Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone still thinks Brexit was a good idea?

231 replies

KimberleyClark · 14/11/2023 13:32

Genuinely curious. I can't see how it has improved things at all.

YANBU - Brexit was a terrible idea
YABU - it was a great idea

OP posts:
Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 11:42

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 17/11/2023 08:53

Lockdown had a lot of consequences for everyone. I lost my relationship, my job, my Master’s degree that I’ve been saving for three years for and I spent three years in a mental hospital. Just because it affected me doesn’t mean it wasn’t worth it on a community level or even an individual level (I’ve still got four grandparents alive) or that it wasn’t preferable to what might have happened otherwise. Also, the country was advised or in your word encouraged to take those measures. Not compelled. The WHO has no coercive or even legal powers. The government, who gained a huge amount more power through Brexit, decided to implement lockdown. Your elected officials. It’s a bit like the old question “if all your friends jumped off a cliff, would you do too?”. You’d be stupid if that was the only reason.

Good points and true enough (except for it being worthwhile).

Our elected officials didn’t have to jump off the cliff because their friends did it. But of their friends hadn’t done it, they wouldn’t even have thought about it.

Probably not an EU thing but the UK was less appalling than most of Europe. Not that that’s saying much.

I’m sorry about your mental health. I’m not sure if it’s helping you to feel that you were sacrificed for something bigger. You were in fact abused just because they could. Can your mental health work if you channel anger instead?

Crikeyalmighty · 17/11/2023 11:12

@lightisnotwhite one reason for many older people is healthcare. There are complications and huge expense in using long term travel insurance that would previously have been covered off (that's if you can get it if you've had prior health issues) and it's sometimes a seasons split kind of thing- they wanted to use say April, May, June and sept oct and that now doesn't work easily.

It's certainly an issue for those who can't afford to keep 2 bases and planned on a place in Spain and a bit of occasional Airbnb when they came back to uk too. Not like your family will want you camped with them 6 months of the year .

KimberleyClark · 17/11/2023 11:10

smilesup · 17/11/2023 08:41

We know it's not a good idea in this house as DS wanted to work in Germany and now can't.
I want to retire in Greece but can't. My parents no longer can spend 6 months in the UK and 6 months in Spain as they had been for 10 years and planned to do for decades.
None of that will be resolved before my parents die.
Let alone the fact we can't trade as cheaply and easily with our neighbours.

I know someone who had a house in Spain and was planning to retire there. Voted Brexit.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 17/11/2023 11:07

Sourisblanche · 17/11/2023 11:03

The EU really has moved on, Brexit is largely forgotten and it’s all about Ukraine and their accession to the EU now.

However, Brexit did appear in French media this week, using the UK as an example that even though the UK has quit the EU it still has a big immigration problem. Interesting I thought.

I imagine this will come up more as the EU deals with its own immigration problem, a big one for some countries, and no one wants voters to get too many ideas on what to do

Sourisblanche · 17/11/2023 11:03

The EU really has moved on, Brexit is largely forgotten and it’s all about Ukraine and their accession to the EU now.

However, Brexit did appear in French media this week, using the UK as an example that even though the UK has quit the EU it still has a big immigration problem. Interesting I thought.

smilesup · 17/11/2023 10:52

lightisnotwhite · 17/11/2023 08:51

All of those issues are being re assessed currently though. It would have happened quicker if not for Covid.
Why can’t your parents spend 6 months in Spain then ? It’s 90 days out of every 180. That’s 6 months a year.
People from all over the world work in the EU.

They will be dead or too old before it's sorted. They are 80 plus.
The 180 days is rolling. So would have to come home for 180 days before the next 90 so doesn't work as tips into the next year's allowance (180 plus 90 x 2 is more than 365! )
They rented out their house for 6 months to travelling academics, lots of work to get it ready can't do that twice as won't work with seasons etc.

CaramacFiend · 17/11/2023 10:48

jasflowers · 17/11/2023 08:43

Not really, its a rather stupid analogy.

When you leave a controlling partner, you don't expect to still have a close working relationship with them & then pay in large amounts of your income to still be able to use the facilities you used to enjoy together.

DV isn't really a nice thing to drag into this debate either.

Infantile thinking, much like blaming remainers in parliament when they were in the minority and that it was the ERG that gave us a poor NI deal, took us out of Horizon and Europol.

We then thought Oh shit and decided to pay in billions to renegotiate and rejoin Horizon.

Edited

Maybe it's more like going self employed and losing your company benefits in the short term but having more freedom as you grow the business. 😂 No more holiday requests, you go when it suits you.

MidnightOnceMore · 17/11/2023 09:25

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 17/11/2023 08:53

Lockdown had a lot of consequences for everyone. I lost my relationship, my job, my Master’s degree that I’ve been saving for three years for and I spent three years in a mental hospital. Just because it affected me doesn’t mean it wasn’t worth it on a community level or even an individual level (I’ve still got four grandparents alive) or that it wasn’t preferable to what might have happened otherwise. Also, the country was advised or in your word encouraged to take those measures. Not compelled. The WHO has no coercive or even legal powers. The government, who gained a huge amount more power through Brexit, decided to implement lockdown. Your elected officials. It’s a bit like the old question “if all your friends jumped off a cliff, would you do too?”. You’d be stupid if that was the only reason.

This is such an interesting post.

I hope things have improved for you Flowers

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 17/11/2023 08:55

Wait, sorry, it was one year, I was typing quickly. It’s been three years of Covid but I spent ONE year in the mental hospital (and a lot of accumulated time on general wards. Apologies.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 17/11/2023 08:53

Lockdown had a lot of consequences for everyone. I lost my relationship, my job, my Master’s degree that I’ve been saving for three years for and I spent three years in a mental hospital. Just because it affected me doesn’t mean it wasn’t worth it on a community level or even an individual level (I’ve still got four grandparents alive) or that it wasn’t preferable to what might have happened otherwise. Also, the country was advised or in your word encouraged to take those measures. Not compelled. The WHO has no coercive or even legal powers. The government, who gained a huge amount more power through Brexit, decided to implement lockdown. Your elected officials. It’s a bit like the old question “if all your friends jumped off a cliff, would you do too?”. You’d be stupid if that was the only reason.

lightisnotwhite · 17/11/2023 08:51

smilesup · 17/11/2023 08:41

We know it's not a good idea in this house as DS wanted to work in Germany and now can't.
I want to retire in Greece but can't. My parents no longer can spend 6 months in the UK and 6 months in Spain as they had been for 10 years and planned to do for decades.
None of that will be resolved before my parents die.
Let alone the fact we can't trade as cheaply and easily with our neighbours.

All of those issues are being re assessed currently though. It would have happened quicker if not for Covid.
Why can’t your parents spend 6 months in Spain then ? It’s 90 days out of every 180. That’s 6 months a year.
People from all over the world work in the EU.

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 08:46

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 17/11/2023 08:39

@fifteen and @ClareBlue no, I’m sorry, that’s just silly. Countries aren’t people and even if they were, Brexit has put the UK under the thumb of a government intent on institutionally gaslighting is on a grand scale with as few moderating influences as possible. It’s much more like choosing to flounce out of the local council where your opportunity to deliberate and equal vote with the other councillors isn’t good enough for you, you actively sought membership in the first place (it’s not like the EU love-bombed us), have consented to all the changes over the years in an active way, even if it means a compromise and the outcome has been an overall rise in standards of living.

One of the most pernicious bits of Brexit rhetoric is assuming the country is a homogeneous bloc of “the People”. It’s not. It’s not “national self-harm” because it’s a group of rich, powerful, corrupt people imposing these decisions on us according to their personal needs and goals, it’s them doing it to us. A country is a group of people who don’t generally have free choice as to where they’re born, with differing opinions, outlooks, priorities, needs. We weren’t oppressed in the EU, we were big power players with special privileges. To flounce out because you don’t want to abide by mutually agreed rules, causing a pretty nasty knock-on impact and diverting interest from what the government ought to be focusing on, which is improving the lives of the populace.
Also, the DV analogy is shite because a country isn’t going to be emotionally damaged by the decisions of an NGO. Btw, as a victim of DV it’s truly offensive as well. And every line @ClareBlue has written has been fed to them by an organisation which has hired consultants, advertisers, strategists specifically to play on people’s emotions and it is so, so tiring to hear the same shit for years on end when it’s nonsense.

One big recent example….

People have been hugely emotionally damaged by Lockdown (Govt action), encouraged by WHO (NGO). Personally I’ll never get over it.

jasflowers · 17/11/2023 08:43

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 08:28

This is a good way of thinking about it. Thanks.

Not really, its a rather stupid analogy.

When you leave a controlling partner, you don't expect to still have a close working relationship with them & then pay in large amounts of your income to still be able to use the facilities you used to enjoy together.

DV isn't really a nice thing to drag into this debate either.

Infantile thinking, much like blaming remainers in parliament when they were in the minority and that it was the ERG that gave us a poor NI deal, took us out of Horizon and Europol.

We then thought Oh shit and decided to pay in billions to renegotiate and rejoin Horizon.

smilesup · 17/11/2023 08:41

Dotjones · 14/11/2023 13:43

We'll never know whether Brexit was a good idea or not, just as we'd never have known whether remaining was better if the vote had been to stay.

We weren't voting to freeze everything as it was in 2016. We were voting whether to continue down the route of ever-closer integration. I think a lot of people who voted Brexit weren't anti the status quo, it just felt like it was now or never - if we didn't vote Leave then, we'd be trapped for another generation at least.

I never expected there to be any big immediate benefits - it was always going to take a decade of things being worse before we'd start to reap the gradual improvements. I admit I didn't factor the pandemic into my expectations, neither did I expect it to take so long to actually leave after the votes were counted. So my expectation of things being better by the late 2020s has slipped to the mid 2030s.

We know it's not a good idea in this house as DS wanted to work in Germany and now can't.
I want to retire in Greece but can't. My parents no longer can spend 6 months in the UK and 6 months in Spain as they had been for 10 years and planned to do for decades.
None of that will be resolved before my parents die.
Let alone the fact we can't trade as cheaply and easily with our neighbours.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 17/11/2023 08:39

@fifteen and @ClareBlue no, I’m sorry, that’s just silly. Countries aren’t people and even if they were, Brexit has put the UK under the thumb of a government intent on institutionally gaslighting is on a grand scale with as few moderating influences as possible. It’s much more like choosing to flounce out of the local council where your opportunity to deliberate and equal vote with the other councillors isn’t good enough for you, you actively sought membership in the first place (it’s not like the EU love-bombed us), have consented to all the changes over the years in an active way, even if it means a compromise and the outcome has been an overall rise in standards of living.

One of the most pernicious bits of Brexit rhetoric is assuming the country is a homogeneous bloc of “the People”. It’s not. It’s not “national self-harm” because it’s a group of rich, powerful, corrupt people imposing these decisions on us according to their personal needs and goals, it’s them doing it to us. A country is a group of people who don’t generally have free choice as to where they’re born, with differing opinions, outlooks, priorities, needs. We weren’t oppressed in the EU, we were big power players with special privileges. To flounce out because you don’t want to abide by mutually agreed rules, causing a pretty nasty knock-on impact and diverting interest from what the government ought to be focusing on, which is improving the lives of the populace.
Also, the DV analogy is shite because a country isn’t going to be emotionally damaged by the decisions of an NGO. Btw, as a victim of DV it’s truly offensive as well. And every line @ClareBlue has written has been fed to them by an organisation which has hired consultants, advertisers, strategists specifically to play on people’s emotions and it is so, so tiring to hear the same shit for years on end when it’s nonsense.

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 08:37

fearfuloffluff · 16/11/2023 13:24

If the EU falls apart, do you really think the UK would be unharmed?

The rest of the world is forming trade blocks in order to compete with the likes of US and China. They do it because it makes sense.

Standardisation is usually the product of consensus from experts and stakeholders. Brexiteers always criticise the concept of standards but can never identify which are problematic, because they represent best practice that industry tends to sign up to. It's a principled opposition that doesn't make business sense.

Like now we've left the EU, are manufacturers queuing up to start making products in inch sizes etc? No because it would be idiotic. Using standards gives you access to the widest possible market and helps ensure products are high quality/don't injure people.

You are conflating two things.

When businesses copy good ideas from each other and become more similar, that’s fine. It’s beneficial to the business and the customer.

When Govts enforce standardisation that prevents good ideas from competing. It also costs businesses to implement and to demonstrate compliance to enforcers. Quite apart from its abusive nature, this makes products more expensive and less innovative for customers.

But the most important thing is Govt. Govts are nothing but coercion. If Govts co-operate they can be as abusive as they like because there is nowhere for the citizens to run and no alternative system for them to point to. Preventing Govts from merging is literally life preserving.

Adamfromgirls · 17/11/2023 08:36

It's a terrible idea but I don't go along with the idea that everyone who voted leave was either thick / racist. I know a few people, who have admitted to voting leave and they're neither of the above but there was so much misinformation about at the time. I can't think of any benefits, there may be some but I can't think of any.

I feel really sad for the future generations, DS really wants to go and study and work in Europe when he's older and it's so expensive and complicated now. It just took away so many things that we took for granted for our DC .

Maybe they'll reverse it when they all come of age.

