Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed that my university group have plagiarised on our group project?

35 replies

notmygroup · 13/11/2023 21:44

We have a group project deadline at midnight, and I have just uploaded our final document onto our university's plagiarism software only for it to show that one group member has plagiarised their entire section. Her section is lit up like a Christmas tree with sentences and paragraphs directly copy and pasted from textbooks and papers.

I've rewritten her section and reuploaded it, and gently said to the group what the issue was (without naming names) and that they need to resubmit and they're annoyed that they are having to resubmit it so late in the evening.

I had finished my contribution to the project last week, and have been messaging my group all day asking for them to finalise it so it's not my fault that the plagiarism wasn't picked up until it was finally ready to be submitted this evening. If I hadn't noticed it I think we'd of all had our marks docked and probably had to have a meeting as we've been told very clearly what plagiarism is.

AIBU? I've encountered this in so many group projects, and feel so frustrated about it

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
istolethetalisker · 14/11/2023 17:58

I’d discuss this with my tutor pronto, and state that I’m not happy to work with this cheat person ever again, and I’d explain why. Do you still have the original assignment as evidence?

billy1966 · 14/11/2023 17:49

WaWaWaWaaaaaa · 14/11/2023 09:39

Gawd this is why I hate group projects for university. They should be voluntary and you should have the option of working on your own. Uni group projects do not reflect working with people in actual real jobs.

One of my kids did a big project where two of the, worked hard and two slacked completely. He highlighted it to the lecturer running it and handed in a clearly colour coded project. Highlighting who did what. Him and the other good guy gets A's and the useless guys failed. I thought the lecturer was good to do that.

Exact same situation with one of my sons and it was a really important end of year project.

3 worked, 3 didn't get involved until the night it was being submitted and then claimed they had been excluded.

Fortunately my son had contacted the lecturer and flagged his concern a couple of days earlier, as advised by us. IRL you wouldn't ignore the possibility of a deadline being compromised

It was one of several nightmare projects but it does provide a steep learning curve that is maturing.

JellyIegs · 14/11/2023 17:35

endofthelinefinally · 13/11/2023 22:19

This is why I hate group projects.

Agreed. Group projects are a nightmare notion. When I was at uni years ago I was in a group of three with a girl who didn’t speak and a boy who either didn’t turn up or turned up drunk.

Superscientist · 14/11/2023 17:24

We had this once. We didn't need to put it through a checker the language was fully textbook and nothing like the context the presentation was meant to have.
We got to say how the marks were divided and the person in question agreed to a lower proportion. We rewrote her section entirely and she didn't turn up to the presentation. She dropped out at the end of the year. I do sometimes feel that I missed an opportunity to check she was alright.
I always try to be compassionate and hope that maybe they have found themselves out of their depth or has things going on I'm not aware of and not just a lazy so and so

HollaHolla · 14/11/2023 17:24

I'm a member of staff in a University, who has plagiarism reviews/student disciplinaries as part of my job. This is a major issue - and you don't want to be accused of participating in it. In it's most serious forms, students can be removed from their course. I would go to the Course Leader, and ask to speak to them about your concerns. You need to be upfront, and this would be best to be flagged as soon as you can - and before anything inadvertent is picked up.

Oakbeam · 14/11/2023 17:17

I really don't know why they have them as part of degrees at all.

They are often required to gain accreditation from professional bodies.

Working effectively as part of a team is regarded as an essential skill.

fuzzleberry · 14/11/2023 11:09

notmygroup · 13/11/2023 22:00

I have to work with this same group for another project so don't want to make it awkward. I also have anxiety and would rather sort it out myself and submit a corrected version so I don't have it looming over me. I presume this student will plagiarise their future independent assignments and get caught out that way.

They'll do it again unless you tell everyone!

DogLegMotor · 14/11/2023 11:08

Ds has this in his second year and so the marks count toward his grade. He did exactly what the OP did and rewrote it because this kid had failed to turn up to their scheduled meetings etc so hadn't a clue what to write and so wrote some bullshit.

Luckily they all had to do a report and feedback on each other but half the group were not going to admit that Ds wrote a lot of it, had to teach them stuff they should have learned themselves it was a fucking mess and has brought his overall grade down. He is completely pissed but nothing you can do because you can't complain to the people about how these things are run and marked as they will be marking your final year work too. Well, hopefully, there are modules that haven't been marked from last academic year that the uni has just written off.

I don't think group work should be graded as a whole piece, there is always at least one in the group who is completely shit and rides on the grades of others.

@notmygroup I wouldn't protect them though, I would raise it with whoever you submitted it to with the original to compare against the one you wrote instead. I hate people who cheat like this.

Meatarian · 14/11/2023 11:06

Gosh that's horrible. They should be freaking grateful you saved their bacon. I would not work with them again on another project.

Stroopwaffels · 14/11/2023 11:03

I have just finished a MSc and the group project was the most hated part of the whole course. Even though we didn't have anyone copying or using chat GPT, it is not the way I prefer to work.

I would be LIVID and it's just as well you caught it. There are enough free checkers like Copyscape that there is no justification for laziness. I would also have no hesitation in shopping the cheating student to the tutor/lecturer.

DinoDaddy · 14/11/2023 11:00

They could have at least used chatgpt.

YoKookoY · 14/11/2023 10:53

Twixxer · 14/11/2023 09:45

I always get my students to work off one document so that the collaborative software (OneDrive) picks up who did what in a report. The plagiarism is picked up by the software and then the person who plagiarised is picked up via the collaborative document. I think you got well out of your lane sorting out some else’s work. Leave them to it and speak up to your tutor/lecturers.

