Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give him an ultimatum?

42 replies

FLRT · 14/11/2023 11:08

First time poster. I ask you to please be kind, I'm a sensitive soul!

In a nutshell, 33F, DP38, own a house & a dog together, we've been together for over 6 years. It had always been the plan to get married then have children. However, years keep creeping by and no proposal and no sex life.
AIBU to tell him he needs to 'put out' and propose or I leave... even though I have nowhere to go and an expectation that no one else would want me?

Have had sex around 4 times in the last 5 years. This is due to a combination of him having low sex drive as on antidepressants (despite managing ok when we first got together..), and me being overweight with no body confidence. I don't want a thrilling sex life, just enough for me to feel wanted and able to TTC.

I'm overweight (UK size 20) but was slim when we met. I eat as a coping strategy which has become a vicious cycle I can't seem to break. I now feel completely unattractive to men. DP insists he does still fancy me but I think his actions say otherwise.
Dating in your thirties is really tough even if you aren't bigger, so I fully expect I would end up alone, and therefore without children anyway, if I was to leave.
I don't have the financial means to live on my own, let alone explore having a child by myself.

The relationship is otherwise good. We've been through a lot in life and support each other, trust each other, understand each other.

So, back to the question, AIBU to tell him he needs to 'put out' and propose or I leave?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OhComeOnFFS · 14/11/2023 14:43

If I were you I'd take a year to think about things. In that year I'd aim to lose a lot of weight and get fit. I'd tell him my plans and encourage him to take care of himself, too, but I have to say I would put myself first.

Intermittent fasting will be your friend. The problem with a diet is that you're constantly having to think about food. You can never have a meal that you love because you're always having to deny yourself something, whether that's fat or sugar or other carbs.

Don't eat anything until 1 pm. At first you might think this will kill you but honestly, after just one week you'll love it. Then don't eat anything after 6 pm. Nothing at all - no meals, takeaways, sweets, wine, nothing. Instead, in the evening, put your jacket on and go for a long walk.

Put in your headphones and listen to podcasts that make you laugh. There are tons of them about. I love Off Menu - every single episode really cheers me up. If you listen to something like that while you're walking, you'll come home in a much better mood.

Before you go out for the walk, brush your teeth. That will stop you wanting something to eat later.

When you come home, use really good skin care on your face. Have a shower and use body lotion.

Wear perfume every day. Make up for the lack of food by stimulating your other senses - that's where the body lotion and perfume and podcasts come in.

Don't make any plans for marriage. Don't push the sex issue. If your boyfriend joins in with the care package, you may well find that happens anyway. Have as your goal that you will be different in a year's time. That's not a year in January, it's a year from today. Then you'll be in a great position to make a decision as to what you want to do next.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/11/2023 14:33

I think you do know what to do OP but you are, very understandably, afraid of doing it. Of course you are. The unknown is always scary however the 'known' in this situation is staying with a man where there is little or no physical attraction and little or no desire (at least on his part) to progress to marriage and children. If you stay, you will drift along, perhaps for years or decades even, in a failing relationship until one of you finally makes a decision (or dies).

This is right. You do know, deep down, that this isn't the right relationship for you. A happy, fulfilling relationship isn't one which makes you put on stones in weight, leaves you starved of affection or intimacy and unable to plan your future. This is a relationship based on habit and expediency, not a loving partnership.

Of course a leap into the unknown is frightening. But you are at a crossroads here and staying with this man out of inertia or fear is not a pathway to your own self-fulfilment.

It will be scary and it might be tough for a few months. But you know you need to leave.

jolies1 · 14/11/2023 14:25

If you really want to work on the relationship instead of cutting your losses, could you start trying to spend some healthy quality time together and see if that makes a difference? Joined a nice gym with a pool/sauna with DP and it’s made such a difference, we’re more likely to head there together straight from work, do some exercise, chat about our day in the jacuzzi. Then home for a healthy dinner. We’re fitter and happier and that’s improved all aspects of our relationship.

