Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone still thinks Brexit was a good idea?

231 replies

KimberleyClark · 14/11/2023 13:32

Genuinely curious. I can't see how it has improved things at all.

YANBU - Brexit was a terrible idea
YABU - it was a great idea

OP posts:
Topseyt123 · 16/11/2023 13:42

I'm a remain voter.

Brexshit was a terrible idea and there are no upside. Well, except that UKIP finally disintegrated and Nigel Farage is now heading into the jungle on I'm a Celebrity. He should be right at home there surrounded by cockroaches, snakes and huge, horrendous spiders.

EasternStandard · 16/11/2023 13:27

Economic trade will likely stay in tact but FOM is the part that will be strained.

Same for U.K. we’re more likely to go back to trade without FOM if it becomes an option

fearfuloffluff · 16/11/2023 13:24

Fifteenth · 15/11/2023 19:16

When it falls apart, we will be outside it.

As a moral principle, Govt should cover the smallest feasible geographic area. We should not have continent wide or global Govt.

if there is nowhere to run, Govt can do what it likes.

In a milder way, Govts should compete. People should have other examples and be able to say “look, what they are doing in France works better”. That doesn’t happen with continent wide standardisation. And it’s important.

Also politicians won’t be able to lie and say “It’s Europe” when they do unpopular things.

If the EU falls apart, do you really think the UK would be unharmed?

The rest of the world is forming trade blocks in order to compete with the likes of US and China. They do it because it makes sense.

Standardisation is usually the product of consensus from experts and stakeholders. Brexiteers always criticise the concept of standards but can never identify which are problematic, because they represent best practice that industry tends to sign up to. It's a principled opposition that doesn't make business sense.

Like now we've left the EU, are manufacturers queuing up to start making products in inch sizes etc? No because it would be idiotic. Using standards gives you access to the widest possible market and helps ensure products are high quality/don't injure people.

fearfuloffluff · 16/11/2023 13:18

caringcarer · 15/11/2023 13:56

I still think it was good to get out of the EU. The EU was demanding more money each year from some countries, net contributors, like we were. It was planned to make us pay almost 3 billion more each year. At the same time Macron in particular was edging ever closer to his EU army. The brakes have been put on this since the UK left which is good. The UK has been able to negotiate its own trade deals with developing economies. We've now joined the Trans Pacific Trading block and have deals with India and many individual US states. A new deal was announced with Florida today. We have deals with Australia and New Zealand too. In 2024 we take back more of our own fishing zone than we were allowed to enjoy under EU rules. We can limit our legal immigration and set limits by points to ensure immigrants can prove they have a job earning a set amount which means they won't need to immediately claim benefits. We can make it easier for people with skills we need like nurses to enter with fewer points. We also got vaccines well ahead of EU countries during Covid. Friends of ours in France got their vaccines 5 months after us and they are older than us.

I know there are disadvantages too but compared to staying in and handing over more and more money each year so the EU could play silly games moving their parliament around every few months and waste so much money it still seems good to me.

I have a holiday home in France and whilst I enjoy traveling to and having holidays in Europe I have no wish to have Brussels make rules and have unelected bureaucrats make rules we all had to obey.

There were many initiatives like the EU army that the UK blocked. We're no longer able to block anything any more.

The net contribution didn't account for what we made as a result of frictionless trade, did it? And supporting other countries to develop gives a stable environment so it'sworth the money.

The transatlantic trade deal is puny and why would we prioritise trade with far flung nations over our neighbours?

We need immigrants, a large reason for the NHS being so colossally fucked is that the migrant labour we relied on has dried up.

We could always limit immigration, the freedom of movement was dependent on people finding work, we could have refused residency/benefits etc if they didn't but we chose not to.

The COVID vaccines were delivered while we were still part of the EU system. So the EU did not stop us there.

As the the democracy element - we elected EU reps and then had influence over the whole of the EU. Now they can make rules and we pretty much have to follow them if we want to trade.