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 08:29

ClareBlue · 16/11/2023 23:05

You know that the remainers who refused to accept the democratic decision and spent years frustrating the process and challenging and delaying the democratic wish of the people were the reason we now have this government. Think on how much damage that has done. The only reason we got Borris is because he sent out a message of getting brexit done which was what people wanted. It would have been done well before if it wasn't for the illiberal elite trying to stop a democratic decision and creating division by labelling and vilifying people because they couldn't accept not everybody has the same life as them.
So can you name anything positive for trying to stop Brexit once it had been voted for. That has caused the most damage to the UK.

Absolutely.
Though we are still better off. This is beginning to be admitted now.

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 08:28

CaramacFiend · 17/11/2023 08:26

I've seen it likened on here to leaving a controlling partner where you're better off just getting out than 'waiting for the right time' and never leaving. You may have been financially better off with the controlling partner but escaping coercion and having your freedom is more important.

This is a good way of thinking about it. Thanks.

CaramacFiend · 17/11/2023 08:26

Pipsquiggle · 17/11/2023 06:58

@ClareBlue

I am afraid the Leave campaign lied and lied and lied.
They didn't have a plan. I will say that again They. Did. Not. Have. A. Plan. There was no 'oven-ready deal,' probably because they didn't think they were going to win.

Blaming the remainers for the shit show that has followed is misdirection.

Anyone who knows even a smattering of how EU trade works, knew that divorcing these decades old arrangements would take rigour, process and detail - attributes none of the leave MPs had. It was all slogans with no substance.

I've seen it likened on here to leaving a controlling partner where you're better off just getting out than 'waiting for the right time' and never leaving. You may have been financially better off with the controlling partner but escaping coercion and having your freedom is more important.

bombastix · 17/11/2023 08:25

The joke is that the UK is, because of the proximity and size of the EU and it's commercial significance to us, unlikely to derogate away from its standards in any significant sense.

Business doesn't want that. Yes maybe technically these decisions are ours, but in most cases we are rule followers.

All this stuff about lorry drivers and goods is pretty old fashioned. Yes that's a part of the economy but the major part of the economy for the U.K. is services. And we were doing really well at that before we decided to leave.

The absolute best deal for services is the EU. It is was easy.

Repositioning our economy so we should prioritise goods and manufacturing is the mentality of some time in the 19th century. It is stupid. And it's not going to grow our economy which we desperately need.

I cannot help but feel a lot of people had no idea why the UK was a rich country but it's our services and IP. Not small business, farming, or light manufacturing.

Pipsquiggle · 17/11/2023 06:58

@ClareBlue

I am afraid the Leave campaign lied and lied and lied.
They didn't have a plan. I will say that again They. Did. Not. Have. A. Plan. There was no 'oven-ready deal,' probably because they didn't think they were going to win.

Blaming the remainers for the shit show that has followed is misdirection.

Anyone who knows even a smattering of how EU trade works, knew that divorcing these decades old arrangements would take rigour, process and detail - attributes none of the leave MPs had. It was all slogans with no substance.

CaramacFiend · 16/11/2023 23:53

ClareBlue · 16/11/2023 23:05

You know that the remainers who refused to accept the democratic decision and spent years frustrating the process and challenging and delaying the democratic wish of the people were the reason we now have this government. Think on how much damage that has done. The only reason we got Borris is because he sent out a message of getting brexit done which was what people wanted. It would have been done well before if it wasn't for the illiberal elite trying to stop a democratic decision and creating division by labelling and vilifying people because they couldn't accept not everybody has the same life as them.
So can you name anything positive for trying to stop Brexit once it had been voted for. That has caused the most damage to the UK.

That's a fair point tbh. People voted for him because he made all the right noises about finally 'getting it done'.

And now we're stuck with the Tories as a result.

fearfuloffluff · 16/11/2023 23:18

ClareBlue · 16/11/2023 23:05

You know that the remainers who refused to accept the democratic decision and spent years frustrating the process and challenging and delaying the democratic wish of the people were the reason we now have this government. Think on how much damage that has done. The only reason we got Borris is because he sent out a message of getting brexit done which was what people wanted. It would have been done well before if it wasn't for the illiberal elite trying to stop a democratic decision and creating division by labelling and vilifying people because they couldn't accept not everybody has the same life as them.
So can you name anything positive for trying to stop Brexit once it had been voted for. That has caused the most damage to the UK.

What?!

The delay was because brexiteers had zero plans for what to do if they won.

And democratic wish of the people - 52%, many of whom wanted a protest vote. Give me a break. There has been a pro remain majority since the referendum and it only gets larger.

Brexit has failed, it's the fault of the twats who pushed it through, not the people who voted against it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread