Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone still thinks Brexit was a good idea?

231 replies

KimberleyClark · 14/11/2023 13:32

Genuinely curious. I can't see how it has improved things at all.

YANBU - Brexit was a terrible idea
YABU - it was a great idea

OP posts:
ClareBlue · 16/11/2023 23:05

You know that the remainers who refused to accept the democratic decision and spent years frustrating the process and challenging and delaying the democratic wish of the people were the reason we now have this government. Think on how much damage that has done. The only reason we got Borris is because he sent out a message of getting brexit done which was what people wanted. It would have been done well before if it wasn't for the illiberal elite trying to stop a democratic decision and creating division by labelling and vilifying people because they couldn't accept not everybody has the same life as them.
So can you name anything positive for trying to stop Brexit once it had been voted for. That has caused the most damage to the UK.

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 22:48

Tbf I didn't even vote for Brexit. 😂

It's just funny winding up the people that create and indulge in these endless threads aimed at creating a pile on.

Always goes the same way. They create a thread with a title like 'if you voted for Brexit please explain the benefits' (as if you couldn't have just googled it). All the usual suspects pile in and start frothing and then somebody trolls them all and they end up getting massively butthurt, making the entire thread a massive home goal lol.

And the people who actually voted Brexit don't care one iota because they already got what they voted for. They're probably lurking and smirking.

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 22:27

jasflowers · 16/11/2023 21:04

@CaramacFiend Never really used a trade, we can do most stuff ourselves or we ve friends that can, don't really want to pay £250 per hour for a plumber as i might a surgeon...... do you?

Lorry drivers wages have not stagnated for decades and decades (partners best friend is a driver) and he says wages have risen BUT because of the extra distances driven and overnight stays, lorry reat areas are terrible too, he is trying to get a better paid job with Open Reach.

You can bet all you like, you ve not a clue what anyone does with their money, its just a guess.
EU nationals live here, they have kids in schools, husbands. wives, cars, pay council tax, belong to gyms, book holidays in Scotland or Wales.

But you just keep posting uninformed 'Express style rants, got a horrible cold & i'm bored lol.

It sounds like your partner's friend just has a shit job. The money is in ADR tankers, supermarket/agency work, and people like DPD. My mate got paid £400 for a shift the other day, admittedly doing 13-14 hours but she now has four days off as she works 4on/4off doing a compressed week, so it was only a few extra hours.

Sleeping out is known as 'tramping' and is usually associated with general haulage. GH pays notoriously shit as the hauliers have driven down the prices in a race to the bottom. There's not much money in haulage. The money is in companies where haulage is a secondary function, especially 'own account' work.

The wages did stagnate. I know somebody getting paid £20 an hour at the same company I was paid £10.50 an hour six years ago. Exactly the same job. And ftr I never did a single night out in almost six years of trucking.

Also, are Openreach Engineers really earning £60k+? Or even £50k, which any half ambitious Class 1 driver can earn (basic salary before bonus and O/T is around £45k at the big supermarkets, with O/T usually paid at 1.5x rate).

travellinglighter · 16/11/2023 21:20

CranfordScones · 14/11/2023 14:09

All the supposed benefits of EU membership could be achieved without relinquishing sovereignty to an unelected, unaccountable, foreign body. The supposedly 'democratic' element (the Parliament) is possibly unique in being the world's only parliament without the powers to propose legislation (translation: it's a rubber-stamping talking shop).

Conversely, all the supposed disadvantages of Brexit could be eradicated at the stroke of a bureaucrat's pen. Political power games prevent that from happening. And yet people want more of that kind of thing.

The EU is unaccountable political patronage at its very worst.

And there we have it. Brexit wasn’t done right. Bloody bureaucrats could solve it all the stroke of a pen, we can have the same deal despite EU ruled saying we can’t etc. The fact we were told that it would be shit is irrelevant.

jasflowers · 16/11/2023 21:04

@CaramacFiend Never really used a trade, we can do most stuff ourselves or we ve friends that can, don't really want to pay £250 per hour for a plumber as i might a surgeon...... do you?

