Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop buying shit they don't like

209 replies

youhavebadtaste · 14/11/2023 09:42

Please, I beg you, as kind and thoughtful as you think you are being, please stop buying people home furnishing, decorative items, artwork, anything that they will feel compelled to display in their homes - unless you are absolutely certain they want it.

Every Christmas, birthday, birth, or any special event that might incur a gift being given I get nervous because I know we are going to be given things by well meaning people that I just absolutely hate and don't want to show in my home.

A few examples;

When we got married a very good friend gave us a mirrored picture frame covered with diamantes spelling our name. It's large, ugly and does not even begin to blend in with our home decor, that is, well, the total opposite. They thought it was absolutely gorgeous, I do not.

An aunt has taken up woodwork and keeps making us things. I have a lump of wood with various place names that vaguely mean something to us, but not massively significant. I have to display it because she's round all the time. It might sound nice but it's poorly made and I just don't like it. I know she has other things lined up and I keep trying to tell her no in a polite way but she doesn't get it.

Another relative gave me a framed print when we moved in to our house. I can see it's very much her taste but it's just not mine.

I get this may all sound really ungrateful, but I feel bad that these people are wasting their time and money getting us things we just don't like. It's not like it's a cardi that I can wear twice when I see them then shove in a drawer until it gets gifted to the local charity shop - these are things people expect to see us use in our home.

AIBU to just not want this stuff?

OP posts:
KirstenBlest · 14/11/2023 11:49

That's you though @WandaWonder . It's not just me it happens to.

I don't particularly want consumables. It's usually something home-made like chutney, cheese with bits of fruit in, a gift set of cheap handwash and handcream, or a pongy scented candle.

With the owl ornament, friend/relative goes on holiday and asks if you'd like something from that country. You mention something inexpensive that's not available in the UK. They promise to get you it. When they come back, they didn't bring it because they got you an owl ornament instead.

(I don't have any owl ornaments but didn't want to name the often given displayable item in case it outed me)

Night409 · 14/11/2023 11:47

MrsSkylerWhite · 14/11/2023 10:29

Why are you telling us? Tell them.

Exactly!

My family and friends know I don’t like clutter and won’t have ornaments etc unless I’ve chosen them myself.

I don’t like people wasting their money so I am very upfront about it and say I’d rather have fluffy socks, bubble baths, chocolates etc.

TheBirdintheCave · 14/11/2023 11:45

Canisaysomething · 14/11/2023 11:34

Gift giving is about the process of giving the gift, not about whether you like it - that’s just pot luck.

Once the gift has been given and thanks given in return, do what you want with it, there’s no obligation to keep the gift. If you stop feeling this sense of obligation you may well find the unwanted gifts stop coming.

When gifts become purely about what you like and what is useful, you may as well just buy them yourself.

This is daft. A good gift giver takes the time to think about what someone would like, something that is personal to the recipient and that they need and want. That's the true joy of gifting, no? Choosing something you know is going to be treasured, used or appreciated by the recipient, not giving some random piece of tat just because you feel like it.

My Christmas list is full of frivolous things that I wouldn't buy for myself because I don't really need them, I just like them. Those are the things I ask my husband or parents for.

Why should we be stuck in an endless cycle of pointless giving and receiving of unwanted goods? If everyone just spoke up and said that they actually want (even if that's no gifts at all!) I think we'd all be much better off.

susiedaisy1912 · 14/11/2023 11:41

Canisaysomething · 14/11/2023 11:34

Gift giving is about the process of giving the gift, not about whether you like it - that’s just pot luck.

Once the gift has been given and thanks given in return, do what you want with it, there’s no obligation to keep the gift. If you stop feeling this sense of obligation you may well find the unwanted gifts stop coming.

When gifts become purely about what you like and what is useful, you may as well just buy them yourself.

I agree to a certain extent but it's a waste of money and terrible for the environment for us all to buy stuff that's going to going to get thrown away. Saying that I did find it difficult to say no to gifts when I was younger I'm now in my 50s and find it much easier.

5128gap · 14/11/2023 11:39

I know my friends' and family's tastes and they know mine, so we're happy as we are. Not to mention no one gets so offended by a candle that they need to implore and plead with people to spare them.

thecatsthecats · 14/11/2023 11:37

Can you maybe tell people you’re trying to declutter so you can cut back on dusting, house work etc?

I did this with MIL once. Amazon vouchers for kindle, moving house, didn't want more physical books. She bought physical books, and a half dozen other pieces of crap.

And that was the year I started immediately chucking gifts I didn't want.

