Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right to buy - grossly unfair on private renters and private home owners

210 replies

Winterday1991 · 14/11/2023 15:57

Is it just me or is RTB grossly unfair. People that already have cheap subsidised rent and a secure tenancy can get over to £105k off the market value of their council property.

This seems so unfair to us who have to brought in the private market at full market price and private renters who often do not have secure long term tenancies. Why should the public subsidise this?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Squoo · 18/11/2023 03:27

TizerorFizz · 17/11/2023 23:10

I don’t entirely see that everyone can get a good job. Clearly they cannot. It’s not unfair, it’s the way it is. However this is the type of person social housing is for, but buying it takes it away from others who need it. It’s a vicious circle and where do you build new social housing in central London? When it’s gone, it’s gone.

This is a fair point. And relying on always building new to replace old clearly isn't a sustainable solution long term. But not all areas offer RtB in anycase, so it's not exactly a scheme that's fair to all who are in social housing anyway! There's also a difference between right to buy and right to acquire (not sure what the difference is though).

Perhaps buying options shouldn't be limited to the house you live in. I think that's why there's been a shift towards housing associations and shared ownership schemes etc.

I'd personally like to see more self build community schemes for low cost housing like shipping containers and the like, but we're too hung up on private mass developers who make £££ and are focussed on profit.

AllWeWantToDo · 18/11/2023 01:14

Leah5678 · 15/11/2023 22:46

It's true though 🤷🏻‍♀️ where I live a two bed apartment is over a grand a month privately. If my landlord sells I'm screwed. I know council tenants paying 500 for a three bedroom house. It's not their fault they have it easy and I don't blame them. But can you really blame private renters for being pissed off and jealous

Well mine certainly isn't half the rent of private .

Private renters can do the same as I did when private renting. Apply to the council 🤷‍♀️

TizerorFizz · 17/11/2023 23:10

I don’t entirely see that everyone can get a good job. Clearly they cannot. It’s not unfair, it’s the way it is. However this is the type of person social housing is for, but buying it takes it away from others who need it. It’s a vicious circle and where do you build new social housing in central London? When it’s gone, it’s gone.

Squoo · 17/11/2023 20:01

💯

karenute · 17/11/2023 19:58

I got a council house tenant when I was a pregnant single mum fleeing DV. The flat was in quite a run down estate in central London, and had a reputation for gang wars, though I was never affected by it. It was over 20 years ago and it's gentrified a lot since then. I bought it through RTB 2 years ago and got a discount of £112k.

It might seem unfair but then again all the tenants on the estate have had unfortunate life circumstances in some way or another, usually in more than one way (DV, severe MH issues, other disabilities, disabled dc, being in care or prison, addictions). The waiting lists are so long that it's only those with the highest needs who get housed. It's terribly unfair that they've had all of those bad experiences and haven't been able to have a more straightforward life path with leaving education and getting a good job that would allow them to rent or buy on the open market. I dont think the unfairness of RTB is any worse than the unfairness of other inequalities in society.

Squoo · 17/11/2023 19:29

Well if you end up being evicted every 6 months until you've spent all your savings and can't afford a deposit/moving costs for another new tenancy and wind up being housed (that's how I ended up with mine, it wasn't fun and I get the stress, I really do!) you might find you change your perspective and lay the blame where it's due. On the system that doesn't provide enough or replace social housing, rather than take away often the only chink of light from those who have already lost it all and are trying to scrape their way back up! You might be one of them one day!!

And yes I work full time as a single mother! And no I haven't had a new kitchen or bathroom gifted to me in the 10 years I've lived here!

The anger on this thread is all to cock, it really is.Confused Why aren't we demanding more and better social housing and a sustainable replacement scheme, then more would benefit. We should be taking to the streets!

Leah5678 · 15/11/2023 22:46

AllWeWantToDo · 15/11/2023 21:12

🙄 that would be nice

It's true though 🤷🏻‍♀️ where I live a two bed apartment is over a grand a month privately. If my landlord sells I'm screwed. I know council tenants paying 500 for a three bedroom house. It's not their fault they have it easy and I don't blame them. But can you really blame private renters for being pissed off and jealous

vernatheraven · 15/11/2023 22:00

If the HA were on top of repairs and the houses were all like private rentals and decent then I would agree that the RTB should be redundant.

But they are not.

Lots of us have had to pay significant amounts to bring these up to standard.

So if you have had to plough money in then why shouldn't you use the RTB

AllWeWantToDo · 15/11/2023 21:12

Leah5678 · 15/11/2023 20:46

Boo boo you pay half the rent private renters pay 😂😂 must be so hard for you

🙄 that would be nice

Leah5678 · 15/11/2023 20:46

Princessbananahamock · 14/11/2023 17:35

@Teapot32 every bloody time this old tripe gets rolled out “so unfair, not paying marKet rent, we are subsidising them” Ffs people need to just stfu. Here’s a few facts

  1. I have NEVER had a new bathroom or kitchen! If you are lucky enough it’s the cheapest type nothing fancy or nice like private rents. Ffs
  2. private rents are higher cause the renters are paying a landlord’s mortgage!
  3. The only maintenance I get is a boiler service once a year. If something happens yes they come out to fix…….eventually like my fire escape window upstairs I reported broken start of October (common fault that happens with double glazing) my appointment is in December.
  4. They are not decorated when you move in ,no carpets NOTHING! Gardens are more than likely very overgrown. You are responsible for everything.
  5. You can’t move exactly where you want it’s a bit of a lottery. So if you get horrible neighbours well you’re buggered.

I so want to live in the ivory towers/cloud cuckoo land that some do. You also don’t contribute as a tax payer unless you earn in excess of £100k per annum. Under that amount you take out what you put in. NHS Education and so on.

