Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to buy - grossly unfair on private renters and private home owners

210 replies

Winterday1991 · 14/11/2023 15:57

Is it just me or is RTB grossly unfair. People that already have cheap subsidised rent and a secure tenancy can get over to £105k off the market value of their council property.

This seems so unfair to us who have to brought in the private market at full market price and private renters who often do not have secure long term tenancies. Why should the public subsidise this?

OP posts:
Dobbyatemysocks · 15/11/2023 15:48

I have just left a rented property.

My landlords grandparents purchased it under right to buy for £45,000.

I paid over £60,000 in rent and often paid for repairs because he & the agent didn't care.

My landlord inherited the property with no outstanding debt.

Property is now worth £110,000.

Landlord evicted me under a section 21 stating he wanted to sell.

He re-rented the property a month after I left with a 50% increase in the rent.

Riverstep · 15/11/2023 15:33

People have now changed and those who can afford to buy privately even without RTB don't want to and I don't see how we can make them.

This hasn’t been helped by how much smaller houses are now. A three bed council property built in the 50’s is so much more spacious than three beds on newer estates plus costs less to buy. It’s easy to see why people would exercise their right to buy ( for those who have that preserved).

DiscoBeat · 15/11/2023 15:09

Although I did buy an ex council house (to let out) I think it's a really poor decision to sell them off. So many were sold on when Thatcher was in. We need social housing!

Purplebunnie · 15/11/2023 15:02

If you want people to give up their council house then maybe we have to change their mindset. If I remember correctly the original idea was to "tide people over" until they could afford their own property. My grandparents lived in a council house just after the war and when they could afford they bought privately as did my uncle and aunt.

People have now changed and those who can afford to buy privately even without RTB don't want to and I don't see how we can make them

I'm not in favour or RTB but I can understand it and I can understand people not wanting to downsize or move out from where they have brought their families up. I don't have answers.

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2023 14:47

If it is well below market rent then it is subsidised!

You clearly don’t understand the meaning of subsidy. The housing provider quoted above clearly states there is no subsidy.

Dontcallmescarface · 15/11/2023 14:42

A social housing property is to support those most in need of accommodation it should never be a longterm solution for that person when and if their situation improves they should move on.

Given that this is MN and £50k is "not enough to live on" according to some posts on other threads I've read, how much money do you think people should have before they are booted out of their home for having the audacity to be earning above NMW?

Dulra · 15/11/2023 14:17

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2023 12:52

Social housing isn’t subsidised. From Cambridge City Council:

If the tenant pays their own rent in full, as a tenant of a local
authority, they are paying the full rent charged by the local authority
for the occupation of the dwelling. Social housing rents are well below
market rents, but are not subsidised rents.

The Housing Revenue Account (HRA), which is where all of the properties are accounted for if they are owned by a local authority, is what is known as 'ring fenced', which means all of the costs of providing the social housing need to be met from the rental income received from them.

The housing fund cannot be subsidised
from other areas of Council activity i.e.; Council Tax, planning fees,
parking income etc. Under the same rules, the HRA cannot use its funds to
subsidise the rest of the Council's services.

Apologies I live in Ireland so not 100% familiar with your system but they are very similar.

If the tenant pays their own rent in full, as a tenant of a local
authority, they are paying the full rent charged by the local authority
for the occupation of the dwelling. Social housing rents are well below
market rents, but are not subsidised rents.
If it is well below market rent then it is subsidised! Kind of splitting hairs there. My point is that social housing is a very finite resource at a time when there is massive need. Housing waiting lists are sky high and many people on them are unlikely to ever get offered a property. I think it is crucial access to these properties are based on need not when or how long you have your tenancy. In Ireland people who are on housing waiting lists have the option for housing assistance payment (HAP). They source a property privately and the council pay a percentage of the rent. Unfortunately as private rents increase many still can't afford them even with HAP. I work in the community sector and the amount of families I am working with that are in emergency accommodation or at risk of homelessness is scary, yet there are plenty of social housing 3/4-bed properties in the area with sole occupancy, makes no sense 🤔

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2023 14:11

TizerorFizz · 15/11/2023 14:04

It is if you are well off. You take something you don’t need. Happy for those who need social housing to have it. HAs borrow money to acquire and build homes. Issues they face are ability to borrow and find land. Using assets fairly should be a very important aspect of HA delivery of goals for the government. Of course they won’t tackle this so we don’t have enough homes. We don’t build them either. Unless we use a variety of strategies we get no further forward.

You clearly don’t understand what a subsidy means. It couldn’t be much clearer.

all of the costs of providing the social housing need to be met from the rental income received from them.

That means social housing washes its own face. No subsidy from any other source of funds.

Night409 · 15/11/2023 14:06

I don’t agree with RTB but I understand that it’s some peoples only chance of ever getting onto the property ladder.

But there is absolutely no way that you should be allowed to own multiple properties, rent out rooms as air B&Bs, be earning hundreds of thousands etc and still be allowed a council home.

The issue isn’t people who are on a low income and can’t get a mortgage in the normal way.
Its the people who take the piss out of the system.

