Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think society hates children?

434 replies

Orangeandgold · 14/11/2023 08:51

During a crisis people tend to defend children and babies, but on a day to day basis when everything is “normal” I usually find and feel so much hatred towards children.

My DD picked this up quite young too. It is small subtle everyday conversations and actions.

I would have to remind an adult not to barge past a 5 year old when there is enough space on the pavement; or people that feel that they can comment or roll their eyes at you and be malicious because you have a buggy; or general comments in conversations about “all kids are brats/ those children/why would anyone have them.”; animals are so much more loving than children …

… and the comments go on!

If you don’t want children you don’t have to have them, but we were all kids once. AIBU to feel that society in general hates children and to get upset about it every now and then? Or am I just in a pessimistic bubble? Maybe it’s also the city, people have less tolerance? I just feel nobody really looks out for each other the way we would growing up - I would have neighbours on the look out as a child but now it’s different.

OP posts:
TripleDaisySummer · 14/11/2023 11:30

Bumpitybumper · 14/11/2023 10:48

@TripleDaisySummer
*I must admit I was taken aback at the school demands and the educational support need when my DC did fall behind.

The whole You have to parent like you don't work and work like you don't have kids does seem to be an expectation in our society - I don't think house prices and longer commutes help with that but as PP says we aren't only society that has working parents - my DGM both worked full time and DMum worked p/t to be there when we got home having been a latch key kid herself and MIL full time - DH was very much a latch key kid from a very young age. So working mothers aren't new thing even here*
I remember many of my friends being latch key kids too but to be honest, the parents weren't rushing home to help them with their homework or take them to an extra curricular club. There weren't the number of parties there are now and parents weren't expected to facilitate their children's social lives in the same way. My friends' parents would get home, give them some tea and then that would be a job well done. The parents wouldn't log on in the evening and catch up on the work they missed due to cramming in time with their kids after school. It really was a different time!

DH and Mum were when older expected to actually put the tea for everyone on but you are right - they'd be fed and that was it. I also wouldn't be able to leave them as young as they were first left either as it's not acceptable these days.

Even with me homework wasn't set to end of primary - wasn't a lot and could be done and was expect to be done by myself - and I'd be walked down to brownies and back and that was it - swimming was taught in school.

My kids got so much busy homework - started with youngest in preschool- and we were expected to do support at home or let them fall even further behind and I needed to pay for and get them to swimming lessons and then other groups on top.

DS was overwhelmed with GCSE revision last year. I really did think at 15 I wouldn't be involved any more - he asked for support and did well in end and I take opportunity to did teach revision techniques for future-but as IL said if I didn't have those skills, made the time bought the resources he'd have been fucked. Already had to do similar for youngest - bright hardworking but poor school disciple lack of staff and very inexperienced teachers in core subjects aren't helping her.

Housing never been more expensive but now it's often seen as undesirable that kids have to share bedrooms.

So expectations really have grown/exploded.

TempsPerdu · 14/11/2023 11:25

@KimberleyClark Absolutely, that’s what I was getting at - and yet, they still felt the pressure to conform and tick that box (and also to go on and have 2/3 kids whereas DP and I, despite outwardly being more child-centric in our lifestyle, recognised our limits and stuck at one!)

BlingLoving · 14/11/2023 11:22

KimberleyClark · 14/11/2023 11:18

Almost every discussion on WhatsApp groups, at the school gate, on nights out etc revolves around how to carve out as much time as possible without the kids, how the kids are hampering their careers, how they wish they were at Glasto or a gig rather than doing childcare, how boring they find playing with their kids, how much less fun holidays are now etc. Many of the kids are dragged from pillar to post every weekend attending (adult) festivals, visiting old university friends on the other side of the country, going on weekend mini-breaks to Porto or Berlin etc. We’re taking babies, preschoolers and young school-aged children here.

These people probably had kids as a tick box exercise - something they felt they should do rather than something they deeply wanted to do.

I just don't recognise this. The school gate complaining about not having enough adult time is usually because the parents involved haven't had a night out in 2 months and are desperate for a single evening of adult time. Most of the families I know spend weekends being dragged from pillar to post by their children as they shuffle them to activities and parties and playdates.

When a weekend can be carved out for a city break or to visit old uni friends in another part of the country, everyone enjoys it as a way to do something different. My DC love travelling and seeing new places. A weekend away with friends - happens maybe once a year, tops - is usually fun because there are other children and places to explore.

LadyMacB · 14/11/2023 11:20

Completely disagree with the OP. In fact, I think it’s the exact opposite. Society is built around and geared up for families with kids. There are facilities and services everywhere, specifically aimed at families with kids.

Since DD was born I’ve had nothing but positive interactions with strangers about her. I’ve never received any hostility.

I was single and childfree until my late 30s and there was never a point when I thought society favoured me because I didn’t have kids. I’m not saying it was actively against me either, I just never detected or heard anything negative about children.

Milkmani · 14/11/2023 11:20

@Neitheronethingnortheother I agree with you on the unknown adult thing. It’s a major worry of mine and has been my whole life. I went to the same school as Milly Dowler, I was one year below. It’s something that will never leave my mind. After that my mum picked us up everyday day, had to cut her hours at work to fit in the pickup/drop off. She was terrified, as you would be. Great that you live in a village with a nice community, but even if I moved I could never relax to let my children walk home from school.

KimberleyClark · 14/11/2023 11:18

Almost every discussion on WhatsApp groups, at the school gate, on nights out etc revolves around how to carve out as much time as possible without the kids, how the kids are hampering their careers, how they wish they were at Glasto or a gig rather than doing childcare, how boring they find playing with their kids, how much less fun holidays are now etc. Many of the kids are dragged from pillar to post every weekend attending (adult) festivals, visiting old university friends on the other side of the country, going on weekend mini-breaks to Porto or Berlin etc. We’re taking babies, preschoolers and young school-aged children here.

These people probably had kids as a tick box exercise - something they felt they should do rather than something they deeply wanted to do.

Milkmani · 14/11/2023 11:16

My partner is Latvian and noticed very early on that Brits in general don’t seem keen on children unless they are tucked away in their houses. Maybe it’s how busy British life is rather than a slower pace? That children kind of get in the way of all the hustle and bustle? That pushchairs are in the way on overcrowded buses, trains and pavements. I agree that children do seem to be seen as a bit of a nuisance here and even though my son is well behaved I do worry if he gets a bit loud in a cafe or in a shop because I’m worried what people will think - ‘British’ mindset I guess.

Neitheronethingnortheother · 14/11/2023 11:14

I just feel nobody really looks out for each other the way we would growing up - I would have neighbours on the look out as a child but now it’s different.

That's because now people are quick to jump to an assumption of grooming if an unrelated adult pays attention to your child. And if you defend them then you are normalising grooming.

Whilst I understand people wanting to protect their children, and there are predatory adults out there, you cannot simultaneously push everyone out of the village and also complain there is no village when raising a child.

Round by us people do still look out for each others children. But that's possibly because we are literally in a village, a small on, where people tend to know each other fairly well and are therefore more trusting/tolerant of people looking out for their kids.

justaboutdonenow · 14/11/2023 11:12

I don't see it, if anything it's the exact opposite.

Hate is a very strong word, but I do think the last few decades have gone too far pushing against the admittedly dreadful Victorianesque values like 'children should be seen & not heard' or 'spare the rod & spoil the child'.

Now there's a widespread acceptance of any & all sorts of unpleasant behaviours, especially amongst lazier or more entitled parents, or those that just don't set boundaries.

And of course other people aren't allowed to comment on their little poppets for fear of getting a mouthful of abuse or even violence, so instead they just quietly seethe to themselves.

I bet they're going to be insufferable as adults, but it's the parents who are the assholes.

Neriah · 14/11/2023 11:11

I dislike badly behaved / entitled children. I dislike badly behaved / entitled adults. Oddly, the two things often come in matching pairs.

Goldbar · 14/11/2023 11:02

BlinkinKnackered · 14/11/2023 10:56

Not all heroes wear capes 🙏🏽I wish more people were like you.

😂. It is the one thing that really gets my goat! Large groups sauntering along, and you're forced to step out into the road to pass them to continue going at a decent pace.

I am told by my husband that I am a slow walker so on that evidence I don't think it's me (accompanied by two young children) being too impatient and wanting to get places super-quickly!

RaininSummer · 14/11/2023 10:58

I really like nice polite children but can't stand ones who run me over on bikes and scooters on the pavement or run around screaming in shops and offices. It's no doubt their parents to blame however.

TempsPerdu · 14/11/2023 10:57

@Bumpitybumper Absolutely what I’ve noticed re PT and FT working too. We had DD relatively late and most of my friends from school/university had their DC 10-15 years before us. The difference between their working landscape and that of my NCT/school mum friends is incredible, despite both groups being in professional jobs - back then the norm was very to work PT, on average about 3 days a week, whereas now that would be very unusual and almost everyone is working either FT or a 4-day week with compressed hours. And the strain and frustration is very evident in the latter group.

My background is in education and I know a lot of primary teachers - many of them have said recently that, while a decade ago you it was typical for the vulnerable children in school to be those from deprived or abusive backgrounds, there is now a second group of children who are struggling which consists of those children who have very stressed and time-poor working parents - they’re not being read with at home, aren’t completing homework, come into school in the wrong clothes, are anxious attending FT wraparound care etc.

BlinkinKnackered · 14/11/2023 10:56

Goldbar · 14/11/2023 10:54

Tbh, anyone who hasn't programmed themselves to leave a 'passing lane' annoys me.

When my DC1 was little, I'd constantly be barking 'move to the side' or 'move out the way, someone is trying to pass us' at them - happily, now, it is second nature.

Edited

Not all heroes wear capes 🙏🏽I wish more people were like you.

NotLactoseFree · 14/11/2023 10:56

Bumpitybumper · 14/11/2023 10:48

@TripleDaisySummer
*I must admit I was taken aback at the school demands and the educational support need when my DC did fall behind.

The whole You have to parent like you don't work and work like you don't have kids does seem to be an expectation in our society - I don't think house prices and longer commutes help with that but as PP says we aren't only society that has working parents - my DGM both worked full time and DMum worked p/t to be there when we got home having been a latch key kid herself and MIL full time - DH was very much a latch key kid from a very young age. So working mothers aren't new thing even here*
I remember many of my friends being latch key kids too but to be honest, the parents weren't rushing home to help them with their homework or take them to an extra curricular club. There weren't the number of parties there are now and parents weren't expected to facilitate their children's social lives in the same way. My friends' parents would get home, give them some tea and then that would be a job well done. The parents wouldn't log on in the evening and catch up on the work they missed due to cramming in time with their kids after school. It really was a different time!

Yes, my parents were very involved. We all sat round the dinner table every evening. They took me to activities and sports clubs and we spent time together....

.... they wouldn't have dreamed of getting involved in my homework. the closest was to ask me if I'd done it.

I also find it quite frustrating. DS school keep saying we should be overseeing their homework, checking it etc. I do not have time for that. Nor do I have the skills or the inclination. I can and do ensure he has the tools and equipment and space he needs. I chat to him every day about what happened at school, what he's enjoying/not enjoying. I know his favourite teachers and subjects and his friends. We do lots of things together, and enjoy spending time together. I am involved and active in his life. But I resent this implication that I have to play a major role in helping him get better grades.

Goldbar · 14/11/2023 10:54

BlinkinKnackered · 14/11/2023 10:52

I admit that I do get annoyed when people are pushing a pram/buggy because most of the time, they will walk in the middle of the pavement leaving no space for people to get past or they will leave it in the middle of an isle at the supermarket. A lot of people with prams have no spacial awareness and think that they and their child are the only people to exist.

Tbh, anyone who hasn't programmed themselves to leave a 'passing lane' annoys me.

When my DC1 was little, I'd constantly be barking 'move to the side' or 'move out the way, someone is trying to pass us' at them - happily, now, it is second nature.

Goldbar · 14/11/2023 10:53

BloodyHellKen · 14/11/2023 10:50

I agree, but then who the hell likes noisy, disruptive children? I definitely don't and I've made a lot of effort to make sure our 3 are polite and well behaved.

Some people would define a 'noisy, disruptive child' as one who is talking at all, even if quietly. People on public transport are particularly intolerant of children.

BlinkinKnackered · 14/11/2023 10:52

I admit that I do get annoyed when people are pushing a pram/buggy because most of the time, they will walk in the middle of the pavement leaving no space for people to get past or they will leave it in the middle of an isle at the supermarket. A lot of people with prams have no spacial awareness and think that they and their child are the only people to exist.

Goldbar · 14/11/2023 10:51

Most kids are great, but some do need to wise up a bit. Maybe they've been a bit cossetted and overprotected but some seem completely oblivious to those around them... standing in the way when people are trying to pass, blocking bus and train exits and not giving up seats to those who need them more. Maybe with older kids it's the herd effect though, since most are absolutely delightful individually.

Children need to learn to observe social conventions but adults also need to respect the right of children (particularly teenagers, I think) to take up space in our society and be seen.

BloodyHellKen · 14/11/2023 10:50

Shoxfordian · 14/11/2023 08:54

I don't agree; society doesn't like disruptive noisy children so maybe that's your issue

I agree, but then who the hell likes noisy, disruptive children? I definitely don't and I've made a lot of effort to make sure our 3 are polite and well behaved.

PrincessHoneysuckle · 14/11/2023 10:50

Roundandroundandroundsound · 14/11/2023 09:10

SeulementUneFois · Today 08:58

Shoxfordian · Today 08:54

I don't agree; society doesn't like disruptive noisy children so maybe that's your issue
This OP.

Look at French society - children included but that's because they're brought up to be well behaved.

This old chestnut!!
On holiday in Crete this summer I experienced the worst children's behaviour in a restaurant that I have ever seen. 4 French (speaking) kids, literally running around between the tables, knocking into my own (British) DC's chairs, shrieking and actually climbing onto the sea wall which was next to our table and pushing and shoving each other, so that I had to intervene mid dinner because their parents were ignoring it and I was worried the little one who was about 4 was going to end up falling about 6 foot to the stony beach below. So no I don't believe that French kids are necessarily better behaved than British ones.

The rudest I have ever met were French

Frisate · 14/11/2023 10:49

From my experience of being a child in the past and now having my own children, I think it’s absolutely the opposite.

Bumpitybumper · 14/11/2023 10:48

@TripleDaisySummer
*I must admit I was taken aback at the school demands and the educational support need when my DC did fall behind.

The whole You have to parent like you don't work and work like you don't have kids does seem to be an expectation in our society - I don't think house prices and longer commutes help with that but as PP says we aren't only society that has working parents - my DGM both worked full time and DMum worked p/t to be there when we got home having been a latch key kid herself and MIL full time - DH was very much a latch key kid from a very young age. So working mothers aren't new thing even here*
I remember many of my friends being latch key kids too but to be honest, the parents weren't rushing home to help them with their homework or take them to an extra curricular club. There weren't the number of parties there are now and parents weren't expected to facilitate their children's social lives in the same way. My friends' parents would get home, give them some tea and then that would be a job well done. The parents wouldn't log on in the evening and catch up on the work they missed due to cramming in time with their kids after school. It really was a different time!

CaramacFiend · 14/11/2023 10:47

I don't have kids but don't think I agree from what I've observed.

TempsPerdu · 14/11/2023 10:46

Great post @Bumpitybumper

I think the pressures on parents are huge atm, and I’m not surprised that increasing numbers of younger people are opting out of parenthood entirely. But you also have the opposite phenomenon (which I see around me a lot) where many people are still very anxious about conforming to societal norms and therefore have the requisite 2 children, when really they would have been much happier if they’d stuck at one, or even remained child-free. So many of the resentful parents I posted about above would be better off having done this (some of them by their own admission) but the stigma around non-traditional family types remains surprisingly potent even now.

@SeulementUneFois Re dual income families and childcare, I agree - it’s certainly the norm in many places outside the U.K. and wouldn’t even be up for debate. But I think we need to consider the quality and affordability of that childcare. Our local nursery is easily the most sought after in the area - baby’s name on waiting list before birth etc - but I was still relieved that I only needed to leave DD there two days a week as, while the staff were universally lovely, they were incredibly young, inexperienced and often barely educated themselves. Even from our two days a week I found myself having to ‘undo’ lots of speech/grammar errors and gender/behaviour stereotypes that DD had picked up from them. We need to value and invest in Early Years education much more in the U.K. if we are to emulate what happens on the continent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread