Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lying DH... wtf do I do?!

563 replies

CinnamonSwirl82 · 13/11/2023 10:52

Didn't think I'd be putting this one up but here we go. If anyone saw my previous post about finding DH & friend cuddled up on the sofa... surprisingly this isn't the lie I've uncovered but stay tuned because that cat will probably also come out of the bag when he gets his ass home!!

DH has always told me he was in the Army. He comes from a military family (MIL confirmed) so I never saw any reason to doubt. He was apparently injured and discharged, he has scars, but never wanted me to discuss with MIL as she was upset about it all. First 🚩. He'd get upset talking about it, nightmares, tell me about killing kids and constantly talking weapons, military vehicles, etc.

Some things haven't lined up for me and having caught him out lying about when he last had surgery yesterday I decided to ask MIL.

Weellll.... it was all a lie! He's never even been in the Army never mind getting deployed. He doesn't know that I know and I'm wondering how to approach it. I want to ask him if he's got anything to admit to because I know the truth, but then exactly what else will I uncover? Will he get angry? I dunno.

I've just come out of surgery and I'm still healing so I'm fragile in terms of being able to pack his shit and throw it outside. I don't know if I'm ready to admit to anyone yet what's happened and I don't even know who I could call for backup. Do I hide the kitchen knife block just in case? Who is this man that's in my house?!

OP posts:
Baffledandalarmed · 13/11/2023 14:21

Whoopy · 13/11/2023 14:00

Not true. Prince Harry did talk about his service action and gave a total of his “kills.” This wasn’t just speaking to someone, he wrote about it for anyone in the World to know! If he can, others can.

And multiple military personnel who served with Harry have since come out and called him a liar - which proves my point nicely.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 13/11/2023 14:21

Having read your update and details of his violent nature I think you should leave before he comes back
Everything else can be dealt with out of the house
I really don't think it's worth the risk to confront him

Lovemychair · 13/11/2023 14:18

When did you have your surgery, you sound very vulnerable and really shouldn't be confronting him at this stage.

Ell435 · 13/11/2023 14:17

Sorry first time on this app 🙈

FictionalCharacter · 13/11/2023 14:14

I've taken some steps to protect myself when he's home, like moving the ring doorbell to the living room and giving said friend access. I've given her a code word for if I need her to ring the police.
I’m sorry to be blunt but that doesn’t protect you. It doesn’t stop him attacking you, it just allows your friend to watch while he’s doing it, and by the time the police arrive it’s too late.
If you suspect he’ll be violent, the only way to protect yourself is to be away from him.

CinnamonSwirl82 · 13/11/2023 14:14

Volvooo · 13/11/2023 14:09

Is he called Patrick?

No

OP posts:
Spaceracers · 13/11/2023 14:13

I would be looking up solicitors.

thatbigbear · 13/11/2023 14:12

@CinnamonSwirl82 you poor love, way too much to cope with on top of the surgery and the reasons for it.

I divorced a man who was equally good at lying, different lies but the consequence was the same, I could never, ever trust him again once I realised. I agree with PP's, no point in trying to talk to him about it, just get yourself well enough to get out of there, and then divorce his lying arse.

Oh and the house, 2 years is considered a short marriage so don't automatically assume it'll be treated as a marital asset, get yourself a good solicitor (I can recommend someone really good if that would be helpful) and let them help you sort this out.

In the meantime, many (careful) hugs, I know what it's like to discover this level of lying, it leaves a very empty hole where you thought your relationship was. Take very good care of yourself, and don't look back.

Silvers11 · 13/11/2023 14:11

@CinnamonSwirl82 Honestly - given that you are recovering from surgery, I would go to your Mum's right now before he comes home. You are extra vulnerable and from what you have said, you may not have enough time to get help if he turns violent when you call him out on his lies.

DID you ringfence your share of the house? It's perfectly possible to do so. I remarried when I was 40 and I already had a house with a mortgage - my DH was renting. So I own 2/3 of the house and DH owns a 1/3

IMarchToADifferentDrummer · 13/11/2023 14:11

MIL might have been in the dark, too. It was confirmed by her that he comes from a military family, NOT that HE was in the army! So quite possibly his father, g/father, brothers etc, but NOT him!
I expect she'll be very embarrassed as, no doubt, she will be proud of her husband - maybe her family, too - and everyone having served, possibly still serving!

