Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that you can have an ‘easier’ baby if you do the right things?

237 replies

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 09:05

I know that some babies quite literally scream and scream. Some have reflux etc and there are reasons why they are harder to look after.

But AIBU to think some people just don’t do what works? I have a close friend who won’t allow her baby to cry at all in their cot. I get it, but obviously that means the baby won’t self settle. That’s her choice. By the time the baby was two, they had a sleep consultant as the marriage was almost broken and hey presto, leaving to cry for a minute then going back in - literally - over three nights solved things. This could have been done from day one, not two years later.

Food… my child won’t eat X. If that’s all that’s on offer first thing in the morning when most hungry, then they will eat it. You have to persevere, surely?

My baby won’t be put down… they might not like it but they can be put down? AIBU to think this approach just feeds into the baby feeling a bit out of control as the parent is literally doing what they want even if it’s not best overall?

I am by NO means a perfect parent and I am genuinely interested in what people think to this. But I have noticed that people have different approaches to their babies obviously, and sometimes I do think problems are made by the parents. AIBU?!

OP posts:
Bumpitybumper · 14/11/2023 10:03

Babyboomtastic · 14/11/2023 09:37

I agree that you can have an easier baby if you do the right things.

I wholeheartedly disagree on what you mean by 'right things' though.

I think it's easier when you try not to fight the type of baby you have. Some babies love routine, other babies hate it. My first, would have been miserable if I tried to force boobs on her, it's not what she wanted. My second hated anything that wasn't boobs!

I think things are easier when you parent the child you have not the child you want to have, or thought you would have. Likewise, when you are willing to change what you do and adapt rather than stick to how you wanted to do things. I also think it's easier when you stick to your parenting instincts, which for me would not be letting a child cry.

I agree with this. Babies aren't the blank canvas we are led to believe as they come preprogrammed to a certain extent with characteristics and traits that can be very difficult and sometimes impossible to change.

If you are blessed with a baby that is easy to parent then you are very lucky indeed. Other babies need some persuasion and encouragement to sleep through the night or wean but ultimately aren't that difficult to parent. There are some babies though that are naturally very hard to parent and they are very resistant to change. This can quickly become a war of attrition as parents desperately try to implement every trick and technique possible to get a decent amount of sleep or be able to get anything done. The last thing these parents need is well meaning parents with much easier babies suggesting that if only they would let the baby grizzle a bit in the cot or implement a night time routine then that would solve everything. It is ridiculously naive and just completely irrelevant when you're dealing with a high needs baby.

It reminds me of people with colds trying tell people with the flu to try some warm vimto or those with a touch of morning sickness suggesting to a woman with hypermesis that they should eat a ginger biscuit. Humans do not like being in a state of discomfort and will naturally seek solutions to problems that are creating this discomfort. You can safely assume that most parents will have tried the relatively easy solutions if the baby is keeping them awake all night or won't be put down.

TomeTome · 14/11/2023 10:03

I think you don’t have much experience of babies @isthisunfairth
The reality is your input is much more controlled by the baby you are dealing with than you driving anything.

Tinybrother · 14/11/2023 10:02

Londonscallingme · 14/11/2023 09:56

The best piece of advice anyone ever gave me before I had a kid was "Don't feel smug if it's going well but equally, don't beat yourself up if it's going badly." As you say, it's often just random what you get!

This.

whatever makes you feel good about yourself OP

BertieBotts · 14/11/2023 10:02

Hmm, I think both.

If you think about it, at any given stage there are going to be children at either end of the scale. Some who are just easy, compliant, easygoing, sleep well, eat well, generally happy and you don't have to do anything to achieve this, indeed you might well assume that it's your parenting but it could just be their temperament.

Then some at the opposite end of the scale where nothing works and they are just difficult and you'll have a hard time whatever you do.

Plus a decent chunk in the middle - where they do need some active management and you can end up with a harder or easier time based on what you're putting into place. It's certainly true in general that proactive parenting is usually more effective and easier overall than reactive parenting, but it is more work upfront.

And with all of these children might be in a different category at different stages of their life. So you might get a difficult baby who turns into an angelic toddler, and then is a middle of the road preschooler, needing a bit more active management.

I was listening to a parenting expert talk the other day and she reckoned it was about 20% on either extreme, with around 60% being in the middle, which is the majority, which is probably why most parenting advice assumes that this is the universal experience.

OTOH there is a study looking at baby routine books, the ones which suggest all the standard ideas like drowsy but awake, establish a routine, get baby sleeping independently, don't feed to sleep etc, and how effective new mothers (sounds sexist, but I suppose representative of the fact it tends to be mothers doing the bulk of baby care) found the book's instructions and how it affected their overall wellbeing and confidence. This study found that the books were only effective for around 20% of the mothers in the "book group" in the study, and when they compared the group that had used the books with the group that did not use the books, they found that the book's success was correlated heavily with the mothers' senses of confidence and happiness. Basically, if the book worked for them, it increased their confidence and they were likely to recommend it to everyone, assuming that it was the book which caused the outcome. And if the book did not work, it actually reduced the mother's confidence and happiness.

Those numbers are very different because they suggest that 80% of the babies (at least in that study) are in the "nothing works" category, with only 20% total being in either "unicorn baby" or "normal baby" category.

That might just be babies, whereas the expert was talking about school aged children. It might be that the proportions of easy/medium/hard are different at different ages - there are known challenging ages, like babies, toddlers, teenagers. It doesn't really tell you whether they did the methods in the book properly. And it's only one study as well.

For sleep routines/sleep training in particular, it is difficult to find high quality research because what apparently tends to happen is that there will be families who screen themselves out because they are starting with an idea of "That definitely will not work for my baby" and/or "I am not prepared to leave my baby to cry". And sometimes people sign up for the study and then you get a fairly high rate of drop out once people are assigned to a category. So I think that actually it's probably better to look at anecdotal evidence, usually from professionals who work with large numbers of families and see a range of baby/toddler/child behaviour. But even this will be skewed because people only tend to seek professional support when things are going badly.

Anyway there is more research coming out now about temperament, which should be interesting. But my main point is that I think the OP assumes that the "difficult" babies are a very tiny percentage, and I think that it's likely to be higher than this.

Also, with baby sleep in particular I do think there is an argument FOR playing the longer game sometimes. I know that for me, I preferred to co-sleep and feed overnight and then put them in their own rooms when they were older. That worked for me and wasn't a problem, whereas a lot of baby sleep advice is presented as this kind of moral thing like this habit is "good" that is "bad" or "unhealthy" when it's nothing of the sort.

Caerulea · 14/11/2023 10:02

Children are just wildly different & unless you can go back & do it differently you don't know what leads to what in many respects.

DS3 didn't sleep through till he was about 4, we tried & tried. The thing that solved it? Our cat! When he started stirring in the night she'd go rest her muzzle on his forehead & he'd go back to sleep. I didn't know why he'd stopped waking till I caught her actually doing it (I have photo evidence lol). She slept on his pillow every night after that for years. Not sure what triggered her to start or why tf she didn't do it earlier 😂

Echobelly · 14/11/2023 10:01

I think it's all luck of the draw with newborns and for the most part babies and toddlers too. I got lucky, mine were both decent sleepers and both happy to sleep while out and about in a buggy. I initially didn't understand why a parent would do that very set nap schedule thing because it seemed to be so limiting - eg all the parents who did it had to base their day around it and it was 'I can't come then he has to nap at home', but then I figured if otherwise the baby had a naptime that was all over the place without a routine and would only settle in a dark room, then maybe that was the best solution for them.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/11/2023 09:59

I wouldn't be too smug too soon, OP.

A lot of the people I know who went on and on about me making a rod for my own back when our kids were babies had an absolute nightmare of a time when their kids were teens. Just saying....

ssd · 14/11/2023 09:59

Oh god i love these smug first time mum threads Grin

Londonscallingme · 14/11/2023 09:56

boochristmas · 14/11/2023 09:53

I have a large family. Believe me, it's entirely random what you get.

The best piece of advice anyone ever gave me before I had a kid was "Don't feel smug if it's going well but equally, don't beat yourself up if it's going badly." As you say, it's often just random what you get!

honeylulu · 14/11/2023 09:56

It's not as simple as that. My first child was a brilliant sleeper (I was firm about a routine so I thought it was all down to my excellent mothering skills <hollow laughter>). He also ate absolutely everything.

Second child. Same upbringing. In fact I was even firmer as I had less time and energy for pandering. Did not sleep reliably in her own bed until she was 6. Very fussy eater, would rather go hungry than try something new. Does my head in.

Just to throw in another wildcard my first child (no sensory issues) has ASD. Second child is NT. Go figure. Kids are just different and there's no single parenting formula which works.

Sholkedabemus · 14/11/2023 09:56

I agree with you @isthisunfairth .

GentlemansRelish · 14/11/2023 09:55

boochristmas · 14/11/2023 09:53

I have a large family. Believe me, it's entirely random what you get.

This.

Elastica23 · 14/11/2023 09:54

I think yes, sometimes people do make a rod for their back but some babies are easier than others and sometimes there is very little the parents can do except try and manage the situation.

My DDs were both opposites in so many ways - neither were difficult babies, DD1 was a more stroppy toddler and stroppy teenager but someone who shows their feelings can actually be easier than someone who doesn't, until they do in other more subtle ways, like DD2. She seems really easy going but suppresses things until they become a bigger problem, and it's harder to pick up on subtle cues than on someone who is briefly angry and upset then it's over.

boochristmas · 14/11/2023 09:53

I have a large family. Believe me, it's entirely random what you get.

Babyccino11 · 14/11/2023 09:53

YABU, though I suspect I may have held this view before I had my child. I know my friend felt similarly, then she had her second!

EarthlyNightshade · 14/11/2023 09:52

You probably can have an easier baby if you just leave it to cry.
Eventually your baby will stop crying and you can congratulate yourself on having a baby who self settled.
Spending time with your baby is work - work that some/many parents enjoy.
Baby time is short, feels long while you are going through it, but I'd give anything now to hold my crying baby and feel him calm down in my arms as that was where he wanted to be.

Givemepickles · 14/11/2023 09:51

Seeline · 14/11/2023 09:28

@Givemepickles it's because you had easy babies that you could impose the routines. Not the routines making easy babies.
Do you honestly think that those parents on their knees haven't tried a routine?

Could be! Though one friend who was struggling at 6 weeks started the routine and her baby became much 'easier'. Another started at 8 weeks and same thing.

My friends who were on their knees didn't try routines, no. In fact they could barely even say routine without spitting fury. They thought routine meant cry it out. I never spoke to them about it after mentioning I was doing it with my DC and they looked horrified. (I never did CIO). So no, they didn't try it. Our babies are only 1 and a bit now so maybe they will at some stage, maybe not.

RHOShitVille · 14/11/2023 09:51

Except 2 year olds are not always diagnosed with SEN.

I tried everything, child would not sleep, would not eat. Judgy people like you made me feel like shit because there is an assumption it is parenting.

Many years on we have multiple diagnoses and a child who is most certainly experienced the negative impact of being left to cry because I listened to the judgy people over and over, despite it being clear that it would not work with our child.

Well done on not having a child with additional needs.

Stillwaitingfor · 14/11/2023 09:50

Please, come to my house and "be strict" with my second baby. She is en entirely different temperament to my first and I promise you, the strategies simply don't work with her. But please, give it a go 😀

headcheffer · 14/11/2023 09:49

Funderthighs · 14/11/2023 09:11

My neighbour had 3 children. All slept through the night from early on, ate everything, etc,. Then she had number 4😱 Despite doing everything the same, number 4 was a nightmare. (They’re now an adult, no SEN). She said she used to raise her eyebrows at people who had babies who didn’t eat/sleep……until baby number 4 came along.

My sister says this too, and it was her 4th that broke her! She realises now how judgemental she was to other parents.

I think there's an element of truth to what OP says. Pandering to your children all the time isn't healthy, but you do need to meet their needs. It's a fine balance. But for example if I really do need to finish getting the washing in from outside before it rains, my baby might have to cry for a minute or two because they don't want to be left alone. But I wouldn't leave them crying for me while I spent 15 mins clearing out a cupboard in the kitchen or something! And the older they get the easier it all becomes with them understanding you will meet their needs but they need to wait until you've finished your task as it's time sensitive.

Shodan · 14/11/2023 09:46

If I'd had my two children the other way around I might have agreed with you, OP.

As it is, I cut my parenting teeth on my now-adult ds1.

He would NOT sleep. I tried every method in the book- CIO, co-sleeping, gradual withdrawing...I can't even remember the full list now. He didn't sleep through the night until he was six YEARS old.

He wouldn't eat most foods. And if he was offered something for breakfast that he didn't like, he just wouldn't eat. He would go hungry. Even when I persevered.

He was tested for so many things and all came back the same- nothing untoward, nothing wrong.

He was (and still is) the most stubborn child.

DS2, on the other hand- a breeze. Even by other parents' standards (who have much 'easier' children) he has been so easy to raise. By my standards, he's almost brought himself up. A bit of gentle guidance here and there has been all that's required.

I don't doubt that there are some parents who are inclined to martyr themselves at the altar of child-rearing, but I suspect that there are also some who have already tried everything, and whose children are just...stubborn.

JanewaysBun · 14/11/2023 09:43

If i only had DD I would be smugly posting like this too. HowEver I had DS first so well aware you get the child you are given 🤣🤣

Merrymouse · 14/11/2023 09:42

I’m very impressed by this confidence in ‘the right things’. It’s a few years ago now, but from memory there was huge controversy over the ‘right’ way to get a baby to sleep when my children were babies.

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 09:42

Not being judgemental, I had a very tricky first baby. I know people who are strict with babies and they seem easier. So I tried to be more strict with my second.

OP posts:
SallyWD · 14/11/2023 09:41

UpUpUpU · 14/11/2023 09:11

I did cry it out as a baby/toddler and now have a 5 year old who is scared to be left alone in bed. If I could turn back the clock I wouldn’t have done it

You have no idea if it's related. Perhaps they would always have disliked being alone. I did controlled crying with my two and they were both so much happier afterwards. Like different children. They were no longer over-tired, over-emotional. They've both loved bedtime ever since. My son is now nearly 11 and still tells me "Oh I can't wait for bed. I'm going to snuggle up under the duvet and be all cosy".