Mrsttcno1 · 14/11/2023 14:07

One thing you CAN do right now to improve your chances and fertility (whether with this man or with another), is start looking after yourself better starting today.

Could you both look into going to counselling together, to discuss some of these issues, if you genuinely feel that there is something worth saving in your relationship?

Do you genuinely want THIS man’s children, or do you just want children and see him as your only option?

Wishimaywishimight · 14/11/2023 14:05

"but I feel the clock ticking and am at a point where I'm exasperated but don't know what else to do."

I think you do know what to do OP but you are, very understandably, afraid of doing it. Of course you are. The unknown is always scary however the 'known' in this situation is staying with a man where there is little or no physical attraction and little or no desire (at least on his part) to progress to marriage and children. If you stay, you will drift along, perhaps for years or decades even, in a failing relationship until one of you finally makes a decision (or dies).

The relationship has, quite clearly to outsiders at least, run its course. You cannot make the impossible possible just by wanting it or by fearing the alternative.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/11/2023 13:58

@Draculina

I never understand why people play House before marriage, especially when not getting married is actually a deal-breaker for them. You should have honestly asked for marriage before committing to a house with your partner. Now, you are in a situation where it's more difficult for you to pack up and leave, because you own a house together.

But being married won't help her much with a man who doesn't want to have sex with her, apparently isn't bothered about having children and seems not really to give a shit about her at all. In so far as it could give her a bit of equity it would help but it doesn't really address the fundamental problems in the relationship.

There's always someone who jumps up with the kneejerk "you should have married him beforehand", and sometimes that's a sound principle but that isn't really the point here.

There's no point getting married to someone who you effectively don't have any kind of relationship with.

FLRT · 14/11/2023 13:53

@ShelleyPercy What sort of discussions have you had over the last 6 years about marriage and children? Did you have any even loose timeline in place? When is the last time you discussed this?

Is he taking any steps to manage his depression? Are you taking any steps to manager your confidence issues? Do you talk about these things openly and honeslty?

I'm just trying to understand how you get into a situation 6 years into a relationship with some significant individual problems as well as unhappiness within the relationship and not having discussed when and how to move things forward that it would come to the need for an ultimatum.

These are good questions, especially because I can't figure out how I got here either! We have open communication and have regularly discussed goals and timelines. Rightly or wrongly, our first goal was to get a house together. We've now done this, but covid cost us time. We agreed we were going to get engaged within a year (didn't happen) marry in 2024 and start TTC in 2025.

We both have gradually stopped taking proper care of ourselves over time. We talk openly about this a lot, make a plan to eat better and exercise, then it all falls apart for one reason or another. There's no excuse for this.

From yours and others' responses I know I'm wrong in considering an ultimatum, but I feel the clock ticking and am at a point where I'm exasperated but don't know what else to do.

OP posts:
ShelleyPercy · 14/11/2023 13:31

What sort of discussions have you had over the last 6 years about marriage and children? Did you have any even loose timeline in place? When is the last time you discussed this?

Is he taking any steps to manage his depression? Are you taking any steps to manager your confidence issues? Do you talk about these things openly and honeslty?

I'm just trying to understand how you get into a situation 6 years into a relationship with some significant individual problems as well as unhappiness within the relationship and not having discussed when and how to move things forward that it would come to the need for an ultimatum.

AnneLovesGilbert · 14/11/2023 13:26

This isn’t a relationship to bring a baby into. Deciding sex is worth it because you want to ttc is a terrible idea. And why does he have to propose marriage? If that’s what you want you do it! You haven’t even suggested it and are jumping straight to an ultimatum, otherwise known as blackmail. That’s not how healthy functional relationships operate.

Draculina · 14/11/2023 13:25

I never understand why people play House before marriage, especially when not getting married is actually a deal-breaker for them. You should have honestly asked for marriage before committing to a house with your partner. Now, you are in a situation where it's more difficult for you to pack up and leave, because you own a house together.

On another note, it sounds like you both have personal issues to deal with, on your own. He needs to seek help for his abnormally low sex drive, and, for the sake of your own self-esteem, it might help you to start a healthier lifestyle, and do things that make you feel better about yourself. It's hard to make a relationship work when both parties struggle with something big, but I feel like if your relationship has reached a point where you feel a need to make ultimatums...it's probably a dead-end anyway.

Quartz2208 · 14/11/2023 13:16

You aren’t being proactive either though at breaking the cycle - you need to work on that

Mrsttcno1 · 14/11/2023 13:11

As an aside as well, if your sex life is already basically non-existent and you both find it difficult to be intimate, believe me when I say TTC will be extremely difficult. I am currently pregnant, my partner and I had no previous issues with intimacy or sex, always had a regular sex life, and even for us “ttc sex” really became a chore! It changes sex from something that should be fun, exciting, spontaneous, to something that is “are you ovulating? Have you already ejaculated in the last 12 hours? I got my peak on test 2 hours ago so we need to have sex right now. Can’t be bothered- TOUGH it’s peak week!!”. It can be a mental and physical battle even where you both had a healthy interest in sex before ttc, I honestly don’t see any way that from your starting point it would be possible.

Also, you cannot use an ultimatum to make him have sex with you. As others have mentioned, the physical changes in your body could well have impacted his desire to be intimate in the same way it has affected your confidence. The best thing you can do is work on yourself and once you find your own confidence, find someone who makes you feel desired, happy, loved, appreciated. Start a family with THAT man, the one who makes you the happiest you could he, not the one who makes you unhappy.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/11/2023 12:40

MrsPinkL · 14/11/2023 12:35

I’m sorry but your post reads like you don’t want him really but you’ll stay because you are overweight, have no where to go and think online dating must be hard. WTF!

What do you bring to this table that makes you think an ultimatum is a good idea? Nothing you’ve wrote here would make anyone want to propose and have children.

This relationship has possibly ran it’s course and you both need out.

I agree with this. It comes across here that neither of you really wants the other but you have convinced yourself this is as good as it gets and are willing to “settle” and he is just not fussed either way. It would be a really bad situation to bring a child into. Not wanting to date in your 30s is not a good enough reason to cling to a dying relationship like a life raft.

You really need to split up with him and work on yourself and figure out who you are and what you actually want.

Bobtheamazinggingerdog · 14/11/2023 12:39

Lovely, you aren't going to magically turn this back into a marriage material relationship with an active sex life which is going to produce children. It's not going to happen. I get that you feel lacking in confidence and worried about being alone but if you want a relationship with sex and babies this isn't it.

MrsPinkL · 14/11/2023 12:35

I’m sorry but your post reads like you don’t want him really but you’ll stay because you are overweight, have no where to go and think online dating must be hard. WTF!

What do you bring to this table that makes you think an ultimatum is a good idea? Nothing you’ve wrote here would make anyone want to propose and have children.

This relationship has possibly ran it’s course and you both need out.

YeahIsaidit · 14/11/2023 12:32

Do you really want to start a life together with children based on what is a threat? You don't sound compatible

CalistoNoSolo · 14/11/2023 12:30

His lack of interest is probably directly linked to your weight gain. Going from a size 10/12 to a size 20 is a very big change in how you look. Your lack of ambition is most likely also a problem for him - if you can't afford to support yourself and live independently why do you think your partner should support you? I think in your physical state and financial position having a baby would be irresponsible and thoughtless. The baby won't fill any emotional holes you have, and you won't be a good parent if you're only having a baby to make up for what's lacking in your life. Work on yourself first otherwise you'll always feel like this.

Laurdo · 14/11/2023 12:29

Neither of you are in any position to be starting a family. He needs to work on his MH issues and you need to work on your self-esteem issues and lose weight.

I think it's a bit cheeky for you to issue an ultimatum when you have work to do as well.

You both need to sit down and have a good chat about where your future is headed. Regardless of what he says, you still need to lose the weight and work on your self esteem so that you can be the best person for you, in or out of this relationship. Focus on feeling better rather than having a proposal or baby as a end goal. If you're both on the same page and willing to do the work that will fall into place eventually.

