Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Restaurant maître d' talking about us to other customers

234 replies

heynow1111 · 13/11/2023 11:19

Went out for a meal with husband to a nice restaurant and booking was 1.5 hours. I am a slow eater and we were having a lovely time chatting so I wasn't clock watching.

In retrospect Maître d'/head waiter was hovering when I was close to finishing and I should have perhaps read this as they were rushing us to finish but I was so enjoying the meal and company I didn't register at the time.

Finished meal and Maître d'/head waiter said (in other words can't remember exactly) "sorry I've been waiting for you to finish, I didn't know what to do". I know they said sorry but you know when from someone's tone they are NOT sorry and what they said was more to point out you had annoyed them? At the time I felt really awkward and embarrassed like I should have been tracking the time or something? So I apologised.

After this had happened husband said that PRIOR to this, he had seen Maître d' talking behind their hand whilst looking at us and saying sorry. So talking about us whilst we were at that point totally unaware we had gone over time.

I think this could have been better managed by when we were coming close to end of our booking, saying excuse me, just to let you know you are coming to the end of your booking as we have another table at X time? I would have thought oh sh** and rushed up!

I completely get it must be annoying when customers go over on bookings and it must be complex coordinating everything but i thought it was handled unprofessionally. Just tell us you need the table now/soon rather than talking about us behind our backs to other customers and then informing us after the fact that we had 'held up' a booking? AIBU?

OP posts:
CynicalOne · 13/11/2023 14:24

I know a fella who has a very prestige* *job in hospitality and he has to coordinate bookings, timings, etc., for extremely wealthy people (think Beckham type wealth or the Waleses), who have no concept of time whilst dining/relaxing, and he would think it extremely gauche to "hover" around the table or allow one of the wait staff to do so!

I've seen him very adeptly "hurry" people up without appearing too (if it's an event like a concert that he's in charge of, so he hss to keep people moving) and he's a bloody marvel and well loved by the clientele he serves and the company he works for! He gets 5 figure sums for organising Christmas Day lunches, as well as food and gifts, and his services for private functions are very sought after.

If only he could give me a drop of his tact...

RainySummer · 13/11/2023 14:13

TudorBeckham · 13/11/2023 13:52

Total non-event. This sort of thing happens multiple times a day in restaurants. Normally an experienced waiter can manage to get you out without you even realising you’ve been managed. Perhaps this guy was new.

Anyway, not worth another second’s thought.

I agree with this. I think you’re getting a bit of a hard time OP. Restaurants with online booking systems often give a slot (usually 2 hours) but they don’t always need the table back in that time (I’m sure in that situation they’d rather you stayed and continued spending money ordering more coffees and drinks, than rushing off just because your time’s up). I wouldn’t clock-watch if I was out to enjoy a nice meal, but when I’ve been to busy restaurants that are fully booked with quick turnarounds, in my experience the staff manage it very efficiently without you even realising.

Lemevoir · 13/11/2023 14:08

The maitre d' could definitely have handled it differently.

And I agree that 1.5 hours in a restaurant is nothing, esp if the meal is the event, i.e. not a quick fuel stop on a long journey or before going to the cinema or theatre etc.

It's quite normal for 15 minutes to be given to peruse the menu and allow for the diners to have a chat, then another 15 minutes before any food is brought out at all.

That's a third of the time gone. Then at the other end of the meal it can take an absolute age for dessert menus to be brought out and then for the bill to be settled.

I know people are saying that the OP shouldn't have agreed to the 90 minute booking, but I think it's unreasonable for restaurants to have such short slots in the first place.

I had an almost two hour lunch the other day with a couple of friends I haven't seen for ages - two hot drinks and a sandwich and the time flew by. And that was in a coffee shop. Not a restaurant with a maitre d'.

KatBurglar · 13/11/2023 14:00

People are conflating all sorts of restaurant. We don't know the type the OP was in, so we can't judge if 90 minutes was unreasonable (for a normal person, not someone who eats their dinner when it's gone cold)

Pizza Express? rarely there more than an hour.

The Black Swan At Oldstead? there for the whole night.

MrsRachelDanvers · 13/11/2023 13:56

I get why people say it’s unreasonable to eat a meal in 90 minutes-but I also assume they had the choice not to book it-it’s always made clear when you book that there’s a time limit. It’s totally unreasonable to agree to the booking and then get annoyed when they’ve run over and due to the chat didn’t notice.

Mylovelygreendress · 13/11/2023 13:54

The issue isn’t whether or not 1.5 hours is sufficient time to eat a meal . The point is that she and her husband were aware of that restaurant’s policy yet still overstayed . If you don’t want a time slot , don’t go to a restaurant which operates one !

TudorBeckham · 13/11/2023 13:52

Total non-event. This sort of thing happens multiple times a day in restaurants. Normally an experienced waiter can manage to get you out without you even realising you’ve been managed. Perhaps this guy was new.

Anyway, not worth another second’s thought.

XiCi · 13/11/2023 13:48

Jesus christ 1.5 hours in a restuarant

It wasn't McDonalds. Once you're seated you have to have time to look over the menu, make your choices, orders have to go into the kitchen etc. You dont just sit down, get a plate of food put in front of you and start chomping away.

We were in a restaurant on Friday night that had a 1.5 hr time limit and left bang on time but only had mains, desserts/coffee and a couple of drinks. We knew we had to be somewhere after the meal so didnt mind the time slot. However, if we had wanted something more, a 3 course meal with aperitifs, wine etc would take much longer. Who wants to pay restaurant prices to be rushed out of their seat instead of enjoying a good meal?

