Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think society hates children?

434 replies

Orangeandgold · 14/11/2023 08:51

During a crisis people tend to defend children and babies, but on a day to day basis when everything is “normal” I usually find and feel so much hatred towards children.

My DD picked this up quite young too. It is small subtle everyday conversations and actions.

I would have to remind an adult not to barge past a 5 year old when there is enough space on the pavement; or people that feel that they can comment or roll their eyes at you and be malicious because you have a buggy; or general comments in conversations about “all kids are brats/ those children/why would anyone have them.”; animals are so much more loving than children …

… and the comments go on!

If you don’t want children you don’t have to have them, but we were all kids once. AIBU to feel that society in general hates children and to get upset about it every now and then? Or am I just in a pessimistic bubble? Maybe it’s also the city, people have less tolerance? I just feel nobody really looks out for each other the way we would growing up - I would have neighbours on the look out as a child but now it’s different.

OP posts:
sollenwir · 15/11/2023 09:23

CaramacFiend · 15/11/2023 09:08

But is losing a year as bad when you have another 70 left to live?

That's a very simplistic view because significant things happen in the earlier years, right through from baby/toddler early socialisation to those starting a new school to those sitting exams, never mind those children who are vulnerable or abused in home environments.

theadultsaretalking · 15/11/2023 09:22

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/11/2023 09:13

Everyone was asked to do that. I didn’t see another human being for months because of the way the bubble system failed people living alone. Others had to stop working but received no sustenance because they weren’t eligible for furlough. Even those who were working as normal had to put their plans for weddings, holidays, trips, fertility treatments, medical treatments, seeing beloved friends and family in far off places - life - on hold.

And it wasn’t to “save the elderly”, so much as to save the NHS. Politicians were happy to let it rip through the population (“let the bodies pile up”) until they realised it would cause the NHS to fail. Clearly we shouldn’t have been in a position where the NHS was that fragile, but that was the rationale for lockdowns and closed schools.

I don’t doubt that kids had it particularly tough due to their age and vulnerability (and kids in deprived households especially). But I strongly dislike this revisionist history that’s so prevalent now, that kids are the only ones who suffered and that they sacrificed their livelihoods for superfluous selfish old people who hate them and would have delighted in putting them in solitary confinement had they only had the chance.

Edited

I am not being a revisionist and not disputing that everyone was affected - the whole thing was a mess.

What I am saying is in response to people who accused parents of expecting others to care about their 'little darlings'. Little darlings took it on the chin massively for the benefit of society.

theadultsaretalking · 15/11/2023 09:16

CaramacFiend · 15/11/2023 09:08

But is losing a year as bad when you have another 70 left to live?

It was not a year, first of all. Second of all, some children have still not caught up on what they missed both developmentally and educationally.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/11/2023 09:13

theadultsaretalking · 15/11/2023 09:04

Interestingly, kids were expected to put their lives on hold during COVID-19 to protect those, who, if tables were reversed, would have happily locked them inside while continuing to live their lives as normal.

If COVID was really bad for the children, I don't think for one second that life would have stopped to the extent that it did.

Everyone was asked to do that. I didn’t see another human being for months because of the way the bubble system failed people living alone. Others had to stop working but received no sustenance because they weren’t eligible for furlough. Even those who were working as normal had to put their plans for weddings, holidays, trips, fertility treatments, medical treatments, seeing beloved friends and family in far off places - life - on hold.

And it wasn’t to “save the elderly”, so much as to save the NHS. Politicians were happy to let it rip through the population (“let the bodies pile up”) until they realised it would cause the NHS to fail. Clearly we shouldn’t have been in a position where the NHS was that fragile, but that was the rationale for lockdowns and closed schools.

I don’t doubt that kids had it particularly tough due to their age and vulnerability (and kids in deprived households especially). But I strongly dislike this revisionist history that’s so prevalent now, that kids are the only ones who suffered and that they sacrificed their livelihoods for superfluous selfish old people who hate them and would have delighted in putting them in solitary confinement had they only had the chance.

jannier · 15/11/2023 09:11

Awittyandclevername · 15/11/2023 06:34

This in a way does prove her point a little. It’s completely developmentally normal for a 5 year old to be ‘disruptive and noisy’ as they do not have the intellectual capacity for impulse control. Obviously there needs to be discipline and boundaries when raising a child.. but I’m not sure what 5 year olds couldnt be described as noisy or disruptive at times. A child like that has likely been made to feel afraid of the parents- short cut parenting that isn’t worried about creating kind, well adjusted adults but more so just obedient little slaves to authority. IMO.

