Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop buying shit they don't like

209 replies

youhavebadtaste · 14/11/2023 09:42

Please, I beg you, as kind and thoughtful as you think you are being, please stop buying people home furnishing, decorative items, artwork, anything that they will feel compelled to display in their homes - unless you are absolutely certain they want it.

Every Christmas, birthday, birth, or any special event that might incur a gift being given I get nervous because I know we are going to be given things by well meaning people that I just absolutely hate and don't want to show in my home.

A few examples;

When we got married a very good friend gave us a mirrored picture frame covered with diamantes spelling our name. It's large, ugly and does not even begin to blend in with our home decor, that is, well, the total opposite. They thought it was absolutely gorgeous, I do not.

An aunt has taken up woodwork and keeps making us things. I have a lump of wood with various place names that vaguely mean something to us, but not massively significant. I have to display it because she's round all the time. It might sound nice but it's poorly made and I just don't like it. I know she has other things lined up and I keep trying to tell her no in a polite way but she doesn't get it.

Another relative gave me a framed print when we moved in to our house. I can see it's very much her taste but it's just not mine.

I get this may all sound really ungrateful, but I feel bad that these people are wasting their time and money getting us things we just don't like. It's not like it's a cardi that I can wear twice when I see them then shove in a drawer until it gets gifted to the local charity shop - these are things people expect to see us use in our home.

AIBU to just not want this stuff?

OP posts:
Pinkpinkpink15 · 14/11/2023 20:43

AlltheFs · 14/11/2023 15:59

I didn’t reply to you? I replied to the OP, are you on glue?!

@AlltheFs

no need to be do bloody rude!!

it's not a private conversation, you have posted on a public forum & anyone can reply.

Pinkpinkpink15 · 14/11/2023 20:38

cleanasawhistle · 14/11/2023 11:10

I have had this over the years,very awkward.
Got rid of lots of shelves ,ornaments ,pictures a few years ago and told everyone I wouldn't be replacing any clutter and needless stuff.
Friend came round after I had decorated....messaged a few days later saying she had bought me something large for the bare wall.
I had to be honest and say so very sorry but the wall is staying bare so I won't be able to accept the gift.Never mentioned again.

The last couple of years its been house plants,
Surely if you are a regular visitor to someones house and they don't have any house plants that means they don't want any

@cleanasawhistle

kust bizarre isn't it WTF would you buy some massive thing to go on someone's else's newly decorated wall?!?!

at least she took it well 😊

& yes. I don't like /want house plants. If I'd did I would buy them!!

Katemax82 · 14/11/2023 19:30

mummybear945 · 14/11/2023 10:34

You are not being unreasonable people keep getting me scented things even though I have told them I don't like scented things because they make me nauseous. I have hinted that I like socks, but no one ever seems to get it. BTW I really love socks and a pair of socks would be enough for me as a present. My mum is the one who benefits though as I always give her all the scented things I get.

You should try the happy sock company. One of the women I'm a housekeeper for gets a sock subscription from them and has loads of cool socks

LemonLight · 14/11/2023 18:15

Someone once gave DH and I for Christmas two really cheap looking blow up canvases of very unflattering photos of us with their baby (who resembled Chucky) to display in our house. Straight to the attic. Still there.

KirstenBlest · 14/11/2023 17:44

@Todaysproblem , you obviously put a lot of thought and effort into it and that's what matters.

Todaysproblem · 14/11/2023 17:37

LittleMissUnreasonable · 14/11/2023 15:36

@TodaysproblemI gifted them 12 framed best couple pictures I could find after stalking their SM accounts. Engagement pic, beautiful wedding day one, holidays etc to all go on the wall.

Sorry I would also hate this 😔 I live with DH, we have some couples photos but a lot are us with friends, family, the DCs etc. I think it's smug when a married couple makes their house a shrine to photos of the two of them only.

I'm very easy to buy for, I love clothes, I drink alcohol and like everything from beer to Bailey's, love chocolate, am quite girly and like beauty products, things with a specific animal on them, things for the house, vouches for most shops, hampers, candles, even the bayliss and Harding sets MN cower at.... But one of DHs friends always gets it wrong. Last year we got a bird feeder for the garden which sounds lovely. But we have cats that go outside. DH friend also has cats. It's like he thinks the item sounds good but doesn't think beyond the practicalities.

I don’t know what I was thinking. At the time I thought it was the most thoughtful and amazing gift I could get them for the new home, but after reading this thread I put myself in their shoes and I would find it very weird if someone gave me the same. 🤦‍♀️

MaliciaKeys · 14/11/2023 16:51

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 14/11/2023 16:02

I know someone whose family member with Downs syndrome bought her a Mills and Boon book. In the circumstances she faked enthusiasm and was very thankful. So she continued to receive nothing but Mills and Boon for every birthday and Christmas 😃

That’s quite sweet though, and the Mills and Boons can be regifted to the local residential care home. A lot of elderly ladies love a bit of romance, my granny certainly does!

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 14/11/2023 16:02

I know someone whose family member with Downs syndrome bought her a Mills and Boon book. In the circumstances she faked enthusiasm and was very thankful. So she continued to receive nothing but Mills and Boon for every birthday and Christmas 😃

AlltheFs · 14/11/2023 15:59

Pinkpinkpink15 · 14/11/2023 10:04

No, you're not being unreasonable to not want things in your home that aren't to your taste.

However, you need to pull up your big girls pants & deal with the situation instead of quietly seething.

like the lovely mirror frame. Take it to the tip. No one else will want it with your names in it. If your friend says anything, just say you're changing the look of your house (you are, to things you like!!) & it no longer (don't say never did!!) fits in to you xyz look. Thank her for the effort she went to, to get it made (or whatever) and being at your wedding (if she was)

Aunty Woodwork - tell her you're going minimalist and are not buying/getting things for your house because you have too much stuff & it saddens you to have to give away the excess.

its not easy, but you have to stick up for yourself & your house.

i think this is why I'm such a terrible gift giver, because I only want to buy things that people will find useful or love.

I tend to buy things that get used up. Food/drink/flowers/good quality hand soap, etc. or 'treats' meal out, voucher for things/places I know they like.

also everyone knows I'm incredibly fussy, so they tend not to buy me 'stuff', especially not 'big/display' stuff.

Also if I do buy a thing, I always say I bought it because I thought they'd like it, but if I've got that wrong, then don't hesitate to pass it on, because there's no obligation to keep things you don't like. The gift is in the giving, it's not an obligation to keep stuff you don't want.

I didn’t reply to you? I replied to the OP, are you on glue?!

ManchesterLu · 14/11/2023 15:57

YANBU. When growing up, my dad's sister ALWAYS used to send us things like this, and it became a family joke. We actually displayed them when she was visiting and then removed them the second she left - luckily it's v long distance so only an every other year thing!

GasPanic · 14/11/2023 15:42

It's amazing what sort of strange accidents can happen to stuff I don't like.

LittleMissUnreasonable · 14/11/2023 15:36

@TodaysproblemI gifted them 12 framed best couple pictures I could find after stalking their SM accounts. Engagement pic, beautiful wedding day one, holidays etc to all go on the wall.

Sorry I would also hate this 😔 I live with DH, we have some couples photos but a lot are us with friends, family, the DCs etc. I think it's smug when a married couple makes their house a shrine to photos of the two of them only.

I'm very easy to buy for, I love clothes, I drink alcohol and like everything from beer to Bailey's, love chocolate, am quite girly and like beauty products, things with a specific animal on them, things for the house, vouches for most shops, hampers, candles, even the bayliss and Harding sets MN cower at.... But one of DHs friends always gets it wrong. Last year we got a bird feeder for the garden which sounds lovely. But we have cats that go outside. DH friend also has cats. It's like he thinks the item sounds good but doesn't think beyond the practicalities.

Ireolu · 14/11/2023 15:12

My SIL insists on baking us cakes for each of our birthdays. Problem is she is a terrible cake maker. One year I managed to convince her to make a cake made from fruit. The only one enjoyed so far. Keep telling her not to bother all requests fall on deaf ears.

MitchellMummy · 14/11/2023 14:49

Agree that consumables make the best gifts.

DogInATent · 14/11/2023 14:42

I have to display it because she's round all the time
No. You don't.

I have a significant birthday coming up, and I'm doing my best to ensure it doesn't become a tatfest.

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/11/2023 14:40

I only give hand made stuff if it's something the recipient has asked me to make and most of the time, still no... if they really wanted it, they'd buy it from me (people do).

Rare gifts I have given though.... hand woven silk scarf/pashmina + silver wire wrapped shawl pin. I see the recipient wearing it in photos often, though never round to mine (dogs all over and she encourages them to climb all over her!)...

Miniature cotter pin jointed teddy (6") wearing nalbinded cloak, secured with bronze cloak pin and carrying a leather bound copper headed spear. Because what bronze age bear wouldn't...

They're (and more rather identifiable things) very very niche and so the recipients are also... rather niche people.

The hours of work that go into the weird shit I make means there isn't a fucking hope in hell someones getting something they don't appreciate and truly love.

I also have friends who just say 'not my thing thanks' if offered something not to their tastes (I do have a lot of prototype ideas stuff that gets rehomed else I'll drown in it all, but not everyone wants a 4" embroidered beetle!

Is it really them, or is it you, or is it a combination?

LubaLuca · 14/11/2023 14:27

YANBU. We were given a huge armillary for the garden (pointy metal sundial thing on a 18" stone plinth). Our children were then at an age when then whole garden was given over to football, climbing frame, rope swings etc so it would have been an incredibly dangerous thing to have anywhere. I had to be honest and return the damned thing!

MIL gave me a few of those godawful faceless Willow figurine things. At least they're easy to get out only for state visits.

CloudPop · 14/11/2023 14:27

ReadySalty · 14/11/2023 11:00

Just get rid of it, that will stop them.

What's wrong with a candle? Flowers?

I can't stand Xmas food hampers either. Other than the cheese it's all weird shit no one in their right mind would buy/eat.

God yes Christmas hampers. Just why.

Mumsgirls · 14/11/2023 13:48

I would never try to impose my taste on someone, sheer arrogance. I f given something like this, do not display it , straight to tip or charity shop, otherwise they never learn. Have to be cruel to be kind. Relative of mine kept buying me hideous cheap clothes. Never wore them, message got through. Would prefer bath stuff, chocolates or fizz. Rest is a waste of money.

susiedaisy1912 · 14/11/2023 13:42

KinS24 · 14/11/2023 12:43

We got a massive framed print of Warwick castle in a gold frame for our wedding. We had never been to Warwick and neither had the lovely friends who gave it to us 🤔

😁😁

fingerguns · 14/11/2023 13:34

YANBU! My ex-bf's family used to make stuff for me like giant cushions that didn't match anything anywhere in the house, which added even more pressure to display it all.

MotherWol · 14/11/2023 13:29

Legomania · 14/11/2023 13:10

This is definitely something to bear in mind for the next wedding list thread, for the posters who say that they won't be dictated to by a list and prefer to choose their own gift.

Or the ‘no party gifts’ threads where posters insist that their children love choosing birthday gifts for classmates they barely know and you’re being a snob by asking for no gifts.

Cryingbutstilltrying · 14/11/2023 13:26

Every Christmas I sit and unwrap gifts and thank the giver, while wondering when the next charity bag will drop through the door. Fortunately I don’t usually have to wait too long. It makes me so sad to think of the wasted time and money but at least it can be passed on to someone who might love it.

DM is the worst culprit. She can’t help herself. Last year I had already told her I’d seen a winter coat I wanted, she said yes and told me to order it (only available online) and she would give me the money. This was great, but then she also bought a weird ear warmer and muff set, an ornament and vase, and a book that I’d already read. The whole lot other than the coat went in the next charity bag. So pointless but also made me feel rubbish too, I can’t really explain why. I would truly rather have nothing at all.

MaliciaKeys · 14/11/2023 13:20

I only buy adult family members food and drink, I’d never buy ornaments or paintings. Since most weddings now ask for money and not gifts, that’s a lot easier. I do make a photo book of the family through the year for my mum though because I know she really loves them. I wouldn’t foist photos of my family on anyone else though!

FictionalCharacter · 14/11/2023 13:20

HighywayToHell · 14/11/2023 10:07

Stop displaying it. If you have it on show people think you love it and give you more. My ex MIL used to give really ugly picture frames to me when she was decorating and i didnt want them, they went to the charity shop and when she didnt see them on display she stopped giving me her cast offs that i never asked for.

Yes! You have to stop being so ultra polite and being so worried about hurting their feelings that you display ugly stuff in your home!
Maybe I’m lucky but nobody has ever asked me “why aren’t you displaying/ wearing that hideous thing I bought for you”?