Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think society hates children?

434 replies

Orangeandgold · 14/11/2023 08:51

During a crisis people tend to defend children and babies, but on a day to day basis when everything is “normal” I usually find and feel so much hatred towards children.

My DD picked this up quite young too. It is small subtle everyday conversations and actions.

I would have to remind an adult not to barge past a 5 year old when there is enough space on the pavement; or people that feel that they can comment or roll their eyes at you and be malicious because you have a buggy; or general comments in conversations about “all kids are brats/ those children/why would anyone have them.”; animals are so much more loving than children …

… and the comments go on!

If you don’t want children you don’t have to have them, but we were all kids once. AIBU to feel that society in general hates children and to get upset about it every now and then? Or am I just in a pessimistic bubble? Maybe it’s also the city, people have less tolerance? I just feel nobody really looks out for each other the way we would growing up - I would have neighbours on the look out as a child but now it’s different.

OP posts:
ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 12:07

Performance parenting just seems to be another lazy excuse to judge parents for actually talking to their children and responding to them with interest. As opposed to sticking them in front of an IPad which will also be judged as “lazy parenting”. I speak to my children, read to them and actually enjoy interacting with them. If that bothers you then you need to get help with your absolute selfish narcissism whereby you imagine everything is about you and centring your needs. Honestly, grow up, you really are not that important.

clarebear111 · 14/11/2023 12:06

ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 11:53

Absolutely agree OP. There is a real hatred and intolerance of children in the UK. I have experience of living in other countries (South America, Germany, Greece) and have never come across this same cold attitude. In those places it’s accepted that children will be children. They will run, shout, play, be curious, make noise - all completely natural. Not sit in silent contemplation like little monks, as some posters seem to expect. DH is Greek and children are adored there. There isn’t this attitude of seen and not heard as here. People here are quick to judge other people’s parenting but very unwilling to offer any help or support. I had this recently at an airport, DS1 was crawling, I was there alone with him, trying to hold him, whilst hauling a pushchair off a carousel and erect it. I had to put him down and obviously he started crawling off towards the carousel, cue audible gasps from people but not one of those fuckers offered to help me. I had to ask a young couple near me to help with the pushchair whilst I grabbed him. Lots of judgment but zero support.

We have really moved to an older age centric society - you can see it in the benefits position - the greatest welfare spending is on pensions and universal pensioner benefits but as soon as someone mentions 27% of children living in poverty and lifting the 2 child benefit cap it’s all “it was your choice to have children, I am not paying for them, lifestyle choice etc”. There is no sense of society or investment in future generations, we are a really individualistic, selfish society, geared towards serving the elderly (many of whom expect their elder care to be funded by taxpayers rather than having to sell their homes or assets but don’t want to contribute anything towards struggling families and children - who have borne the brunt of austerity). There is growing inequality and inter generational animosity - the two are linked and only going to get worse. It’s very depressing to see how children are treated in the UK, and no surprise that there are so many children with mental health issues as a result.

I agree with this. Sorry for your airport experience.

NotLactoseFree · 14/11/2023 12:05

Very few people are going to get upset at some parent handing a toddler a £20 note to give to the checkout person at the supermarket while being encouraged to say hello and thankyou. People do get irritated when it becomes a time-consuming extended maths exercise that said toddler is not engaging with yet the parent insists on completing no matter how long they hold everyone up.

Absolutely this! My DC loved doing the self checkout when they were small. if it was quiet, I would let them help me. If it was busy, I had to do it myself with them just doing the odd item, because it wasn't fair to make everyone else wait for ages.

clarebear111 · 14/11/2023 12:04

SeulementUneFois · 14/11/2023 08:58

This OP.

Look at French society - children included but that's because they're brought up to be well behaved.

I'm not sure I agree with this. I've come across some badly behaved French children. One French child was snatching repeatedly in a play setting (and not being discouraged to by their mother, who simply smiled her way benignly through it) and another one trying to run into a kitchen in a cafe (mother did not physically attempt to retrieve her child, but I assume was asking them to come back in a half hearted sort of way. A member of staff had to physically block the child from getting in to the kitchen). It may be that these are minority incidents but they do show that generalisations about badly behaved British children vs well behaved French children are not always accurate.

I think it's fair to say that most children are well behaved most of the time, and that every child will have a temper tantrum/ behave badly at some stage (usually when their parents least want them to!). I genuinely think most parents are doing their best, but obviously that does not extend to all parents.

TripleDaisySummer · 14/11/2023 11:59

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/11/2023 11:50

You're not imagining it, OP. As much as people will love to tell you you are.

So why do you think people have such wildly different experiences?

If the OP is not imagining it, then surely it must be that her kids are behaving in such a way that elicits negative reactions from those around them. Otherwise all parents would have similar experiences, and it's clear from this thread alone that they don't.

Different areas of the country are different in social expectations and as UK is increasingly age segregated - side affect of housing costs - different exposure levels -seeing less children means less experience of what is normal behavior and people do forget - plus some areas often more middle class do have concertation of permissive/gentle parenting cohort.

So I think it to be expected that experiences vary.

Several posters including me have also posted about our kids being pre-judged - so it's not our kids behavior but people expecting poor behavior from young kids and reacting to their prejudices.

TheCadoganArms · 14/11/2023 11:55

On the performance parenting thing there is a world of difference between the ‘show offs’ and the normal parents just positively engaging with their kids as they use day to day encounters to help them develop confidence in themselves and basic life skills. Very few people are going to get upset at some parent handing a toddler a £20 note to give to the checkout person at the supermarket while being encouraged to say hello and thankyou. People do get irritated when it becomes a time-consuming extended maths exercise that said toddler is not engaging with yet the parent insists on completing no matter how long they hold everyone up. We have all seen this along with the loud humble brag conversations about how terribly advanced Lulu is for her age and that she is now reading Solzhenitsyn and Tolstoy because the pre school reading list is not challenging enough. I have seen toddlers in high end restaurant who are clearly bored shitless being loudly lectured on taste groups and being asked to articulate their thoughts on the truffle langoustine.

“Can you describe the taste Archie”

“Poo poo bum bum”

“That’s right I am getting a very elegant and clean hints of citrus with classical aromas of saffron too”

Performative parenting most definitely exists which is why we have the ‘overheard in Waitrose’ stereotypes

ParsnipSurprise88 · 14/11/2023 11:53

Absolutely agree OP. There is a real hatred and intolerance of children in the UK. I have experience of living in other countries (South America, Germany, Greece) and have never come across this same cold attitude. In those places it’s accepted that children will be children. They will run, shout, play, be curious, make noise - all completely natural. Not sit in silent contemplation like little monks, as some posters seem to expect. DH is Greek and children are adored there. There isn’t this attitude of seen and not heard as here. People here are quick to judge other people’s parenting but very unwilling to offer any help or support. I had this recently at an airport, DS1 was crawling, I was there alone with him, trying to hold him, whilst hauling a pushchair off a carousel and erect it. I had to put him down and obviously he started crawling off towards the carousel, cue audible gasps from people but not one of those fuckers offered to help me. I had to ask a young couple near me to help with the pushchair whilst I grabbed him. Lots of judgment but zero support.

We have really moved to an older age centric society - you can see it in the benefits position - the greatest welfare spending is on pensions and universal pensioner benefits but as soon as someone mentions 27% of children living in poverty and lifting the 2 child benefit cap it’s all “it was your choice to have children, I am not paying for them, lifestyle choice etc”. There is no sense of society or investment in future generations, we are a really individualistic, selfish society, geared towards serving the elderly (many of whom expect their elder care to be funded by taxpayers rather than having to sell their homes or assets but don’t want to contribute anything towards struggling families and children - who have borne the brunt of austerity). There is growing inequality and inter generational animosity - the two are linked and only going to get worse. It’s very depressing to see how children are treated in the UK, and no surprise that there are so many children with mental health issues as a result.

CeciledeVolangesdeNouveau · 14/11/2023 11:53

I’m frankly scared of children (autism and my sister had a childhood illness that meant she actually screamed for about five years straight) but I don’t hate them, they’d be rescued first in a fire. I’ve seen the exact opposite of hatred from people around me though, eg at my church the entire choir including those child free by choice would rush over to coo at anyone younger than about seven and to pluck something else randomly out of the air, think of Marcus Rashford’s effort - children were rightfully prioritised even though poverty-stricken parents were skipping meals left and right.

Ballsbaill · 14/11/2023 11:51

No they don't. Mother's seem to hate everyone else's children but their own.

Mumsnet alone, never mind other parenting spaces, are full of threads about annoying children\hating children\dreading playdates\excluding children from birthday parties\dont want my children around my niece\horrible neighbour kids etc.
It doesn't stop.

Maybe consider people feel about your kids the way you feel about theirs.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/11/2023 11:50

You're not imagining it, OP. As much as people will love to tell you you are.

So why do you think people have such wildly different experiences?

If the OP is not imagining it, then surely it must be that her kids are behaving in such a way that elicits negative reactions from those around them. Otherwise all parents would have similar experiences, and it's clear from this thread alone that they don't.

TempsPerdu · 14/11/2023 11:48

I think many British people are unique in defining this as children being entirely silent (seen and not heard) though.

Yes, I’m always interested to know what constitutes ‘well behaved’ in this context - not making one’s presence felt, perhaps? Do other cultures have their own equivalent of our Victorian ‘children should be seen and not heard’ thing?

For example, my own DM sometimes expresses disapproval of DD (and by implication our parenting) because she expresses opinions about things - in her conception of children, they shouldn’t have any kind of agency or form an opinion on anything independent of adults.

OutsideLookingOut · 14/11/2023 11:47

TempsPerdu · 14/11/2023 10:11

Men and women in their 40s and 50s revolving their life around music gigs and bars as if they are still teenagers at university. Adulthood has lost it's way and the attitude towards children reflects that, mostly because it does not match up to the lifestyle that a lot of people are choosing

@Newphony

It’s a really uncomfortable thing to broach, but I think there’s an element of truth in this. My local social circle consists largely of what would be older parents (we’re in London, so the ‘norm’ is having DC later) who have established their careers before having DC. Most people aren’t wealthy but are reasonably comfortably off.

Almost every discussion on WhatsApp groups, at the school gate, on nights out etc revolves around how to carve out as much time as possible without the kids, how the kids are hampering their careers, how they wish they were at Glasto or a gig rather than doing childcare, how boring they find playing with their kids, how much less fun holidays are now etc. Many of the kids are dragged from pillar to post every weekend attending (adult) festivals, visiting old university friends on the other side of the country, going on weekend mini-breaks to Porto or Berlin etc. We’re taking babies, preschoolers and young school-aged children here.

Of course, maintaining your own identity post-kids is important, but there’s very little consideration of routine, stability, what would be optimal for the DC etc - it’s primarily about how they can continue to live as similarly as possible to the way they lived pre-kids. It’s quite striking how different this approach is from my school/university friends who had their DC much earlier, 10-15 years ago, and largely accepted that their lives would now be different and compromises would have to be made.

In the past, children were also expected to slot into parents lives. There have been threads where adults talk about how their parents left them in the car when they went to the pub, or they were latch key kids, never helped with homework etc etc. The new modern parenting is very intense (not saying wrong).

Nothing wrong with men and women in their 40s and 50s enjoys gigs and bars so long as the children are cared for! Adulthood does not have to look the same for everyone, you don't need to have children or even do adult hobbies. It is freedom to make your own life choices.

LadyGrinningSoul85 · 14/11/2023 11:46

Orangeandgold · 14/11/2023 08:51

During a crisis people tend to defend children and babies, but on a day to day basis when everything is “normal” I usually find and feel so much hatred towards children.

My DD picked this up quite young too. It is small subtle everyday conversations and actions.

I would have to remind an adult not to barge past a 5 year old when there is enough space on the pavement; or people that feel that they can comment or roll their eyes at you and be malicious because you have a buggy; or general comments in conversations about “all kids are brats/ those children/why would anyone have them.”; animals are so much more loving than children …

… and the comments go on!

If you don’t want children you don’t have to have them, but we were all kids once. AIBU to feel that society in general hates children and to get upset about it every now and then? Or am I just in a pessimistic bubble? Maybe it’s also the city, people have less tolerance? I just feel nobody really looks out for each other the way we would growing up - I would have neighbours on the look out as a child but now it’s different.

You'll get people telling you you're being unreasonable and looking into it too much, but you're not.

I have children (not going to say how many, as people love to judge) and the general intolerance for them daring to take up any space whatsoever is ridiculous.
It's like they're not allowed to leave the house, and heaven forbid they talk!
I'm not taking about shouting and screaming, just any noise in general, even normal conversation.

My mum is terrible for getting them to be quiet when we are out, I'm forever telling her that they have as much right to talk as anyone else.
They don't shout and misbehave, in fact the more tolerant, nicer adults out there tend to compliment me on how well behaved they are, but so many seem to think I'm really putting everyone else out by leaving my home with them.

And don't get me started on how much of a nuisance I'm made to feel if I'm pushing a pram (yet mobility scooters are totally acceptable? No difference, my child can't walk any more than someone using a mobility scooter).

I'm borderline agoraphobic these days, something which has a crippling impact on my life, and a huge part of that is just how miserable people are towards myself and my kids if we dare decide to venture out and about amongst the 'grown ups'.

And it's 90% people who are 50+
People of my parent's generation.
The same people who had no issues with taking us out and letting us shout and run about.

The same people that tell you they have 'no responsibility to help you with your kids/their grandkids because they've done their child reading, but you vividly remember them eagerly accepting any help offered when you were kids, but that's a whole different subject, so I'll leave that there.

You're not imagining it, OP. As much as people will love to tell you you are.

TeaMistress · 14/11/2023 11:45

I disagree. Society as a whole is tolerant and inclusive and welcoming to children who are well behaved and pleasant. Society generally and quite rightly frowns upon ill behaved feral children who cause noise and mess and disrupt the lives of everyone around them and quite rightly have no time for entitled parents who allow their children to behave like this.

Bumpitybumper · 14/11/2023 11:43

Goldbar · 14/11/2023 10:51

Most kids are great, but some do need to wise up a bit. Maybe they've been a bit cossetted and overprotected but some seem completely oblivious to those around them... standing in the way when people are trying to pass, blocking bus and train exits and not giving up seats to those who need them more. Maybe with older kids it's the herd effect though, since most are absolutely delightful individually.

Children need to learn to observe social conventions but adults also need to respect the right of children (particularly teenagers, I think) to take up space in our society and be seen.

Children do need to learn social conventions but it should also be appreciated that they do need time and experience to learn these. Children are not mini adults and it is totally normal for them to not have the same level of impulse control and social awareness as adults. As a society we need to be more tolerant of those who for whatever reason struggle to conform to social norms and cause some level of inconvenience.

Prams and dawdling toddlers may well get in your way when you're in a hurry but so will the disabled and elderly. I stood for 10 whole minutes in a queue the other day as an elderly person insisted on paying with the exact change for something. It was unbelievably frustrating as I really was in a rush but I had to remind myself that she may not have been intentionally inconsiderate and we can't always assume that people are capable of behaving how society expects.

TempsPerdu · 14/11/2023 11:42

@Elastica23 Yes I agree on the nature/nurture aspect, and it’s true that I am linguistically very able myself so DD was always a bit likelier to be strong in that area too. But it’s not a case of one particularly advanced DC against a lot of more average kids - it’s one advanced DC in a cohort that in many cases arrived at school unable to speak in full sentences, form or respond to questions or enunciate clearly at all.

This is a relatively new phenomenon being noticed by a lot of schools and nurseries, to the point where speech and language skills are becoming a major focus in the majority of education settings. And IMO it’s about home life, early childhood development and school readiness as well as innate cognitive ability.

HipHouse · 14/11/2023 11:41

I feel the opposite - in real life, I’d say the vast majority of people, young and old (especially old) love kids and are very accommodating & kind. Whenever I’m out with dcs, we get lots of smiles and old ladies coming up to chat to us.

I wouldn’t give another thought to the mn threads where certain posters think it’s funny to threaten violence on young kids. They’re just weirdos & probably just hate everyone & everything.

BloodyHellKen · 14/11/2023 11:38

Goldbar · 14/11/2023 10:53

Some people would define a 'noisy, disruptive child' as one who is talking at all, even if quietly. People on public transport are particularly intolerant of children.

If someone defines anyone, child or not as disruptive for talking in a normal speaking voice or quietly then they are clearly insane and best ignored.

Goldbar · 14/11/2023 11:37

susiedaisy1912 · 14/11/2023 11:34

Overall I think the British like well behaved kids anything else is irritating.

I think many British people are unique in defining this as children being entirely silent (seen and not heard) though. Other countries probably like well-behaved kids too but are more tolerant of their normal playing noise and conversation.

UsernameCreater · 14/11/2023 11:36

Scalottia · 14/11/2023 11:32

If you've never had to witness performance parenting, lucky you. It exists and it's extremely annoying.

No need to be so defensive, if you don't do it then you have nothing to worry about 😉

What exactly is it to you? I don’t believe anyone performance parents so I have no need to be defensive. It’s just more MN bollocks wheeled out as a way to attack other women/parents. And I have witnessed showing off from parents yes, and I couldn’t care less about it.

susiedaisy1912 · 14/11/2023 11:34

Overall I think the British like well behaved kids anything else is irritating.

UndertheCedartree · 14/11/2023 11:34

Our society is definitely unwelcoming to children. My DP live in Spain and I always notice the difference - it's so much nicer in that way.

Scalottia · 14/11/2023 11:32

UsernameCreater · 14/11/2023 10:16

And Bingo! The performance parenting trope has been rolled out too.

So that’s French kids are perfect and PeRfOrMaNcE pArEnTiNg so far.

If you've never had to witness performance parenting, lucky you. It exists and it's extremely annoying.

No need to be so defensive, if you don't do it then you have nothing to worry about 😉

Elastica23 · 14/11/2023 11:32

TempsPerdu · 14/11/2023 10:23

@UsernameCreater @Elastica23

Yes, absolutely the ‘performance parenting’ thing - people definitely see it as a bit weird and somehow ‘fake’ if you’re pointing things out to your preschooler or asking them their opinion about something, but things like this form a vital part of natural language/cognitive development.

Impossible to state something like this without being accused of bragging, but DD5 has a vocabulary far beyond her years and her advanced language skills are frequently commented on by other parents and teachers at her school. Many of her peers, meanwhile, still struggle to form sentences and the school is having to have a huge push on speech and language and oracy, spending money on additional training etc.

But it’s not rocket science, and DD isn’t a genius - all I did was talk to her constantly when she was little, take time to respond to her questions, point things out in the park (naming flowers and animals etc), avoid excessive screen use and make sure she was facing me in her buggy in the early years. That this is all now considered OTT and weird parenting is a sad indictment of where society currently is.

A lot of it is innate ability though/differences- which yes, can be fed by parenting, but so much is within them. I have a aptitude for words and languages, so does DD1. I thought her wonderful vocabulary and early abilities were down to my wonderful parenting, talking to them all the time, sharing books, then I had DD2 who was a much later talker and reader, has ADHD and ASD and still doesn't like reading and writing (or school apart from PE and sport which she loves and is quite talented at) very much aged 14.

betterangels · 14/11/2023 11:30

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 14/11/2023 08:59

I genuinely believe that society does not hate children.

Society hates parents that think that society should love their children as much as they do and enable and allow their children to do whatever they want regardless of the impact it has on others around them.

It’s not a children problem - it’s a parenting problem.

It's this. I don't hate the child, who blasted some children's YT shite all over the train carriage for hours this week. I did think her mum was inconsiderate and entitled for not putting headphones on her kid! Fucking annoying.