of improvements he would have liked to make if it was his.

I am pretty sure there had been a period of time, well before Thatcher government, when there had been a version of RTB. My parents couldn't afford it then and subsequently the policy was changed and that RTB withdrawn.

So yes I suppose your parents house may have been bought from council way before Thatcher. Doesn't really change the illogicality of your DFs fury at neighbours exercising RTB when they wouldn't have the house they were in without a similar, earlier policy!

caringcarer · 14/11/2023 22:18

Social houses should not be sold as it depletes the social housing stock.

Notaflippinclue · 14/11/2023 22:10

It did get some families on the housing ladder and made them very happy - have you ever walked through a council estate and played spot the privately owned houses - there is 2 sides to it

Soontobe60 · 14/11/2023 22:05

Winterday1991 · 14/11/2023 16:04

But it doesn't seem fair on a societal level. It's unequal playing field

Actually, the unequal playing field is the differences in income. Some receive minimum wage incomes (if they are employed) whilst others receive 6 figure salaries. Everything else that stems from income differentials is ‘unequal’

RudsyFarmer · 14/11/2023 22:02

5foot5 · 14/11/2023 22:00

But that implies that the house your parents bought was an ex council house so the people your parents bought from must have done RTB at some point. Hence your parents would not have been able to buy that particular house if it wasn't for RTB. Did they not realise when they bought it? And how could he justify being furious at the neighbours doing exactly what their own vendors had done?

It was an ex council house but interestingly the time lines don’t add up from memory. I need to go check if there was phases of it as we had lived there quite a while before the neighbour had the right to buy.

5foot5 · 14/11/2023 22:00

RudsyFarmer · 14/11/2023 16:12

I never understood it as a policy. I remember my father absolutely furious that our neighbour bought his identical next door semi for about £4K when he had a £200k mortgage on ours.

But that implies that the house your parents bought was an ex council house so the people your parents bought from must have done RTB at some point. Hence your parents would not have been able to buy that particular house if it wasn't for RTB. Did they not realise when they bought it? And how could he justify being furious at the neighbours doing exactly what their own vendors had done?

Beezknees · 14/11/2023 21:55

Squoo · 14/11/2023 21:50

That's very gracious of you @Beezknees but I'd rather pressure was put on the state to make it possible for more people to have the opportunity you do. It isn't your personal fault that there isn't enough social housing to go round and I wouldn't knock anyone who is able to progress to ownership in this way. Done correctly, it's a sustainable solution.

Oh I agree, I know it's not my fault. But I was given this property when I was on my own living in temporary accommodation with a toddler. It's benefited me so much and I'd like to see it benefit someone else who is in the same position that I was. I accepted a long time ago that I'd never own and made my peace with it 😂

My own DS will have the opportunity that I didn't - to live at home and save to buy his own place so I won't have to worry about not having anything to leave to him.

Squoo · 14/11/2023 21:52

Plus, cheaper mortgages makes for more disposable income, which is also better for society!

Squoo · 14/11/2023 21:50

That's very gracious of you @Beezknees but I'd rather pressure was put on the state to make it possible for more people to have the opportunity you do. It isn't your personal fault that there isn't enough social housing to go round and I wouldn't knock anyone who is able to progress to ownership in this way. Done correctly, it's a sustainable solution.

Beezknees · 14/11/2023 21:42

It's absolutely not unfair to private home owners. If you can afford to buy your house at full price, you are not at a financial disadvantage in life in any way. No sympathy from me.

However I do think it isn't fair for people who can't afford to buy. As a housing association tenant myself who has the right to buy, I won't take advantage of it. There is such a shortage of these properties and I don't think it should be taken away.

Princessbananahamock · 14/11/2023 21:35

A poster replied to me I would say to you.
no I would never be at the mercy of a private landlord or pay their mortgage.

The point I was trying to make is there is a huge disparity between council and private. Private landlords do their properties up to meet the demands of prospective tenants and on the whole to a high standard. Then compare that to council housing you get what you are eligible for and it’s very very basic its bare floors etc. however I am extremely grateful for the position I’m in. Like others I would not be able to buy under the RTB unless I had a large win on the premium bonds.
With regard to RTB there have been people that I feel unethically milked it. For example bought grannies/older relatives house for cheap (they live elsewhere owned home) wait for gran etc to go and bingo huge profits for them. That was wrong.

HighlandCowbag · 14/11/2023 21:31

The only unfairness about RTB is the sale value goes to central government not the local council who loses a property but doesn't get the funds to reinvest in a replacement property.

The tax payer doesn't fund council or social housing, they are priced as sustainable property ie they pay for themselves.

Squoo · 14/11/2023 21:25

Council/HA properties are not subsidised! They are rented out at the rate that they are affordable to sustain, and not to make profit. The only error has been not to replace those sold and that has been an utter travesty! Had they done that there wouldn't be the mad rise in private rental rates we have today - due to supply and demand! More social housing would mean cheaper rents/house prices all round. And that is what we should be fighting for! It's headed the way it has because greed for profit and backroom private developer deals overrule longterm sustainability.

Sothisiit · 14/11/2023 21:12

Everyone knows there is a lack of social housing so I never understand why government and local authorities allow housing stock which are assets that belong to the taxpayer to be sold off below market value.
It seems a disservice to me that houses are sold to allow people to become 'homeowners' to the detriment of those in the same situation behind them. If you are able to raise a mortgage with a bank purchase from the private housing stock so as not to deprive others of a home when in need.

Sassy306 · 14/11/2023 21:07

What bugs me more are the people who, (and I see it regularly) used the right to buy to purchase their council houses, sold them, used the massive profit to move to a posher area, then complained like hell when any new social housing was built anywhere near them!

"Oh, we couldn't possibly live next to council tenants" ......The horror!! Well you wouldn't be in your posh house now if it wasn't for social housing so pipe down! 🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread