Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Made dessert but not invited....

188 replies

Happbee · 13/11/2023 21:39

Hi

I just wanted to find out some other opinions. The short story is my MIL had a dinner party. She asked me (via my husband at first) if I could make dessert for it. So I made the dessert and my husband took it round. However, I didnt receive an invite to come. I wouldnt have gone anyway as I have kids and it would be past their bedtime (on a school night). But AIBU to think its rude to ask someone to make a dessert but not invite them to come? My husband doesnt see the problem so wanted to know if anyone else sees my POV.

OP posts:
Nanny0gg · 15/11/2023 19:55

pphammer · 15/11/2023 18:29

I'm sure you were part of your husband's invite.

Then he should have communicated that to the OP

pphammer · 15/11/2023 18:29

I'm sure you were part of your husband's invite.

YDBear · 15/11/2023 18:26

The problem is with your DH. If he was putting you first, as he should, and he knows you and the MIL don’t get on, he should have made an excuse for why you couldn’t do it. At the very least he should have said “I’m not sure she’s free for dinner that night, I’ll have to ask” thereby implying that attending the dinner was a condition of providing the dish. It would have been interesting to see if the MIL had the brass face to then say you weren’t invited, she just wanted the dish. I suspect she would just make an excuse about being able to source it elsewhere.

sensationalsally · 15/11/2023 18:25

Not the least bit unreasonable.In fact, it's flattering to be asked - she obviously thinks your desserts are great.

BarelyCoping123 · 15/11/2023 17:55

Initially I didnt want to make it. But DH would be upset if I refused...I suppose as some have said I could have said "no". But in the long run would have probably caused more strain on the relationship tbh and I dont want to be so outright petty.

Wtf OP. Just say no. It's not being petty. You are being treated like crap by MIL and "D"H. You obviously see that it's wrong, as you've come on here to discuss it.

Jellytot1234 · 15/11/2023 14:50

I kind of feel like if my partner was invited that the invite included me automatically? Perhaps it’s you that has read the whole situation incorrectly?

Dontsayyouloveme · 15/11/2023 10:55

Just me desperate to know what the dessert actually is? 🤤

Whyamiherenow · 15/11/2023 10:48

I think it depends on your relationship. I’m very close to my mother in law. I’ve known her since I was 11. She comes to our house for a meal 2-3 times a week. I know she finds cooking very stressful. If she has friends / relatives to stay, I will always try and give her a whole or part of a dinner party to ease the pressure eg a dessert / a main / a starter etc. but that is something I want to do to help her. My mum also does the same to help her - we live in a small one street town so geographically close - and mum and I don’t mind cooking.

I am sure my mum will have made a portion of a dinner party for me and I’ve not been invited before.

Conversely my mother in law does all my sewing and any stain removal from the kiddos clothes that I just can’t manage. She also does childcare for us at the drop of a hat.

But the difference is we all get along well and want to help each other where we can.

If it is a strained relationship then it is potentially a bit rude / mean. But as a general making a dessert for a dinner party you aren’t invited to - it probably isn’t rude.

Catlady1978 · 15/11/2023 10:07

@Happbee out of interest what made you make it given the relationship with your MIL? My MIL doesn’t speak to me and my children and due to her behaviour is no longer welcome in my house. I’ve bent over backwards to accommodate the FIL and MIL but I’ve decided I’ve had enough. They haven’t seen my kids in over 2 years out of their choice, not mine. Let her make her own dessert in future!

Eleganz · 15/11/2023 08:58

It always amazes me how people acquiesce to such breathtaking arrogance and rudeness. Paying in time and money to make food for an event you were not invited to is horrendous. Surely "sorry I'm too busy" is the most polite response to be expected of such a request?

I suspect this is not MIL's first offence. But if you let her get away with it you normalise it.

HalebiHabibti · 15/11/2023 08:31

I can see the awkwardness here OP, and realistically you'd have been lambasted as the rude one if you'd declined. In future I think I'd establish the date/time and then ask up front "Am I invited please? Only I was thinking about last time and it seemed a little strange to be preparing a dish for an event I wasn't invited to." Then see what they say. They can't really say it isn't odd, because it is odd!

Tonight1 · 15/11/2023 08:26

I'd feel a little hurt as she should have made it clear it was as a favour as she was overwhelmed/you're very good at desserts/whatever.

You know what to say next time though: NO. Especially as she's not been particularly friendly towards you.

Nolongerlight · 15/11/2023 08:22

I would have assumed that being asked to make a desert WAS the invite.

Are you absolutely sure you were excluded from the invite.

Drpawpawspaw · 15/11/2023 08:18

Happbee · 13/11/2023 21:56

So our relationship is not very friendly. She mostly communicates with DH. If I call her she normally rushes me off the phone and keeps the convo as short as possible. Not nice vibes from her at all. She doesnt come into my house she will stand outside. Its a strained relationship. Previous to this request i havent spoken to her or seen her for a few weeks.

I would decline any further requests to cater for her guests in that case!

dhworry · 15/11/2023 05:14

If your husband was going round then surely he should have made the dessert?

I wouldn't be annoyed they asked. But I wouldn't have done it.

YerArseInParsley · 15/11/2023 02:12

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 14/11/2023 03:04

This. Absolutely.

She probably thinks of you as family @Happbee.

I know that I do with my DC's partners/spouses. They all get treated as near as dammit possible, in exactly the same way as those I gave birth to. I love them so much, and before reading Mumsnet AIBU threads, I would have expected them to understand that I was asking them for a favour because I really enjoyed their 'cooking' - in this particular case. I would ask that of my daughter - if she could make such tasty desserts - and would not think it was any different to ask my DiL for the same favour.

Maybe in future I should go down on my knees, put my hands together, and say
"Please my most blessed DiL, would you do me the massive favour of making me one of your delicious Tiramasu's, as I am having FiL's brother and wife over for supper on Wednesday, and when I mentioned your wonderful pudding to them they almost drooled. Of course Dad and I will pay for the very expensive ingredients and for any electricity used, and of course we will pay you top dollar for your time. You are of course very welcome to come as well, but then you must know by now that you are always welcome, no invitations necessary. However, I do think I should warn you that my dear BiL isn't exactly the most scintillating company, and his dear wife always brings her crochet with her, even doing it and talking about it throughout any meals at the dinner table - in fact I'm surprised she didn't bring it to your Wedding reception..."

I noticed OP that she did ask your DH if he wanted to go. Unfortunately (IMO), one of the few things wrong with the English language is that unlike many other Latin based languages we don't have a plural 'you', so if your MiL said to her dear son "would you like to come, she almost certainly meant both of you(s)!"

NB I mean this light-heartedly, no serious sarcasm meant - which is just as well as I am not very good at it!

NB2 - to anyone reading this: I know that the English Language is not solely a Latin based language. There is also a large ancient Greek influence, some norse, some Indian, we also adopted a few of Shakespears made up words, and there might even be some double Dutch for all I know.

It really is time I was asleep, so sleep tight, and don't let those pesky mainland European bed bugs bite.

Oh, I think you're very good at sarcasm. Infact it's a bit of a C reply. Not all families are like yours, not all MILs like their DIL the same way as you. If your going to post a shitty comment then own it!

Maybe in future I should go down on my knees, put my hands together, and say
"Please my most blessed DiL, would you do me the massive favour of making me one of your delicious Tiramasu's, as I am having FiL's brother and wife over for supper on Wednesday, and when I mentioned your wonderful pudding to them they almost drooled. Of course Dad and I will pay for the very expensive ingredients and for any electricity used, and of course we will pay you top dollar for your time. You are of course very welcome to come as well, but then you must know by now that you are always welcome, no invitations necessary. However, I do think I should warn you that my dear BiL isn't exactly the most scintillating company, and his dear wife always brings her crochet with her, even doing it and talking about it throughout any meals at the dinner table - in fact I'm surprised she didn't bring it to your Wedding reception..."

