Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to pay for her lunch? DD is 5

471 replies

prideinmystrides · 13/11/2023 20:25

Okay so DD is in Reception class

A classmate's mum had a cake taken in for her (I have done the same and they all seem to really enjoy it! It's a small village school with only 14 kids)

My DD apparently took an extra slice. As reported to this girls mum by her own daughter, the birthday girl

DD was invited over for birthday tea, cake and play. They were going to a trampoline park on Saturday to celebrate properly

The girls mum has messaged to say

'Hi, it was lovely having L round. She's very sweet. Would you please transfer me £20? We got pizzas in but she said she doesn't eat the ones we had so we got her the one she wanted'

AIBU not to transfer her? I have already spoken to DD and asked if she said she wouldn't eat the pizzas the woman had got? She said she wouldn't, because she put sweetcorn on one, and anchovies on the other one?

I haven't asked the woman if this information is true or not, but DD was very matter of fact and just said she couldn't eat it.

I have already explained to her that she was better off just picking those toppings off as it is quite rude fo ask for a separate pizza. She got a little bit embarrassed, seemed to take this on board and just said 'Okay mummy'

AIBU though not to transfer this? I replied that I hadn't realised I needed to send her with cash, and was about to type something else when she said 'you didn't, but I just didn't expect to buy another pizza'

OP posts:
Zone2NorthLondon · 13/11/2023 21:20

Hell no. Don’t pay the mum is rinsing it.Usual to include a margarita pizza just to have a regular option eg not meat,not out there toppings.
At the party she could have offered up cake ,sweeties, and told your dd to eat at home. Ordering another pizza and charging you is not on.

presumably other kids got to share this additional pizza, are their mums being charged too?

However,these petty disagreements can become full on mafia style gripes if not properly managed. Try deescalate and see if she’s still expecting you to fully pony up. People can get funny about minor disagreements and then shun or exclude child or parent

Katbum · 13/11/2023 21:20

Really? This seems strange -
sure the cake thing is naughty, but she’s five and trying her luck. But to not eat something she doesn’t like (anchovy flavour is strong and will taint the pizza) seems fair enough to me. When my stepdaughter who is 6 comes over she quite often doesn’t like what I have cooked and we just make her something she likes. I wouldn’t expect an adult to eat something they didn’t want out of politeness, let alone get annoyed at a child for it!

Gillypie23 · 13/11/2023 21:21

How much was the pizza ffd!

CatsTheWayToDoIt · 13/11/2023 21:21

I’d pay - and never send my kid to her house again. But I’d pay so we could be civil, as in such a tiny cohort you don’t want anyone you have to avoid.

travelallthetime · 13/11/2023 21:22

Nope dont pay it. In what world does a cheese pizza cost £20. Nope. At the weekend I got my kids a pizza each, large chips and a chocolate cake £22.60.
Send her a message: Hi, sorry dd didnt like the pizza, not sure many 5 years olds would go for those flavours haha! Not sure where you are getting a cheese pizza for £20 though, seems a lot, assuming she didnt eat it all, given she normally struggles to eat half a pizza, although she didnt come home with any of the leftovers?

Mamabear2424 · 13/11/2023 21:23

im amazed people are saying pay, no way would I!!! From when my kids were that age i'd normally ask the parent if there's anything they dont like, usually a margarita pizza is safe, but anchovies ???? weird

Fairospop22 · 13/11/2023 21:24

£20 for an individual pizza? That’s ridiculous. Why don’t they order plain ones? Sound a bit pretentious to me, I hardly know any adults who will eat anchovies never mind 5 year olds

Fairospop22 · 13/11/2023 21:25

Did your daughter eat the whole £20 pizza, doubt it!!

BadBarry · 13/11/2023 21:25

If you invite a child over for dinner or out to dinner you pay - bizarre that they would invite and then send the bill.
She's 5 years old - most 5 year olds are picky eaters, if I were them I'd have checked what she liked before ordering the ones to share.
I'd pay just to have an easy life but they are extremely rude to ask you for the money.

Supersimkin2 · 13/11/2023 21:25

Party mum might not be used to children who don’t just eat whatever there is on the table they like.

That’s the trouble here - most DC managed fine.

£20 is not steep in London, sadly.

Asking for another pizza is CF of DD - not that she knew. She should know.

Suggest you pay up and send her with a sandwich next time.

(I wouldn’t have bought another pizza, I’d have given DD toast. Too much to do at a party to devote time to every food refuser, we’d all have sat there till midnight.)

tachetastic · 13/11/2023 21:25

momonpurpose · 13/11/2023 21:12

I'd be really irritated if my dd took a extra piece of cake then didn't just pick the toppings off. I wouldn't asked you for the 20 but this mum did. Pay the money. I'd also remind dd not to do this before the next party

You can't pick anchovies off a cooked pizza and the pizza not still taste of anchovies.

I do get that kids need to learn that in life there are times when you need to suck up, but is it that bad if sometimes they say they don't like something?

Kleinocsky · 13/11/2023 21:26

I'd be tempted to invite the other kid and serve up boiled kale and feta with truffles or smt then call for most expensive alternative in town. But yeah just a fantasy, couldn't do that to a kid, so I'd pay and avoid the weirdo.
Might ask for a receipt though.

YourNameGoesHere · 13/11/2023 21:27

Supersimkin2 · 13/11/2023 21:25

Party mum might not be used to children who don’t just eat whatever there is on the table they like.

That’s the trouble here - most DC managed fine.

£20 is not steep in London, sadly.

Asking for another pizza is CF of DD - not that she knew. She should know.

Suggest you pay up and send her with a sandwich next time.

(I wouldn’t have bought another pizza, I’d have given DD toast. Too much to do at a party to devote time to every food refuser, we’d all have sat there till midnight.)

Most children of 5 do not manage fine eating a pizza with anchovies or sweetcorn on it, neither do most adults. Honestly why are posters so keen to paint this perfectly normal 5 yet old as fussy!

InWalksBarberalla · 13/11/2023 21:27

I don't think anchovies is super weird. It's probably what her 5 year old likes, and my DC have loved anchovies on pizzas since they were tiny. What is weird is not checking what the guest 5 year old likes before ordering pizzas and just assuming they'll like the families usuals.

Katbum · 13/11/2023 21:28

What? I live in Forest Hill and the artisan sourdough pizza place charges £15 for a large pizza with porchini mushrooms and truffles! £20 for a kids margarita? You can get a kids 3 course meal at most places for under £10!

Bellyblueboy · 13/11/2023 21:28

You could always be very passive aggressive and text back

’my five year old demanded £20 worth of pizza?? I am absolutely mortified and astonished. While I will of course reimburse you I am gobsmacked that she had such bad manners and thought she could possibly eat that much. I hope she didn’t eat an extra large family sized pizza to herself - if she did we are in for a very uncomfortable night! I think this has taught me she is too young for play dates.’

WilmaWonka · 13/11/2023 21:29

So your DD was the only guest invited from outside the family?

In which case surely you’d ask what pizza she liked before ordering (different if there’s loads of 5 year olds who all love anchovies 🤔and they didn’t realise your DD didn’t like them). Even so if she’s invited to a birthday tea, you wouldn’t expect to pay for it!

Sounds like she only ordered what her family eats with no thought for your DD. Absolutely ridiculous and no way would I hand over £20!

I’d respond that it was unfortunate she didn’t check what your DD eats as if she had told you she was ordering anchovy pizzas, you’d have sent your DD with her own pizza which would have cost a darn sight less than £20. She should have called you to check if you agreed to paying her for it before she ordered it and you didn’t.

I wouldn’t give a toss about keeping it friendly. She’s the one being the cheeky fucker and obviously has no shame. Just tell everyone what happened if she starts anything at the school gate. They’ll think she’s batshit.

momonpurpose · 13/11/2023 21:29

tachetastic · 13/11/2023 21:25

You can't pick anchovies off a cooked pizza and the pizza not still taste of anchovies.

I do get that kids need to learn that in life there are times when you need to suck up, but is it that bad if sometimes they say they don't like something?

I respect your opinion but not changing mine. Have a great day!

Cantbeardarknights · 13/11/2023 21:29

Why on earth didn’t she offer her some toast or something or take it away and pick the toppings off for her. Madness

tachetastic · 13/11/2023 21:30

And what's the issue that she took an extra slice of cake?

If I sent cake in I'd be happy if someone took an extra slice if it was a sign they enjoyed it and so there wasn't any cake wasted. If a child took six slices so others went without then that would be different, but sure, take an extra slice.

Eva90 · 13/11/2023 21:31

Please can we have an update OP I'm dying to know what goes down with this anchovy pizza topping lunatic 😄

Supersimkin2 · 13/11/2023 21:31

I don’t know a single kid who hates anchovies! Cultural, innit 😀

I worked with a man who had a phobia of green olives 🫒. He truly thought they were ‘sinister’, blanched at the sight and had to leave the room. Interesting office parties.

GetBackIntoBed · 13/11/2023 21:32

mangoallergy · 13/11/2023 20:56

Did she finish the whole pizza? Or did the other mum packed the leftover for your Dd to take home? As she's charging you the whole thing

That is what I was thinking - NO WAY a 5 year old ate a whole £20 pizza!

So I would tongue in cheek be saying "of course - will send the money over. Cant wait to finish off the leftovers as she only usually eats about a quarter 😂"

prideinmystrides · 13/11/2023 21:32

Supersimkin2 · 13/11/2023 21:31

I don’t know a single kid who hates anchovies! Cultural, innit 😀

I worked with a man who had a phobia of green olives 🫒. He truly thought they were ‘sinister’, blanched at the sight and had to leave the room. Interesting office parties.

She loves them in oil. Just not on pizza. She loves olives and garlic cloves in oil too!

She isn't generally fussy. At all.

OP posts:
GigiAnnna · 13/11/2023 21:32

Very rude and strange of her to ask you to pay. Who the hell does that? If they just wanted their anchovy pizzas they could have just not invited your daughter as they must have known most 5 year old aren't going to eat that. I would probably pay but then have nothing to do with her out of school and decline future invitations for your daughter.