Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that you can have an ‘easier’ baby if you do the right things?

237 replies

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 09:05

I know that some babies quite literally scream and scream. Some have reflux etc and there are reasons why they are harder to look after.

But AIBU to think some people just don’t do what works? I have a close friend who won’t allow her baby to cry at all in their cot. I get it, but obviously that means the baby won’t self settle. That’s her choice. By the time the baby was two, they had a sleep consultant as the marriage was almost broken and hey presto, leaving to cry for a minute then going back in - literally - over three nights solved things. This could have been done from day one, not two years later.

Food… my child won’t eat X. If that’s all that’s on offer first thing in the morning when most hungry, then they will eat it. You have to persevere, surely?

My baby won’t be put down… they might not like it but they can be put down? AIBU to think this approach just feeds into the baby feeling a bit out of control as the parent is literally doing what they want even if it’s not best overall?

I am by NO means a perfect parent and I am genuinely interested in what people think to this. But I have noticed that people have different approaches to their babies obviously, and sometimes I do think problems are made by the parents. AIBU?!

OP posts:
Whydoifeelsobadallthetime · 14/11/2023 11:14

Hmm, yeah I guess you can have an easier baby if your post is your expectation out of parenting.
You're pretty much advocating the cry it out method, and like it or lump it mentality. I wouldn't be so smug about that.

LolaSmiles · 14/11/2023 11:14

Some parents make it hard for themselves - and perhaps others make it hard for their babies instead 😁
Agree with this completely.

I've never been of the school of thought where parents should allow a 2 year old to dictate what's on offer every meal time, but I did find myself wondering why some people kept pushing foods a toddler dislikes. What do they want to happen? A gold star? Or the ability to sit at playgroup tilting their head and saying "oh Jemima isn't a picky eater. None of mine are. I told her you can eat you courgette and anchovy paste or go hungry. Unsurprisingly she eats everything".

Don't most people want a middle ground where they're not endlessly picking fights with their children over random reasons (or as they say principles, like shut up and clear your plate because I said so), but also not creating environment where young children have developmentally inappropriate levels of power and control?

Mamato29192 · 14/11/2023 11:12

Donmeistersleepmachine · 14/11/2023 10:51

Anyone saying babies can't be taught to self settle are just incorrect. Maybe not all babies but if we are talking babies in general yes you can. And young too, a few months old. I feel there is a holier than thou attitude oh I couldn't possibly leave my little one to cry for a minute, my heart renches, any mother than can do that clearly doesn't care... Well not really, I love my little boy, I would do anything for him, and him learning to self settle has cut out about one hour of crying throughout the day as he can drift off by himself now. And are there mums that really don't leave baby to cry for ebem a second? You never been busting for a wee? Needed a drink? Needed to ... eat food? Teaching babies to self settle does actually work at least for some, no need to be self richeous and believe you are a better mother because your little darling didn't cry alone for a second until the age of 4.. some of us have things that need to be done and need to put babies down here and there

My son learnt to self settle at 11 weeks. It can happen

EarthlyNightshade · 14/11/2023 11:12

myotherkidisacassowary · 14/11/2023 11:09

Some parents make it hard for themselves - and perhaps others make it hard for their babies instead 😁

This.

Sharontheodopolodous · 14/11/2023 11:11

No 1 and 2 where easy enough babies

Both ate and slept well

Then came no 3-he broke me

I still say I'm broken-hes 23 and about to become a dad himself

I wouldn't wish him on anyone-he was what is now called a high needs baby-he had to be touching me at all time or he'd scream

I'd get him to sleep if I was lucky and then dare to need a wee-hed wake up and scream I'd then spend ages trying to get him back to sleep-rinse and repeat

My mother was as much use as a chocolate fireguard-i think she was a bit scared of him-my friends tried but he wouldn't let me go

For 3 years I muddled through until he started nursery and it got a tiny bit better-I could be in the same room without him screaming and clinging

I was such a smug mother with the other two-i was doing it all right,they ate,slept and where very chilled

Then he appeared and hell happened (I mean I adore him,don't get me wrong But his first 3 years where torture)

Caerulea · 14/11/2023 11:10

UsernameCreater · 14/11/2023 10:38

So bizarre that people think the perfect child is one who sleeps when their parents want them to and eats what their parents want. It seems to me that most parents just want kids who fit in with their own lives.

I think that's my problem with all the books & regimens. You might find they work but actually your life is more limited as you've no flexibility with naptimes & bedtimes & dinnertimes etc. You can't go out later with baby, do things that break the routine. SIL's children are LOVELY! But on their visits they've been restricted in what they can do. Wanted to take them to an evening thing at the Eden project (they live in another country so this was a really special thing) but they couldn't go cos Routine. She's now much more relaxed with DS3 (who is also adorable & very easy going, so maybe she just makes chill kids?).

I'm a wing-it type, all of my 3 were different. We worked around them, were exhausted to distraction, made mistakes I'm sure. Ime there does seem to be a difference in approach between socioeconomic groups regards how regimented & strict people are.

My advice to DS1 & his partner about his new baby was not to listen to other people, just do what feels right for you. That they go through phases & it's nothing to do with you failing, it's just what babies do. Their baby is the most chill thing I've ever seen to the point of me saying not to have another cos this is too good to be true 😂

LynnThese4reSEXPEOPLE · 14/11/2023 11:10

Both children were non-sleeping, refluxing, failing to thrive, permanently stuck on me despite doing all the "right" things. Both breastfed for over 2 years. Baby 2 spent most of his early life in a sling because it was the pandemic and freed up my hands for my then aged 4 DS1.

At about 8 months, they both decided that they quite liked sleeping and stopped waking every 45 mins and making me feel like I wanted to die of tiredness. Up until then, no amount of leaving to cry, not leaving to cry, gradual retreat or any other form of "training" worked.

People would say I have 'easy' children; they sleep very well, eat well and will go to bed for anyone within 20 mins including brand new babysitters. I consider myself lucky, and no better at parenting than anyone else - the first 8 months were awful, and I was better prepared for it with the second child but it still didn't help.

You don't get to chose the sort of baby you have, and judgey comments during their early days made me feel awful.

YouAreBeingUnbearable · 14/11/2023 11:10

Fizzadora · 14/11/2023 09:08

No. I have one child and he was a dream. My best friend had her first at the same time and he too was a dream. Then she had her daughter. Despite doing everything exactly the same, she was not a dream.

This has been my experience too. I was so smug 😂 Turns out I was actually just lucky.

myotherkidisacassowary · 14/11/2023 11:09

Londontown12 · 14/11/2023 11:08

I agree ! Sometimes people do make life hard for themselves when it comes to parenting .
But I also think if there is a medical problem ect ect it can’t be helped whatever u try x

Some parents make it hard for themselves - and perhaps others make it hard for their babies instead 😁

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 11:08

@Humbugg two, one hard and one easier

OP posts:
MrTiddlesTheCat · 14/11/2023 11:08

My baby didn't want to be put down, so I didn't put him down. Worked fine us. I was happy, baby was happy. What's the problem with that?

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 11:08

Humbugg · 14/11/2023 10:53

YABVU and goading.

how many children do you have op?

@Humbugg have you even read any of my posts? I am not goading

OP posts:
Londontown12 · 14/11/2023 11:08

I agree ! Sometimes people do make life hard for themselves when it comes to parenting .
But I also think if there is a medical problem ect ect it can’t be helped whatever u try x

pizzaHeart · 14/11/2023 11:07

Fizzadora · 14/11/2023 09:08

No. I have one child and he was a dream. My best friend had her first at the same time and he too was a dream. Then she had her daughter. Despite doing everything exactly the same, she was not a dream.

this^
I know a few parents who were in the same boat : settled, experienced, etc but the second child was far from the ideal first.
you are very naive

Seeline · 14/11/2023 11:02

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 10:43

Ok let’s take one example…

I was in the camp of ‘my baby won’t be put down’

but he would be… if I had put him down. Which is what I did with my second and they were generally easier. Just my experience though and as this thread shows, there’s lots of different experiences

But they were two different babies with different needs.

You could put your first down but didn't because they cried if you did.

You put your second down and they didn't cry so you left them.

That's just reacting to your baby's needs. Not doing the right thing.
Well in my view it is because you responded to your first when they cried (because that's what they needed). You didn't pick your second up again because they weren't crying, so probably didn't need anything.

luckylavender · 14/11/2023 11:00

I have many friends with 2 children (including twins) where 1 was a dream and the other a menace. So no.

LifeofBrienne · 14/11/2023 10:56

AnnaTortoiseshell · 14/11/2023 09:21

Imagine getting up in the morning and not being offered anything other than food you dislike to eat, just our of principle. Incredible.

Exactly, crazy! And how many days or weeks are you supposed to ‘persevere’ and serve up a breakfast that your baby / toddler / child won’t eat? Are you allowed to give them a mid morning snack or are you supposed to starve them until lunch? I really don’t think OP has thought this through…

Changednayme · 14/11/2023 10:55

You’re not meant to leave them to cry

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 14/11/2023 10:54

I think there are a lot of variables. Sometimes people forget that babies and toddlers aren’t little robots - they’re humans with variability and idiosyncrasies and preferences, just like adult humans.

There are definitely ‘easier’ babies and toddler and more difficult ones. There are also differences in how they respond to things - what ‘works’ for one baby won’t work for another.

There are also differences in what parents can tolerate. I tried ‘controlled crying’ with my youngest. After 35 minutes I picked up and cuddled a very sad, very scared little boy - swollen eyes, gasping for breath, trembling. Never again. But if you can tolerate that, then all power to you.

Fizbosshoes · 14/11/2023 10:54

Eskarina1 · 14/11/2023 10:39

I had twins. If I'd had one first I would have been so smug, believing myself a very talented parent. He slept 5 hours a nigh straight out of hospital, was even tempered, ate anything once it came to weaning

If I'd had his brother first, I'd have decided I wasn't cut out to be a parent. He never slept more than 2 hours straight for the first year, she's a very fussy eater, he had massive separation anxiety.

They ate both lovely, well behaved preteens now.

Proof that some posters need that actually here are 2 babies that are being parented exactly the same and still can have different habits and temperaments...

...who'd have thought... ? 😉

Humbugg · 14/11/2023 10:53

YABVU and goading.

how many children do you have op?

LolaSmiles · 14/11/2023 10:52

YABU if think that if you just do certain things then a baby will fall into line, my way or the highway style.

YANBU if you think that many babies will be easier if parents do certain things that match the baby's needs.(Eg. The parent would have an easier time if they accepted a car nap/used a sling/accepted a pushchair nap and followed their baby instead of insisting naps have to happen in the cot at 11am and 2pm on the dot / the parent stopped turning weaning mealtimes into a battle and instead served a balanced plate that includes food their baby likes)

UsernameCreater · 14/11/2023 10:52

Also @isthisunfairth, how have you decided what you’re doing is the “right thing”?

we used to think continuing to smoke during pregnancy was the “right thing”

we used to think drinking Guiness when pregnant was the “right thing”

we used to think laying our babies to sleep on their front was the “right thing”

we used to think smacking our children was the “right thing”

Why are you so convinced your parenting is perfect? And what would you do if science one day showed it was not the right thing?

Donmeistersleepmachine · 14/11/2023 10:51

Anyone saying babies can't be taught to self settle are just incorrect. Maybe not all babies but if we are talking babies in general yes you can. And young too, a few months old. I feel there is a holier than thou attitude oh I couldn't possibly leave my little one to cry for a minute, my heart renches, any mother than can do that clearly doesn't care... Well not really, I love my little boy, I would do anything for him, and him learning to self settle has cut out about one hour of crying throughout the day as he can drift off by himself now. And are there mums that really don't leave baby to cry for ebem a second? You never been busting for a wee? Needed a drink? Needed to ... eat food? Teaching babies to self settle does actually work at least for some, no need to be self richeous and believe you are a better mother because your little darling didn't cry alone for a second until the age of 4.. some of us have things that need to be done and need to put babies down here and there

ColleenDonaghy · 14/11/2023 10:51

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 10:43

Ok let’s take one example…

I was in the camp of ‘my baby won’t be put down’

but he would be… if I had put him down. Which is what I did with my second and they were generally easier. Just my experience though and as this thread shows, there’s lots of different experiences

If I put my first down, she screamed. Whatever, she screamed. Every nap was on me or in the car, until she was 7 months and one day wanted her cot. There was no teaching her, she just screamed and I wasn't willing to let her (and I would judge a parent who could leave a baby to cry like that tbh). She's now 5 and has been a terrific sleeper for years now, she got there when she was ready.

Youngest could be put down from week 1. I couldn't believe it, she actually slept in the pram. I could go to the loo and do laundry and all the rest during naps. She could do it! She became a terrible sleeper at 18 months and was up for hours every night for a good 18 months from that point. And then the switch flicked back and she's pretty solid again at 3.5.

The thing with babies is that it's useful to put them down, because you need to pee, or have a shower, or wipe the toddler's bum - people find out very quickly if their baby can be put down. I don't know anyone who chose not to.

Ages and stages.