Plus the prorogation of parliament, several unelected PMs, undermining rule of law, dodgy referendum funding, parade of liars. And now an unelected Lord Cameron is brought in by an unelected PM. Great. That's really taking back control.

We just blamed so many things on the EU that were our own fault. Now the EU can't be blamed any more, the politicians are saying the ECHR is somehow the thing that holds us back from greatness. It's all populist bullshit.

Pipsquiggle · 16/11/2023 11:15

The ONLY reason that I hope this subject keeps getting re-surfaced is so that we join some kind of customs union or a better deal than we have now. Then, by the time my DC are my age perhaps we can rejoin.
(I am hoping the world hasn't turned into some nationalistic shit hole by this point)

DogInATent · 16/11/2023 11:09

BIWI · 16/11/2023 10:31

@CaramacFiend @caringcarer @DogInATent

Did any of you read the link I posted above?

Here

Which shows that relative to many other countries, including the Eurozone, the UK is really not doing very well! Only Germany is performing worse than we are.

And these are the government's own figures, released yesterday.

For a very strange value of "worse".

The German economy is growing slower than the UK economy, but from a much, much higher starting point.

Your argument is that the worst kid at spelling learned 5 new words this week but the top kid only learned two. The top kid is still the top kid, but you're clapping for the thick kid.

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 11:04

I think that part of the difficulty is that neither side will ever concede they were wrong, even if it does start to look that way. Hell would literally freeze over before remainers would ever admit there were any benefits to Brexit.

ladeluge · 16/11/2023 10:42

StarTrek6 · 16/11/2023 06:23

Ireland dropped it's corporation tax levels so all the american silicon valleys are there, making billions and paying the least tax they can - 1t was 12.5% in Ireland I think - ours was 20+ (can't be arsed to look it up but if you are interested you can ) - They are being forced to raise it as eg France has lots of eg amazon users but Ireland is getting the tax revenue. Good on ireland but it was due to undercutting other countries rather than their hard work or anything else.

I often wonder why the UK did not compete with Ireland on a CT tax level anyway. What stopped UK from undercutting the Irish 12.5% rate at the time?

I realise now that CT is somewhat harmonised within the EU, but it is still relatively low in Ireland, and in comparison to the US rate of 21%, 15% in Ireland is still very attractive to US multinationals.

BIWI · 16/11/2023 10:31

@CaramacFiend @caringcarer @DogInATent

Did any of you read the link I posted above?

Here

Which shows that relative to many other countries, including the Eurozone, the UK is really not doing very well! Only Germany is performing worse than we are.

And these are the government's own figures, released yesterday.

KimberleyClark · 16/11/2023 10:08

As a moral principle, Govt should cover the smallest feasible geographic area. We should not have continent wide or global Govt.

if there is nowhere to run, Govt can do what it likes.

In a milder way, Govts should compete. People should have other examples and be able to say “look, what they are doing in France works better”. That doesn’t happen with continent wide standardisation. And it’s important.

On the other hand, in your ideal model, for things that require a global approach, such as climate change, which is really important, no one can agree on what should be done. So nothing gets done.

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 16/11/2023 09:50

khw666 · 15/11/2023 18:51

The government sent the money to the EU and the EU handed back pocket money to fund it and kept the rest.

As said that isn't quite the truth. But at least the WC North saw money being spent on stuff that made life better.

I'm still very bitter that the public could decide this, but boaty mcboatface was apparently too big a decision and over ruled.

Abhannmor · 16/11/2023 09:49

StarTrek6 · 16/11/2023 06:23

Ireland dropped it's corporation tax levels so all the american silicon valleys are there, making billions and paying the least tax they can - 1t was 12.5% in Ireland I think - ours was 20+ (can't be arsed to look it up but if you are interested you can ) - They are being forced to raise it as eg France has lots of eg amazon users but Ireland is getting the tax revenue. Good on ireland but it was due to undercutting other countries rather than their hard work or anything else.

The Corporation Tax was criminally low in fairness. I think there is an EU minimum of 15% now?

But a big part of our attraction to Foreign Direct Investment is simply that we are in the EU. Cork is now the second largest English speaking city in the EU. Strange times we live in.

bombastix · 16/11/2023 09:38

@DogInATent - absolutely right. The UK fell behind its competitors. We have a lot of work to do.

I have made more money from Brexit. But honestly I do not think the UK is overall better off in terms of investment or growth, and it is certainly not better run.

Aurasauras · 16/11/2023 09:23

Personally, my life and career have improved since Brexit. Which is irrelevant to whether it was a good idea of not.

Rishi's "masterplan" was bringing David Cameron (who told us all Brexit was a terrible idea after offering it up on a platter in the first place) to sweep triumphantly back in,in the style of Boris and triumphantly tell us that he was right about Brexit, that he offered us unasked for but said was a mistake, that he is here to fix and usher in a period of sensible, boring rich people getting richer and making deals with the EU again.

Except multiple countries are thinking of leaving the EU and it was David's utter stupidity that caused all of this. The world is a very different place now, we have GB news, social media and huge disillusionment. David's triumphant return will be met with little more than raised eyebrows.

DogInATent · 16/11/2023 08:41

Yes, but if you're measuring relative growth it's easier to achieve a higher figure if you crash the economy harder first. UK GDP has a lot more room to grow because it's inherently so shit to start with compared to the rest of Europe. Per capita GDP as an absolute figure, the UK lags far behind the leading EU nations and is lower than the Euro area as a whole.

We haven't overtaken anyone, we're still three laps behind. We're just starting to show some signs of catching up with a view to unlapping ourselves.

caringcarer · 16/11/2023 08:24

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 08:06

Nobody has really discussed this point in detail. Does it suggest things aren't actually as bad as originally thought (it says UK economic growth was 'hugely underestimated') or are Germany and France just struggling for other reasons?

Underestimated as part of Project Fear.

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 08:06

Nobody has really discussed this point in detail. Does it suggest things aren't actually as bad as originally thought (it says UK economic growth was 'hugely underestimated') or are Germany and France just struggling for other reasons?

jasflowers · 16/11/2023 07:55

Fifteenth · 15/11/2023 19:16

When it falls apart, we will be outside it.

As a moral principle, Govt should cover the smallest feasible geographic area. We should not have continent wide or global Govt.

if there is nowhere to run, Govt can do what it likes.

In a milder way, Govts should compete. People should have other examples and be able to say “look, what they are doing in France works better”. That doesn’t happen with continent wide standardisation. And it’s important.

Also politicians won’t be able to lie and say “It’s Europe” when they do unpopular things.

Well we ve had decades of EEC/EU and yet all the EU countries are different, they have their own transport, health & education systems, still have their own national traditions,
Italy keeps having GE/new PMs, though recently we matched or even beat them on that score - competitive govt i guess.

We have never had continental wide govt, not even close.

& the only standardisation is in min safety standards and some goods/trade, the UK has kept miles, driving on the left and its electrical earthing systems - German has it own speed limits and the French have the TdF !!!

Politicians will lie and blame something other than themselves or their policies, look how we blame Ukraine for price rises, ignoring the huge profits supermarkets and others are making?

@lightisnotwhite Our net £12bn contribution would run the NHS around ONE month, true, still a lot of money but look what we got for that, just in terms of trade, we are now paying in billions for Horizon - 2.6 billion just for that.

lightisnotwhite · 16/11/2023 06:57

ladeluge · 15/11/2023 19:06

Honestly, that response deserves complete derision. Do you not understand that the surplus that according to you "the EU kept" was used as funding for other less well off members of the EU with a view to bringing them up to similar standards as the UK (at that time).

I'm afraid your response demonstrates the ease with which those who voted for Brexit were indoctrinated. Maybe they were incapable of critical thinking and were only capable of swallowing the latest propaganda from UKIP and the ERG.

Edited

Well critical thinking would surely tell you that “funding for other less well off members of the EU with a view to bringing them up to similar standards as the UK “ means we keep ALL the money.

We were the third largest contributor. That was lots of countries being bought up to standard.
Now Covid is done it is gradually sorting itself out. Spain and France both heading towards relaxing visas etc. Trade is was thing. A federalised Europe was never going to be great for the U.K.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 16/11/2023 06:46

I campaigned for Remain and watched the pre-Brexit process with increasing horror. IMO it was a bad idea, badly executed, and increasing numbers of people are expressing that view in polls etc, but constantly going back to it is not really helpful any more. It’s done. The same reason people voted remain because the remain campaign was crap or they hated Cameron or they thought they were being patronised when someone told them leaving was a shit idea is the same reason that constantly telling them “I told you so” or “oh look I was right” will alienate them further. We need to look forward and focus on untangling the massive mess that’s been created.

catsanddogsandrabbits · 16/11/2023 06:41

OP - do you really expect an analysis of economic and social changes with a nuanced dissection of how things are/ were /could have been? Are you looking for figures? Or examples? Or anecdotes? (Which you dismiss if they don't say the same as you).

Or do you want lots of people to come on to the thread - like all the other threads on the same subject - and say "Yeah it's a shit show and the half population who voted differently from me are all thick racists" (smug, smug).

If you really want to know there are better places to do your research, (including in Sweden, France, Germany, Hungary, Ireland, Italy etc etc)

StarTrek6 · 16/11/2023 06:23

ladeluge · 15/11/2023 16:40

Being a net recipient is part of the ethos of the EU. Bring the lower performing economies UP with good use of the funds, and then when they are UP, they become net contributors, helping the next country that needs it.

Ireland has used it's EU funding very well, it it booming at the moment from what I read. Good on that country, and it seems to have an outward looking optimistic view of the world. Its education system is very good, which is why there are so many tech, scientific and pharma companies there, amongst others. OK I understand that there is a tightening of belts in some sectors right now, but the low CT rate will keep them here. Intel being one example of a company that has invested vast amounts in its Irish campus.

I am so envious of them. But I can go and live there and use its services anytime due to the CTA. Might just do that some day. I can't do the same in the wider EU though unless I get a visa to work there.

Ireland dropped it's corporation tax levels so all the american silicon valleys are there, making billions and paying the least tax they can - 1t was 12.5% in Ireland I think - ours was 20+ (can't be arsed to look it up but if you are interested you can ) - They are being forced to raise it as eg France has lots of eg amazon users but Ireland is getting the tax revenue. Good on ireland but it was due to undercutting other countries rather than their hard work or anything else.

MissyB1 · 15/11/2023 19:32

Throwhandsupintheair · 15/11/2023 11:45

The next campaign for the Leave leaders is to pull us out of the European Court of Human Rights due to the Rwanda ruling.

Apparently the Tories plan also fell foul of the Supreme Court so I guess some of them will even demand we leave the United Nations.

You can never give an inch to these people, their craziness can’t be sated.

This 👆to me the kind of people who are happy about Brexit will be totally supporting Sunak to change our laws in order to send asylum seekers to Rwanda.

Fifteenth · 15/11/2023 19:16

When it falls apart, we will be outside it.

As a moral principle, Govt should cover the smallest feasible geographic area. We should not have continent wide or global Govt.

if there is nowhere to run, Govt can do what it likes.

In a milder way, Govts should compete. People should have other examples and be able to say “look, what they are doing in France works better”. That doesn’t happen with continent wide standardisation. And it’s important.

Also politicians won’t be able to lie and say “It’s Europe” when they do unpopular things.

HRTQueen · 15/11/2023 19:13

As if anyone who is genuinely interested in knowing the response would ask on MN 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread