Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that you can have an ‘easier’ baby if you do the right things?

237 replies

isthisunfairth · 14/11/2023 09:05

I know that some babies quite literally scream and scream. Some have reflux etc and there are reasons why they are harder to look after.

But AIBU to think some people just don’t do what works? I have a close friend who won’t allow her baby to cry at all in their cot. I get it, but obviously that means the baby won’t self settle. That’s her choice. By the time the baby was two, they had a sleep consultant as the marriage was almost broken and hey presto, leaving to cry for a minute then going back in - literally - over three nights solved things. This could have been done from day one, not two years later.

Food… my child won’t eat X. If that’s all that’s on offer first thing in the morning when most hungry, then they will eat it. You have to persevere, surely?

My baby won’t be put down… they might not like it but they can be put down? AIBU to think this approach just feeds into the baby feeling a bit out of control as the parent is literally doing what they want even if it’s not best overall?

I am by NO means a perfect parent and I am genuinely interested in what people think to this. But I have noticed that people have different approaches to their babies obviously, and sometimes I do think problems are made by the parents. AIBU?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Saracen · 15/11/2023 11:36

I don't know many people who've had several "easy" babies or several "difficult" babies - siblings vary quite a lot. That suggests that parental behaviour isn't the major determining factor in most cases.

Fizbosshoes · 15/11/2023 08:59

When DD was a few weeks old PIL came round.
DD wanted to be held/carried all the time and cried when we put her in the pram or laid he down.
MIL insisted we were making a rod for our own back (she had 4 children and 7 GC) and took DD. She put her in the pram, DD of course screamed, then MIL spoke very sternly and said "that's enough now, quiet now" . I was amazed as a new mum - was it really that easy...? DD stopped crying - for about a nano second - and then resumed screaming! MIL was seemed quite surprised!
She either had forgotten what newborns were like or had more placid babies (or left them to cry)
My parents were amazed at how content my DC were when they were babies - they said they only remembered screaming when me and siblings were babies. They were advised to feed every 4 hours so feeding on demand was new to them.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 15/11/2023 08:31

Newsenmum · 14/11/2023 18:02

Me too and everyone even the kindest friends told me I needed to sleep train. I felt like a failure, cried so much. But I listened to my gut and my child is autistic. Imagine how bad I’d have felt if I’d let him cry!!!

I had a lot of 'you have to nip this in the bud, don't let it become a habit' type comments.

Generally I took the view that it wouldn't last forever. He started sleeping in his own room at 9, though he still needs me with him to go to sleep, but now he's taking melatonin that takes nowhere near as long.

Sceptre86 · 15/11/2023 08:09

I think you do whatever you need to survive. With my eldest I could cater wholly to her needs as she was my first, when her brother unexpectedly came along things changed. I needed him to sleep so did whatever I could to get him down for a nap so I could sort out my eldest. Rocking him worked for me when he was little but it became a habit and was very hard to break. He had colic for the first few months and that was hard with 2 under 2.

My third child eats well and has slept through from 3 months. This time I have been more consistent in putting her down for all naps in her next to me crib. Instead of rocking her to sleep I put her down drowsy as I had to sort out one of my other kids, came back and she was asleep this scenario happened again and then i just started to do this. If she cried I would go to her and comfort her but she just didn't. She did have reflux and that was upsetting and a difficult time but I just took it on my stride as had other kids to deal with. Dirty clothes got soaked in a tub and then stuck in the washing machine when she napped. We play together lots but equally I have a house to clean and meals to cook so she gets set up with her toys whilst I do that. Her eating well is down to her. The only thing I did was allow her anything she wanted off my plate when she was 6 months, she seems to eat a variety of things compared to her siblings at this age. Doesn't mean she won't grow up to be fussy but at 2 she is doing well. She feeds herself but she took well to this whereas dc1 had gross and fine motor issues so it took her much longer.

Dc3 is a relaxed baby but dh and I were more chilled parents this time around and took things in out stride. I've finally gotten over having showhouse standards and would sit and smother her in kisses when she was a baby instead and just soak up her cuddles. I don't know if this has contributed to her being the way she is or vice versa.

All kids are different, instead of judgement maybe it's better to appreciate others are just doing what they need to to get through the day.

Tumbleweed101 · 15/11/2023 07:50

I had four easy babies. My first was hardest as I was on a steep learning curve but I read a brilliant sleep book just off a magazine when I was pregnant with my second which talked about core nights and core sleep times that helped me identify when it would be easiest to put my baby down so they were ready to self settle. It worked amazingly for mine.

I now work in a nursery and I have seen so many difficult children. Some of which can be helped by parents making changes but quite often it is just the child’s personality.

Tree12 · 15/11/2023 07:42

So leaving your baby to cry is the ‘right’ thing? OK then.

BertieBotts · 15/11/2023 07:40

Yes exactly. And it is important to understand the distinction.

There is so much stigma about neurodevelopmental conditions like ADHD and I don't really understand why - if there can be disorders in other organs then why not the brain? But people are determined to explain it away or make out that it's not real, just an excuse etc and I find that very frustrating.

Trauma exists and ADHD exists and they can co-exist together, but they are different things with different causes and effects.

RecoveringBorderline · 15/11/2023 01:56

@BertieBottsspot on analysis there. I think being misunderstood due to having a disability which causes your parents, teachers or peers to bully/misunderstand/reject you as a child due to having ADHD or autism would definitely cause a secondary CPTSD to develop, it's that way round.

BertieBotts · 14/11/2023 23:02

Yes the definition of trauma is dismissive, he is retired and wasn't a trauma specialist anyway so his understanding of current trauma research is probably out of date.

However it's still true that Gabor Maté's claims about the causes of ADHD have been disproven many times. It is genetic, not caused, except for some cases associated with birth hypoxia and brain injury (which are not necessarily related to emotional trauma).

It's true that there is a large correlation between having ADHD and experiencing childhood ACEs and trauma. In fact, having ADHD is highly predictive of traumatic experiences, but the causation is the other way around - as explained in the video, children's behaviour with ADHD tends to cause parents to react in unhelpful ways, this might make the behaviour worse, but it's not causing the ADHD, because the ADHD was already present. Also, many children with ADHD have parents with ADHD and yes, you're absolutely right, statistically adults with ADHD are more likely to struggle with things that tend to be crucial in parenting (which doesn't mean that all parents with ADHD are bad or that parents with ADHD can't be good parents). So again yes you will quite commonly find that people with ADHD have traumatic memories of childhood or difficult relationships with their parents. By the way, there are other experts who recognise this distinction and recognise that people with ADHD, especially undiagnosed/untreated until adulthood are likely to be carrying unresolved trauma which it would help to address. But they aren't saying this is the sole cause of ADHD, nor that if you address the trauma the ADHD will magically go away (which is what Dr. Maté claims).

Some of the symptoms of ADHD and some of the symptoms of PTSD and c-PTSD overlap, so it's quite possible that there are people who have been misdiagnosed and told "You have ADHD" when they are actually suffering from the after effects of trauma. But that is not ADHD caused by trauma, that's just misdiagnosis. If Gabor Maté was saying this then I'd be totally behind him, but he's not saying this at all, he makes the same claim about various mental health disorders, that the root cause is trauma, when this is highly unlikely to be the case.

RecoveringBorderline · 14/11/2023 22:15

BertieBotts · 14/11/2023 17:34

This is a harmful theory and it is not true. You didn't cause your son's ADHD.

Useful video on the topic that came out today:

I'm not saying ADHD is caused by trauma, I'm sure it's more complicated than that and there may be genetic factors.

I couldn't finish the video though because the guy 's definition of trauma is way off. Gabor Mate may indeed be wrong about the causes of ADHD but he does a lot to work with trauma and there's no way he would define it by anything than the correct clinical criteria. Also the video guy is missing the point; experiencing or witnessing violence in childhood certainly is a major cause of trauma but so is ongoing verbal or emotional abuse or neglect, sometimes it's subtle. But no way is it just a one time insult and saying so is very belittling of those of us who did experience actual CPTSD from childhood abuse. There is a huge spectrum of complex trauma and it isn't always physical violence. I

Although I'm pretty sure the posters on here with ADHD are likely to be loving parents who aren't abusive in the slightest, it has to be said that if they were toxic it is pretty common for abusive parents not to see what they are doing as abuse especially if it isn't something one beating or starving the child. My physically verbally and sometimes even sexually abusive father would have said I had a wonderful childhood with no actual trauma. As a matter of fact I was terrified of him and attempted suicide to escape him as a teenager. More than once.

Lelophants · 14/11/2023 21:43

myotherkidisacassowary · 14/11/2023 21:41

What research has tended to show is that some babies are inherently capable of ‘self soothing’ behaviours (thumb sucking / rocking / drifting off) which mean they can happily be left to fall asleep without support.

Other babies don’t have this personality trait and need supported to sleep.

What you can’t do is teach a baby who isn’t inherently capable of drifting off without support to do so by leaving them alone when they express distress. Ignoring their distress doesn’t magically turn them into the type of baby who can sleep without support. It just teaches them that expressions of distress don’t work.

For babies who are happy to be left alone to fall asleep there is, of course, no harm in doing so. For babies who find this distressing, not responding to their distress doesn’t make it magically vanish.

I agree with this.

myotherkidisacassowary · 14/11/2023 21:41

JudgeJ · 14/11/2023 20:59

Babies aren’t developmentally capable of self settling.

And you accuse others of bollocks! This sentence implies that no baby has ever 'self settled', by which jargon I assume you mean 'gone to sleep'.

What research has tended to show is that some babies are inherently capable of ‘self soothing’ behaviours (thumb sucking / rocking / drifting off) which mean they can happily be left to fall asleep without support.

Other babies don’t have this personality trait and need supported to sleep.

What you can’t do is teach a baby who isn’t inherently capable of drifting off without support to do so by leaving them alone when they express distress. Ignoring their distress doesn’t magically turn them into the type of baby who can sleep without support. It just teaches them that expressions of distress don’t work.

For babies who are happy to be left alone to fall asleep there is, of course, no harm in doing so. For babies who find this distressing, not responding to their distress doesn’t make it magically vanish.

Newsenmum · 14/11/2023 21:40

lifehappens12 · 14/11/2023 21:11

I must try your approach with my autistic son who would literally rather starve than eat food we can't cope with.

Me too 😂

lifehappens12 · 14/11/2023 21:11

I must try your approach with my autistic son who would literally rather starve than eat food we can't cope with.

JudgeJ · 14/11/2023 20:59

Babies aren’t developmentally capable of self settling.

And you accuse others of bollocks! This sentence implies that no baby has ever 'self settled', by which jargon I assume you mean 'gone to sleep'.

Fizbosshoes · 14/11/2023 20:53

Bluedabadeeba · 14/11/2023 19:00

This is hilarious. With 2 kids too.

Self-soothing/settling is a myth invented by a MADE UP industry, scamming thousands or desperate, vulnerable parents out of their hard earned cash every year. What actually happens, is the child gives up on anyone coming to support them when they are asking for it. Anyone who I know who 'sleep trained' (in fact, MOST people I know with kids did this), had it 'work' initially but then had to continue to redo the 'training' for the foreseeable future.

I would not leave an adult stranger to cry alone in a dark room (unless they clearly asked for that), much less a friend, so I have no idea why parents have such little empathy for infants/toddlers who cannot communicate how distressing they find it. I understand sleep deprivation, been there (still there!!), but that's an obvious part of parenting before you have kids, surely!!

And no, I do not share this opinion with anyone IRL, unless specifically asked, but seeing as this is such a laughable / judgy thread, I thought I'd share.

A friend told me that she "wouldn't put up with " DD coming into our room at night (DD was about 4 at the time) and should leave her to cry.
A few years later same friend got a puppy. Someone asked if she was crate training it and she said she planned to, but couldn't bear to hear it whimpering/crying and being left alone (sorry I don't know what unhappy dog noises are called) ...so took into her bedroom to sleep. I reminded her of our previous conversation.. . That funnily enough I didn't like to listen to my toddler/child being distressed on their own!

Bluedabadeeba · 14/11/2023 19:01

Mamato29192 · 14/11/2023 19:00

A baby can learn to self settle. And isn't left to cry

This is an entirely different case. If the baby is quite content, then wonderful!!

Bluedabadeeba · 14/11/2023 19:00

This is hilarious. With 2 kids too.

Self-soothing/settling is a myth invented by a MADE UP industry, scamming thousands or desperate, vulnerable parents out of their hard earned cash every year. What actually happens, is the child gives up on anyone coming to support them when they are asking for it. Anyone who I know who 'sleep trained' (in fact, MOST people I know with kids did this), had it 'work' initially but then had to continue to redo the 'training' for the foreseeable future.

I would not leave an adult stranger to cry alone in a dark room (unless they clearly asked for that), much less a friend, so I have no idea why parents have such little empathy for infants/toddlers who cannot communicate how distressing they find it. I understand sleep deprivation, been there (still there!!), but that's an obvious part of parenting before you have kids, surely!!

And no, I do not share this opinion with anyone IRL, unless specifically asked, but seeing as this is such a laughable / judgy thread, I thought I'd share.

Mamato29192 · 14/11/2023 19:00

SandandSky · 14/11/2023 18:46

A baby doesn’t learn to settle themself, they just learn to stop crying because they learn no one will come.

fuck that

A baby can learn to self settle. And isn't left to cry

SandandSky · 14/11/2023 18:46

A baby doesn’t learn to settle themself, they just learn to stop crying because they learn no one will come.

fuck that

TheOutlaws · 14/11/2023 18:33

@BertieBotts

Thank you for posting the video, I’ll watch it in full when I get a minute later. I’m really grateful. Your advice is always very sage!

myotherkidisacassowary · 14/11/2023 18:27

cardibach · 14/11/2023 16:03

I’m not being defensive at all. I have no skin in the game. DD is 27 and perfectly secure and happy.
What I’m doing is calling out the attitude that if you don’t spend 24/7 with your baby you don’t care enough about them/their happiness/their security.

Which is not what that poster said at all, so you’re effectively just arguing with yourself 🤷‍♀️

RecoveringBorderline · 14/11/2023 18:19

karmakameleon · 14/11/2023 09:12

How do you explain it when one child in a family is a dream and the other is a nightmare?

Temperament maybe. Or different life circumstances, maybe additional stressors affecting the baby? The same parenting method might work well for one child's temperamemt or circumstances at the time but not for others.

According to our own parents my sister was born when my father worked abroad and they did a lot of travelling. My sister learned to adapt to not having the same routine every day and was an easier going baby. My father's work ended when my mother was pregnant with me two years later and they came back to England where I was born. Their new lifestyle and also the health visitors advice about needing to have a set routine for babies meant my babyhood was a little more regimented, parents were very stressed, and miserable about being back in England and apparently if my meals were late or I didn't get to sleep in time I screamed the place down. Though I do tend towards being quite rigid and do struggle with OCD tendancies (diagnosed) so I expect temperament a huge factor also. This was the early 80s and I think things are different now.

Newsenmum · 14/11/2023 18:02

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 14/11/2023 17:28

Thing is at this point, I guess, you usually have no idea if you're child will later be found to be autistic etc.

As a small baby DS slept very well, after the first few weeks he slept without waking from midnight-7am. He was generally an easy, content, baby. He did feed a lot, but he'd lost 12.5% of his birth weight so I wasn't surprised by that.

But from 6 months DS would not settle on his own, tried leaving him in his cot and resettling - he cried and screamed non stop, 3hrs, 4hrs, on it went. Tried to get him to eat a variety of foods, he would starve rather than eat anything he didn't like.

He still can't go to sleep on his own, he still has a limited diet, he's also been diagnosed as autistic. His sensory issues suggest that he didn't like being in his cot as he wasn't being held - he likes clothing etc to be tight.

So I could have done everything "perfectly" and we'd still have had issues. Maybe different issues, but still issues.

Me too and everyone even the kindest friends told me I needed to sleep train. I felt like a failure, cried so much. But I listened to my gut and my child is autistic. Imagine how bad I’d have felt if I’d let him cry!!!

BertieBotts · 14/11/2023 17:34

TheOutlaws · 14/11/2023 14:43

@cardibach

Additionally, I was recently told by someone that my son’s ADHD was caused by trauma he’d experienced 😢 so you can see why giving my kids some extra reassurance might be important to me.

This is a harmful theory and it is not true. You didn't cause your son's ADHD.

Useful video on the topic that came out today:

Why Dr Gabor Mate' is Worse Than Wrong About ADHD

Gabor Mate’, MD has proposed that ADHD is NOT genetic or inherited but arises out of exposure to childhood traumatic events (as well as cross generational tr...

https://youtu.be/bO19LWJ0ZnM?si=UaiFn2bNOX6nKECi

Swipe left for the next trending thread