I asked on here about buying my council home a few years ago (I wasn’t in a position to do it at the time but it was more to understand it for the future) and posters were telling me to buy it and then get a buy to let property or to move and rent it out etc.
A poster was on a few months ago saying she’d inherited a house and loads of people told her not to give up her council home.

I am always really shocked at so many MNers lack of morals when it comes to taking advantage of the system like benefit fraud or RTB.

No wonder there is such a shortage in such an housing.

TizerorFizz · 15/11/2023 14:04

It is if you are well off. You take something you don’t need. Happy for those who need social housing to have it. HAs borrow money to acquire and build homes. Issues they face are ability to borrow and find land. Using assets fairly should be a very important aspect of HA delivery of goals for the government. Of course they won’t tackle this so we don’t have enough homes. We don’t build them either. Unless we use a variety of strategies we get no further forward.

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2023 13:38

TizerorFizz · 15/11/2023 13:37

@BIossomtoes It depends who owns the social housing and what needs it was designed to meet. Many people years ago chose it as an option. They were not poor. Not in awful jobs or no jobs. Often they were professionals such as teachers and those who needed accommodation quickly as they worked for local industry and their skills were needed. They didn’t pull themselves up.

It really depends whether we see housing as a resource for those who need it or a long term home for those who don’t. When there’s a shortage we need flexibility. So yes, there should be an understanding that reviews of need are carried out. As we do for most other benefits paid by the state.

It’s still not subsidised. 🤷‍♀️

TizerorFizz · 15/11/2023 13:37

@BIossomtoes It depends who owns the social housing and what needs it was designed to meet. Many people years ago chose it as an option. They were not poor. Not in awful jobs or no jobs. Often they were professionals such as teachers and those who needed accommodation quickly as they worked for local industry and their skills were needed. They didn’t pull themselves up.

It really depends whether we see housing as a resource for those who need it or a long term home for those who don’t. When there’s a shortage we need flexibility. So yes, there should be an understanding that reviews of need are carried out. As we do for most other benefits paid by the state.

Its5656 · 15/11/2023 13:14

Agree it was a terrible policy. My In-laws live in a council house, 3 bedrooms and huge garden.. It was given to them in 1981 when they had children at home but now it's just the two of them, They don't want to leave (don't blame them) but it's because of this, along with right to buy that there is no social houses left for families that need them now.

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2023 12:52

Dulra · 15/11/2023 12:24

Social housing is to support people to live in a property when they cannot afford to buy or rent privately. Once the need for that property is no longer there people need to move on and let people who are more in need access it. I also don't believe children of social housing tenants should have succession rights. Yes a partner or spouse but not their adult children.

If you read above there are plenty of cases where people can well afford to move, but it's their home so they don't want to
It is not their home, it belongs to the state. So they get to live in a subsidised tenancy for ever more? Very few people are able to afford to buy or rent properties in the areas they grew up in that's life! A social housing property is to support those most in need of accommodation it should never be a longterm solution for that person when and if their situation improves they should move on.

The only way round this is to means test everyone living in a council house/HA and then force them to move if they are seen to be earning too much/have too much money. Yes because they no longer have a need for that property and others do

Is this the society you want to live in where we force people out of their homes because at the end of the day, it may not be their house but it is their home.
Yes it is. A society that looks after its most vulnerable because what you describe is clearly not working, the homeless figures are increasing, families and children are stuck in unsuitable emergency accommodation while others are living in subsidised accommodation that they no longer financially need and in many cases are under-occupying.

Edited

Social housing isn’t subsidised. From Cambridge City Council:

If the tenant pays their own rent in full, as a tenant of a local
authority, they are paying the full rent charged by the local authority
for the occupation of the dwelling. Social housing rents are well below
market rents, but are not subsidised rents.

The Housing Revenue Account (HRA), which is where all of the properties are accounted for if they are owned by a local authority, is what is known as 'ring fenced', which means all of the costs of providing the social housing need to be met from the rental income received from them.

The housing fund cannot be subsidised
from other areas of Council activity i.e.; Council Tax, planning fees,
parking income etc. Under the same rules, the HRA cannot use its funds to
subsidise the rest of the Council's services.

Dulra · 15/11/2023 12:24

Purplebunnie · 15/11/2023 11:35

@Dulra

If her mom hadn't bought the house her mom would still be living in it as a tenant. When she dies if she was still a tenant the tenancy could be passed to one of her children if they are still living there so she's done the PP out of a potential home by exercising her RTB

So this property could still be unavailable to other single moms - this is what people don't get. If you read above there are plenty of cases where people can well afford to move, but it's their home so they don't want to. Same with RTB they don't want to leave their homes so they if they can, they buy it.

The only way round this is to means test everyone living in a council house/HA and then force them to move if they are seen to be earning too much/have too much money

Is this the society you want to live in where we force people out of their homes because at the end of the day, it may not be their house but it is their home.

Edited for spelling

Edited

Social housing is to support people to live in a property when they cannot afford to buy or rent privately. Once the need for that property is no longer there people need to move on and let people who are more in need access it. I also don't believe children of social housing tenants should have succession rights. Yes a partner or spouse but not their adult children.

