Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Missed the boat on a sibling

38 replies

EmilyEllisBell · 13/11/2023 21:47

My son is 5 and currently an only child.
He was 18 months - 3 during the lockdown/Covid time. And it didn’t feel like a good idea to have another baby at that point, although this would have been the time we’d choose, if it wasn’t for Covid.

I know some will say it’s not too late, but I don’t feel like I could go back to sleepless nights, night feeding, nappy changing and so on.

But conversely I feel sad he won’t have a sibling either.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
chappoi · 14/11/2023 02:06

Bournetilly · 14/11/2023 01:29

I think you need to consider if you want another child not if you want a sibling for first DC.

Siblings of any age gap can get on well or dislike each other so there’s no gaurentee they would be close either way.

Exactly, Any age gap comes with ups and downs. But if you want another child you don't let Covid put you off. Siblings work because parents support that relationship. There's no perfect time

CareConumdrum · 14/11/2023 01:38

The sleepless nights/back to babyhood thing isn't nearly as bad second time around. I think it's because the baby isn't your main focus. Second/third babies etc get looked after while you're sorting out their sibling.

So instead of hours entertaining a baby, they're out with you in the sling/buggy/car while you're dropping off at school/Beavers/parties. Or big brother plays a game with them in the high chair while you cook dinner.

Yes, it's undoubtedly more work, but you've already navigated the biggest shock - from non-parent to parent, so the upheaval won't feel as great. Generally about 50% of the stress, compared to a first baby.

Good luck if you decide to go for it! 🍀

Bournetilly · 14/11/2023 01:29

I think you need to consider if you want another child not if you want a sibling for first DC.

Siblings of any age gap can get on well or dislike each other so there’s no gaurentee they would be close either way.

demopelm · 14/11/2023 01:21

I have a 4 year gap and they don't play together at all. Hard to picture how siblings with a bigger gap would play together. DH and I usually take them out together and one parent ends up doing something slightly different with each child as they are at different stages. Very difficult when I take them out on my own and end up having to ignore the older one to chase around the younger one. Very hard for me to help the older one with anything involved like Lego or crafts. I don't regret it at all but life is definitely harder and busier with a second child and DC1 has had more disadvantage from it so far than any advantage.

champagnetruffleshuffle · 14/11/2023 01:08

My dsis was also unsure about a second due to age gap, but our advice was if it is in your heart to have another then go for it, don't over-think. My nephews have a 6 year gap and have a great bond.

Livelovebehappy · 13/11/2023 23:55

Definitely don’t feel that you need to have another to provide your dc with a sibling. I know people who have only children, and they have grown up to be confident happy individuals, who haven’t suffered through being an only child. Does your dc have cousins and friends?

DueyCheatemAndHow · 13/11/2023 23:35

I think the question is do you want another baby?

My eldest is the same age as yours and we had our second in 2020. If I'd waited I don't think I could have faced all the sleepless nights and nappies again. But if you want another baby don't use the age gap as a reason not to, nothing guarantees siblings are close!

WrylyAmused · 13/11/2023 23:31

Some siblings get on really well. Some don't. Some actively dislike their siblings, to extremes. And you won't know which until you have them....

Some kids (me, and quite a few of my friends!) loved being only children, had zero desire for siblings, and zero desire for them now we're adults, even where our parents have died and we're now without blood family.
I imagine that some onlies feel that they would like siblings, although I don't know any...

If you want another, have time and resources for it, great, but do it because you and your partner want another and you think it would add to your lives, not because you imagine something for your son that may well be quite different in reality to how you picture it.

And if you don't want another, for any reason at all, that's also fine and will do him no harm at all. He's never known different, it would be no loss to him.

FlowerTink · 13/11/2023 23:25

I have a 3 and an 8 year old here, they love each other and enjoy playing together, they have a very close bond even with the age gap

Beseen22 · 13/11/2023 23:21

I have 2 with 3 years between and we would have loved a third but I have had infertility and miscarriage and totally get the feeling of are we past all that now? We are settled, comfortable, day to day life is a breeze and my career is getting fun. Just wish I had the courage to say we are done and clear out my garage of all the baby crap.

EmiliaRuusuvuori · 13/11/2023 23:05

Doyoumind · 13/11/2023 22:18

Siblings aren't just about when you're young though. Sibling relationships can be important when you're an adult, and the age gaps mean much less anyway.

This is very true, my sibling is eight years younger than me but as we've aged into our forties and fifties the gap seems to have closed and he actually looks older than me now.

Goldbar · 13/11/2023 22:54

I find the age gap helps to keep the older one younger for longer as well. My older one will happily play with the baby toys and we've had 10 year olds on the floor with the baby engrossed in building block towers and playing with the xylophone or baby drum. It's really made me question whether we hurry kids through childhood too fast.

WaltzingWaters · 13/11/2023 22:52

5.5 years between my brother and I and we were very close growing up. There was very little jealousy or rivalry as we were at such different stages but still played together and had a great bond.
I’d love the same gap as it also means you have time to focus on each as a baby and not be too stressed as the older child is more independent.

Nomnomnom66 · 13/11/2023 22:48

Depends if you're too old for a second or not. There are nine years between my children.

Icepop79 · 13/11/2023 22:47

Nearly 6 years between mine. I hadn’t planned on such a big age gap, but it really works. No competitiveness, no sibling rivalry. My son brings out the childishness in my teenage daughter, which I love - it gives her an excuse to play with toys, or mess around in the swimming pool when she’d be too cool for that with her friends.

Going back to the newborn stage was tricky, but at least my daughter was becoming self-sufficient which made it all a lot easier.

Goldbar · 13/11/2023 22:47

It's a different sort of relationship with a bigger age gap. I occasionally feel wistful when I see friends with children close in age playing together, but my older one is so caring, considerate and helpful with the younger one, and so proud of them, in a way I don't think would happen if DC1 had been younger when DC2 arrived.

As pp have said, don't focus on age gaps but whether you want and could cope with another child.

ladycarlotta · 13/11/2023 22:43

I understand completely. My daughter is 4.5 and I have had multiple miscarriages trying for a second, and am now reaching the point where I wonder if I really want to go back to the baby stage. I'd love her to have a sibling, I'd love to have another baby... but I do wonder if the moment has now passed. My career is recovering, we're finally free of the expense of nursery, and we have so much more freedom in other ways too: she's independent and we can enjoy adventures that were not possible with a baby/toddler.

So, yes. I get it. I do not have the answer for you I'm afraid, but I understand wanting another child in theory but wondering if in practice it is time to embrace what we have and the new phase of life we are in.

I suppose for me there's the added question of do I want to put myself through the grief and trauma of more losses, which hopefully for you will not be a factor. But if you decide you do want a baby, there is no 'bad' age gap, all families have their logistical headaches and their plus points. You can be sure there'll be love and happiness there whatever you choose.

morrrr · 13/11/2023 22:40

I completely understand as I feel the same way.

I have 2 Daughters, aged nearly 4 & 6. Deep down I would like another one but I can't bear to go through all of that again and feel like I've left it too long. Ideally, I would've had a small gap between them all, had a terrible few years and then got my life back.

I do think in your position though, I would try for second. It's probably better in that your 5 year old wouldn't be as jealous as they are when they are closer in age. Perhaps your Son would also enjoy helping out and I imagine would entertain the baby at times. It's also nice at that age because they can half fend for themselves rather than having 2 of them asking you to do everything for them, every single minute of every day!!

BorrowersAreVermin · 13/11/2023 22:30

There are nine years between me and my sister and we get along great. There are four years between me and my brother and we did nothing but fight for a long time.

DS is 10 now. I'd have loved another kid but we left it too late in terms of our age. Both the wrong side of 40 now. If you feel you can do it you don't want to regret it.

coldcallerbaiter · 13/11/2023 22:27

Nothing wrong with a gap, mine are 7 years apart

Humdingerydoo · 13/11/2023 22:25

It will almost certainly be difficult to go back to the baby days of no sleep etc, but at least your older one can now go to the toilet on their own, doesn't need to be spoon fed, is out of the house at least 6 hours a day at a minimal cost to you... Plus at the right age to want to help out a bit with baby by fetching nappies etc. Presumably has a reasonably earlyish bedtime and sleeps well. I wouldn't let the age gap get in the way if you want another child!

Sprinkles211 · 13/11/2023 22:25

We left big gaps on purpose, needed to make sure we could give them a good lifestyle and lots of attention. Mine are 15, 7 and 9 months xx

TeaKitten · 13/11/2023 22:21

Your OP is written quite oddly. Entirely about wether or not your child should have a sibling.

Do you want another baby? If you don’t and feel bad like you didn’t want the sleepless nights etc then that’s fine. If you DO want another baby but worry about the age gap, then that’s different, the age gap won’t matter once they grow up. Your child doesn’t need a sibling either way though.

Hold old are you?

Doyoumind · 13/11/2023 22:18

Siblings aren't just about when you're young though. Sibling relationships can be important when you're an adult, and the age gaps mean much less anyway.

TeddyBeans · 13/11/2023 22:13

DS is 5.5, DD is 8.5 months. He absolutely adores her and she thinks he's hilarious. They're a right pair and I love the age gap ❤️ going back to sleepless nights and endless nappy changes wasn't that difficult, it's like learning to ride a bike. You've done it, you know it doesn't last forever, you just crack on and get the job done