Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop buying shit they don't like

209 replies

youhavebadtaste · 14/11/2023 09:42

Please, I beg you, as kind and thoughtful as you think you are being, please stop buying people home furnishing, decorative items, artwork, anything that they will feel compelled to display in their homes - unless you are absolutely certain they want it.

Every Christmas, birthday, birth, or any special event that might incur a gift being given I get nervous because I know we are going to be given things by well meaning people that I just absolutely hate and don't want to show in my home.

A few examples;

When we got married a very good friend gave us a mirrored picture frame covered with diamantes spelling our name. It's large, ugly and does not even begin to blend in with our home decor, that is, well, the total opposite. They thought it was absolutely gorgeous, I do not.

An aunt has taken up woodwork and keeps making us things. I have a lump of wood with various place names that vaguely mean something to us, but not massively significant. I have to display it because she's round all the time. It might sound nice but it's poorly made and I just don't like it. I know she has other things lined up and I keep trying to tell her no in a polite way but she doesn't get it.

Another relative gave me a framed print when we moved in to our house. I can see it's very much her taste but it's just not mine.

I get this may all sound really ungrateful, but I feel bad that these people are wasting their time and money getting us things we just don't like. It's not like it's a cardi that I can wear twice when I see them then shove in a drawer until it gets gifted to the local charity shop - these are things people expect to see us use in our home.

AIBU to just not want this stuff?

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 15/11/2023 12:10

WandaWonder · 15/11/2023 00:10

Then there is
"What would you like for Christmas?"
"I would love a book token/box of Quality Street/a really nice pair of fluffy socks"
"That is not a present I can't buy you that"

then why ask?

This! I asked for what I would like and said a type of vase from IKEA for Christmas one year. It was a max £2 each for one, local to them whereas it takes either a 45 min drive with DH or a bus, train, and walk for one ikea and two trains and a bus to another going on my own. Received something else that was more expensive and was bog standard gift that made me wonder why ask in the first place yet saying “no gifts for me” is an issue.

It’s worse with the kids. They have more than enough toys, books, etc and with our oldest (8) being autistic, it can be a bit of an issue since he does sometimes put some toys with little pieces in his mouth or with the youngest he’s been given toys that we not only already have but are for children 2+ years younger than him even though we have said specific items when asked based on their interest. We’ve kept it to activities that they both enjoy and doesn’t clutter our home.

I’m doing a massive decluttering again and don’t want anymore unnecessary stuff added.

Sturnidae · 15/11/2023 12:04

YANBU. I remember when my eldest was born we were gifted some handmade decorative items from various people which were hit and miss on quality, but none of it was anything we'd ever get for ourselves at all. And we didn't have anything up of our own choosing either so it made it even more obvious (various reasons for that). The givers were offended that we didn't display them, but it did stop them gifting us more handmade stuff which was appreciated!

I am a crafter as well and I have made things for others, but I wouldn't gift something, especially something that had hours of effort put in like one of the things we received, without knowing absolutely that the person would enjoy it! I generally ask before I make, or I make it with them in mind and ask if they'd like it once it's complete (no deadlines that way!)

Catlord · 15/11/2023 11:23

LubaLuca · 15/11/2023 11:04

Do none of these people know you well enough to choose gifts that you'll actually like?

Obviously not, or they wouldn't persist. It's the people I'd love to stop exchanging presents with that are the worst for these impersonal personal gifts, but they won't hear of stopping - God knows I've tried.

I think even though the friend I moaned about up thread cares about me deeply (as did a late aunt who bought piles of shite too) in their cases the pleasure of giving almost anything outweighs needing to consider the receiving pleasure on your end. It isn't just missing the mark or hating shopping, it really is sending any old tat. I love her anyway, no one is perfect!

dutysuite · 15/11/2023 11:13

I agree. My mum bought me a Pandora bracelet and every year at Christmas and on my birthday would buy me charms to go on the bracelet. I hate Pandora bracelets and charms, I never wore it and in the end I had to tell my mother to stop buying the charms. We have such different taste, she still buys me things as if I’m a teenager and I’m in my 40s!

LubaLuca · 15/11/2023 11:04

Do none of these people know you well enough to choose gifts that you'll actually like?

Obviously not, or they wouldn't persist. It's the people I'd love to stop exchanging presents with that are the worst for these impersonal personal gifts, but they won't hear of stopping - God knows I've tried.

WYorkshireRose · 15/11/2023 10:40

Do none of these people know you well enough to choose gifts that you'll actually like?

I can't say I've had this issue come up too often, but then nor would I display/wear/use something that isn't my taste just to keep someone else happy.

DilemmaDelilah · 15/11/2023 09:51

I bought my sister a picture I loved and thought she would like for her birthday, it was an original and not cheap. I gave it to her on the understanding that it she didn't like it she would give it back to me for my birthday a few months later. Not ideal, as I know it would have been better to have given her something she would have liked to keep, but I did really think she would like it.
I think it can be really difficult to know what other people like (apart from the obvious minimalist/bling type of thing), but if somebody has made an effort to find you something they do think you would like then it WBVU to be rude about it.
We have a hand decorated plate on display in our living room that my (adult) step daughter made for our wedding. It is horrible (we both agree on that), but we will never get rid of it. It is a reminder of a very special day, and of our daughter who has since died.

39and · 15/11/2023 03:41

Can you ask people to not do gifts? I only buy for DH and DS. Means our tiny house isn't full of crap we'll never use.

Aria999 · 15/11/2023 03:10

I have a solution which is to live in a slightly obscure part of America where almost none of our uk family ever visits.

The occasional well meaning gift I would never display has gone straight to the thrift shop with a clear conscience.

One family member when we moved in very kindly asked if he could get us something that said 'new home'. I interpreted it metaphorically and said it would be wonderful to have a contribution to some rugs we needed to buy 😁

DrNo007 · 15/11/2023 02:35

Totally agree. People know I am fussy so don’t buy me stuff to display but DH has friends and colleagues who regularly buy him the ugliest pictures, ornaments etc. DH knows I hate them so for the time being they all live in his work office (not in our house) but he retires soon and I am dreading all this crap coming into our house!

user1477391263 · 15/11/2023 02:27

It’s hard, as there are some people to get the hump if given consumables (edibles, bath products) or vouchers, and demand something “thoughtful,” but then trying to work out what they would like is a nightmare!

I’m glad my family is mostly no-gifts/vouchers, but I know some families get offended at the idea of stopping presents, so it’s hard to win with this one!

Weatherwax13 · 15/11/2023 01:22

YANBU. I was politely very enthusiastic about an ornament years ago and lived to regret it as I now have over a dozen figurines of said animal. I don't buy any decor myself apart from pictures and plants.
Last year I was quite explicit that I love flowers and house plants and use a lot of candles.
Was completely ignored. I do not need "stuff" and I also don't like the young AC spending on me. They have LOs and their own households to pay for now.
I said the same to DD last week and was met with "oooh too late now, I already spotted something you're going to love"
I sound like an ungrateful old cow. It's all so well meant but I wish they'd listen!

Sugarfree23 · 15/11/2023 00:26

I had someone who regularly bought stuff that just wasn't me.
I bought them some things to display in their house. They seem to have got the message.

WandaWonder · 15/11/2023 00:10

Then there is
"What would you like for Christmas?"
"I would love a book token/box of Quality Street/a really nice pair of fluffy socks"
"That is not a present I can't buy you that"

then why ask?

determinedtomakethiswork · 14/11/2023 23:56

🤣🤣🤣

SwordToFlamethrower · 14/11/2023 23:15

My fil gifted us a pair of pepples painted to look like penguins, in a picture frame.

The paint was smudged too.

It accidentally fell on the floor and got smashed.

Shame...

LeggyLegsEleven · 14/11/2023 23:04

DH unfortunately is a person who thinks his taste is everything and tries to enforce it on others. He has to be stopped from buying things like art for people.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 14/11/2023 23:00

YANBU at all
Home decor is very personal and tasteful is subjective!
Just a small example here but an older friend bought me an ornate garish one cup Teapot mug thing.. and I don't even drink tea but I feel obliged to keep it just in case she calls in

minipie · 14/11/2023 22:52

jlpth · 14/11/2023 12:57

No presents for adults

Makes everything better

Or ask to be given consumables as you are on a decluttering mission.

This x 1000000

WiddlinDiddlin · 14/11/2023 22:48

I don't im afraid @krustykittens but inbox me and i can show you some pics if you like. Currently out of beetles but ive two moths hanging out done and planning another beetle soon. These are my 'hobby' things so I tend to make what I fancy and if someone loves it, I can be bribed to part with them and if not, they add to the joyous clutter in my house of stuff! :)

krustykittens · 14/11/2023 22:42

@WiddlinDiddlin I would LOVE a 4" embroidered beetle! Do you have an online shop?

hellosolly · 14/11/2023 22:21

I never liked this, and in the years before the family agreed to stop en masse to stop buying, we would regularly drive to the charity shop as soon as it opened after Christmas. So much wasted money!

Montegufoni2017 · 14/11/2023 21:54

100% agree. HATE it. I just get rid but luckily it doesn’t happen much now, people can see how minimal our house is and how OCD we are 😂

paddlinglikecrazy · 14/11/2023 21:51

Just stop displaying the things.
Pre kids my Sil would gift us pictures of their kids ( our nieces ) huge pictures of them ! We love our nieces but freakishly massive pictures of them for the wall ? Nope, we just didn’t put them up.
We have kids now & would never put huge pictures of them on the wall either.

Cherrysoup · 14/11/2023 21:16

A relative gave me a weird carved wooden cat that was looking at its own bum, quite large. I have dogs. The dogs eventually were given the cat to chew (oh no, the dogs got hold of it and destroyed it!) then it went in the woodburner. Another relative gave us metal dogs, with heads on springs. They were kind of cute, but nowhere near my taste. Can’t remember what I did with them.

I would never give anyone ornaments/something they’d need to display, it’s just stupid.