Of course 5 year olds and older have times they are disruptive, noisy or do things that are ill advised that's not an issue the issue is the parents who ignore it or worse say to the public things like what's your problem

Roundandroundandroundsound · 15/11/2023 09:11

CaramacFiend · Today 09:08

theadultsaretalking · Today 09:04

Interestingly, kids were expected to put their lives on hold during COVID-19 to protect those, who, if tables were reversed, would have happily locked them inside while continuing to live their lives as normal.

If COVID was really bad for the children, I don't think for one second that life would have stopped to the extent that it did.
Show quote history
But is losing a year as bad when you have another 70 left to live?
I hope this is a joke! You may as well say - they've lived 80 years. Who cares if they do t have any more

Peablockfeathers · 15/11/2023 09:11

theadultsaretalking · 15/11/2023 09:04

Interestingly, kids were expected to put their lives on hold during COVID-19 to protect those, who, if tables were reversed, would have happily locked them inside while continuing to live their lives as normal.

If COVID was really bad for the children, I don't think for one second that life would have stopped to the extent that it did.

Are you seriously suggesting that if when covid emerged it was noted that it disproportionately affected children that people would have been less bothered? Behave. Tonnes of people had the attitude ah well old people are going to die soon anyway who really cares. Society generally on a population level values children more highly than others when it comes to risk of harm, when children are injured in war for example people are (rightly) horrified, there's nothing to suggest this would be different if a novel virus was wiping children out at a wild rate or hospitalising them. There's also nothing to suggest that the rate of old people thinking screw it I'm doing as I please anyway would be proportionately higher than the rate of those who did just that during covid.

CaramacFiend · 15/11/2023 09:08

theadultsaretalking · 15/11/2023 09:04

Interestingly, kids were expected to put their lives on hold during COVID-19 to protect those, who, if tables were reversed, would have happily locked them inside while continuing to live their lives as normal.

If COVID was really bad for the children, I don't think for one second that life would have stopped to the extent that it did.

But is losing a year as bad when you have another 70 left to live?

warriorofhopelessness · 15/11/2023 09:05

Yippet · 14/11/2023 23:37

Yes I have mobility issues. And a lot of people do. So should they go in to the road too? Why can’t two people pushing buggies hand the common sense to stop and let the other person by? Ah yes it’s entitlement

I walk with a stick and very often people won’t move over for me and it is hard to move sideways or change direction quickly with a stick. Also, you need more space because you have half a width of a person by the side of you. People get very irritated when I tell them I can’t get through. There is a lack of awareness of the difficulties of people using mobility aids in general I find.

theadultsaretalking · 15/11/2023 09:04

Yippet · 15/11/2023 01:30

100% their issue. Just another entitled parent thinking everyone should care about their little centre of the universe.

Interestingly, kids were expected to put their lives on hold during COVID-19 to protect those, who, if tables were reversed, would have happily locked them inside while continuing to live their lives as normal.

If COVID was really bad for the children, I don't think for one second that life would have stopped to the extent that it did.

TheCadoganArms · 15/11/2023 08:54

I noticed the ‘children in the Med countries are better behaved when out in restaurants then their UK counterparts’ trope has been made already. In my opinion though you are comparing apples and pears. Having lived and worked in various Med countries over the years my observations is that their restaurant scene is a lot more geared to outside dining and there is usually somewhere safe nearby for kids to play away from the table. Parents there do not bring screens or drawing pads out with them as usually the kids are excused from the table between courses where they can let off some steam. For all the ‘UK hates kids’ rhetoric it is also noticeable how quick parents in those Med countries are at using smacking as a form of discipline despite it being illegal in some of them.

sollenwir · 15/11/2023 08:47

Samlewis96 · 15/11/2023 08:42

Hmm as the mother of a 19 year old boy I asked him about this He says he's never been given issues by anyone? Mind you he's never been " hanging around " the streets. He used to head for the football patches with his friends or being out doing clubs sports training g etc

You have translating 'hanging out' to 'hanging around the streets'. Why?

sunights · 15/11/2023 08:46

I saw this a lot when DS was a toddler, but only ever when it was just me and DS out together - whenever DP (male, age 50s) was with us - people couldn't be more considerate!

theadultsaretalking · 15/11/2023 08:45

picturethispatsy · 15/11/2023 08:20

That is so sad.

Children in the uk are almost second class citizens not youngsters learning how to be in this world with all the ups and downs that brings. I don’t care what anyone says there is still a ‘children should be seen and not heard’ hangover going on especially amongst the older generations.
There is a word for this ‘adultism’ and I see lots of it in this thread. people saying things like ‘children should be kept under control’ and calling them ‘little darlings’ in a passive aggressive way.

I really hate the 'little darling' descriptor, it just drips with scorn.

Samlewis96 · 15/11/2023 08:42

BoohooWoohoo · 14/11/2023 10:01

I completely disagree.
If your child is a boy then wait until he's a teen and grown adults are suspicious of his presence - especially when he's hanging out with his friends.

Hmm as the mother of a 19 year old boy I asked him about this He says he's never been given issues by anyone? Mind you he's never been " hanging around " the streets. He used to head for the football patches with his friends or being out doing clubs sports training g etc

picturethispatsy · 15/11/2023 08:20

Tryingmybestadhd · 15/11/2023 00:47

I’m assuming you are in the U.K. ? I grew up in another European country and simple things that over there are the norm are not here . A example is to give a public transport seat to a child under 10 . Children are supposed to be protected and are vulnerable so should be seating , over here people are proud to say “ I would never give my seat to a child “ or similar . Other things are people who are pregnant and with. young kids have priority on service like supermarket tills or the bank . We also take kids out for dinner often , I was shocked when I moved to the U.K. at 19 and realised many packed don’t even allow children to have dinner .plenty of other examples , like having to take a child to an hospital or hairdresser is highly acceptable there and not here etc .
I find it very sad .

That is so sad.

Children in the uk are almost second class citizens not youngsters learning how to be in this world with all the ups and downs that brings. I don’t care what anyone says there is still a ‘children should be seen and not heard’ hangover going on especially amongst the older generations.
There is a word for this ‘adultism’ and I see lots of it in this thread. people saying things like ‘children should be kept under control’ and calling them ‘little darlings’ in a passive aggressive way.

ShoesoftheWorld · 15/11/2023 07:58

I didn't feel criticised - I didn't want to come across as a biased Britain-basher with rose-tinted glasses on about everywhere else Grin I think my point was more to do with the fundamental approach to children and what they mean to society that comes across in the ensemble of policy and its effects in this area (iyswim), and IMO the UK does tend, much more than its European neighbours, to 'privatise' the raising of children.

sollenwir · 15/11/2023 07:35

ShoesoftheWorld · 14/11/2023 16:18

In the cities, yes (Berlin especially, it's a nightmare); in other areas, not so much. You might not always get the nursery/kindergarten you want, but generally, you'll get one. The shortage is correct (likewise for school teachers).

Of course it's not a utopia - where is? But nobody is working just to pay nursery fees, and everybody can afford to work. There's a year's parental leave paid by the state, too (more if you share it), at two-thirds of your monthly income before the birth.

Thanks for that.
My question wasn't a leading one, trying to be critical, genuinely just curious.

BubziOwl · 15/11/2023 07:04

ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 12:07

Performance parenting just seems to be another lazy excuse to judge parents for actually talking to their children and responding to them with interest. As opposed to sticking them in front of an IPad which will also be judged as “lazy parenting”. I speak to my children, read to them and actually enjoy interacting with them. If that bothers you then you need to get help with your absolute selfish narcissism whereby you imagine everything is about you and centring your needs. Honestly, grow up, you really are not that important.

Absolutely - a woman's place is in the wrong and all that

SeethroughDress · 15/11/2023 07:02

Yippet · 15/11/2023 01:38

I find this too. When I was a child we were very respectful, didn’t run feral and generally very well behaved. If a child was misbehaving or being unruly another parent would sometimes point out our behaviour and my parents would be thankful for it for being disruptive. No idea where this parent entitlement has came from

What, like when you were a toddler?

Awittyandclevername · 15/11/2023 06:34

This in a way does prove her point a little. It’s completely developmentally normal for a 5 year old to be ‘disruptive and noisy’ as they do not have the intellectual capacity for impulse control. Obviously there needs to be discipline and boundaries when raising a child.. but I’m not sure what 5 year olds couldnt be described as noisy or disruptive at times. A child like that has likely been made to feel afraid of the parents- short cut parenting that isn’t worried about creating kind, well adjusted adults but more so just obedient little slaves to authority. IMO.

Stylishnewmama · 15/11/2023 04:34

I dislike people who give dirty looks to parents of toddlers and babies who are crying or having a tantrum. We were all that age once upon a time! Children under the age of 3 can't always be reasoned with as they don't understand.

I don't like undisciplined entitled children of entitled parents though.

Jimmyneutronsforehead · 15/11/2023 01:41

I haven't seen society in general be intolerant of children in general, but I have seen them first hand be intolerant to SEN children, and just people with disabilities hidden or otherwise.

It's just like anything a disabled child does that's annoying in the same way a NT or able bodied child would do something perceived as annoying is doubly annoying when it comes from a disability, and I've had my fair share of sharp words towards people who have expressed that they're intolerant of it.

Yippet · 15/11/2023 01:38

I find this too. When I was a child we were very respectful, didn’t run feral and generally very well behaved. If a child was misbehaving or being unruly another parent would sometimes point out our behaviour and my parents would be thankful for it for being disruptive. No idea where this parent entitlement has came from

Yippet · 15/11/2023 01:30

100% their issue. Just another entitled parent thinking everyone should care about their little centre of the universe.