Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think society hates children?

434 replies

Orangeandgold · 14/11/2023 08:51

During a crisis people tend to defend children and babies, but on a day to day basis when everything is “normal” I usually find and feel so much hatred towards children.

My DD picked this up quite young too. It is small subtle everyday conversations and actions.

I would have to remind an adult not to barge past a 5 year old when there is enough space on the pavement; or people that feel that they can comment or roll their eyes at you and be malicious because you have a buggy; or general comments in conversations about “all kids are brats/ those children/why would anyone have them.”; animals are so much more loving than children …

… and the comments go on!

If you don’t want children you don’t have to have them, but we were all kids once. AIBU to feel that society in general hates children and to get upset about it every now and then? Or am I just in a pessimistic bubble? Maybe it’s also the city, people have less tolerance? I just feel nobody really looks out for each other the way we would growing up - I would have neighbours on the look out as a child but now it’s different.

OP posts:
PostItInABook · 14/11/2023 13:04

I don’t have children of my own.
I don’t hate children at all.
I deal with sick and injured children in my job on occasions.
I would do, and have done things to help a child in need whether I know them or not, and whether I’m at work or not.
I dislike parents who raise their children to be spoilt, entitled, selfish, bratty little shits.
I don’t hate badly behaved children because it’s not their fault. It’s their selfish, shitty, inept parents that I hate, but I can’t always help showing irritation unfortunately.
I think society is set up for and geared entirely towards children and families.

Roundandroundandroundsound · 14/11/2023 13:03

@ParsnipSurprise88 exactly. All the miserable bastards claiming that their taxes pay for other people's children's (underfunded) education should appreciate knowing that the better educated today's kids are, the better paid jobs and therefore more tax they'll one day pay, to help cover your pensions.
Even if they do dare to make noise in public.

tablevan · 14/11/2023 13:02

But you know what, me and just about every other working parent out there also pays “huge amounts of tax for my DC’s education and healthcare (what healthcare - a few vaccines?! That’s the only healthcare my D.C. have ever had to date)” why do you think you are unique in doing this? And previous generations including those without children also paid tax and NI to pay for your education and healthcare. My children will pay tax and NI to pay your state pension and healthcare - it’s called the social contract and it’s a feature of a healthy society. I am a higher rate tax payer - I don’t claim child benefit because I earn too much, I frequently pay tax towards things that do not directly benefit me or that I actually use - like the armed forces, the judiciary, the prisons and probation service, the environment agency, flood defences, ambulance and the fire brigade. I don’t resent doing so and even if I did I don’t have a choice in paying towards any of these things. None of us does. And I have no possible way of identifying where or how my tax and NI is spent as opposed to other people’s.

I really really resent people who weaponise this line about paying taxes for my D.C. Its inaccurate and untrue and it really feeds into this attitude of selfishness and individualism I mentioned - “I pay for your DC” - no you don’t. You don’t pay anything towards the cost of caring for or providing for my children or anyone else’s so please stop with the entitlement.

👏

Well said !!

What a ridiculous thing to say ' I pay for your DC '. Absolutely ridiculous.

ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 12:54

FarEast · 14/11/2023 12:46

Indeed.

And you know, most young children bounce. The elderly do not. There are very good reasons for some elderly people to be very wary of children in public.

I remember one of the first threads I read here on MN - about a decade ago- was about the appallingly huge consequences of a child on a scooter flying along the pavement and knocking an elderly woman over. She ended up in a care home permanently whereas she had previously been independent.

And the responses on the thread were mostly that the child couldn’t help it and the “old woman” should have looked where she was walking. I couldn’t believe how shockingly heartless some of those poster were. And supposedly having DC makes you more aware of the world in a special way - “As a mother …”

Nice judgement of mothers there. Is it only the mother who should be more aware of the world in a special way or does this apply to fathers too? Echoing a previous poster who said it’s always a mother’s place to be in the wrong.

ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 12:47

FarEast · 14/11/2023 12:34

Other people don’t like bad parenting in public.

But “hate”? That’s your projection.

I pay huge amounts of tax for your DC’s education and healthcare, and I’m happy to do so - that’s not hate. But please stop your children and your buggy to take up all the space in the disabled spots on public transport; make sure their Peppa Pig is not watched at volume in public without headphones; if they’re tantrumming and screaming take them out of the cafe; and stop your 5 year old scooting out of control on the pavement .

It’s pretty simple give and take @Orangeandgold

But I suspect you just want to be goady.

But you know what, me and just about every other working parent out there also pays “huge amounts of tax for my DC’s education and healthcare (what healthcare - a few vaccines?! That’s the only healthcare my D.C. have ever had to date)” why do you think you are unique in doing this? And previous generations including those without children also paid tax and NI to pay for your education and healthcare. My children will pay tax and NI to pay your state pension and healthcare - it’s called the social contract and it’s a feature of a healthy society. I am a higher rate tax payer - I don’t claim child benefit because I earn too much, I frequently pay tax towards things that do not directly benefit me or that I actually use - like the armed forces, the judiciary, the prisons and probation service, the environment agency, flood defences, ambulance and the fire brigade. I don’t resent doing so and even if I did I don’t have a choice in paying towards any of these things. None of us does. And I have no possible way of identifying where or how my tax and NI is spent as opposed to other people’s.

I really really resent people who weaponise this line about paying taxes for my D.C. Its inaccurate and untrue and it really feeds into this attitude of selfishness and individualism I mentioned - “I pay for your DC” - no you don’t. You don’t pay anything towards the cost of caring for or providing for my children or anyone else’s so please stop with the entitlement.

FarEast · 14/11/2023 12:46

SapphOhNo · 14/11/2023 09:22

I think it's the polar opposite: The older you get, the less society cares about you.

Indeed.

And you know, most young children bounce. The elderly do not. There are very good reasons for some elderly people to be very wary of children in public.

I remember one of the first threads I read here on MN - about a decade ago- was about the appallingly huge consequences of a child on a scooter flying along the pavement and knocking an elderly woman over. She ended up in a care home permanently whereas she had previously been independent.

And the responses on the thread were mostly that the child couldn’t help it and the “old woman” should have looked where she was walking. I couldn’t believe how shockingly heartless some of those poster were. And supposedly having DC makes you more aware of the world in a special way - “As a mother …”

feellikeanalien · 14/11/2023 12:35

Is it considered wrong now to talk to your baby or toddler?

I had DD quite late and didn't really read up on parenting theories but I thought it was just part of normal child development and bonding to talk to and interact with your kids. Isn't that how they learn about the world and how to relate to other people?

People complain about too much screen time but now we're not supposed to talk to our children either?

No wonder parents get stressed.

One of the benefits of being an older mother is that I have got to the stage where I no longer care much what judgement others might pass on me. Although teenage DD does think I talk too much.😀

FarEast · 14/11/2023 12:34

Other people don’t like bad parenting in public.

But “hate”? That’s your projection.

I pay huge amounts of tax for your DC’s education and healthcare, and I’m happy to do so - that’s not hate. But please stop your children and your buggy to take up all the space in the disabled spots on public transport; make sure their Peppa Pig is not watched at volume in public without headphones; if they’re tantrumming and screaming take them out of the cafe; and stop your 5 year old scooting out of control on the pavement .

It’s pretty simple give and take @Orangeandgold

But I suspect you just want to be goady.

ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 12:31

TempsPerdu · 14/11/2023 12:12

I largely agree@ParsnipSurprise88

I do think that we need to consider the fact that none of these attitudes and experiences around childhood and parenting are happening in a vacuum. We need to look at it against the wider context of government policy and demographics.

When most of my friends were having their DC it was against a backdrop of Surestart centres, Child Trust Funds, lower university tuition fees, better funded schools - and, very broadly, optimism for the future. The U.K. felt younger - dynamic and forward thinking.

By the time DP and I belatedly got round to having DD, it was during a time of austerity, crumbling schools, increased tuition fees and every man (or, more accurately, woman) for himself in terms of the baby/preschool years. The media was/is filled with stories about triple lock pensions, the housing crisis, climate change and our ageing population. It doesn’t really feel as if we, as a country, want more children - they’re seen as an expensive burden or a luxury choice rather than a positive, energising life force for our society.

Absolutely agree with what you have written. The UK feels like a very old, stagnant, declining country right now.

ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 12:29

erikbloodaxe · 14/11/2023 12:17

Society dislikes poor parenting which produces poorly behaved children.

But what is “poor parenting”? You see from the range of responses on here that it encompasses everything from giving your child an iPad, to interacting with them, to refusing to impose absolute silence and stillness on them, some of which is just totally ridiculous and unrealistic. I think the attitude of what constitutes “poor parenting” has become much stricter in the UK.

I remember growing up in the 80s and being allowed to run wild, play in the street, call for my friends at their houses unannounced & chat to my parents when out at dinner - we weren’t so tightly controlled or had this huge set of expectations imposed on us in the way that happens now. I am sceptical about a lot of what is now described as “poor parenting”. It also used to be the case that children were frequently hit growing up to impose discipline on them (DH was smacked every day by his mother - she wanted little soldiers who would loyally obey her every command). I am glad that we have mostly moved away from that model of parenting and if that makes my parenting “poor” then so be it.

Mooshamoo · 14/11/2023 12:27

I agree. We live in a culture where the strong bully the weak.

Children, women and elderly are constantly abused.

I have worked as a teacher. I have seen abuse towards children in a lot of schools.

Some adults abuse children because they can. The adult is bigger and more powerful.

I remember working in a very posh private school, where the parents were paying huge money for their children to go there.

I thought "if the parents knew what went on here they would be shocked".

It's everywhere. Children are abused.

I just read Paris Hilton's book. Her family are multi millionaires. They paid huge money for Paris to go to a therepuetic boarding school when she was a teen.

Paris has since said that huge, massive abuse went on in that school. That she was locked in solitary confinement. That male staff watched her have showers.

It's so bad

tablevan · 14/11/2023 12:25

A lot of posters here have written that they don't hate children, but they dislike loud children who don't sit quietly.

The thing is, children find it hard do be perfectly behaved at all times. They're children and they're learning.

As long as the parents are trying to teach them good manners and removing them from situations if the child / parents are overwhelmed by the situation, I don't think there is a problem.

But to expect children to behave perfectly is unreasonable. The parents need to try to teach / distract / find ways to show their children how to safely behave in public- but you kind of need to be in public to teach and show them that I think.

As the mother of two children under 4 years old, I think society can be pretty judgy if your children are having meltdowns in public. I won't stop taking my kids to restaurants, cafes and shopping though. They're learning and getting better each day. So am I.

My overall experience has been positive though. Just yesterday I was in a shop and my DD was crying about something that had happened. The ladies in the shop looked a little bit off to begin with. I then went on to explain why my DD was crying and what had just happened. They were massively sympathetic and had a chat with my DD to explain that they understood why she was sad and distracted her a little bit/ offered her some sweets etc. initially they thought she was just being a brat about something but then they understood her feelings, they were really nice about it.

I think sometimes people judge to
quickly. I think when the public see you're trying your best to educate your child, they get it. People get irritated if the parents don't even bother, I think.

Anycrispsleft · 14/11/2023 12:25

Roundandroundandroundsound · 14/11/2023 09:10

SeulementUneFois · Today 08:58

Shoxfordian · Today 08:54

I don't agree; society doesn't like disruptive noisy children so maybe that's your issue
This OP.

Look at French society - children included but that's because they're brought up to be well behaved.

This old chestnut!!
On holiday in Crete this summer I experienced the worst children's behaviour in a restaurant that I have ever seen. 4 French (speaking) kids, literally running around between the tables, knocking into my own (British) DC's chairs, shrieking and actually climbing onto the sea wall which was next to our table and pushing and shoving each other, so that I had to intervene mid dinner because their parents were ignoring it and I was worried the little one who was about 4 was going to end up falling about 6 foot to the stony beach below. So no I don't believe that French kids are necessarily better behaved than British ones.

It's not just me then! I live on the border to France and whenever we go to the French supermarket you can hardly hear yourself think from all the screaming kids. If someone's not kicking off in the toy aisle are you really even in Leclerq? And the parenting is not better. I saw a man slap a grizzling toddler the last time I was in. And yes I was too cowardly to say anything about it.

ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 12:22

In all honesty those refusing help when out with their kids and struggling are likely to do so because they feel hugely judged that they can’t manage (as seen from the comment) or are seen as imposing or an inconvenience on other people. Not because they don’t need help. It’s arising from the general attitude of “you had kids, you deal with it - not my problem”, which is so harmful.

BlingLoving · 14/11/2023 12:21

HoHoHoliday · 14/11/2023 12:13

"DS1 was crawling, I was there alone with him, trying to hold him, whilst hauling a pushchair off a carousel and erect it. I had to put him down and obviously he started crawling off towards the carousel, cue audible gasps from people but not one of those fuckers offered to help me. I had to ask a young couple near me to help with the pushchair whilst I grabbed him. Lots of judgment but zero support."

But on the flip side of this situation, I have often offered to help a parent, offered to hold the baby, offered to help a child off the bus while the parent has shopping bags, picked something up off the floor that a child has thrown down while the parent has hands full feeding, and so on. Usually I'm met in response with annoyance, snappy parents declaring they don't need help (literally only offered), "do I look like I can't manage" (usually, yes, or I wouldn't have offered).

Yes, this. I was with my brother once on the tube. A woman had a pram with a baby and a toddler. I can't quite remember but I think the toddler sort of made a break for freedom and my brother grabbed him, picked him up and said to the mother - would you like me to put him on the train for you?. She acted like he'd tried to molest/abduct her child.

Similarly, the many people on MN who are outraged if an elderly person touches their child or asks for a cuddle with a baby. I once handed baby DS over to an elderly couple in a cafe (at their request). I was waiting for some other NCT friends to arrive. We were chatting nicely and I asked if I could grab some water and they were happy to keep him. The water fountain was about 3 metres away so not like I was leaving him with strangers out of sight. My 2 NCT friends came in - one was fine and got chatting with the older couple, the other one was horrified I'd let DS be held by strangers.

So many parents are so precious about their children, it makes a lot of other people very unwilling to engage.

Elastica23 · 14/11/2023 12:19

Hardbackwriter · 14/11/2023 12:18

I think I'm ambivalent on whether or not society is unfriendly to children. I AM very certain, though, that society absolutely loves to find an excuse to criticise mothers (not parents - mothers). The two can feel quite hard to distinguish in practice.

Yes, you quickly learn that a mother's place is in the wrong.

Hardbackwriter · 14/11/2023 12:18

I think I'm ambivalent on whether or not society is unfriendly to children. I AM very certain, though, that society absolutely loves to find an excuse to criticise mothers (not parents - mothers). The two can feel quite hard to distinguish in practice.

erikbloodaxe · 14/11/2023 12:17

Society dislikes poor parenting which produces poorly behaved children.

aSofaNearYou · 14/11/2023 12:16

Plenty of adults are loud, slow, angry, distracted etc but we accept that that behaviour is normal. But the same behaviour is to totally unacceptable in children, despite the fact that their brains are not fully developed and mature. Completely unrealistic expectations.

I'm not sure we do accept this behaviour as normal? I think people in general are scared to appear to be judging someone who is disabled in some way but otherwise, when a person is any of those things, they generally get dirty, annoyed looks, much the same as children do.

Peablockfeathers · 14/11/2023 12:15

I don't think people are saying that they expect children to sit in silence though are they? There's a huge gulf between silence and being hugely disruptive to other people. Of course some people are nasty and will make comment on children not doing anything overly disruptive; just as some parents will just let their children do whatever and fuck everyone else. There's a balance like most things in life.

Large swathes of the elderly are treated like shit here too, its ignorant to claim its not the case. Adult social care is woefully lacking, a lot of people have a vile attitude towards them as seen in real life and by posts on here on various topics, not all pensioners are sitting on expensive properties with swathes of savings in the bank (im sure on principle those who moan about this would forego any inheritance they may recieve because of how unfair it all is). I don't think pitting two groups against eachother when most people in this country are being failed is really that productive to be honest. People should take some responsibility when they bring children into the world though as an aside, it's seem as controversial to suggest that nowadays which is ridiculous.

HoHoHoliday · 14/11/2023 12:13

"DS1 was crawling, I was there alone with him, trying to hold him, whilst hauling a pushchair off a carousel and erect it. I had to put him down and obviously he started crawling off towards the carousel, cue audible gasps from people but not one of those fuckers offered to help me. I had to ask a young couple near me to help with the pushchair whilst I grabbed him. Lots of judgment but zero support."

But on the flip side of this situation, I have often offered to help a parent, offered to hold the baby, offered to help a child off the bus while the parent has shopping bags, picked something up off the floor that a child has thrown down while the parent has hands full feeding, and so on. Usually I'm met in response with annoyance, snappy parents declaring they don't need help (literally only offered), "do I look like I can't manage" (usually, yes, or I wouldn't have offered).

TempsPerdu · 14/11/2023 12:12

I largely agree@ParsnipSurprise88

I do think that we need to consider the fact that none of these attitudes and experiences around childhood and parenting are happening in a vacuum. We need to look at it against the wider context of government policy and demographics.

When most of my friends were having their DC it was against a backdrop of Surestart centres, Child Trust Funds, lower university tuition fees, better funded schools - and, very broadly, optimism for the future. The U.K. felt younger - dynamic and forward thinking.

By the time DP and I belatedly got round to having DD, it was during a time of austerity, crumbling schools, increased tuition fees and every man (or, more accurately, woman) for himself in terms of the baby/preschool years. The media was/is filled with stories about triple lock pensions, the housing crisis, climate change and our ageing population. It doesn’t really feel as if we, as a country, want more children - they’re seen as an expensive burden or a luxury choice rather than a positive, energising life force for our society.

ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 12:12

Roundandroundandroundsound · 14/11/2023 12:07

"We have really moved to an older age centric society"
100% agree with this. And the fact that families and kids are pre-judged by a lot of people.
An example is the animosity people get if they dare to board a plane with a baby or young child. I shared before - coming back from NY on a night flight many years ago was a man in his 50s with his elderly mother. The poor woman clearly had dementia. She was shouting, getting out of her seat and even soiled herself and he had to get her to the toilets and clean her up. It was an awful flight for her, and him and everyone around them. But there was no animosity or judgement that I could sense. Everyone seemed to have sympathy for them both. Now imagine how different that would have been if she'd been 2 or 3 years old.
Why do we expect little children to have the cognitive abilities of healthy adults?

Absolutely this. Plenty of adults are loud, slow, angry, distracted etc but we accept that that behaviour is normal. But the same behaviour is to totally unacceptable in children, despite the fact that their brains are not fully developed and mature. Completely unrealistic expectations.

CaptainJackSparrow85 · 14/11/2023 12:12

This hasn’t been my experience at all, although I’m fully prepared to believe it’s variable by area.

I’ve got two young children and I notice a difference in the way I’m treated when I go out with them and without them. When I go out with them, I get a lot more kindness and friendliness than if I’m by myself - people holding doors open, smiling, I’ve even had people let us go in front of them in queues for toilets/to pay for things. And I find people are more likely to strike up conversations.

I remember the first time I went out without a buggy/baby carrier when I went back to work after maternity leave I really noticed it!

I’m not complaining at all, I’m not suggesting people should be ultra-friendly to me when I go out by myself, but my point is just that I don’t feel like I live in a society that hates children.

Roundandroundandroundsound · 14/11/2023 12:07

"We have really moved to an older age centric society"
100% agree with this. And the fact that families and kids are pre-judged by a lot of people.
An example is the animosity people get if they dare to board a plane with a baby or young child. I shared before - coming back from NY on a night flight many years ago was a man in his 50s with his elderly mother. The poor woman clearly had dementia. She was shouting, getting out of her seat and even soiled herself and he had to get her to the toilets and clean her up. It was an awful flight for her, and him and everyone around them. But there was no animosity or judgement that I could sense. Everyone seemed to have sympathy for them both. Now imagine how different that would have been if she'd been 2 or 3 years old.
Why do we expect little children to have the cognitive abilities of healthy adults?

Swipe left for the next trending thread