Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask if anyone still thinks Brexit was a good idea?

231 replies

KimberleyClark · 14/11/2023 13:32

Genuinely curious. I can't see how it has improved things at all.

YANBU - Brexit was a terrible idea
YABU - it was a great idea

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
jasflowers · 13/12/2023 07:53

Everanewbie · 12/12/2023 14:20

Thanks for the correction, duly noted.

So you'd like to see a world government? Or just a European government? Or perhaps a UK government when its a party that you agree with, but then cede control back to Brussels once your approved party loses?

You seem to hold continental Europe in much higher esteem than the UK, but I'm afraid that power hungry, corrupt politicians that work out of self interest are just as prevalent out in the continent. If not, more so, look at Italy for example. I'd rather keep the power to evict in the UK and I want our laws to be for our benefit, first and foremost, while being responsible neighbours and trading partners at the same time.

European (EU) countries seem to be able to jail their corrupt politicians, not so here in the UK.
Italy jailed their former leader, as did the French....

So either we aren't corrupt enough (Iraq war and PPE/Covid scandals/Grenfell etc etc would suggest otherwise) OR don't hold our politicians to account?

atm we aren't responsible neighbours, far from it, we cannot even bring ourselves to be part of Europol, essential in order to fight organise crime inc trafficking gangs.

No idea why you think there is going to be a European wide government, the eU struggles to agree on much at all, even their much vaunted "regulations" are pretty lame,
The UK is the King of red tape, most of it utterly pointless, as a CEO friend of mine said a few years ago "Its easier to export to Lisbon than it is to send stuff to Luton"

lightisnotwhite · 13/12/2023 07:02

You don’t have to have a referendum on everything though. The U.K. through letters and email to the media, to MP’s through surveys and research will say that “people” want less illegal immigration and probably less legal migration into the U.K. as well.

Which is fine except refugees of all types are coming through safe EU countries to be here. Despite the Tories and how terrible the whole place is. So Rwanda is both the deterrent and somewhere safer than where they’ve originally come from.

Crikeyalmighty · 12/12/2023 16:21

@Everanewbie you speak as if we didn't have representatives in it or the power of veto - we also had a great deal of influence in it till theTorys got in in 2010 and toned it down to please the headbangers in their party.

The fact is we have lost influence in the world generally and certainly commercially for many businesses. I wouldn't invest here unless I had a totally UK centric business. All we have essentially done is handed much of our best business to EU competitors on a plate. Do you have a business operating mainly within UK and EU as that's where the market is and always will be for your product? (we do sell to rest of world too but that isn't where the market is) I do, and it is now full of beauracratic red tape, huge costs , tax and VAT issues . I find that people that don't factor all this in usually have very UK centric business and don't give a shit about others businesses.

To be frank I quite like the fact there were checks and balances within the EU that would stop the Tory's making outrageously awful and very poorly thought out policies.

An example today is Rwanda and cleverly saying this is 'what the British public want' - I clearly missed that referendum. It's the whole manner of 'we will do whatever we want and push through changing the law to suit our ideology' - that is not democratic- the top law court disagreed- so off they go tinkering around with the law and burning £295 million in the process.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 12/12/2023 15:59

Also @Everanewbie sorry but the EU is about as accountable as our government. Elected politicians - MEPs. Elected heads of state - the Council. Extensive, published debate on every single piece of law they make. Before we left, a right for one state to veto any bit of legislation.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 12/12/2023 15:56

@Everanewbie of course I don’t think a “world government” is a good idea, but we as a country are signed up to a multitude of agreements which keep our actions to some extent in check. It’s part of the “least worst” way to run the world as it is at the moment.

And again, no, I accept it when a government I don’t approve of is in power (although some of the specific actions of the current one leave much to be desired). But they, and past Labour AND Tory governments, signed up to those floors for rights etc and I was grateful to have that check in place.

Everanewbie · 12/12/2023 15:02

@SerendipityJane well they don't make laws, they approve them or send them back to the commons. But there is a very good argument for doing away with the lords, but on balance I don't think it hurts to have a house subject bills to further scrutiny. But the existence of the lords doesn't suddenly make a federal and unaccountable Europe acceptable to me.

SerendipityJane · 12/12/2023 14:48

People don't like the idea of someone making laws whom they cannot remove.

Ah, you mean the house of lords !

Everanewbie · 12/12/2023 14:20

Thanks for the correction, duly noted.

So you'd like to see a world government? Or just a European government? Or perhaps a UK government when its a party that you agree with, but then cede control back to Brussels once your approved party loses?

You seem to hold continental Europe in much higher esteem than the UK, but I'm afraid that power hungry, corrupt politicians that work out of self interest are just as prevalent out in the continent. If not, more so, look at Italy for example. I'd rather keep the power to evict in the UK and I want our laws to be for our benefit, first and foremost, while being responsible neighbours and trading partners at the same time.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 12/12/2023 14:09

Also, it’s trade bloc for next time.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 12/12/2023 14:08

All right - why should it be the UK electorate? Why should this specific bit of land, or Germany or Spain for that matter, be the HUGE number of people who determine democratic decisions? Do we get any input on what the government do day to day (the answer is a categorical no)? Is it possible to ensure true democratic participation when tens of millions of people are involved? Democracy was designed in Athens, a comparatively tiny city-state where the elite could be roped in to every decision. I’d rather have the EU, however imperfect, having the final call on some - not all, just some - decisions than let our elected elite rip.

And yes, if Labour or the Greens were in power, I’d welcome a safeguard. International law is fairly ineffectual anyway but at least there was someone out there deciding on floors for execrable behaviour, whatever their nationality.

Everanewbie · 12/12/2023 13:59

Who were the EU democratically accountable to? If it isn't the UK electorate, then it isn't democratically accountable. That's the point. People don't like the idea of someone making laws whom they cannot remove. I can't see why someone has more trust in a beaurocrat in Brussels that they cannot elect or remove, than their own MP. I can't see why a Dutch, French, German, Maltese or Irish MEP is the adult in the room, when for some reason our own elected representative is the child in the room? If a UK government makes decisions on a hypothetical bill that I disagree with, and I voted against, I can console myself that a greater proportion of people in my town and by extension, country, wanted this person with these views. Its less palatable when I oppose it, our politicians oppose it, but people from another country want it so its imposed on us.

Would your view be different if the party in power in the UK were more aligned to you ideologically? Are they still the child in the room who need a grown up German or Spaniard holding their hand?

For what it is worth I was a remainer, now an accepter. My thoughts were that the treaties, directives, legislation etc. were so ingrained an integrated that Brexit wasn't worth the hassle. But the sovereignty argument is one I have great sympathy for.

All in all, Brexit is down to EU mission creep where a trade block snowballed into greater and greater degrees of federal political and legislative union. That is where many drew the line.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 12/12/2023 12:26

@Everanewbie no they don’t. Sorry to get upset about this but I think the EU was highly imperfect and yet still better than nothing. There was actually more democratic accountability within the EU structure than there is within our own government. Can you think of a single incident of democracy triumphant in our country (countries? Never sure how to describe the UK but Wales, Scotland and NI have even less power than England) apart from the Brexit vote in the past twenty years? We get titbits thrown to us occasionally - gay marriage etc - when we can get the press on our side and mostly when we take extra-democratic measures like mass protest, which, oh look, is being cracked down on hard. Like the ability of citizens to vote a failing government out, which has already been removed by the FTPA. Of course the EU had many flaws - let’s go back to everyone’s favourite Winston Churchill and remember that he once said democracy was the least worst system of governance, NOT the best. But at least there were some adults restraining the full-grown brats who run our government. They wanted to let water companies discharge sewage in our rivers, the EU said no chance. Now look what’s happening.
In addition, they are piggybacking on this to try to get us out of the ECHR. Courts ARE a form of democratic accountability.

Everanewbie · 12/12/2023 12:10

@Crikeyalmighty in my opinion this lack of engagement with opposing views contributed to the loss of the brexit vote in the first place. The UK electorate had no powers to oust foreign MEPs or EU officials and were therefore not accountable to us. Unfortunately, many rejoiners labour under the illusion that the EU is a perfect organisation and represents all that is good in the world, and that critics are either stupid, racist or both.

Crikeyalmighty · 12/12/2023 11:44

Democratic accountability?? We always had that- maybe your moniker matches your outlook !

bonkersAlice · 12/12/2023 11:02

No longer part of the European federal experiment. Democratic accountability. Self governance. Independent foreign policy. Less limited parochial outlook and a wider global view.

Crikeyalmighty · 18/11/2023 00:23

The strange thing is that somewhere like the US seems to have an awful lot of people pumping out the 'libertarian' model- I've always found it pretty regulated on many things when it comes to taxation in particular - taxes on everything and it's mother, lots and lots of public service jobs and certainly not low cost and you actually don't get much for your tax dollar either.

The Americans I met in Denmark felt it was a better deal paying more tax but getting much more covered off for it- health, cheap childcare, good public transport,

The libertarian model is all well and good if you are doing ok- not so great when anything at all goes wrong and is an incredibly selfish model too

Crikeyalmighty · 18/11/2023 00:13

@DogInATent none at all that I know of- sweden Denmark, Switzerland, Germany, Norway- all have high standard of living (higher for some obviously) but have shit loads of regulation.

Pipsquiggle · 17/11/2023 22:27

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 22:00

Govt is expensive. The more we carry, the poorer we get. Who do you think suffers most.

I can’t speak for others. But when people identify and advocate for something that makes us all better off, it’s likely they believe it.

You can’t pretend not to see that richer countries have lower regulation. And countries who grow their Govts too far become poorer.

@Fifteenth please just read your posts. You are not making sense.

Just Google richest countries in the world - some will be in the EU (that all pay to be in it), some will be authoritarian states, some will be democracies. 'Richer countries have less regulation' is just false.

You are conflating the cost of effective government with our government, (which should have rigorous scrutiny) & the cost of the EU.

I can’t speak for others. But when people identify and advocate for something that makes us all better off, it’s likely they believe
Again you were told lies

DogInATent · 17/11/2023 22:19

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 22:00

Govt is expensive. The more we carry, the poorer we get. Who do you think suffers most.

I can’t speak for others. But when people identify and advocate for something that makes us all better off, it’s likely they believe it.

You can’t pretend not to see that richer countries have lower regulation. And countries who grow their Govts too far become poorer.

Which richer countries have lower regulation and a high standard of living for the least well off in society?

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 22:00

Pipsquiggle · 17/11/2023 20:32

@Fifteenth
Yeah those pesky health and safety laws and high food standards (to name but 2) - they really oppress the working class.

FFS, read what you've posted and engage critical thinking.

Those that bankrolled the leave campaign don't give a shit about the working class. It's all about how they can make more profits with less red tape (by lowering standards)

Govt is expensive. The more we carry, the poorer we get. Who do you think suffers most.

I can’t speak for others. But when people identify and advocate for something that makes us all better off, it’s likely they believe it.

You can’t pretend not to see that richer countries have lower regulation. And countries who grow their Govts too far become poorer.

Pipsquiggle · 17/11/2023 20:32

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 19:28

Not “softies”. People who don’t think about the longer term consequences or costs of their actions, particularly on those who are poorer already.

Regulation increases costs in all areas. Poor people suffer most. Remainers should think about that. The libertarians have thought about it.

@Fifteenth
Yeah those pesky health and safety laws and high food standards (to name but 2) - they really oppress the working class.

FFS, read what you've posted and engage critical thinking.

Those that bankrolled the leave campaign don't give a shit about the working class. It's all about how they can make more profits with less red tape (by lowering standards)

DogInATent · 17/11/2023 19:36

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 19:28

Not “softies”. People who don’t think about the longer term consequences or costs of their actions, particularly on those who are poorer already.

Regulation increases costs in all areas. Poor people suffer most. Remainers should think about that. The libertarians have thought about it.

Yeah, because it's not the poor people living in flood-prone areas, doing the shitty dangerous jobs, and exposed to the worst pollution. FFS. TAM.

Fifteenth · 17/11/2023 19:28

fearfuloffluff · 17/11/2023 19:04

We could have exceeded EU protections within the EU, they were a minimum not a maximum. Leaving only facilitates a dilution of standards and weakening of protections.

Because the people who bankrolled brexit don't believe in silly stuff like benefits, mat leave, environmental law. They're libertarians who think that stuff is for softies.

Not “softies”. People who don’t think about the longer term consequences or costs of their actions, particularly on those who are poorer already.

Regulation increases costs in all areas. Poor people suffer most. Remainers should think about that. The libertarians have thought about it.

fearfuloffluff · 17/11/2023 19:04

ClareBlue · 17/11/2023 17:06

And we don't need to be in EU to have environmental protection, or social justice or employment protection, we can legislation for any area we want to.

We could have exceeded EU protections within the EU, they were a minimum not a maximum. Leaving only facilitates a dilution of standards and weakening of protections.

Because the people who bankrolled brexit don't believe in silly stuff like benefits, mat leave, environmental law. They're libertarians who think that stuff is for softies.

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2023 18:09

Democracy doesn't stop after a referendum though, does it? This 'will of the people' crap suggests that just because dom cummings' lies got brexit over the line, it needs to stay that way for all eternity.

I was told repeatedly in 2017 - and 2019 - that I had to vote Tory to "respect the referendum".