Edited

That's a really good way of dealing with this issue.

RoomOfRequirement · 14/11/2023 10:47

Group projects are bullshit. I absolutely despise them. And no it does not prepare you for the world of work.

mindutopia · 14/11/2023 10:35

I'm a lecturer. Please do speak with the module lead or tutor about this. You don't have to name any names, but do flag it up as an issue. I handle plagiarism cases for our department and I'd be grateful to know this, firstly, so I could make sure that students are protected from being accused of plagiarism when they were doing their best, but secondly, so that it could be addressed with the student, even if indirectly, if you don't want to identify them. It's so much less stress and hassle to catch these things before they happen than to have to deal with the aftermath.

Drpawpawspaw · 14/11/2023 10:11

notmygroup · 13/11/2023 22:00

I have to work with this same group for another project so don't want to make it awkward. I also have anxiety and would rather sort it out myself and submit a corrected version so I don't have it looming over me. I presume this student will plagiarise their future independent assignments and get caught out that way.

bite the bullet and call out the plagiarist @notmygroup ! You’ll save yourself a lot of grief in future projects and feel empowered into the bargain! Doesn’t have to be in an aggressive way

“please can we bear in mind plagiarism was an issue on some sections of our previous project (as shown up by the uni software), this meant I had to rewrite a section of another participants work myself before submission; obvs this is unfair on the whole group who could be penalised for it - let’s do our own work!”

you have every right to say your bit 💪

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/11/2023 10:09

Twixxer · 14/11/2023 10:01

I understand the argument that students need to develop teamworking skills, but if that's the point of the group assignments, then Universities need to find a way of assessing the process and practice of teamwork rather the end product, which is so often the work of just one or two individuals.

We are required to mark students individually for group projects and there are many ways of doing this. Journaling who did what, a collaborative document which picks up each students contribution. Group work is a core skill in our discipline and evidence of it is sought from outside accreditation bodies. Without that accreditation our students could not get subsequent professional qualifications.

If individual marks are given on the basis of individual contributions, and you have an effective system for monitoring/measuring this, then there is a value in the process. However, that isn't how a lot of group assignments work.

When I did my MBA a few years ago, it was one grade for the group, based on the end product. Invariably, I ended up doing a disproportionate amount of the work, as did some others, while some just didn't produce anything at all. We all got the same grade for the assignment at the end of it.

Pointless.

Twixxer · 14/11/2023 10:01

I understand the argument that students need to develop teamworking skills, but if that's the point of the group assignments, then Universities need to find a way of assessing the process and practice of teamwork rather the end product, which is so often the work of just one or two individuals.

We are required to mark students individually for group projects and there are many ways of doing this. Journaling who did what, a collaborative document which picks up each students contribution. Group work is a core skill in our discipline and evidence of it is sought from outside accreditation bodies. Without that accreditation our students could not get subsequent professional qualifications.

VickyEadieofThigh · 14/11/2023 09:58

endofthelinefinally · 13/11/2023 22:19

This is why I hate group projects.

I really don't know why they have them as part of degrees at all. I had to do one way back in the early 90s as part of my MBA - which was fine as Internet plagiarism wasn't a thing then AND it was a very 'practical' project.

But these days, as the OP demonstrates, it can land entirely innocent colleagues in a sorts of trouble.

EVERYONE knows the university will use plagiarism software - surely?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 14/11/2023 09:53

Tell the responsible academic that you aren't willing to work with that individual on any future projects because of the plagiarism. Show them the evidence and ask for them to be removed from the group.

Group assignments are a pile of pants in my experience. There are always lazy sods who end up getting carried by the rest of the group. Universities really need to put an end up this shit.

I understand the argument that students need to develop teamworking skills, but if that's the point of the group assignments, then Universities need to find a way of assessing the process and practice of teamwork rather the end product, which is so often the work of just one or two individuals.

Twixxer · 14/11/2023 09:45

I always get my students to work off one document so that the collaborative software (OneDrive) picks up who did what in a report. The plagiarism is picked up by the software and then the person who plagiarised is picked up via the collaborative document. I think you got well out of your lane sorting out some else’s work. Leave them to it and speak up to your tutor/lecturers.

WaWaWaWaaaaaa · 14/11/2023 09:39

Gawd this is why I hate group projects for university. They should be voluntary and you should have the option of working on your own. Uni group projects do not reflect working with people in actual real jobs.

One of my kids did a big project where two of the, worked hard and two slacked completely. He highlighted it to the lecturer running it and handed in a clearly colour coded project. Highlighting who did what. Him and the other good guy gets A's and the useless guys failed. I thought the lecturer was good to do that.

Oakbeam · 13/11/2023 23:00

Will there be any peer assessment of the submission?

OhComeOnFFS · 13/11/2023 22:47

What would have been the consequences for the rest of the group if you'd left it as it was?

By speaking gently to the whole group you are ensuring the culprit will do the same again next time. They've been treated gently too often and this was the result.

I would speak to my tutor about it if I was put in a group with them again.

justasmalltownmum · 13/11/2023 22:35

notmygroup · 13/11/2023 22:00

I have to work with this same group for another project so don't want to make it awkward. I also have anxiety and would rather sort it out myself and submit a corrected version so I don't have it looming over me. I presume this student will plagiarise their future independent assignments and get caught out that way.

No she won't if people keep fixing it.

justasmalltownmum · 13/11/2023 22:34

Why are you being gentle? Name and shame. How else will she learn. She could have jeopardised the whole project.

Swipe left for the next trending thread