Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Made dessert but not invited....

188 replies

Happbee · 13/11/2023 21:39

Hi

I just wanted to find out some other opinions. The short story is my MIL had a dinner party. She asked me (via my husband at first) if I could make dessert for it. So I made the dessert and my husband took it round. However, I didnt receive an invite to come. I wouldnt have gone anyway as I have kids and it would be past their bedtime (on a school night). But AIBU to think its rude to ask someone to make a dessert but not invite them to come? My husband doesnt see the problem so wanted to know if anyone else sees my POV.

OP posts:
mirax · 14/11/2023 03:42

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 14/11/2023 03:04

This. Absolutely.

She probably thinks of you as family @Happbee.

I know that I do with my DC's partners/spouses. They all get treated as near as dammit possible, in exactly the same way as those I gave birth to. I love them so much, and before reading Mumsnet AIBU threads, I would have expected them to understand that I was asking them for a favour because I really enjoyed their 'cooking' - in this particular case. I would ask that of my daughter - if she could make such tasty desserts - and would not think it was any different to ask my DiL for the same favour.

Maybe in future I should go down on my knees, put my hands together, and say
"Please my most blessed DiL, would you do me the massive favour of making me one of your delicious Tiramasu's, as I am having FiL's brother and wife over for supper on Wednesday, and when I mentioned your wonderful pudding to them they almost drooled. Of course Dad and I will pay for the very expensive ingredients and for any electricity used, and of course we will pay you top dollar for your time. You are of course very welcome to come as well, but then you must know by now that you are always welcome, no invitations necessary. However, I do think I should warn you that my dear BiL isn't exactly the most scintillating company, and his dear wife always brings her crochet with her, even doing it and talking about it throughout any meals at the dinner table - in fact I'm surprised she didn't bring it to your Wedding reception..."

I noticed OP that she did ask your DH if he wanted to go. Unfortunately (IMO), one of the few things wrong with the English language is that unlike many other Latin based languages we don't have a plural 'you', so if your MiL said to her dear son "would you like to come, she almost certainly meant both of you(s)!"

NB I mean this light-heartedly, no serious sarcasm meant - which is just as well as I am not very good at it!

NB2 - to anyone reading this: I know that the English Language is not solely a Latin based language. There is also a large ancient Greek influence, some norse, some Indian, we also adopted a few of Shakespears made up words, and there might even be some double Dutch for all I know.

It really is time I was asleep, so sleep tight, and don't let those pesky mainland European bed bugs bite.

You people are really clutching at straws here. The Mil did not ask the OP directly, she has not the basic courtesy to do so. She used her wimpy son instead. She extended an invitation to the son but not OP. Explain the logic of that. She hasnt thanked nor paid OP (even acknowledged a favour done) for her trouble. Is this what your dear families are like?

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 14/11/2023 03:04

Whattodowithit88 · 13/11/2023 21:48

She needed help and outsourced it to family, that’s perfectly fine as long as she helps you out too, so I suppose it’s cheeky if she doesn’t ever help you out but if she does then it’s fine, that’s what family is for. People are so busy being offended these days I’m surprised anyone breathes!

This. Absolutely.

She probably thinks of you as family @Happbee.

I know that I do with my DC's partners/spouses. They all get treated as near as dammit possible, in exactly the same way as those I gave birth to. I love them so much, and before reading Mumsnet AIBU threads, I would have expected them to understand that I was asking them for a favour because I really enjoyed their 'cooking' - in this particular case. I would ask that of my daughter - if she could make such tasty desserts - and would not think it was any different to ask my DiL for the same favour.

Maybe in future I should go down on my knees, put my hands together, and say
"Please my most blessed DiL, would you do me the massive favour of making me one of your delicious Tiramasu's, as I am having FiL's brother and wife over for supper on Wednesday, and when I mentioned your wonderful pudding to them they almost drooled. Of course Dad and I will pay for the very expensive ingredients and for any electricity used, and of course we will pay you top dollar for your time. You are of course very welcome to come as well, but then you must know by now that you are always welcome, no invitations necessary. However, I do think I should warn you that my dear BiL isn't exactly the most scintillating company, and his dear wife always brings her crochet with her, even doing it and talking about it throughout any meals at the dinner table - in fact I'm surprised she didn't bring it to your Wedding reception..."