NB I mean this light-heartedly, no serious sarcasm meant - which is just as well as I am not very good at it!

YerArseInParsley · 15/11/2023 01:52

@Happbee

Can you please tell us who was at the dinner party as quite a few people have asked and it's never been answered.

Also, you say DH was invited as it was happening. What do you mean by this? Did MIL call him and ask him to come round or did she invite him to stay when he was already there dropping off the pudding?

Doing a family member a favour like this is acceptable and I wouldn't ask my mum etc for the money for the ingredients but she would offer and thank me and that makes the difference.

It's different if you don't get on with MIL and especially since she won't set foot in your home and she's no time for you on the phone, it's kind of rude to be expecting favours from you when she's no time for you. Did she call and thank you for the pudding at least? I suspect not but you haven't told us.

I'm assuming your husband has noticed yous don't get on, does he ask his mum why she doesn't come into your home? Do you ask her at the time why she isn't coming in?

I don't think you should be offended you weren't invited, it's a normal thing to ask for a favour but if DH was invited anyway then I'd think differently about it. I do think she had the cheek to ask for this favour when she's no time for you and I wouldn't be doing it again. If you have no time for me you have no time for my pudding.

As for DH, let him be annoyed when you refuse to do his mum a favour. You shouldn't need excuses but next time a favour is asked you can say no your last favour was shown no appreciation. If your still going to be a doormat say sure, tell your mum to give me a call direct with her requirements.

Oh...and stand up for yourself!!

Findinganewme · 14/11/2023 23:32

If it’s a dinner party for her friends, colleagues, or another group that you wouldn’t be part of…eg her siblings or cousins, then it makes sense that you’re not invited. If you’re husband is invited, as his wife, you should be invited too. Unless there’s a really good reason?

I would make something for my mum, if she was hosting for her friends or sisters only, without expecting an invitation to their thing. It doesn’t seem however, like you have that sort of relationship with her, so it does seem odd.

the thing is, why doesn’t your husband see any of this?

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 14/11/2023 22:16

You could add some foraged mushrooms?

… just a thought 😉

SurelySmartie · 14/11/2023 20:22

Is it the Delia Smith Amaretti chocolate cake?

Mamabear48 · 14/11/2023 20:15

Why would you assume you weren’t invited? If my OH got invited to his parents I would automatically be invited even without being asked

AngelAurora · 14/11/2023 19:54

Well you could of said No, you could not go anyway, so why is it an issue? You choose to make it?

TeaGinandFags · 14/11/2023 19:43

IF you make another dessert make sure that YOU'RE the one to deliver it, otherwise it's possible that DH not only offered the dessert but was already invited. As the cook you should be present to accept the adulation. MIL will then get to thank you in person.

The next time someone offers your services to others, let them do the work. DH znd MIL seem to be taking the piss.

OhYeahOhYeah · 14/11/2023 18:58

Happbee · 13/11/2023 21:43

No my husband paid for the ingredients

Wow, that’s cheeky!

‘Yep, sure I’ll make dessert and I’ll only charge you 95% customer cost!’

Luxell934 · 14/11/2023 14:49

Who was invited to the dinner party? I’m assuming MILs friends so I don’t really see a problem with her asking you to make a dessert that she obviously really enjoys. It actually seems like you really don’t like the woman so why would you have even wanted to be invited to this dinner party?! Especially if it was all her friends and you say you have a strained relationship? I doubt you would have gone even if she had invited you.

Your husband wasn’t invited either, she probably just said your welcome to join us when he dropped off the dessert as a customary gesture and she would have probably extended the same customary gesture to you if you had been the one to drop it off.

Not sure why you’re acting like you’re baffled why you didn’t get an invite surely you knew you weren’t and you husband weren’t going when he asked you to make the dessert.

You say she “asked” your husband if you could make it, I’m assuming she didn’t demand it from you, you had a choice to make the dessert or not. For all you know your husband could have offered your dessert making services to her!

Swipe left for the next trending thread