The maitre d' sounds like he has no people skills whatsoever. There are plenty of ways he could have let OP know that they needed the table back without being rude. He's probably cost the restaurant future business as I doubt the OP will be rushing back after that experience.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/11/2023 13:47

"If we value the restaurant industry, accepting such small measure that help keep them viable seems perfectly reasonable."

We can do what we want with our own money. If I've taken 30-45 minutes to travel somewhere I'm not going home after an hour and a half with no pudding.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/11/2023 13:45

"any decent restaurant. 2+ hrs at a minimum would be acceptable. Although any nice restaurant I’ve been to in the last few years hasn’t had a time limit!"

Exactly. What kind of places are these? Even with pub meals you don't get rushed out.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/11/2023 13:44

"How on earth do you manage with lunch breaks at work?"

Going to a restaurant is nothing like eating your salad or sandwich in your lunch break FFS.

Greatbigfluffytrousers · 13/11/2023 13:42

I feel a bit sorry for the maitre d’ if he doesn’t know what to do when a table is over running, it’s a pretty standard part of the job. It sounds like he didn’t know what to do because he realised he should have been on it enough to realise when the next booking was and that you should have been reminded of this before it was too late (I assume they did make it clear when you were seated). Probably realised he might get bollocked for not managing the flow of customers properly.

MarmitePizza · 13/11/2023 13:35

SisterMichaelsHabit · 13/11/2023 11:28

Jesus christ 1.5 hours in a restuarant? Didn't you have a watch or a clock on your phone or any sense of time that it was taking a lot longer to eat than usual? How on earth do you manage with lunch breaks at work? During Covid they gave people 45 min slots. That's an entire booking for the table they've lost!

And no it's not the restaurant staff's job to tell you to leave. In fact they are explicitly not supposed to do this as it is construed as rude.

He was probably apologising to the people who booked a table and couldn't have it for 30-45 minutes because you were sitting there, and instead of feeling bad you're wondering if you should choose to be offended about this?

Have you ever been to a proper restaurant? 1.5 hours is nothing!!

YoKookoY · 13/11/2023 13:35

AgentProvocateur · 13/11/2023 11:32

1.5 hours for dinner at a nice restaurant is unreasonable. Aperitifs, starters, mains, bottle of wine, coffee…

I refuse to go to places where they give you a time limit.

I agree that 1 and 1/2 hours is too short. 2 hours is ok though. I don't think the waiter saying sorry to the other customer counts as talking about you though. He was just saying sorry that the table wasn't ready surely??

Tawlk · 13/11/2023 13:32

KatBurglar · 13/11/2023 12:39

All those posters saying they wouldn't accept a time limit...

You do know thw sector has been hit very hard and is struggling to keep afloat, don't you? They state when you make a reservation that the table is available for a set period in order to make bookings as efficient as possible.

My experience since the pandemic is that roughly half of restaurants I frequent have a time slot. It's usually 2h, in more casual places 90m. There's often also a deposit to protect against no-shows, which I find perfectly understandable.

If we value the restaurant industry, accepting such small measure that help keep them viable seems perfectly reasonable.

also I think how much you’re spending needs to come into consideration, if it’s a really nice restaurant and spending €200+ on a meal out with my OH I’m not going to be very happy with a 1.5hr slot, 1.5hrs is completely unreasonable in any decent restaurant. 2+ hrs at a minimum would be acceptable. Although any nice restaurant I’ve been to in the last few years hasn’t had a time limit!

ManchesterLu · 13/11/2023 13:32

I don't actually think 1.5hrs is THAT long. By the time you've ordered drinks, ordered and received each course, a lot of time could go by, particularly if they're making food from fresh rather than just microwaving like Wetherspoons etc (nothing against them, I go there all the time!)

christmascrackle · 13/11/2023 13:31

why the heck is everyone giving the OP a hard time about this? what on earth is going on. You can stay as long as you like surely once you've shelled out??

christmascrackle · 13/11/2023 13:30

Jesus do we now have to eat inside a 'booking time' as well as freaking paying an arm and a leg for eating??? Who in the heck is ever going to go out? Is this a new thing?

greenhydrangea · 13/11/2023 13:29

DysmalRadius · 13/11/2023 13:25

That's not at all what happened - the OP has acknowledged that she should have kept track of time better and has been pretty gracious about accepting some fairly robust (and some completely unnecessary IMO) criticism.

She has banged on repeatedly about the maitre d' being "rude" and "passive aggressive" - which to my mind does not gel with owning it.

GCAcademic · 13/11/2023 13:28

BethDuttonsTwin · 13/11/2023 13:24

I was irritated just reading that so goodness how the maitre’d felt!

Being able to handle situations like that is part of his job. If he's irritated rather than being able to deal with it professionally, that means he's pretty crap at his job.

sherloc · 13/11/2023 13:26

Gordon Ramsay often comes across a grumpy, but his people were lovely for five hours!

DysmalRadius · 13/11/2023 13:25

greenhydrangea · 13/11/2023 13:18

Nobody is crucifying anybody. She made a mistake but seems to think the maitre d' made a bigger mistake, and is not in any case owning her mistake.

The other party waiting for their table (which would have needed to be cleared and reset, once OP finally got around to finishing eating, and then paid the bill) are of no significance, apparently.

Edited

That's not at all what happened - the OP has acknowledged that she should have kept track of time better and has been pretty gracious about accepting some fairly robust (and some completely unnecessary IMO) criticism.

greenhydrangea · 13/11/2023 13:25

BethDuttonsTwin · 13/11/2023 13:24

I was irritated just reading that so goodness how the maitre’d felt!

Precisely.

BethDuttonsTwin · 13/11/2023 13:24

I was irritated just reading that so goodness how the maitre’d felt!

Doteycat · 13/11/2023 13:23

Eh which is why I said that if I did I would.
HTH.