Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To lend money to family?

38 replies

Sunnylove22 · 14/11/2023 13:17

BIL was sacked from his job a couple of weeks ago - he doesn’t think it’s his fault but nevertheless a month before Christmas. He says he can afford all his bills but will struggle to buy food shopping and very few Christmas presents. He has just got a job with an agency so will have some money right before Christmas.

We have come into £300 unexpectedly which we were going to put into our summer holiday find. DH has asked if he could lend it to his brother to tide him over until Christmas. (I’ve agreed as I wouldn’t want to see anyone struggle but in the back of my mind thinking we won’t see this money again).

BIL initially said he would manage and doesn’t want it however phoned this morning and asked if we can still help him. I’m more reluctant now as over the weekend on the dreaded socials we saw his wife and 3 kids, go out for breakfast, go to a soft play, get a McDonald’s, it looks like she had a heavy drinking night and out on the town then out for Sunday dinner.

DH still wants to lend him the money. I won’t say no if he insists but I do think I should point out the fact of we’re helping but his wife looks to be spending as she pleases (she doesn’t work so has no income, they don’t have savings). We haven’t spoken about it as DH went to work early but AIBU by pointing this out?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Notinmylifethyme · 14/11/2023 16:34

Cash? No.

There was a reason he was sacked, and he should have had a safety net anyway if he has a family.

I would consider a food shop delivery, but only the basics we have when we're on a budget.

But hard cash, for him to go out and spend on stuff I couldn't afford? Lol. Oh no!!

Ragwort · 14/11/2023 16:25

Don't ... unless you can genuinely gift the money and don't need it yourself (which it absolutely sounds as though this is not the case).
We have (stupidly) lent money on two separate occasions to a family member and to a friend, both in 'dire straights' at the time .. so they told us. Never saw any of it again ....

uncomfortablydumb53 · 14/11/2023 16:20

I would never lend what I couldn't afford to lose

Sunnylove22 · 14/11/2023 16:17

This is exactly my thoughts.
We’re not well off, we work hard and we budget well to afford what we want but the £300 we have is an unexpected income so we wouldn’t be under hardship if we never got it back.

DH thinks BIL will 100% pay it back. I don’t know him well enough to make a judgment on that.

It just feels a bit in bad taste when BIL is saying they can’t afford food shopping and then I’ve seen all this…

I think DH has seen the socials now as he messaged me but I will be going ahead and having a conversation with him.

OP posts:
Gillypie23 · 14/11/2023 16:08

No your nit unreasonable to point it out. You can't recant the offer. Just be prepared to not get it back. That's my experience.

Dawn17 · 14/11/2023 15:43

@2jacqi yes and the worst of it was he'd told her the amount we'd inherited but he'd knocked a few thousand off the figure. He then asked me to lie and say we'd been left a smaller amount than we had, as he didn't want her to know he'd spent a few thousand treating himself first, before putting the rest in their wedding/house fund. When I questioned him whether lying about money was a good start to a marriage, he told me where to go. Predictably, their marriage didn't last long.

Skodacool · 14/11/2023 15:27

I’m sorry but they must have spent well in excess of £100 over the weekend. That’s not what people do when they’ve just lost their income. Lend them £300 if you’re happy to not see it again and be asked from more.

2jacqi · 14/11/2023 15:09

@Sunnylove22 No No NO!!! OP you cannot lend this money to your BIL when his partner has probably spend the same amount in a weekend with soft play and meals out etc!!

2jacqi · 14/11/2023 15:07

Dawn17 · 14/11/2023 13:48

I completely sympathise. My grandparents had left me and my brother money, not a fortune, just a few thousand(which actually is a fortune to me).
My brother blew his quickly. He then announced he was getting married and his wife to be asked if they could borrow some money towards the wedding as they knew I'd still got my inheritance. She came round to my house one Sunday morning and really put the pressure on. However, I'd seen his post on Facebook the day before saying they'd booked a fantastic holiday abroad to get good tans and relax before the wedding. I was having two nights at a B & B in the lake district which was all I could afford, as I wanted to keep my inheritance for emergencies. I told her I knew they'd booked a holiday and surely they should have used that money to pay for the wedding. They fell out with me and I was no longer invited to the wedding.

@Dawn17 why was he discussing your finances with his girlfriend??? he has a cheek after spending his so quickly and she has a damned cheek even having the audacity to ask after booking a holiday!! dont lend them a sou!!! you will not get it back!

user14699084775 · 14/11/2023 14:54

I’d probably lend it but have no expectation of getting it back. Depends how much you will miss £300…I wouldn’t let my own kids go without because of someone else’s reckless spending.

