Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone still thinks Brexit was a good idea?

231 replies

KimberleyClark · 14/11/2023 13:32

Genuinely curious. I can't see how it has improved things at all.

YANBU - Brexit was a terrible idea
YABU - it was a great idea

OP posts:
Crikeyalmighty · 15/11/2023 13:22

@TooBigForMyBoots and strangely I see lots of retail jobs still being paid minimum wage too or very slightly above. I appreciate getting jobs may be a bit easier in some very specific sectors , retail being one , but it's hardly a massive bonus-

Crikeyalmighty · 15/11/2023 13:20

@jasflowers indeed- anyone would think the UK isn't in Europe. All jingoistic nonsense playing to the UKIP brigade in the public and his party

jasflowers · 15/11/2023 13:11

DdraigGoch · 15/11/2023 12:38

That's what you observed, was it? Perhaps if they did their best to be more conciliatory during Cameron's renegotiation then more people would have voted to stay.

From where I am, I saw plenty of awkwardness for its own sake. Britain had to be punished pour encourager les autres. It didn't help of course that much of the groundwork was done by Theresa May who was too focused on immigration and practically did the Commission's work for them by coming up with the unworkable NI protocol.

In my view EFTA would have suited our needs far better.

Cameron got 3 of his 4 demands, the EU couldn't budge on FOM, as its part of the eu's 4 freedoms.

We left the EU, May had her Red Lines - No to SM and No to CU Brexit means Brexit!!!
Johnson carried on her deal, re badging it his own.

UK then lost access to pretty much all its benefits, why people think the EU should have carried on allowing us to still have these benefits is beyond me, then again, the British seem to wallow in Exceptionalism.

EFTA was never an option, no one (with any power) suggested it and Norway said they did not want the UK in EFTA as our economy is too big.

Also, EFTA has FOM, so was completely unacceptable to anyone on Govt.

Johnson could of course had negotiated a closer relationship, he chose not and went for the hardest of Withdrawal Agreements, he even took us out of EHIC, Eurotom, Erasmus & Europol, infact anything with Europe in the title.

TooBigForMyBoots · 15/11/2023 13:03

OpenLanes · 15/11/2023 10:18

Retail workers have had a huge wage % increase. Its much easier to get a retail job and suitible/more hours now. It's gone from around 80 applicants per job to 3-4.
Nothing that helps the rich, but it does help normal people trying to work around family life.

Has the CoL crisis, increased numbers of those unable to pay their bills, increased numbers using food banks passed you by? What about the increase in homelessness?

The UK working and lower middle class are just about managing or on their knees. Life is not better for them in 2023. The rich meanwhile are just fine.

You should take a wee look at how narrow your own thought process is.

Cattenberg · 15/11/2023 12:56

People have short memories, we had the rise of ukip and extreme right wing sentiments in the uk and I feel brexit has helped stop these sort of parties gaining political legitimacy…

I’d say the opposite has happened. Nigel Farage is regularly interviewed on TV and last weekend, right-wing protesters were clashing with police near the Cenotaph.

DdraigGoch · 15/11/2023 12:38

ladeluge · 15/11/2023 10:55

The irony is that EU members couldn't really give a damn about UK leaving anymore, and from what I observed the EU did their best to come to an agreement, but UK was having none of it. Those most affected for example Ireland have moved on and gained a lot since UK departed the fold.

The hubris of the UK is amazing!

That's what you observed, was it? Perhaps if they did their best to be more conciliatory during Cameron's renegotiation then more people would have voted to stay.

From where I am, I saw plenty of awkwardness for its own sake. Britain had to be punished pour encourager les autres. It didn't help of course that much of the groundwork was done by Theresa May who was too focused on immigration and practically did the Commission's work for them by coming up with the unworkable NI protocol.

In my view EFTA would have suited our needs far better.

StrictlyComeSnoozing · 15/11/2023 12:26

I didn't think it was a good idea then, and certainly don't now that we're dealing with the fallout from it either.

However, I also don't think the continual raking over it does anything other than divide and polarise because we are where we are.

Pipsquiggle · 15/11/2023 12:19

Southwestten · 15/11/2023 11:57

2dogsandabudgie · Today 10:49

These threads always appear when the remainers on the Brexit board get bored with each other and just want an argument.

This. Op, you know there is a Brexit section? You may get more answers there as it has a lot of traffic and loads of different posters and pro and anti Brexit views are welcome.

@Southwestten

The problem with the Brexit board (I have posted there myself) is that it is generally remainers. If you want to hear genuine voices across the spectrum AIBU is probably a better place.

BTW I don't think I will ever come to terms with Brexit -
*The blatant lying with absolutely no consequences from the Leave campaign (apart from some poultry fines for breaking electoral law)
*The fact that my DC can't easily live / work in countries nearby like I did
*Such a huge strategic decision for the the country was given to an uneducated population
*A referendum was used as a protest vote as our electoral system is so shit

Of course it's a disaster

Southwestten · 15/11/2023 11:57

2dogsandabudgie · Today 10:49

These threads always appear when the remainers on the Brexit board get bored with each other and just want an argument.

This. Op, you know there is a Brexit section? You may get more answers there as it has a lot of traffic and loads of different posters and pro and anti Brexit views are welcome.

Whiteday · 15/11/2023 11:53

Peradventure55 · 14/11/2023 13:38

Oh ffs you are not genuinely curious, you have made your own mind up which is fair enough, but you just want to start yet another argument about the pros and cons which has been going on for almost the last ten years. What kind of perverse satisfaction do you get from starting yet another thread.

What pros?

Throwhandsupintheair · 15/11/2023 11:45

The next campaign for the Leave leaders is to pull us out of the European Court of Human Rights due to the Rwanda ruling.

Apparently the Tories plan also fell foul of the Supreme Court so I guess some of them will even demand we leave the United Nations.

You can never give an inch to these people, their craziness can’t be sated.

volunteersruz · 15/11/2023 11:35

I’m still happy with the way I voted as the reason I voted yes has been proved correct. People have short memories, we had the rise of ukip and extreme right wing sentiments in the uk and I feel brexit has helped stop these sort of parties gaining political legitimacy…whereas the rise of the right wing in Europe has become meteoric, certain countries have reintroduced border controls, the anti migration sentiment in the eu has grown and grown and even previously pro immigration countries like Sweden and Germany have become very anti-immigrant. I had family members on both sides of ww2 and the whole aim of European integration was to bring countries together…but humans don’t work like this and it’s now driving countries apart. I also wanted the political parties to stop blaming everything on Europe and the eu….the uk was sunk as soon as the tories introduced their austerity policies but people continued to vote Tory so personally I blame them…if David Cameron hadn’t pushed the referendum then we wouldn’t have been in this position in the first place!

fearfuloffluff · 15/11/2023 11:20

It's a national embarrassment, but I've come to see it as a necessary one. Basically, I think we need to go through this in order to adjust to the end of empire. It's like a mid life crisis where we realise we're not hot stuff any more.

therealcookiemonster · 15/11/2023 11:18

OpenLanes · 14/11/2023 13:46

It's good for people on lower incomes and needing resources such as council housing, needing unskilled or low level skilled jobs.
Bad for middle class or upper class.

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

ladeluge · 15/11/2023 10:55

The irony is that EU members couldn't really give a damn about UK leaving anymore, and from what I observed the EU did their best to come to an agreement, but UK was having none of it. Those most affected for example Ireland have moved on and gained a lot since UK departed the fold.

The hubris of the UK is amazing!

TooBigForMyBoots · 15/11/2023 10:53

OpenLanes · 15/11/2023 09:17

If that's genuinely how narrow your thought process is, at least try to make your point with relevant or believable examples.
As if you're actually meeting up with ex ter to discuss leaving the EU.. 😂

I live in Belfast. I grew up around terrorists and I live amongst Ex terrorists now, but thanks for your post @OpenLanes.Thanks

The lack of thought process amongst Brexiteers is clearly still an issue.🙈😆

Everanewbie · 15/11/2023 10:49

I had no great affection for the EU, which is a trading block that grew beyond what a lot of people felt that we'd signed up for. I have sympathy with the pro-Brexit arguments about sovereignty and accountability to our electorate rather than bureaucrats in Brussels. Unfortunately, the debate got dragged down to one side being desperate to stick one to Jonny foreigner and take a much harder line on immigration and another side who have a weird distrust in the UK an over emotional and ideological attachment to an overgrown trade block with mission creep.

Ultimately, I voted remain because I felt that years of legislation and directives would be so hard to unpick and that the economic turmoil would outweigh the benefits. But I wasn't that gutted to lose as I was 55/45ish. I think I've been proven right.

How is it going? Well politicians trying to undo the result, impose their versions of Brexit by bringing down governments haven't helped a smooth transition, nor did our disastrous overreaction to the COVID pandemic. Much as I'd feared, unpicking directives, making trade deals and supercharging our economy have proven more challenging than we were promised by leave. But we do at least have more sovereign control over our own destiny, which some may say is worth it. Ultimately, we'll never know as there is no control universe where Cameron didn't hold a vote, or remain won the day.

2dogsandabudgie · 15/11/2023 10:49

These threads always appear when the remainers on the Brexit board get bored with each other and just want an argument.

Cattenberg · 15/11/2023 10:41

Dotjones · 14/11/2023 13:43

We'll never know whether Brexit was a good idea or not, just as we'd never have known whether remaining was better if the vote had been to stay.

We weren't voting to freeze everything as it was in 2016. We were voting whether to continue down the route of ever-closer integration. I think a lot of people who voted Brexit weren't anti the status quo, it just felt like it was now or never - if we didn't vote Leave then, we'd be trapped for another generation at least.

I never expected there to be any big immediate benefits - it was always going to take a decade of things being worse before we'd start to reap the gradual improvements. I admit I didn't factor the pandemic into my expectations, neither did I expect it to take so long to actually leave after the votes were counted. So my expectation of things being better by the late 2020s has slipped to the mid 2030s.

We can get a pretty good idea by comparing the UK to the EU countries with a similar-sized population and GDP, such as France.

What are the gradual improvements you’re expecting?

oldwhyno · 15/11/2023 10:32

I answered the first question. YABU to ask. Again. 🥱

Winwit · 15/11/2023 10:23

I think people thought Brexit was going to be great, but then it turned out they’d been lied to and the reality was nothing like what was promised. I’m still shocked that major political parties were allowed to get away with telling bare faced lies like that!

Mind you, the Remain campaign didn’t help itself at all. It presented its facts and statistics in a really bad way, and focused too much on economics despite voters saying they were more concerned about immigration.

OpenLanes · 15/11/2023 10:18

Crikeyalmighty · 15/11/2023 10:14

The fact is that there are certain trades that have benefitted- but they are very specific and it's only by screwing everyone else due to less competition. You tell me how it's benefitted retail workers, nurses, bin men etc.

The idea as well that it's only the middle and upper classes that voted to remain is not correct. Plenty of upper class voted for it so they could keep their assets offshore (eU bought new rules in) and plenty of working class voted to remain too .

The idea that we were full of polish people snagging council houses or filling up doctors waiting rooms is complete poppycock- every time I've been to the doctors it's full of elderly Brits and most EU people here were in shared houses or private rented

Brexit isn't the cause of all the troubles here but it sure hasn't helped- unless of course you are a brickie now charging extortionate money for relatively small jobs and nipping to Barbados every year- it's back to the 89s and loadsamoney for a few - crap for everyone else

Retail workers have had a huge wage % increase. Its much easier to get a retail job and suitible/more hours now. It's gone from around 80 applicants per job to 3-4.
Nothing that helps the rich, but it does help normal people trying to work around family life.

Crikeyalmighty · 15/11/2023 10:14

The fact is that there are certain trades that have benefitted- but they are very specific and it's only by screwing everyone else due to less competition. You tell me how it's benefitted retail workers, nurses, bin men etc.

The idea as well that it's only the middle and upper classes that voted to remain is not correct. Plenty of upper class voted for it so they could keep their assets offshore (eU bought new rules in) and plenty of working class voted to remain too .

The idea that we were full of polish people snagging council houses or filling up doctors waiting rooms is complete poppycock- every time I've been to the doctors it's full of elderly Brits and most EU people here were in shared houses or private rented

Brexit isn't the cause of all the troubles here but it sure hasn't helped- unless of course you are a brickie now charging extortionate money for relatively small jobs and nipping to Barbados every year- it's back to the 89s and loadsamoney for a few - crap for everyone else

Abhannmor · 15/11/2023 10:04

TudorBeckham · 14/11/2023 13:33

I think a lot of Brexit fans have moved onto “Brexit could have been great but it wasn’t done properly”, a bit like Communists who tell you that real Communism has never been tried.

Edited

This ! Or Tories who say privatisation is great and is only a disaster because of government interference.

Free market solves everything. But Britain is f*cked because it's not really really really free. To mangle John Otway.