Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that you can have an ‘easier’ baby if you do the right things?

237 replies

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 09:05

I know that some babies quite literally scream and scream. Some have reflux etc and there are reasons why they are harder to look after.

But AIBU to think some people just don’t do what works? I have a close friend who won’t allow her baby to cry at all in their cot. I get it, but obviously that means the baby won’t self settle. That’s her choice. By the time the baby was two, they had a sleep consultant as the marriage was almost broken and hey presto, leaving to cry for a minute then going back in - literally - over three nights solved things. This could have been done from day one, not two years later.

Food… my child won’t eat X. If that’s all that’s on offer first thing in the morning when most hungry, then they will eat it. You have to persevere, surely?

My baby won’t be put down… they might not like it but they can be put down? AIBU to think this approach just feeds into the baby feeling a bit out of control as the parent is literally doing what they want even if it’s not best overall?

I am by NO means a perfect parent and I am genuinely interested in what people think to this. But I have noticed that people have different approaches to their babies obviously, and sometimes I do think problems are made by the parents. AIBU?!

OP posts:
myotherkidisacassowary · 14/11/2023 10:51

I totally disagree, because you’re assuming kids are a ‘one technique fits all’ deal.

I did all the things you’re critical of in your first post; my son cried when he was placed in his cot awake so I didn’t do it. He hated to be put down (until he could sit) so I held him all the time. I never force him to eat anything he doesn’t want to, and I make sure every meal includes at least one ‘safe’ food that I know he likes.

These were all techniques that suited him and worked out brilliantly for us. He’s now a very confident, calm, easy going three year old. He has never tantrummed in his life, he plays independently for long stretches of time, he has lovely manners, he eats most things, he sleeps through the night.

Almost all of this is down to the lucky fact that I got a child with a calm and easy-going personality bit can you imagine how much harder our lives would have been if I had forced him to cry in his cot, or put him down all the time when he hated it?

Some children may respond fine to the more ‘tough love’ approach you’re advocating but it’s nonsensical to suggest it would work on all kids, or that it’s some marvellous panacea leading to good kids. Parents know their own children best and find what works for them, but the truth is some children are simply more sensitive / in need of support than others.

You can only parent the child you have, and if that means being a responsive attachment parent who doesn’t accept that they have to let their baby cry for their own good, it certainly doesn’t mean they’re failing in some imaginary mission to raise easy children.

EarthlyNightshade · 14/11/2023 10:48

BeeDavis · 14/11/2023 10:35

I completely agree with you and I have a child. We’ve pretty much had no issues with him sleeping apart from when he had a horrendous eczema flare when he was around 7 months old, his sleep was awful as it was irritating him. As soon as we found a cream that worked he was back to sleeping through as usual, took a couple months but we made it 😂😂 he’s 2 now and has been a dream, still is. My nephew has been brought up completely different and you can really tell.

Perhaps you could pass some parenting tips to your nephew's parents since you have it all worked out?

Milkmani · 14/11/2023 10:43

@isthisunfairthNever had to be strict with my son, quite the opposite. Always went to him when he cried in his cot and often co-slept, he’s slept through from 7 months with disturbances here and there of course due to illness etc. He eats everything, sure there will be days when he’s not in the mood for something- that’s fine, I give him something else. Has a varied diet, allowed sweet treats on special occasions or celebrations but very healthy and loves veg, meat, salad - whatever I make he’ll eat it. Never wanted to be put down for the first 5 months, that’s fine I put him in a carrier when I needed to do things even though my c-section scar was agony- guess who doesn’t have a clingy child who has never cried being dropped off at nursery, me. I’m lucky to have an easy child but never had I needed to be ‘strict’ like you said. I know for sure that my second will probably be the devil incarnate 😂 Keep your opinions to yourself, from what I’m reading you’re not as perfect as you think. Much like adults, not all children are the same.

Grimbelina · 14/11/2023 10:43

My mother would have written your post... she was rather smug apparently (according to her) until she had my sister and realised that things can be far more complicated than just 'trying different things'.

I have one easy child and one very challenging one. Very few people can understand just how difficult my life is due to this... and it isn't for want of trying to solve the issues.

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 10:43

Ok let’s take one example…

I was in the camp of ‘my baby won’t be put down’

but he would be… if I had put him down. Which is what I did with my second and they were generally easier. Just my experience though and as this thread shows, there’s lots of different experiences

OP posts:
Gerrataere · 14/11/2023 10:43

You’re absolutely delusional op.

My first was a ‘dream baby/small toddler’. After the first six weeks I could take him anywhere, he was breastfed so quite attached but I could put him down and get on with things. He didn’t love starting solids but tried a bit of everything. Was sleeping through in his own bed by 18 months when I fully stopped BF. Halcyon Days.

My second nearly gave me a breakdown. He came into this world screaming and didn’t stop for two years. He didn’t sleep. I can’t remember much beyond that because I’ve block a lot out for my own mental health, I do remember days of putting him in the pram and having to take 5 minutes in a different room, often clawing at myself because the crying wouldn’t stop. Could only go out for an hour scheduled around a nap otherwise he’d scream until we got home.

They've both been diagnosed with autism since. I wouldn’t wish the first two years with my second on anyone, but bloody hell people like the op have no idea.

ASimpleLampoon · 14/11/2023 10:40

Both my children were "dream children" until 3.

One is still a dream child in the conventional sense. The other was diagnosed with Autism and later Tourettes. Still a dream child in that I love him to bits and he is a wonderful human being who brings me joy.

But the systems I have to battle with and the expectations of a society not Built for him are a nightmare. And "what works" for him is very different to "what works" for my other child.

If both my kids were NT I might also have been arrogant and looking down on others who don't have it so easy as raising these kids is worlds away from each other. But I know better so I'm going for YABU.

Eskarina1 · 14/11/2023 10:39

I had twins. If I'd had one first I would have been so smug, believing myself a very talented parent. He slept 5 hours a nigh straight out of hospital, was even tempered, ate anything once it came to weaning

If I'd had his brother first, I'd have decided I wasn't cut out to be a parent. He never slept more than 2 hours straight for the first year, she's a very fussy eater, he had massive separation anxiety.

They ate both lovely, well behaved preteens now.

IsThatAFact · 14/11/2023 10:38

Oh dear OP.

Your poor children.

UsernameCreater · 14/11/2023 10:38

So bizarre that people think the perfect child is one who sleeps when their parents want them to and eats what their parents want. It seems to me that most parents just want kids who fit in with their own lives.

Tinybrother · 14/11/2023 10:37

BeeDavis · 14/11/2023 10:35

I completely agree with you and I have a child. We’ve pretty much had no issues with him sleeping apart from when he had a horrendous eczema flare when he was around 7 months old, his sleep was awful as it was irritating him. As soon as we found a cream that worked he was back to sleeping through as usual, took a couple months but we made it 😂😂 he’s 2 now and has been a dream, still is. My nephew has been brought up completely different and you can really tell.

Haha at comparing two 2yos and thinking you know anything at all

JellyBabiesSaveLives · 14/11/2023 10:36

Hahaha come back and tell us about "doing the right things" when you've seen three kids through their teenage years.

I'm trying to get dc3 into the routine of actually getting to the school bus on time in the morning so he can study for his bloody GCSEs, it's easy I just tell him how it's going to be, and - oh, wait, no. He has always been a jolly good sleeper though.

BeeDavis · 14/11/2023 10:35

I completely agree with you and I have a child. We’ve pretty much had no issues with him sleeping apart from when he had a horrendous eczema flare when he was around 7 months old, his sleep was awful as it was irritating him. As soon as we found a cream that worked he was back to sleeping through as usual, took a couple months but we made it 😂😂 he’s 2 now and has been a dream, still is. My nephew has been brought up completely different and you can really tell.

Loveandloveandlove · 14/11/2023 10:34

Are your children teenagers yet OP? Word of warning, I had nightmare babies who barely slept but they were an absolute dream as teenagers. My friends who had little angelic babies were horrific teenagers. My friends always said I was doing things wrong as I breastfed and my babies didn’t sleep well but theirs were bottle fed and did, I didn’t use dummies and they said that was wrong too along with a whole heap of other things.

Lammveg · 14/11/2023 10:32

The sleeping thing is a big one. I think you have babies who sleep well, one's that are able to be 'taught' to self settle and one's that just won't tolerate it.

I was reading a very popular parenting book that suggested that if your baby cries so much they vomit when you leave them to learn to self settle, just stick it out for a few days. To me that is unacceptable and is an example of a baby who will not tolerate self settling training.

Some things you can do to make it easier, but it's mostly dependent on your babies temperament. And also what you find acceptable. For example, I'm happy to carry my DD most of the time and I find that 'easy', for others that wouldn't be the case.

Also research suggests babies who self settle still wake up at night with the same levels of cortisol but just don't bother to cry because they learn there's no point. For some that might allow them to get a good sleep and be a better parent in the day, for others they would prefer, and find it easier, to go to thier babies in the night.

Donmeistersleepmachine · 14/11/2023 10:29

Yes they are. My baby has to be rocked to sleep and I couldn't take the back breaking pain of rocking every day after being bedbound in late pregnancy past him being 2 months old. Gradually over a month left him to fall asleep by himself with hand holding and stroking, little 10 minute pockets of crying. Now 5 months old he goes immediately down for a nap or to bed with no cry at all and chatting away for 5 minutes before he closes his eyes and drifts off. People believe whatever they want to believe but my baby went from HAVING to be rocked to now WANTING to be put down and left alone after my own efforts at helping him learn to do that.

Newsenmum · 14/11/2023 10:28

Mamato29192 · 14/11/2023 10:21

Self settling is not bollocks. My son learnt it early on.

And some still won’t, no matter what you do. All these posts do is make women feel like failures.

Newsenmum · 14/11/2023 10:27

Lol. You do realise that a lot of those things don’t work for other babies. Maybe your baby was ok to cry a bit in his/her cot. Some babies will literally make themselves sick with anxiety very quickly. Some mums don’t want that.
Just be thankful.

NotObligedToArgueWithStrangers · 14/11/2023 10:26

Luck of the draw.

Wemetatascoutcamp · 14/11/2023 10:23

Honestly I was that smug parent until I had DC4- he went down in the cot awake and self settled from 4 months old (as my other kids did) until he was over a year old then bang one night it all changed and he would just stand up screaming in the cot for hours- put him in our bed and he’d be asleep within minutes. So yes a year on he still sleeps in our bed.

Yes some people make a rod for their own back but honestly sometimes its difficult to break a cycle and not all babies are the same- just like us adults don’t all go to sleep the same or eat the same etc etc.

ColleenDonaghy · 14/11/2023 10:23

Mamato29192 · 14/11/2023 10:21

Self settling is not bollocks. My son learnt it early on.

But if a baby isn't ready, they won't learn, they'll just cry. So the parents stop trying. The ones who learn are the ones who are ready.

My niece was walking well before her birthday. My second didn't roll until 6 months, no amount of parenting from me was going to get that baby walking by 1. She got there when she was ready.

Scottishskifun · 14/11/2023 10:22

Nope it's baby specific and do you not think that parents have tried half of what your suggesting?!

DS1 was a velcro/koala baby it wasn't just a case of put him down and let him cry he would either get so worked up he would vomit or he would hold his breath and then pass out!
So I would carry him about with me in a sling.

DS2 complete opposite really chilled and would happily be in a bouncer.

I've also had similar comments regarding why they are in such a set routine and that babies/young children should fit around us not the other way....so we did as they requested for a party and went to theirs kept them up way past their bedtime and they screamed the place down for nearly an hour til we left. Safe to day that nugget of advice hasn't been trotted about since.

Mamato29192 · 14/11/2023 10:21

AlltheFs · 14/11/2023 09:21

Depends what sort of parent you want to be. I see none of the things you mention as problems that need fixing. It’s moved on since 1950.

Babies are meant to be held, self settling is absolute bollocks.

Self settling is not bollocks. My son learnt it early on.

ludocris · 14/11/2023 10:21

Have you considered writing a book OP?

ColleenDonaghy · 14/11/2023 10:21

Mamato29192 · 14/11/2023 10:20

My baba is an easy baba as I did routine early on and he learnt to self settle too

Your baby is an easy baby and so easily settled into a routine early on, and easily learned to self settle.

You have the causation the wrong way around.