Canisaysomething · 14/11/2023 11:34

Gift giving is about the process of giving the gift, not about whether you like it - that’s just pot luck.

Once the gift has been given and thanks given in return, do what you want with it, there’s no obligation to keep the gift. If you stop feeling this sense of obligation you may well find the unwanted gifts stop coming.

When gifts become purely about what you like and what is useful, you may as well just buy them yourself.

thecatsthecats · 14/11/2023 11:32

My GMIL - who is an absolutely lovely woman - gave us a painting for our wedding. She's very talented indeed. She's painted landscapes in her house that are very much our style.

For our wedding, she painted us something on a horrible style of a miserable subject. It lives on the stairs. Worse thing is MIL loves it - she has loads in that style. She comments on the location every time.

I won't start on all the ridiculous things we've been sent for our baby, half of them from people we've never even met. My husband won't even let me return them for cash to put on his savings, but he's not the one dressing him most days.

Plisco · 14/11/2023 11:27

My brother lives in a bare flat with an uncomfortable sofa. No shortage of money, but doesn't care much about his environment.

One Christmas I picked out some quite cool (but neutral) cushions for the sofa and sent him a picture to see whether he would like them as his Christmas present. He said no, he didn't want any cushions. So I didn't buy them and got him something he did like instead.

Now in my opinion the cushions would make his flat and his life much nicer. But... it's his flat and not mine.

susiedaisy1912 · 14/11/2023 11:21

I agree op, I don't display things in my house that I don't like the same for jewellery if I don't like it I don't wear it, family have now realised and ask me what I'd like as a gift. I regift things if I don't like them and then tactfully mention that I don't use or like certain things. I can't be responsible for people's reactions to me saying this. But I do try to let them down as kindly as possible. It's my home and I'm not filling it with other people's preferences.

Badatthis · 14/11/2023 11:21

I would claim a bedbug infestation and say it all had to be burned

TiffanyBean · 14/11/2023 11:19

I’ve had some pretty awful displayable stuff from my parents over the years. Not only is it not to my taste, it’s not even nice stuff. I once took some to the local charity shop and apologised for it as it was so bad. Even my kids raised an eyebrow when they saw what I’d been given.

I think on that particular occasion I was actually quite upset as I felt that at the age of 42 my parents should know me a bit better at least have a vague idea of the type of thing I like in my house and what interests me rather than giving stuff they never see displayed at all. They also dislike giving vouchers as they aren’t deemed personal but I don’t really think giving items that someone has never shown any interest in having is particularly personal either.

My DH used to think I was being ungrateful but after 20 years of these type of gifts he can’t really understand either why we get so much from them that isn’t to our taste. We just smile and say thanks and give it to the next tombola/school fair/charity shop.

Catlord · 14/11/2023 11:19

Preach.

I have a lovely friend but she sends so much of this rubbish. It's all quite impersonal bought online and personalised with my name or some place I went to years ago or something 'funny'. Cushions, wall hangings, jewellery.

For example, I'm not a lager drinker. Never have been. But I do have an impressive set of mass brewery signs meant for hanging sent over time. San Miguel etc.

She loves giving but there's no thought involved and I'm absolutely not going to display it (picky bastard). Don't get me wrong, I'm grateful for each one of my friends but this just makes me guilty for not displaying mass produced shite in the house.

I wouldn't be bothered about presents but now have to think of something each time. She also moans about spending so much. Well don't bloody do it!!

That felt good to do anonymously.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 14/11/2023 11:13

I have a family member who does this......the final straw was pebbles with pigeons painted on them (( like the pigeons on pigeon Street))

I'm pretty brutal now and they get told under no circumstances not to bring their shit to my house, I don't want or need any gifts. They get told flatly if any more utter shite crosses my door it will go in the bin. And they know me well enough to know I mean it........I do it in a jokey way but even so, it pisses me off when people try to force their taste onto someone else.

So just tell them. And if they don't listen follow through with it !

krustykittens · 14/11/2023 11:12

You just have to be tough and say no, OP, even if it hurts their feelings. My mother was like this, would always buy me what she liked and never what I liked, even if I made up a list for Christmas or my birthday. "Oh no, what do you want books for, you have enough!" And would buy me an ornment, even though I don't like them. Some people are well meaning but some are actually obnoxious through their gift giving. If anyone in your life is the latter, get obnoxious back!