Abitofalark · 14/11/2023 14:50

It wouldn't be wrong to point out that his wife has been out splashing money around when they are supposed to be in a tight spot and that that doesn't add up. If said to the brother or wife, though, it will probably cause much annoyance and anger. The alternative to mentioning that would be to find some excuse for not advancing the money, e.g, an unexpected bill or unforeseen circumstance - as a compromise, he could say he can only manage half.

If you do mention it and refuse the money...
Your husband has offered which is a huge comfort and morale boost to his brother at a time when he is in a precarious position. If he withdraws the offer that is going to feel like a massive letdown and psychological blow. It will cause acute hurt feelings and will appear like a selfish and heartless 'I am all right Jack' attitude when to him it will seem you are sitting pretty with your job, security and money. You can't weigh the value of brotherly solidarity and dependability against a sum of money. So while it is entirely proper and understandable for you to spend your money on your own family holiday, to his brother it is going to look and feel very bad, leaving a bitter taste.

Tinkerbyebye · 14/11/2023 14:40

Nope he got sacked, that doesn’t just happen, he would have had warnings and chose to not do anything

likewise wifey can get of her arse and get a job

never a lender or borrower be, sure if a genuine emergency, both working and bill for car repair or something ok, but I would want a clear repayment programme

in your case, no way

howdoesyourgardengrowinmay · 14/11/2023 14:16

Tell bil that since your original offer and his refusal, you've spent £x amount of your spare cash so £300 is no longer available but you could still lend him £x, .... or offer supermarket vouchers to the value you've agreed to lend.

Be interesting to note his reaction.

Peanutcookies · 14/11/2023 14:15

Can you just let them know circumstances have changed and you’ve already committed/ spent the money?

it would annoy me too, if they’re so hard up that £300 would make a huge difference, then they shouldn’t be doing spendy weekends.

As others have said, breakfast will be at least £20/30, soft play £15, McDonalds £30, drinks at least £20-50, dinner for a family at least £50. That’s just one weekend

historyrepeatz · 14/11/2023 14:14

Resentment will build. This was already offered so I would talk to your DH. If you are happy to lend this money (knowing you might not be repaid) then ask DH to make it clear that you don't have the means to loan or give anymore after that. A lot of people loan money without thinking about when they may be repaid or making any arrangements. You said you were going to put that towards your summer holiday so DH could ask if they will be able to repay it by then.

Motnight · 14/11/2023 14:11

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 14/11/2023 14:09

Either give it as a gift or don't give it at all.

This. You can't dictate how it will be spent.

You are unlikely to get the money back.

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 14/11/2023 14:09

Either give it as a gift or don't give it at all.

HermioneWeasley · 14/11/2023 14:07

If your only cushion is that £300 then you really don’t have it to spare

IncompleteSenten · 14/11/2023 14:06

I think I'd be saying oh, I thought you'd sorted it out when I saw X post about blah blah on Facebook.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 14/11/2023 14:04

You will probably never get it back. Lending money to anyone is always a mistake.

pontipinemum · 14/11/2023 14:03

It doesn't really sound like they are stuck.

I don't think I would lend it. I doubt you'd get it back!

friendlycat · 14/11/2023 14:02

If you don’t have the money to gift this then no.

His wife is being rather silly spending like this at the moment. I would point out to your DH what you saw as well. Then he might have a different perspective himself.

billy1966 · 14/11/2023 13:56

Unbelievable that you or your husband would entertain this when you have children and an unexpected bill could drop into your own lap.

Those weekend outings are not the actions of someone stuck.

What sort of savings do YOU have?

If £300 is such a big deal to you, you really should be putting it away for your own children not give it to someone as a gift.

It is a gift if you will never see it again.

Do you really have the savings and income to be gifting your BIL £300?

OhComeOnFFS · 14/11/2023 13:50

No, it doesn't sound as though you're rich. Hold onto your money. They are spending money as though they're both working. You'll never see that £300 again and they will turn nasty if you ask for it back, too.

Dawn17 · 14/11/2023 13:48

I completely sympathise. My grandparents had left me and my brother money, not a fortune, just a few thousand(which actually is a fortune to me).
My brother blew his quickly. He then announced he was getting married and his wife to be asked if they could borrow some money towards the wedding as they knew I'd still got my inheritance. She came round to my house one Sunday morning and really put the pressure on. However, I'd seen his post on Facebook the day before saying they'd booked a fantastic holiday abroad to get good tans and relax before the wedding. I was having two nights at a B & B in the lake district which was all I could afford, as I wanted to keep my inheritance for emergencies. I told her I knew they'd booked a holiday and surely they should have used that money to pay for the wedding. They fell out with me and I was no longer invited to the wedding.