Lorry drivers wages have not stagnated for decades and decades (partners best friend is a driver) and he says wages have risen BUT because of the extra distances driven and overnight stays, lorry reat areas are terrible too, he is trying to get a better paid job with Open Reach.

You can bet all you like, you ve not a clue what anyone does with their money, its just a guess.
EU nationals live here, they have kids in schools, husbands. wives, cars, pay council tax, belong to gyms, book holidays in Scotland or Wales.

But you just keep posting uninformed 'Express style rants, got a horrible cold & i'm bored lol.

RocketIceLollie · 16/11/2023 21:01

Yeah lots of the promises by leave were hot air but so were a lot of the claims from remain. The banks haven't left London a ghost town. The car manufacturers haven't left the UK. The UK is not in recession (unlike some EU countries). There has been no jump in unemployment. Yeah there are some rough edges but the UK is doing fine with Brexit.

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 20:51

Yes, they probably didn't send all the money back to Poland. 😂

Crikeyalmighty · 16/11/2023 20:45

@jasflowers or rather like my friends builder who just pissed of to Barbados for 3 weeks in the winter- leaving her without much notice and an unusable kitchen.

Pretty sure plenty of EU tradesmen were eating, drinking , going to the supermarket and buying stuff too- like the rest of us

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 20:42

So the fact the rest of us can't get trades in and when we can they charge a fortune doesn't matter to you?

Did you actually care about (or even know about) the wages of HGV drivers stagnating for decades prior to Brexit as discussed above? Y'know the people that deliver everything you eat/buy, who collect your rubbish etc.

I can't get upset about people paying decent prices for decent labour in short supply. You'd pay it for legal/financial advice which is ubiquitous. You're just used to getting it for peanuts and pissed off you no longer can.

you don't know where EU nationals spent the money, the ones we knew had lives here and b) you don't know where a UK trade spends his or hers.

Well, I'm betting there's a much higher chance an EU national will send money out the country than a UK resident will.

jasflowers · 16/11/2023 20:13

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 19:49

or as has def happened, trades being able to charge what they like and cherry pick work, whether thats a benefit for anyone else is another matter.

Well, it's surely better if the salary is being spent in the UK rather than being sent back to Romania?

So the fact the rest of us can't get trades in and when we can they charge a fortune doesn't matter to you?
How does that help Wren Kitchens? or help build the homes we need? or keep rental properties in good order?

One or two assumptions there.

a) you don't know where EU nationals spent the money, the ones we knew had lives here and b) you don't know where a UK trade spends his or hers.

lordloveadog · 16/11/2023 20:10

It's been great for my country, because not even the numbskull far-right party suggests us leaving anymore.

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 19:49

or as has def happened, trades being able to charge what they like and cherry pick work, whether thats a benefit for anyone else is another matter.

Well, it's surely better if the salary is being spent in the UK rather than being sent back to Romania?

Crikeyalmighty · 16/11/2023 15:53

@bombastix I think it's dawned on some now- but they are too embarrassed to admit they were totally fooled and believed all the bullshit. My father in law being one and has admitted it.

Some of course still feel that way for varying reasons but it's nothing like the small majority it was-

Estimates and polls now have it about 63/37

bombastix · 16/11/2023 15:44

@Crikeyalmighty - exactly. If people were voting for less immigration and more resource on Brexit they are going to be very disappointed.

Crikeyalmighty · 16/11/2023 15:32

@jasflowers I have a desk in a business centre and a company here do visa processing and registering - big style- the face to face bit once they are here.

For the last year it is wall to wall- all from Africa, India, Pakistan, phillipines etc (the odd one from Hong Kong) and no it isn't all computer scientists or surgeons etc by a very long way . These are mainly families too- all will need housing, medical etc - a big difference to younger single EU people who come for a few years and often go back. These people are likely to stay . I don't have an issue with immigration- but I do have an issue when it was stated EU immigration was causing such big problems and we have simply replaced it with developing world immigration- and as a consequence we have now lost all the EU rights to live and work that we personally had- all incredibly pointless- even if you were looking at it purely from an immigration angle.

Crikeyalmighty · 16/11/2023 15:26

@jasflowers absolutely- we lived in Denmark for 20 months and many EU workers went to places like the Netherlands, Denmark, Eire , Sweden etc- where they can get by very well just with good English asa second language. They earn more, housing options are better (although Eire is challenging) and to be frank they aren't made to feel as unwelcome.

jasflowers · 16/11/2023 14:46

@Crikeyalmighty One thing that really pisses me off is that the UK, because of Brexit, is now taking HCPs from countries like Zimbabwe and Nepal, leaving their own populations with even worse healthcare and we are all happy with that.

Over 60 % of new starters in the NHS last year were from overseas, EU HCP's no longer come here because its a PIA to do so, not impossible but lot harder than working in another EU country

Crikeyalmighty · 16/11/2023 14:41

@jasflowers hit the send a bit early!!

Has Brexit made getting a house rental easier- no- because the gvt changed rules that now make it not beneficial anyway

Has it stopped immigration- no it's trebled - because they suddenly realised a lot of those pesky EU people were actually filing in a lot of gaps in the lower paid jobs that need to be done, not sitting around claiming £1000s in benefits every month

Has it made seeing a GP easier?- no, because the root cause of this issue had sod all to do with the EU

Has it made goods cheaper? Of course not because various taxes and red tape now come into play and various trade agreements that were in place now no longer apply (USA being one- there wasn't a formal trade
agreement but there was an informal one on goods up to a certain value)

Has it cut red tape for business? Certainly not for anyone who has any element of nonUK business- be it import or export.

Has it been a ginormous waste of £400 billion that could have been out to better use- an emphatic yes!!

Crikeyalmighty · 16/11/2023 14:29

@jasflowers exactly this. There are a few winners but it's at the expense of everyone else.

jasflowers · 16/11/2023 14:11

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 11:04

I think that part of the difficulty is that neither side will ever concede they were wrong, even if it does start to look that way. Hell would literally freeze over before remainers would ever admit there were any benefits to Brexit.

There are limited and specific benefits to Brexit & some people have mentioned them.
But Brexit wasn't about a former Asda worker becoming an HGV driver and trebling their salary or as has def happened, trades being able to charge what they like and cherry pick work, whether thats a benefit for anyone else is another matter.

Whether Brexitiers like it or not, the EU is a powerful economic bloc, e.g they told Apple to change their charging port to usb c, Apple did this, they wouldn't for the UK, they'd laugh at the request.

I cannot believe how much cheaper a wide range of goods are in the EU compared to the UK, we always paid a small premium but its a lot more now, thats if you can still get them here.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 16/11/2023 14:09

… the question being why people hate DC so much compared to the bunch of… politicians who have followed him.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 16/11/2023 14:08

OK honest question here though - obviously it was a huge miscalculation to concede the option of a referendum by DC. But had we stayed in the SM, what was called BRINO by the hardline brexiteers, it wouldn’t have been as catastrophic. In my view much more damage was caused by the likes of Rees-Mogh, David Davis, even May. Most of the Leave side campaigned on a platform of staying in the single market, which was incompatible with their other proposals but never mind that. I presume Cameron’s lot thought that given that was the only realistic part of their platform, they would run with that.

Oblomov23 · 16/11/2023 14:02

We can ask Cameron, now he's back. AngryImbecile. Miscalculation of his to ever suggest a referendum. UK population has a reading age of 9. Hmm

fearfuloffluff · 16/11/2023 13:47

Topseyt123 · 16/11/2023 13:42

I'm a remain voter.

Brexshit was a terrible idea and there are no upside. Well, except that UKIP finally disintegrated and Nigel Farage is now heading into the jungle on I'm a Celebrity. He should be right at home there surrounded by cockroaches, snakes and huge, horrendous spiders.

UKIP only disintegrated because enough of the Tory party became indistinguishable from them.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 16/11/2023 13:46

Lol @Topseyt123. I don’t watch I’m a Celebrity but it’s quite satisfying to think of Farage putting something nasty into his mouth, makes a change from all the nasty things that come out of it.