Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that you can have an ‘easier’ baby if you do the right things?

237 replies

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 09:05

I know that some babies quite literally scream and scream. Some have reflux etc and there are reasons why they are harder to look after.

But AIBU to think some people just don’t do what works? I have a close friend who won’t allow her baby to cry at all in their cot. I get it, but obviously that means the baby won’t self settle. That’s her choice. By the time the baby was two, they had a sleep consultant as the marriage was almost broken and hey presto, leaving to cry for a minute then going back in - literally - over three nights solved things. This could have been done from day one, not two years later.

Food… my child won’t eat X. If that’s all that’s on offer first thing in the morning when most hungry, then they will eat it. You have to persevere, surely?

My baby won’t be put down… they might not like it but they can be put down? AIBU to think this approach just feeds into the baby feeling a bit out of control as the parent is literally doing what they want even if it’s not best overall?

I am by NO means a perfect parent and I am genuinely interested in what people think to this. But I have noticed that people have different approaches to their babies obviously, and sometimes I do think problems are made by the parents. AIBU?!

OP posts:
EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 14/11/2023 17:28

Thing is at this point, I guess, you usually have no idea if you're child will later be found to be autistic etc.

As a small baby DS slept very well, after the first few weeks he slept without waking from midnight-7am. He was generally an easy, content, baby. He did feed a lot, but he'd lost 12.5% of his birth weight so I wasn't surprised by that.

But from 6 months DS would not settle on his own, tried leaving him in his cot and resettling - he cried and screamed non stop, 3hrs, 4hrs, on it went. Tried to get him to eat a variety of foods, he would starve rather than eat anything he didn't like.

He still can't go to sleep on his own, he still has a limited diet, he's also been diagnosed as autistic. His sensory issues suggest that he didn't like being in his cot as he wasn't being held - he likes clothing etc to be tight.

So I could have done everything "perfectly" and we'd still have had issues. Maybe different issues, but still issues.

QuitChewingMyPlectrum · 14/11/2023 16:52

🙄

ExTheCheater · 14/11/2023 16:41

I was a teen mum with the easiest baby ever. Barely ever cried, always slept through the night from a week old, potty trained like a dream he did not wee himself once, never wet the bed. Such an easy boy. I don't think that was to do with me I think he was just an easy going kid. He's still an easy going teen even though he has autism and adhd.

cardibach · 14/11/2023 16:03

myotherkidisacassowary · 14/11/2023 14:28

She’s talking about what SHE did to make HER babies feel secure, she’s not saying it’s the only way to make a baby feel secure. You’re being needlessly defensive.

I’m not being defensive at all. I have no skin in the game. DD is 27 and perfectly secure and happy.
What I’m doing is calling out the attitude that if you don’t spend 24/7 with your baby you don’t care enough about them/their happiness/their security.

elliejjtiny · 14/11/2023 16:03

Well, my dc have all got special needs so I've no experience of parenting NT children. But dc4 was the only one of mine who slept through the night consistently from 2 months old. Although the paediatrician said I had to wake him up once a night until 6 months to feed him and each feed took 2 hours so I didn't really get more sleep when he was a baby either.

I think a lot of it is down to the personality of the parents. For example one parent might have a baby who sleeps a 5 hour stretch at night and say it's great and they are sleeping through the night while another parent might think it's only sleeping through the night of they sleep for 12 hours. My MIL thinks my dc are incredibly fussy eaters because she expects them to eat any food that's put in front of them. I say they eat well because they eat the main dish which is usually a mild curry, jacket potatoes, roast, pasta bake, spag bol, lasagne etc and then I do at least 3 kinds of veg, usually more, in the steamer and they choose which ones they have and they all eat at least one. Dc2 doesn't like the crispy bit on top of the lasagne, cottage pie etc so I take the top off before I dish his up.

cardibach · 14/11/2023 16:01

TheOutlaws · 14/11/2023 14:41

@cardibach

I meant that I was happy with the level of security I gave them. If it’s more/less than others then that’s not my fault/concern.

DS1 has ASD/ADHD, so it could be that I got it extremely wrong indeed. Now that you know this about my family, does it make you feel better?

Why would it? I’m not the one doing the judging. Which you are still doing in that post - talking about others giving less security

Changednamesforthis22 · 14/11/2023 15:53

If you left a baby to cry in a cot "from day one" there would be a huge risk of SIDS compared to sleep training a toddler. I've never heard of anyone sleep training from day one, and don't think it should be done until baby can have solid food for dinner and roll over both ways by themselves.

DisquietintheRanks · 14/11/2023 15:45

Up to a point, yes. I had a friend who, if her toddler turned down a given food, didn't offer it again. Her child ate chocolate buttons and toast for years. But only up to a point - after that it's temperament and its often easier to work with who you've got than to try and mould them to your will.

Newsenmum · 14/11/2023 15:39

cardibach · 14/11/2023 14:33

Ah yes. You felt comfortable with the security giving.
You don’t see how this suggests anything else would be uncomfortable to a better person?
It’s nasty and a bit passive aggressive.
if you meant it was what you did and it worked for you that’s what you would say. Instead you said it was very hard but gave them security.

Maybe your child felt secure being left. Good for you.

Mine is ND and it wouldn’t work for him, even though some posters like the op would say it was my fault for not letting him cry to himself.

DixonD · 14/11/2023 15:01

Who are you say what’s right? I never left my daughter to settle and she sleeps beautifully. No sleep training required.

MoreThanEnoughSoFar · 14/11/2023 15:00

Oh God. I (thankfully) never met parents like you, but I've run into several dog-owners who think they are geniuses at training dogs because their dogs aren't afraid of fireworks. They are not geniuses. They're just lucky they bought pups who aren't sensitive to sound.

But if your children are 'easy' because they learned the hard way that it's no use calling to Mummy for help, then take a bow. Interesting to see if they'll answer your calls from the old age home when that time comes or they'll, hey presto, ignore you to self-settle there.

TheOutlaws · 14/11/2023 14:43

@cardibach

Additionally, I was recently told by someone that my son’s ADHD was caused by trauma he’d experienced 😢 so you can see why giving my kids some extra reassurance might be important to me.

TheOutlaws · 14/11/2023 14:41

@cardibach

I meant that I was happy with the level of security I gave them. If it’s more/less than others then that’s not my fault/concern.

DS1 has ASD/ADHD, so it could be that I got it extremely wrong indeed. Now that you know this about my family, does it make you feel better?

Excited101 · 14/11/2023 14:33

You’re completely right, but you’ll be slated on here op.

cardibach · 14/11/2023 14:33

Ah yes. You felt comfortable with the security giving.
You don’t see how this suggests anything else would be uncomfortable to a better person?
It’s nasty and a bit passive aggressive.
if you meant it was what you did and it worked for you that’s what you would say. Instead you said it was very hard but gave them security.

MumDadBingoBlueyy · 14/11/2023 14:31

🤣🤣🤣

DD1 was an absolute dream as a baby, DD2 was sent to test everyone’s patience.

Roles have reversed now they are older, but DD2 could not be consoled as a baby, she didn’t sleep -no matter where you put her, and was allergic to just about everything so food was a nightmare.

same parents, same environment, very, very different children!

TheOutlaws · 14/11/2023 14:30

@cardibach

No implication intended, if you read it back, I just said that I did what felt comfortable at the time. I didn’t compare myself to anyone, or my kids to anyone’s.

You can only do what you feel comfortable with. Doing it differently would have felt wrong - for me.

myotherkidisacassowary · 14/11/2023 14:28

cardibach · 14/11/2023 14:27

What a nasty implication. So those of us who didn’t do it like that made our children insecure?
Also nonsense.

She’s talking about what SHE did to make HER babies feel secure, she’s not saying it’s the only way to make a baby feel secure. You’re being needlessly defensive.

cardibach · 14/11/2023 14:27

TheOutlaws · 14/11/2023 09:09

I would never have left my babies to cry. I co-slept, carried them everywhere and met all of their needs. It was hard, but looking after babies is hard. And I’m fairly lazy! Babies haven’t got any control or agency, they rely on you for everything.

They're much older now and I’m glad I helped them to feel secure, I think it worked well for them.

Edited

What a nasty implication. So those of us who didn’t do it like that made our children insecure?
Also nonsense.

riotlady · 14/11/2023 14:23

Nah, like many others have said my two are completely different and it is nothing to do with my parenting. DD wouldn’t settle if she was left to cry- she would scream until she was purple and forget to breathe. Wanted to be on someone 24/7. Took ages to settle for sleep. DS you literally just pop him in a cot, he’ll look around for a bit then drift off to sleep. Couldn’t believe it! He doesn’t cry unless he’s hungry or in pain, he’s the most chilled out baby.

Mountainhowl · 14/11/2023 13:08

Beyond basic safety things there is no right or wrong way to do things IMO.

I breastfed to sleep and co-slept with both my babies from day one, they contact napped and have never spent a full night in a cot or been left to cry it out. My youngest is 3 and still bed shares with me (more for logistics currently). By OPs logic I should have 2 awful sleepers who will only settle themselves if left to scream for nights on end. Yet my eldest went into his own room around 4 (now 10) and has not once gotten out of bed to mess around, he goes to sleep alone without a fuss. My youngest has slept in a different bed to me 5 times in his entire life (when we went on holiday and he had a shared room with his brother), guess what, not a single issue. Both go to bed with no fuss, tears or messing around and both are asleep quickly and sleep through.

We also have zero bedtime routine, they can go from running around like loons or gaming to bed in minutes without issue, they just go to bed and drop. Bedtime has never been a source of stress or upset for them and they're quite happy to go.

Its not for every family, but it works for ours. Same with food, we never force them to eat something they clearly don't like, yet they eat a fairly decent variety with a few dislikes like most kids. They will eat things that aren't their favourites (not without a moan mind you), but we don't make them eat things they actively dislike (my parents did this and I remember nights spent at the table trying to force food down that was making me gag, and suprise suprise, I'm an incredibly fussy eater as an adult)

MegaBlox6 · 14/11/2023 12:56

It's not straightforward though is it? I never left my baby to cry and he can self settle no problem at 16 months. Goes in his cot awake and takes himself off to sleep. Other people achieve the same effect leaving their babies to cry it out. I didn't want to so I didn't, but it is wrong to suggest that not leaving them to cry = a child who can't self settle. I think people take too much credit for themselves if their baby has an easy temperament. And "difficult" babies aren't necessarily the way they are because parents are doing anything wrong- or whatever you consider to be wrong. "What works" isn't the same for every child because funnily enough they're all individuals. Why would I have wanted to let my baby cry "from day one"? Why?

Lelophants · 14/11/2023 12:31

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/11/2023 12:21

I was the type of parent that you're talking about, OP. Didn't leave dd to cry, responded to her every need, ended up co-sleeping etc. I have no regrets about that whatsoever, and would do things in exactly the same way if I had my time again.

Yes, perhaps it made my life marginally harder in the short term, but for me, it was a question about the type of parent that I wanted to be. I wasn't seeking the easiest option, I was seeking to parent in line with my values and the kind of early childhood experiences that I wanted for my dd.

Fast forward a few years, and my dd is a young adult. She is exceptionally confident, resilient, and has great self esteem. She is also very kind, empathetic and emotionally intelligent. We have a very close relationship. Would she have turned out the same if if her needs hadn't been met effectively as a baby? We will never know, but personally, I will always be glad that we didn't take that risk. A lot of the very smug parents that I knew when dd was younger are not quite so smug any more.

And this is it. The guilt I would have for letting my kid scream themselves into exhaustion was much worse than sleep deprivation for me. It’s like how I could never smack my kid. That’s my values and how I work and from what I’ve studied. It might be different if I genuinely thought it wasn’t harmful, but I do. I don’t regret what I’ve done.

Lelophants · 14/11/2023 12:29

There is now countless research saying letting babies vomit is detrimental. Even the Ferber method states that if you baby is that distressed then you need to abandon it. Of course, parents will do what they can cope with.

Stop shaming parents op.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/11/2023 12:21

I was the type of parent that you're talking about, OP. Didn't leave dd to cry, responded to her every need, ended up co-sleeping etc. I have no regrets about that whatsoever, and would do things in exactly the same way if I had my time again.

Yes, perhaps it made my life marginally harder in the short term, but for me, it was a question about the type of parent that I wanted to be. I wasn't seeking the easiest option, I was seeking to parent in line with my values and the kind of early childhood experiences that I wanted for my dd.

Fast forward a few years, and my dd is a young adult. She is exceptionally confident, resilient, and has great self esteem. She is also very kind, empathetic and emotionally intelligent. We have a very close relationship. Would she have turned out the same if if her needs hadn't been met effectively as a baby? We will never know, but personally, I will always be glad that we didn't take that risk. A lot of the very smug parents that I knew when dd was younger are not quite so smug any more.