MeinKraft · 14/11/2023 11:11

This also includes framed pictures and canvases of your kids Blush

cleanasawhistle · 14/11/2023 11:10

I have had this over the years,very awkward.
Got rid of lots of shelves ,ornaments ,pictures a few years ago and told everyone I wouldn't be replacing any clutter and needless stuff.
Friend came round after I had decorated....messaged a few days later saying she had bought me something large for the bare wall.
I had to be honest and say so very sorry but the wall is staying bare so I won't be able to accept the gift.Never mentioned again.

The last couple of years its been house plants,
Surely if you are a regular visitor to someones house and they don't have any house plants that means they don't want any

TheBirdintheCave · 14/11/2023 11:04

NotObligedToArgueWithStrangers · 14/11/2023 10:23

I have a rule - if I can't eat it, drink it, burn it 🕯️ or use up it in the bathroom, I don't want it! Consumables all the way.

Yep. 100% agreed.

FreeRider · 14/11/2023 11:03

My late MIL and her sister were terrible for this...when I was married to ex husband we were always getting household gifts that were so not to our tastes...MIL's house was crammed full of nick-nacks and she thought everyone liked that look...I'm a minimalist who hates dusting! Her sister would buy things like very expensive velvet curtains from catalogues and then change her mind, but couldn't be arsed to return them...so we'd end up with them (if her own son and his wife didn't want them first). While that might seem like a nice thing to do, it did make us feel like the 'poor relations' who would take anybody's cast offs!

Ex husband ended up with most of the stuff and when he had to move flat a couple of years ago most of it ended up in the tip. Bit sad really.

Milkmani · 14/11/2023 11:03

@youhavebadtaste Can you maybe tell people you’re trying to declutter so you can cut back on dusting, house work etc? I have made it quite clear that I don’t want any extra things in our home. We live in a small house and I don’t have much out. Very clear about what we do don’t need for children’s gifts - I usually suggest gift cards for days out, even if it doesn’t pay for the full ticket I still think a £10/15 voucher for the farm or something is nice. Maybe suggest consumable gifts if people insist but still, say no to the clutter and tell them you’re having to clear out as you already have too much. My mum finds it tough sometimes that I don’t want loads of stuff hanging about the house but my home is clean and easy to manage - that way I can spend more time with my son.

BarbaraofSeville · 14/11/2023 11:03

KirstenBlest · 14/11/2023 10:37

I find that if you have something on display in your house, some people will get you something slightly similar.

You might have a treasured owl ornament that you've had since childhood then someone will give you a crappy owl ornament because they think it's what you like. More owl ornaments will follow until you have to get more shelves.

Never display the things you don't like.

And they also see the lack of much on display as a sign that you need more ornaments, picture frames, lamps etc.

Some people like buying and having stuff and unfortunately they seem to win the battle against those of us who don't.

This is why we encourage Christmas lists in our family, ideally with links to the exact product. I love buying presents but the thought of wasting time and money on sonething that gets thrown away or resented is awful

But that's just making work for the recipient, when most of the time they'd really wish you didn't bother. You're not doing a nice thing for them. You're forcing your love of buying and having stuff onto someone who likely isn't interested and giving them a job of thinking of something for you to give them instead of leaving them to buy it themselves in their own time.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 14/11/2023 11:02

Yes I really think people shouldn’t try to decorate the houses of others

ManateeFair · 14/11/2023 11:01

If someone buys me something I don't like for my home, I don't display it. If you display it, people will think you like it and will therefore buy you more of the same. I know it's difficult, because obviously you don't want to offend anyone who had good intentions in buying the gift, but it's the best way to hint that they should stop wasting their money.

I think if you're going to buy a home decor type gift for someone, you need to a) properly know their taste and b) stick to things like vases or photo frames or something that can be more easily moved around or given away rather than something that's meant to be hung on the wall. I know my sister's taste very well indeed and I've bought her smaller things like mugs, candlesticks, coasters, a trinket box, a jug etc. But I wouldn't ever buy her something like a mirror or a picture - even if someone really likes a picture, that doesn't mean they've got the right spot to hang it on their wall! I'd stick to smaller things that don't have to be displayed all the time and can be easily given away / regifted if the recipient isn't keen.

Mazuslongtoenail · 14/11/2023 11:00

Yanbu but I don’t display / use the odd thing that I get that doesn’t hit the mark.

But I’ve also got a SIL with amazing taste and I would hate for her to stop buying things!

ReadySalty · 14/11/2023 11:00

Just get rid of it, that will stop them.

What's wrong with a candle? Flowers?

I can't stand Xmas food hampers either. Other than the cheese it's all weird shit no one in their right mind would buy/eat.