Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Stop buying shit they don't like

209 replies

youhavebadtaste · 14/11/2023 09:42

Please, I beg you, as kind and thoughtful as you think you are being, please stop buying people home furnishing, decorative items, artwork, anything that they will feel compelled to display in their homes - unless you are absolutely certain they want it.

Every Christmas, birthday, birth, or any special event that might incur a gift being given I get nervous because I know we are going to be given things by well meaning people that I just absolutely hate and don't want to show in my home.

A few examples;

When we got married a very good friend gave us a mirrored picture frame covered with diamantes spelling our name. It's large, ugly and does not even begin to blend in with our home decor, that is, well, the total opposite. They thought it was absolutely gorgeous, I do not.

An aunt has taken up woodwork and keeps making us things. I have a lump of wood with various place names that vaguely mean something to us, but not massively significant. I have to display it because she's round all the time. It might sound nice but it's poorly made and I just don't like it. I know she has other things lined up and I keep trying to tell her no in a polite way but she doesn't get it.

Another relative gave me a framed print when we moved in to our house. I can see it's very much her taste but it's just not mine.

I get this may all sound really ungrateful, but I feel bad that these people are wasting their time and money getting us things we just don't like. It's not like it's a cardi that I can wear twice when I see them then shove in a drawer until it gets gifted to the local charity shop - these are things people expect to see us use in our home.

AIBU to just not want this stuff?

OP posts:
Plisco · 16/11/2023 10:54

LuciaPillson · 16/11/2023 08:26

People deciding you collect on an animal theme when you don't is something that bemuses me a bit.

I was once on another site where my username rather randomly referenced an animal and I did have a couple of small plushies of that animal. But then some of my friends made there decided that I wanted gifts of that particular animal, so I'd receive quokka/seal/wolverine plushies and pins and fabric things.

Not too bad but I felt guilty rehoming these things as they were sent with love and in one case hand knitted! I've kept most of them and just got rid of the ones I liked least or took up the most space.

Then somehow a real life friend found out about this and now I get flamingo/wombat/T-Rex stuff from her as well as a yearly calendar. I'm sure I've made plaintive "but I don't collect voles/tigers/budgies" pleas but it falls on deaf ears..... It's all very sweet in a certain way just rather puzzling. Also it becomes hard to say you don't collect something when in actual fact you do have a collection of that thing because you were given so much of it.

(animals listed are not the actual animal) 😁

This reminds me of hearing about somebody's grandmother who collected owl-themed things.

Her whole apartment was full of owl-related items. Pictures, cushions, salt and pepper shakers. Barely an object without an owl motif. She was a lovely lady and people were always giving her things.

When she was in a hospice at the end of her life, she confided to her grandson that she didn't know why everyone kept giving her owls. Somebody had given her an owl tea cosy many years ago. Then somebody else had seen it in use and decided to give her an owl mug for her birthday. And then the whole thing had snowballed on, over decades. She was just too polite and kind to show anything but gratitude for all the gifts. But she didn't especially like owls.

PinkRoses1245 · 16/11/2023 09:57

YANBU at all. We got several wedding presents I literally took straight to the charity shop (and we had said that if guests wanted to give gifts, to contribute to honeymoon). We only do experience gifts in our family, or consumables. The world is choking, people need to wake up to that.

Lorrymum · 16/11/2023 09:54

I have spent years getting dreadful presents from my in-laws. They buy most of them at Sunday markets with unidentifiable brands and just plain tat. It's such a waste of money. I would rather have a bar of Dairy Milk and save me an annual trip to the charity shop.

Todaysproblem · 16/11/2023 09:52

BusySittingDown · 15/11/2023 19:04

YANBU!

I hate when people buy me stuff for the home (unless it's a candle as those run out).

A few years ago my SIL noticed my screensaver on my phone that was a photo of DH, both of our DDs and I at my sister's wedding. She commented that it was a lovely photo and asked if I would send it to her. I was confused 😐 but obliged.

At Christmas we received that same photo emblazoned onto a clock. The image was distorted as it had been enlarged, it looked like it had been taken on a potato.

We had to display it as it was a gift but it was placed behind a door. We've moved since and I have no idea where it went.

You win 😂😂😂

MeinKraft · 16/11/2023 09:36

This thread has made me seriously rethink my grandmothers Christmas present. I've just ordered her an Oodie sleep tee instead as I know she likes a nightie!

Lemonyyy · 16/11/2023 09:27

Agreed. My ILs also like to give me clothes that I don’t like and won’t wear but they obviously love - why? Just buy it for yourself!

anon666 · 16/11/2023 09:26

You've got to move these things out of sight. 😫 I feel so sorry for you having hideous things you don't like in your home.

I think it's okay to give things as long as you don't expect them to be displayed.

People think they're doing something nice but it's misguided.

My lovely mum has her living room full of this stuff given by people. She cares more about the gesture so I think it's her choice but not for everyone.

Ilovecleaning · 16/11/2023 09:23

The whole gift buying thing is a nightmare. I’ve had so many utterly shite gifts over the years that have been insulting, thoughtless, inappropriate or just cheap and nasty. I have never wanted recipients of my gifts to feel that way.
I now buy food and drink gifts chosen according to people’s tastes ( NOT those awful ready done mini hampers containing for example a mini Prosecco and half a dozen dodgy chocolates🤮). They seem to be well received. Well, I hope so 😂

VimtoVimto · 16/11/2023 09:09

This has been helpful to me as I’m trying to sort out presents for my sisters and families. One sister loves buying and receiving lots of stocking fillers and I really struggle as a lot of what I receive is tat, and find I end up buying tat in return.
I volunteer in a charity shop and it’s amazing how many unwanted gifts are donated, some are nice, some not so much. We have a section selling homewares and bric a brac and there is stuff you imagine will never sell yet flies off the shelf.

VimtoVimto · 16/11/2023 08:58

minipie · 15/11/2023 19:53

Do none of these people know you well enough to choose gifts that you'll actually like?

The people that know me well, know that I would prefer to receive nothing. Because I’ve told them.

I am bemused by the threads that appear on MN every year “DH says he doesn’t want anything… what do I get him?” Do him the compliment of taking him seriously and get him nothing!

That reminds me of a question asked on a knitting site. The poster wanted to know what to knit for someone who doesn’t like handknits. Surprisingly the answer of nothing didn’t come up until half a dozen posts in.

SMG1992 · 16/11/2023 08:52

I totally agree with this.
MIL thinks I like pottery (which I do like certain bits of pottery) but keeps getting us the ugliest jugs/ vases!
Also knick knacks from people is my pet peeve. I like an uncluttered home so really don't want to fill it up with bits that I don't even like.

Sartre · 16/11/2023 08:29

YANBU, I hate this too. MIL used to be terrible for it but she’s thankfully given up since covid I’d say. She used to bring huge sacks of shite she’d found in charity shops and expected us to fall over ourselves with glee. I’m an English lecturer so she thinks I just read anything and would ditch a bunch of crappy vampire books in our house fully expecting me to be over the moon. It just caused hassle, we had to take it all back to a charity shop…

LuciaPillson · 16/11/2023 08:26

People deciding you collect on an animal theme when you don't is something that bemuses me a bit.

I was once on another site where my username rather randomly referenced an animal and I did have a couple of small plushies of that animal. But then some of my friends made there decided that I wanted gifts of that particular animal, so I'd receive quokka/seal/wolverine plushies and pins and fabric things.

Not too bad but I felt guilty rehoming these things as they were sent with love and in one case hand knitted! I've kept most of them and just got rid of the ones I liked least or took up the most space.

Then somehow a real life friend found out about this and now I get flamingo/wombat/T-Rex stuff from her as well as a yearly calendar. I'm sure I've made plaintive "but I don't collect voles/tigers/budgies" pleas but it falls on deaf ears..... It's all very sweet in a certain way just rather puzzling. Also it becomes hard to say you don't collect something when in actual fact you do have a collection of that thing because you were given so much of it.

(animals listed are not the actual animal) 😁

erikbloodaxe · 16/11/2023 07:13

I've just had a flashback to the mirrored picture of a hare with a shiny frame. It was big! Sold it on the car boot. The person who bought it loves me very much but obviously doesn't know me very well.

camelfinger · 16/11/2023 05:51

I’m a rubbish gift giver (but then again, based on this thread, giving nothing would be seen as a blessing by many). I’ve wasted ages trying to think of something personal, often not bothered and then have felt guilty. It’s considered rude by many to arrive empty handed - I’ve agonised over the right bottle of wine or chocolates to take somewhere. I know if can be regifted but then what’s the point at all?

We don’t bother with adult gifts and the children do a list. But even that adds to my mental load as I have to explain everything that’s on it, and end up having to triage it so we don’t get too much tat. Same reason I opt out of secret Santa now.

It’s such a pointless endless cycle of buying stuff, sending it to the charity shop for someone else to do the same.

One problem I have is admiring something (it’s nice, but doesn’t mean I want it) or saying that something is nice just to make small talk. Cue me receiving that as a gift later on. I feel I have to be careful what I say.

Madwife123 · 16/11/2023 04:11

Just bin it. I’ve stopped displaying things now in the hope they get the hint.

My worst one was a framed picture made of fabric and buttons etc. on my wedding day. Not only was it ugly, pink when my home in all neutral colours but it had a bride and groom on it when we are a same sex couple. It went straight in the bin!

TruthThatsHardAsSteel · 16/11/2023 04:02

Bunnyhair · 14/11/2023 11:59

I would like to add to this a plea to knitters to stop it with the endless itchy scarves and mittens and hats, unless you are VERY sure the recipient enjoys them.

Agree with this wholeheartedly. I only crochet requests. I'm just finishing the 3rd scarf in a row (3 people asked for one 😭.) You have to know your audience with homemade gifts.

Not the point but I struggle to understand why crafters are using itchy wool there's so much nicer stuff around!

Soozikinzii · 16/11/2023 03:04

I agree 100% with this sand actually think it's quite inconsiderate of people. Surely they go through some kind of thought process as to will the giftee actually like this thing ? I like giving vouchers for this reason .We don't actually give alot of adult presents just a £50 family secret santa and children get presents - of course !

Theoldwoman · 16/11/2023 02:57

Tell them you are becoming minimalist and getting rid of 80% of your stuff, and won’t be bringing anything new into the fold.

Aria999 · 16/11/2023 01:37

*except the room scents with reed diffusers which normally give me the most appalling asthma.

When they are present in Airbnb I stay in I have to collect them all up and hide them in a cupboard.

Aria999 · 16/11/2023 01:35

ChocolateCinderToffee · 15/11/2023 21:51

Think I've found my people on this thread. My oldest friend is someone I've known for decades. She is rather parsimonious. In all the time I've known her, she has only given me one gift that I've liked enough to keep. Nearly everything I've had from her has been awful. Dolls with china faces, cheap 'art' to hang on walls, plastic plants . . . I did eventually say let's not bother as the post is so expensive. A completely different friend is a brilliant present giver: she asked what I wanted and I said something to hang on the wall in a particular place. She found something perfect, very relevant to me.

My problem is I am quite fussy. I can afford to buy what I want for myself. I would say, go for quality not quantity. Small boxes of very expensive chocolates, half bottles of pudding wine, special cheese, flowers, plants, room scents with reed diffusers, washable fluffy slippers, wool socks, wool gloves . . .

I'm currently knitting hats for half my acquaintance. This probably puts me in the category of crafters who can't craft but at least I'm choosing colours I know people will like.

This is so true. I have one relative I always ask for things like clothes and jewelry because though her taste isn't quite the same as mine she normally gets things I love and it's a refreshing spin on things.

From other people pretty much exactly what you have described is the perfect range of gifts.

sobercuriouskind · 15/11/2023 23:58

Actual conversation between me and my Minlaw.

"What happened to that bag I bought you for Xmas?"
"I was able to exchange it for something more to my taste, thanks so much"

She used to also buy us family photo shoots when most of our family hate having our photo taken and then got fed up that we had wasted her money by not using it.

She took the hump and we no longer exchange gifts.

QS90 · 15/11/2023 23:29

My (in every other way lovely) MIL bought me a plastic paperweight the other day - it has plastic flowers set in it. Just why? 😂Even if I popped into a time machine to do admin in the 90s, it isn't heavy enough to weigh the papers down. Apparently it was 50p from a charity shop. I will let the baby investigate it for a while, then back to the charity shop it goes!

ttcat37 · 15/11/2023 22:19

YANBU. Going through a similar thing here with baby stuff. People mean well but I don’t want my child wearing that/ don’t want your old stuff.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 15/11/2023 21:51

Think I've found my people on this thread. My oldest friend is someone I've known for decades. She is rather parsimonious. In all the time I've known her, she has only given me one gift that I've liked enough to keep. Nearly everything I've had from her has been awful. Dolls with china faces, cheap 'art' to hang on walls, plastic plants . . . I did eventually say let's not bother as the post is so expensive. A completely different friend is a brilliant present giver: she asked what I wanted and I said something to hang on the wall in a particular place. She found something perfect, very relevant to me.

My problem is I am quite fussy. I can afford to buy what I want for myself. I would say, go for quality not quantity. Small boxes of very expensive chocolates, half bottles of pudding wine, special cheese, flowers, plants, room scents with reed diffusers, washable fluffy slippers, wool socks, wool gloves . . .

I'm currently knitting hats for half my acquaintance. This probably puts me in the category of crafters who can't craft but at least I'm choosing colours I know people will like.

Swipe left for the next trending thread