Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be genuinely shocked by the apparent illiteracy of Andrea Jenkyns?

256 replies

sorrynotathome · 14/11/2023 15:10

Have we really reached the point where it is acceptable for a senior MP to publish a serious (presumably) document that is barely legible?! It's not a text or a tweet or a Mumsnet post for goodness' sake. It reads as though she spoke it into her phone and hoped for the best. If this is what passes for communication nowadays, no wonder people struggle to connect and constantly misunderstand each other.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Iamnotthe1 · 15/11/2023 17:51

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 17:36

OK, but that article doesn't refer to illiteracy.

It talks about kids not being able to read and write "properly" and "literacy rates".

If you remember, this conversation is about whether Jenkyns is "illiterate" and whether the government refers to children with poor literacy as "illiterate". She isn't and it doesn't.

Government ministers absolutely have talked and do talk about more children or less children ending primary school being literate based on their KS2 results. Clearly, you only want to accept an official state document saying "Children who don't meet the expected standard at the end of KS2 are illiterate," but you won't get that as references like that are not made on data publication documents. They are made by MPs in interviews and can be more nuanced, e.g. read and write "properly" and "literacy levels". Contextual knowledge makes it clear again though, right?

I also didn't say she was illiterate. I said that if posters wished to use that word, they were welcome to given how loosely government officials have talked about literacy and illiteracy. Either way, the letter still fails to meet the expected standard in writing for 10 and 11 year olds. As a former education minister, that's unforgivable.

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 17:36

Iamnotthe1 · 15/11/2023 17:02

That's trickier because we're talking about comments made orally, for example in thw house or on the radio etc., rather than in DfE publications.

Here's one referring to the 2021 results:
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/14541344/kids-primary-school-without-read-properly/
referencing 200,000 pupils unable to read properly by the end of primary following an interview with MP Robert Halfon, then chair of the Education Committee. He's also a current education minister.

Christian Wakefield, MP, said in parliament, in his role as a member of the Education Committee, when talking about a reported drop in KS2 teacher assessments and the need for educational recovery:
"we need a long-term plan to tackle the attainment gap and falling
literacy rates."

OK, but that article doesn't refer to illiteracy.

It talks about kids not being able to read and write "properly" and "literacy rates".

If you remember, this conversation is about whether Jenkyns is "illiterate" and whether the government refers to children with poor literacy as "illiterate". She isn't and it doesn't.

verdantverdure · 15/11/2023 17:02

Nothing Andrea Jenkyns does shocks me.

She's a low quality human being.

To be genuinely shocked by the apparent illiteracy of Andrea Jenkyns?
Iamnotthe1 · 15/11/2023 17:02

That's trickier because we're talking about comments made orally, for example in thw house or on the radio etc., rather than in DfE publications.

Here's one referring to the 2021 results:
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/14541344/kids-primary-school-without-read-properly/
referencing 200,000 pupils unable to read properly by the end of primary following an interview with MP Robert Halfon, then chair of the Education Committee. He's also a current education minister.

Christian Wakefield, MP, said in parliament, in his role as a member of the Education Committee, when talking about a reported drop in KS2 teacher assessments and the need for educational recovery:
"we need a long-term plan to tackle the attainment gap and falling
literacy rates."

Over 200,000 kids to leave primary school without being able to read properly

MORE than 200,000 pupils may be leaving primary school without basic reading and writing, figures suggest. The Government statistics also reveal an extra 30,000 kids struggling with literacy in jus…

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/14541344/kids-primary-school-without-read-properly

mathanxiety · 15/11/2023 16:56

That letter is 5th Grade class president campaign-level stream-of-consciousness drivel, the sort of poorly thought out and poorly punctuated nonsense you'd expect from a ten year old long on daddy's views and short on grammar and self-awareness and any other qualities you can think of that would appeal to people who are educated and thoughtful.

It should play very well amongst the Tory membership.

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 14:59

Iamnotthe1 · 15/11/2023 14:20

It's a comment that they've made annually, both to the press and in the house. The government "line" may not state it, but the ministers repeatedly have across multiple years.

Can you share some examples?

verdantverdure · 15/11/2023 14:20

StarlightLady · 15/11/2023 13:48

I thought both letters was a load of just about coherent rubbish.

But on the issue of starting a sentence with "And". Read anything by DH Lawrence, one of the UK's greats.

He's my excuse for doing it.

Also, I'm on Mumsnet not writing a letter for posterity under a House of Commons letterhead. Grin

Iamnotthe1 · 15/11/2023 14:20

It's a comment that they've made annually, both to the press and in the house. The government "line" may not state it, but the ministers repeatedly have across multiple years.

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 14:13

You are literally copying and pasting a screen grab from this page which rebuts the claim!

https://fullfact.org/education/literacy-year-6/

It's not a "the standard that [the] government uses when talking about the attainment levels of 11 year old children", it's an incorrect off-the-cuff statement used by one minister in a leadership debate.

Are a quarter of 11 year-olds in England unable to read? - Full Fact

A quarter of year 6 students (10 to 11 year-olds) in England do not achieve the expected reading level in their SATs. This doesn’t mean they can’t read.

https://fullfact.org/education/literacy-year-6

Iamnotthe1 · 15/11/2023 14:02

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 13:39

Where do they say that, @Iamnotthe1?

I've found this passage on gov.uk which suggests the opposite:

"It is incorrect to say that pupils who have not met the expected standard in reading cannot read, or that those who have not met the expected standard in writing cannot write, and so on.

There is a spectrum of attainment among pupils who do not meet the expected standard, with some coming close and others further away."

Edited

When they release the full set of data, which they last did in 2019 as no data has been released nationally during the pandemic (this year will be the first full set since).

I've attached a picture of government minister comments at the time, though will be able to find more examples later if needed.

To be genuinely shocked by the apparent illiteracy of Andrea Jenkyns?
BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 15/11/2023 13:50

Crikeyalmighty · 15/11/2023 13:17

@MasterBeth I was always taught that it wasn't- clearly I am very old!!

It's not a matter of age. For decades (and probably still) primary school teachers told children; "Never start a sentence with 'and".

That's nothing to do with it being a fixed rule of grammar. It's because otherwise they have to mark 30 pieces of a week that read: "I went to the park. And I met a dog. And it was friendly. And I threw a ball for it. And then I had lunch. And then my friend came to play...."

That would drive anyone to make up 'rules' that might make it stop.

StarlightLady · 15/11/2023 13:48

I thought both letters was a load of just about coherent rubbish.

But on the issue of starting a sentence with "And". Read anything by DH Lawrence, one of the UK's greats.

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 13:39

Where do they say that, @Iamnotthe1?

I've found this passage on gov.uk which suggests the opposite:

"It is incorrect to say that pupils who have not met the expected standard in reading cannot read, or that those who have not met the expected standard in writing cannot write, and so on.

There is a spectrum of attainment among pupils who do not meet the expected standard, with some coming close and others further away."

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 13:37

GotNewHair · 15/11/2023 00:32

Well MasterBeth with her inability to identify, form or sustain a sentence or to accurately apply end of sentence punctuation while not functionally illiterate she is well below the GCSE pass standard that her party believes is so important.

Is there a comma shortage?

Notmetoo · 15/11/2023 13:35

You are being unreasonable to expect a fully formed grammatically correct argument from the ex Dfe minister whose preferred method of argument is to make obscene gestures to people who disagree with her. She is a terrible person with terrible opinions and she can't string two sentences together.

Iamnotthe1 · 15/11/2023 13:32

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 13:13

Does her government refer to those who have not reached the required standard of literacy as "illiterate"? I suspect not.

They do by stating that only X% of children have achieved literacy at the end of KS2. If you aren't in the X% who were age-related and so achieved literacy, you are, by default, being described as illiterate.

It's one of the things I find most frustrating, each year, when the results are announced exactly because being "age-related" is not the minimum standard for literacy. But if the government wish to describe it as such, they should be held to the same standard.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 15/11/2023 13:29

Misuse of apostrophes is much less egregious than accidentally describing someone you’re trying to stick up for as “unforgivable”. That’s not just bad grammar, it’s terrible syntax. Furthermore, having your tweets proofread would be a bit silly whereas having an important formal letter which doubles as a public statement when you’re a politician with a job which basically consists of public statements, whether written or not.

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 13:25

Crikeyalmighty · 15/11/2023 13:17

@MasterBeth I was always taught that it wasn't- clearly I am very old!!

It's really heartening to see people admit that what they learned in school might not be correct. Many people seem to believe that something they were taught about English at the age of 8 is an irreversible law that must forever be upheld, when it's more likely to be fashion/custom/personal preference.

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2023 13:20

Crikeyalmighty · 15/11/2023 13:17

@MasterBeth I was always taught that it wasn't- clearly I am very old!!

I’m older than you and I was taught that in school. But my English BA tutors said it was fine. In a writing career of over 30 years I often did it and still do.

Crikeyalmighty · 15/11/2023 13:17

@MasterBeth I was always taught that it wasn't- clearly I am very old!!

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 13:15

jemenfous37 · 15/11/2023 12:40

The Braverman resignation letter was a study in the omission of Oxford commas, the starting of a sentence with And, and how not to do grammar!

It's perfectly correct to start a sentence with "And".

MasterBeth · 15/11/2023 13:13

Iamnotthe1 · 15/11/2023 12:32

Illiterate: adjective
unable to read or write.

Jenkyns is not illiterate.

By a simple dictionary standard, no. By the standard that her government uses when talking about the attainment levels of 11 year old children, yes. This was the point that I made.

Does her government refer to those who have not reached the required standard of literacy as "illiterate"? I suspect not.

BIossomtoes · 15/11/2023 12:58

Anycrispsleft · 15/11/2023 07:36

I'm old enough to remember when a backstabbing resignation letter of a rebelling MP would have been a stiletto blade of an assassination, shade thrown so subtly that the target would need to read it twice to even realise they'd been attacked.
Now we're down to "only Suella had the balls to tell the truth". Is this what it's going to be like now? Forever? I find myself (a lifelong Labour supporter) actually glad to see Cameron back, because if I squint my eyes I can see him, Hunt, Starmer etc and it looks as if the adults are in charge again. But it feels more like a series of cameos at the end of a cancelled show than the return of serious politics.

Edited

Me too. An excellent resume. Apologies for the lack of accent on resume, perhaps I should have said summary.

jemenfous37 · 15/11/2023 12:51

You think people are not bothered about SPaG? There's a world of difference between some playing a round and playing around...

jemenfous37 · 15/11/2023 12:40

The Braverman resignation letter was a study in the omission of Oxford commas, the starting of a sentence with And, and how not to do grammar!

Swipe left for the next trending thread