I noticed OP that she did ask your DH if he wanted to go. Unfortunately (IMO), one of the few things wrong with the English language is that unlike many other Latin based languages we don't have a plural 'you', so if your MiL said to her dear son "would you like to come, she almost certainly meant both of you(s)!"

NB I mean this light-heartedly, no serious sarcasm meant - which is just as well as I am not very good at it!

NB2 - to anyone reading this: I know that the English Language is not solely a Latin based language. There is also a large ancient Greek influence, some norse, some Indian, we also adopted a few of Shakespears made up words, and there might even be some double Dutch for all I know.

It really is time I was asleep, so sleep tight, and don't let those pesky mainland European bed bugs bite.

HoppingPavlova · 14/11/2023 02:52

So our relationship is not very friendly. She mostly communicates with DH. If I call her she normally rushes me off the phone and keeps the convo as short as possible. Not nice vibes from her at all. She doesnt come into my house she will stand outside. Its a strained relationship. Previous to this request i havent spoken to her or seen her for a few weeks

In this case, hell would have frozen over before I made a dessert.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 14/11/2023 02:07

I would have taken being asked to bring a dish as an invite.

SurelySmartie · 14/11/2023 01:07

What an odd situation all round really.
And what on Earth is this dessert???

HerRoyalNotness · 14/11/2023 01:00

Is it too late to send her an invoice?

id only do it if I was otherwise friendly with MIL and I am mine. But she’d never be so rude to ask

JMSA · 14/11/2023 00:52

disappearingfish · 13/11/2023 21:46

Outrageously rude.

Like, how? Confused

JMSA · 14/11/2023 00:51

I would be happy to do this as a favour IF the relationship was good, and if helping each other out was reciprocal.
I definitely wouldn't expect an invitation! That's bitter and petty.

IMarchToADifferentDrummer · 14/11/2023 00:40

In future you could just say you'd forgotten the recipe, for that and everything else. Or tell her to ask her DS!!

Crumpleton · 14/11/2023 00:26

She mostly communicates with DH.

No...not on at all.
If MIL can't be bothered to speak to me herself I'd take every message that's given via DH as her just having a chat with him and take her wondering, as in I wonder if Happbee would make a pudding, as just the same.

Mumof2teens79 · 14/11/2023 00:00

Happbee · 13/11/2023 21:56

So our relationship is not very friendly. She mostly communicates with DH. If I call her she normally rushes me off the phone and keeps the convo as short as possible. Not nice vibes from her at all. She doesnt come into my house she will stand outside. Its a strained relationship. Previous to this request i havent spoken to her or seen her for a few weeks.

It's interesting that you say "my house"
I like my MIL, I think we get on quite well, and have known her 20yrs, but I would never call her unless an emergency and she rarely calls me, and I haven't seen her for 2 months easily but she has seen OH and kids.....so in some ways your relationship seems about right, she asks you favours, you do talk on phone, she comes to your house.
How do the conversations go on the doorstep, do you invite her does your OH invite her?

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 13/11/2023 23:57

Lieblingsessen · 13/11/2023 23:19

The MIL didn't ask a family member to make the dessert. The MIL will barely speak to the OP and refuses to enter the OP's house.

Instead the MIL asks her son to ask his wife to make a dessert for her.

The MIL was just plain rude in not asking the OP directly. OP, seems to hope that by doing the favour, her MIL's ice barrier would start to melt. But unfortunately that is not the case.

Here we go again......... It doesn't matter who MIL asked, or whether she speaks to OP or not. OP agreed to make the dessert, knew she wouldn't be able to go to the event, and yet still she whines. She had a choice, make the dessert or not. She was never going to be able to attend the event in any case, so why be so hurt that she wasn't invited. I didn't get on particularly well with my MIL. If she had asked my DH to ask me to make a dessert I would have either made it, handed it over, end of. Or I would come up with a reason why I couldn't do it, end of. It's quite simple really.

As I said, I am so pleased I have a stress free life by not obsessing over these silly little things.

penjil · 13/11/2023 23:52

GetBackIntoBed · 13/11/2023 23:47

Then you are an absolute nutter for making it.

No sympathy from me - if you are going to be so wimpish then it is your fault

This.

penjil · 13/11/2023 23:51

Happbee · 13/11/2023 21:56

So our relationship is not very friendly. She mostly communicates with DH. If I call her she normally rushes me off the phone and keeps the convo as short as possible. Not nice vibes from her at all. She doesnt come into my house she will stand outside. Its a strained relationship. Previous to this request i havent spoken to her or seen her for a few weeks.

Well, then, you've been a mug.

You should've told her or DH that you didn't have time. Or just plainly said no.

Your DH is partly to blame here too.

Avoidingsleep · 13/11/2023 23:50

Who were the guests? Were they a group of her friends, or a group of mutual acquaintances? Also, how did she ask? Was it a “can you make a dessert for a dinner party?” or a “I’m having some friends around for a dinner party, would you mind making a cake for me?”.

If it was friends and she made it clear when asking then I don’t think she was in the wrong.

If it was mutual acquaintances then she was unkind not to extend an invitation.

DoubleTime · 13/11/2023 23:50

Has she called you to thank you?

GetBackIntoBed · 13/11/2023 23:47

Then you are an absolute nutter for making it.

No sympathy from me - if you are going to be so wimpish then it is your fault

Lifeinlists · 13/11/2023 23:46

Never mind your MiL @Happbee your DH is as much the problem here.

Is he scared of her by any chance? Sounds like it, or else he's a total wimp. Sort him out first. Remind him his first loyalty is now to you, he didn't marry his mother, and there's to be no more playing at The Go Between.

Meanwhile tell your MiL there will be no more favours until she treats you as a) an adult and b) a welcome member of the family.

Alternatively, PPs idea of adding laxatives sounds like a plan!

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 13/11/2023 23:38

Fucking weird

SandyWaves · 13/11/2023 23:34

I actually do not see a problem here.

Your MIL asked you to make a dessert. You could have said no.

You say the dinner party was mid week and you wouldn't have gone anyway.

You were helping her out.

Does she do anything for you..babysit, do you go round and she makes dinner for you or the kids, does she ask about your kids, how old is she?

Can people do something nice from the good of their heart without expecting some sort of payback for family?

PassMeTheCookies · 13/11/2023 23:34

Am I understanding correctly, in that MIL had a dinner party, she asked if you'd make a dessert for it, your DH wasn't invited either but when dropping off, he was invited in to stay, and you were home with the kids who were in bed so couldn't have gone anyway?

This'd be a non-issue for me. I do a lot of baking. DP's friends/family will often ask if I'll do a tray of brownies/cookies/blondies. If when he was dropping them off, he was invited in to their house whilst I was at home, I genuinely wouldn't bat an eyelid.

Canisaysomething · 13/11/2023 23:27

Is this downtown abbey and you’re the cook downstairs and she’s the lady of the manor?

I can’t see why else you would make someone a desert for a party you aren’t going to. It’s SO odd.

AdoraBell · 13/11/2023 23:26

YANBU in the least.

Lastchancechica · 13/11/2023 23:24

Next time tell her you are too busy. CF mil! Unbelievable that you actually made it op. I would have put laxatives in the dessert 🤣🤣

Lieblingsessen · 13/11/2023 23:19

ithinkthatmaybeimdreaming · 13/11/2023 22:57

This. I can't see what is so rude about asking a family member to help out with something, and as you couldn't have gone, and she presumably knew this, what is the problem??

I would hate to live the way so many on MN do, taking offence at every little thing. You could easily have told her you didn't have time to make the dessert if you didn't want to do it.

Edited

The MIL didn't ask a family member to make the dessert. The MIL will barely speak to the OP and refuses to enter the OP's house.

Instead the MIL asks her son to ask his wife to make a dessert for her.

The MIL was just plain rude in not asking the OP directly. OP, seems to hope that by doing the favour, her MIL's ice barrier would start to melt. But unfortunately that is not the case.

Swipe left for the next trending thread