Exercise will really help you both so why not start exercising together. Doesn't need to be going to a gym but go for nice long walks or find a hobby you both enjoy. Encourage each other to eat better.

If he's not willing to cooperate or doesn't seem interested then at least you've started your journey to a healthier and better you. Maybe you'll meet someone new, maybe you won't. But being single, healthy and confident is far better than being miserable in a relationship.

Thepeopleversuswork · 14/11/2023 12:25

Honestly your priorities are skewed and you have this arse about face. Focus on yourself, your health and self esteem being the priorities. You will not “fix” this relationship by giving him an ultimatum (and honestly it sounds beyond fixing). You have living an effectively celibate existence with a man who doesn’t want to marry you. It’s based purely on practicality. You should absolutely not bring a child into this dysfunctional situation.

I can’t know if your weight is a problem for him but your lack of self esteem and general passiveness is clearly a factor. You know you deserve more but seek oddly inert about doing something to tackle it.

Stop focusing on mending the relationship and start focusing on getting yourself into a better mindset and looking after yourself. You may find that once you do this he starts to value you but that’s not a reason to do it. Do it for yourself.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 14/11/2023 12:25

I'm so sorry. It sounds like your confidence is absolutely on the floor and you need to address this before anything else. I can understand if you want children that you feel the clock is ticking, but it doesn't sound like you are in the right place ... yet.... but you could work towards that. It would help your confidence and this would have a positive effect on other areas of your life. So get support with dealing with your emotional eating, fitness and confidence issues first and foremost.

If you want children you need to get on top of health issues anyway. You have to be realistic and get as much support as possible as it's not an overnight fix.

If you issue ultimatums you have to be prepared for the other side to say, OK go ahead and do that then. ie it may not have the effect you are hoping for. Are you really ready for that? Maybe you should give yourself time to work on some of these things that are bothering you and make a plan for what you want your next stage to be before you do this.

Its also a bit threaty in relationship terms. No one likes being strong-armed. It would be better to have a no-threat exploratory talk about it. Does he know how much you want children? Or is that something that hasn't been discussed for a while? If this is difficult, then maybe Couple's counseling?

Once you have worked on these two elements, you will be in a better position to decide what you yourself want for your future and also if this relationship is for you, but you will be making that decision from a more confident place.

DartmoorWild · 14/11/2023 12:23

Ultimatums don't work unless you're willing to follow through.

If you issue one and he doesn't change, you'll have confirmed he doesn't want to change and doesn't really care, then you'll have to stay if you're unwilling to leave and will possibly feel worse.

Also, as a previous poster said, kindly attraction can change if one of you physically changes. Sexual attraction isn't something you can force.

Heyahun · 14/11/2023 12:19

how sad - you've given up on life at 33 :(

i bet if you left him and started over you would easily build your confidence again

Mrsttcno1 · 14/11/2023 12:17

Cocoalover · 14/11/2023 12:14

Without sounding harsh, because I absolutely mean this in the nicest way possible because it is a possibility, your significant weight gain may be contributing to the lack of sex. You can totally love someone but lack attraction, especially with a significant amount of weight gain. I think you should be working on your self-esteem and eating issues right now. Eating healthy really does make you feel well mentally and physically, and I know it's easier said than done because I've been there. You will feel amazing when you adopt a healthy eating habit, resulting in a healthy mindset and better self-esteem 🤗

100% this

Cocoalover · 14/11/2023 12:14

Without sounding harsh, because I absolutely mean this in the nicest way possible because it is a possibility, your significant weight gain may be contributing to the lack of sex. You can totally love someone but lack attraction, especially with a significant amount of weight gain. I think you should be working on your self-esteem and eating issues right now. Eating healthy really does make you feel well mentally and physically, and I know it's easier said than done because I've been there. You will feel amazing when you adopt a healthy eating habit, resulting in a healthy mindset and better self-esteem 🤗

FloweryWowery · 14/11/2023 12:10

You've been together for 6 years and have had sex 4 times in the last 5 years. You're not partners. Leave, you're 33 and have time to look elsewhere. I think the weight thing is a red herring.