It’s really pisses me of when you get judgy sorry jealous people going on about it every fucking year like it’s a new thing. Rant over

Boo boo you pay half the rent private renters pay 😂😂 must be so hard for you

Leah5678 · 15/11/2023 20:33

You are not being unreasonable!!
There's also cases of people who have bought their home with right to buy then they rent it out privately for double or even triple what the neighbours pay with their council tenancy 😡
Fr imagine working your butt off to pay over a grand in rent for your apartment while your neighbour is some crackhead bum paying 500 for the same damn thing.

gamerchick · 15/11/2023 20:31

Issummernearlyover · 14/11/2023 16:46

My friend has been offered 10 per cent reduction to buy her house. That's £30,000. She has already paid £72,000 in rent. The mortgage would be more than twice her rent so she's not going to buy it. I don't know where OP gets her figures from.

It's a poke the bear thread. You can always tell when they come out with tripe like 'subsidised rents'. Not worth the energy.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/11/2023 20:28

Social housing was actually being sold well before Thatcher. A dd bought a house that the former owners had bought from the council in 1971 - as dh found after a good old nose on the Land Reg.

Dd paid almost exactly 100 times what they did.

TizerorFizz · 15/11/2023 18:33

Originally receipts for council houses sold could not be spent on building more houses. It’s only recently that has changed.

LookingForPurpose · 15/11/2023 18:04

My council still does right to buy and our council is also in the process of building lots and lots of council houses and affordable housing. It's a very modest town in the nw but we have had 200 new council and HA houses ( In mixed developments of 1500 ish) in the last 2-3 years with another phase due to be completed soon. The council also actively purchases properties on the open market to use as council housing. My DH purchased his council flat a good few years ago and paid £19k for a property valued at £63k. He really struggled to reconcile the choice to purchase with his political beliefs but his rent was £400 a month and his mortgage was £200 for ten years so it was a no brainier really. Neither of us ever expected to own a proper so for us it's amazing.

Zebedee55 · 15/11/2023 17:40

RTB was ok, but it would only have worked if councils/HAs replaced the properties.

Governments stopped them - so now we have a chronic housing social housing shortage.🙁

diddl · 15/11/2023 17:35

So why didn’t Labour abolish it, when they had 13years in which to do it?

Hadn't it originally been a proposal of theirs?

Dulra · 15/11/2023 17:31

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/11/2023 16:58

So why didn’t Labour abolish it, when they had 13 years in which to do it?

Mainly because it was written in to people's tenancy agreements the "Right to Buy". It would have been a legal mess to try and get rid of. As far as I am aware though it is no longer a right for new tenancy agreements so will eventually peter out. When I worked in the sector at the beginning of the noughties, councils were transferring many of their properties and tenancies to Housing Associations and there was uproar over the RTB because Housing Associations did not offer this. In most cases I think they had to honour it for transferring tenants as in like for like

Utterbunkum · 15/11/2023 17:28

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/11/2023 16:58

So why didn’t Labour abolish it, when they had 13 years in which to do it?

Because the last 'Labour' government fundamentally continued to operate on Conservative principles. Also, because when it comes to RTB, it won a lot of votes for Thatcher because people naively took it at face value, as a positive thing which benefited them. Which it did in the very short term. Had Blair's slightly less Tory than actual Tory government abolished it, they would have lost votes and they knew it, basically because individuals (understandably) don't think long term, they think about what will benefit them now. It would take a pretty brave government to convince individuals that something that clearly and obviously benefits them in the here and now should be abolished because it has no benefit to the population at large.

And, let's make no bones about it, social housing is a thorn in any government's side. It is time and resource heavy, and the provision is easy to criticise. Increasing rents to match higher costs of resources to manage social housing will be viewed negatively, however much lower than private the rent remains. How it is distributed, criteria required to be granted social housing will always be a political hot potato, like the NHS. RBS is a convenient tool to.phase out social housing by simply offloading and not replacing. Using homes available for rent in .the private sector as social housing makes more sense to government because it massively reduces the admin by paying the rent to a private homeowner who remains responsible for the property.

LakieLady · 15/11/2023 17:06

MargaretThursday · 14/11/2023 16:09

It's not fair on the people waiting for social housing because it reduces the stock which is not replaced at the rate it's needed. I don't see it as unfair to home owners.

I agree.

If a new social housing property had been built to replace every home sold, I wouldn't have so much of a problem with it, tbh.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 15/11/2023 16:58

VickyEadieofThigh · 14/11/2023 16:04

It's stripped the country of social housing, driving rental prices sky high and leaving many families and individuals with no choice and inadequate housing.

It was an awful policy when Thatcher invented it and it still is.

So why didn’t Labour abolish it, when they had 13 years in which to do it?

AllWeWantToDo · 15/11/2023 16:55

Depends on the area, when we moved into our council house you could earn up to 35k, we applied because it was the 4th time in 6 years we'd had to move due to LL deciding to sell up

Not sure how much you can earn these days but I know people who have only had to go into temp accommodation for a couple of months before being given a house

DiscoBeat · 15/11/2023 16:45

*family member

DiscoBeat · 15/11/2023 16:45

@TTortiemiaw I said it was an ex council house but it had been in the private domain for decades before I bought it for a family to rent cheaply (because they cannot afford market rates). I disagree with social housing being sold on.

Tortiemiaw · 15/11/2023 16:38

DiscoBeat · 15/11/2023 15:09

Although I did buy an ex council house (to let out) I think it's a really poor decision to sell them off. So many were sold on when Thatcher was in. We need social housing!

And there we have it!! Social housing bought to make money?
How can you disagree with the principle, when you're profiting?
Buying ones own social property to live in is one thing - admitting it was bought to make money is another