If you read above there are plenty of cases where people can well afford to move, but it's their home so they don't want to
It is not their home, it belongs to the state. So they get to live in a subsidised tenancy for ever more? Very few people are able to afford to buy or rent properties in the areas they grew up in that's life! A social housing property is to support those most in need of accommodation it should never be a longterm solution for that person when and if their situation improves they should move on.

The only way round this is to means test everyone living in a council house/HA and then force them to move if they are seen to be earning too much/have too much money. Yes because they no longer have a need for that property and others do

Is this the society you want to live in where we force people out of their homes because at the end of the day, it may not be their house but it is their home.
Yes it is. A society that looks after its most vulnerable because what you describe is clearly not working, the homeless figures are increasing, families and children are stuck in unsuitable emergency accommodation while others are living in subsidised accommodation that they no longer financially need and in many cases are under-occupying.

Purplebunnie · 15/11/2023 11:35

@Dulra

If her mom hadn't bought the house her mom would still be living in it as a tenant. When she dies if she was still a tenant the tenancy could be passed to one of her children if they are still living there so she's done the PP out of a potential home by exercising her RTB

So this property could still be unavailable to other single moms - this is what people don't get. If you read above there are plenty of cases where people can well afford to move, but it's their home so they don't want to. Same with RTB they don't want to leave their homes so they if they can, they buy it.

The only way round this is to means test everyone living in a council house/HA and then force them to move if they are seen to be earning too much/have too much money

Is this the society you want to live in where we force people out of their homes because at the end of the day, it may not be their house but it is their home.

Edited for spelling

Dulra · 15/11/2023 09:40

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 15/11/2023 09:22

The waiting lists are what they are because of the government’s failure to build sufficient affordable homes. I don’t hold that against current council tenants and don’t feel they are the ones at fault. I’m sure of most of the people who have issues with it would jump at the opportunity to buy their home at a reduced rate if they had the chance and are only angry because they can’t.

so yes, would be happy for anyone who is eligible for the scheme to use it. Where I live you can only buy your home if you are in an area that isn’t struggling for housing.

Edited

Of course I don't begrudge anyone that had the opportunity to buy their council property, I would definitely have done the same. My issue is with the scheme itself, it should never have been an option unless it was properly enforced that Councils had to use the funds to build more properties that were lost from their housing stock to RTB. I don't support this particular scheme doesn't mean I don't blame anyone for using it.

NorthernSoul55 · 15/11/2023 09:27

HighlandCowbag · 14/11/2023 21:31

The only unfairness about RTB is the sale value goes to central government not the local council who loses a property but doesn't get the funds to reinvest in a replacement property.

The tax payer doesn't fund council or social housing, they are priced as sustainable property ie they pay for themselves.

This! Had local councils been allowed to invest RTB monies in new housing for social rent, the whole housing stock would be increased or maintained.

Twiglets1 · 15/11/2023 09:26

I don't begrudge people doing it because I would buy my own council house if I was in their position and I think most people would.

It's unfair on a societal level though, if the government isn't going to replace all the social housing they allow to be sold off. It just makes it even harder for the next generation.

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 15/11/2023 09:22

Dulra · 15/11/2023 09:14

There are many though that can't even get a council property and are stuck on massive waiting lists. So if you think people should be supported to buy, it should not only be open to those lucky enough to get a council property but open to everyone that is eligible for social housing

Edited

The waiting lists are what they are because of the government’s failure to build sufficient affordable homes. I don’t hold that against current council tenants and don’t feel they are the ones at fault. I’m sure of most of the people who have issues with it would jump at the opportunity to buy their home at a reduced rate if they had the chance and are only angry because they can’t.

so yes, would be happy for anyone who is eligible for the scheme to use it. Where I live you can only buy your home if you are in an area that isn’t struggling for housing.

Cryingmum909 · 15/11/2023 09:18

Don't even get me started on this topic. It's disgustingly unfair. I have some very strong views. You get what you put in in this life.

Tonight1 · 15/11/2023 09:17

@VickyEadieofThigh Thatcher was all about owning your own business and home.

I can't really blame people if they're offered the chance to buy social/council housing, it needs to be addressed with authorities

Notaflippinclue · 15/11/2023 09:16

More lighthouses!

Dulra · 15/11/2023 09:14

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 15/11/2023 09:11

I don’t begrudge people the opportunity to buy their home when they otherwise likely couldn’t afford to. What is an issue is the lack of social housing that has resulted from the policy. If they’re going to sell if conical housing then more need to be built to keep up with demand for affordable housing.

There are many though that can't even get a council property and are stuck on massive waiting lists. So if you think people should be supported to buy, it should not only be open to those lucky enough to get a council property but open to everyone that is eligible for social housing

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 15/11/2023 09:11

I don’t begrudge people the opportunity to buy their home when they otherwise likely couldn’t afford to. What is an issue is the lack of social housing that has resulted from the policy. If they’re going to sell if conical housing then more need to be built to keep up with demand for affordable housing.