ValerieVomit · 13/11/2023 14:10

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 13/11/2023 11:07

Tell him you are organising a party for all of his army mates and can you have their details. Watch him squirm..
Be prepared for his dm to stand by him imo.

YES! Do this one. Brilliant.

Volvooo · 13/11/2023 14:09

Is he called Patrick?

CinnamonSwirl82 · 13/11/2023 14:06

Does he have his dog tags? Cap badge/beret?
Even ex squaddies who dispised army after kept those

  • No. He told me everything was at his parent's house abroad. I've asked for things like photos, etc, and he's never been able to produce. I've always been sceptical that he was actually military but I didn't want to poke the bear in case he was and he's destroyed everything due to bad memories. It sounds silly but he's always come across as a genuine person and honest so I tried to ignore my gut feel.

So in all the time you have been with him it never came up with his in laws about him being in the army? Even a mention?

  • He told me not to mention it to his mum as it upset her as she didn't want him to go. I've honored that wish but always paid attention to anything she's said regarding the family military background. She was mentioning everyone in the family who had servered when she was here just after surgery and his name never came up. That's when the alarm bells truly started ringing and I've been paying attention to every single detail this past week, hence me ringing MIL this morning.

I agree. OP, I remember your last post and I’m agog you’re still with this man.

  • I agree too :(. I wanted to wait until after surgery and getting my diagnosis and that's just opened my eyes to everything. He can't even respect me when I'm vulernable.

I don’t understand why you’re waiting to hear what he has to say. Who cares what he has to say? He’s a pathological liar and he will no doubt lie about why he lied.

  • I think that was shock speaking. I've had a chat with a close friend and I've realised that, irrelevant of this lie, he's been treating me like shit and it'll never get better. I've taken some steps to protect myself when he's home, like moving the ring doorbell to the living room and giving said friend access. I've given her a code word for if I need her to ring the police. I'm going to relocate the pets to a safe location so he can't hurt them, and put a door stop in my pocket so if I think he'll be violent, I can lock and wedge myself in a room. A small bag is also getting packed if I need to get out. I can't pack his things and throw the suitcase out as I'll end up pulling my stitches.

You should be even more wary about the the fresh onslaught of new lies; poor me; I'm suicidal; yada yada to draw you back in.

  • Saves me doing it :)

Have you considered the very real possibility that he may be a top secret international spy?
Either that or a massive wanker.

  • I think there could actually be a very real possibility that he's a massive wanker.

So for the whole time you’ve been together, including prior to getting married his mother never made a single comment about the life he had before you (in terms of his work for example) that would make it very clear that he had never been in the army and was in fact a plumber?!

  • Stories were mostly about his ex wife, what she did to him. She mentioned jobs he did, which corroborated what he had said, but never anything about the military. MIL absolutely loves a gossip and would tell me the juicy family stories. The military was 3 years of his life, apparently, so everything else he's told me about it matches what his mum has sad.

Get in touch with https://thewaltermittyhuntersclubhq.com/ and drop him in it.

  • Thank you! I will do.

Bcg scar that most people over a certain age have?

  • It's from a young age. Heart issue that needed fixing

Brrr, that's very intimidating. Is there anyone who would take you in? I think it's safest to get away from him as soon as possible.

  • I'm packing a bag and I can turn up at my mother's. She's got space and wouldn't need prior notice.

You could have him request a subject access report SAR via the veterans agency. That will supply a service leaver with a copy of their military service records. Everyone who has served is entitled to make the request. He is correct about having to hand his ID back, but no idea what the book is that he mentioned. Unless it is a record of his trade experience.

  • This is what baffles me. He must have done some really extensive research on it all as he knew so much. When I asked him about his military ID it was because I was trying to catch him out on the lie that he'd served but he came back with that answer. Then when I caught him in another lie about it yesterday that's when it's played on my mind that I had to find out for definite and the only person I could trust wouldn't lie to me would be MIL. I translated the text on the front of the book and it even says 'armed services' so I've no idea how he's got it.

TWMHCHQ - The Walter Mitty Hunters Club HQ | Investigating and Exposing Walter Mittys in the UK | TWMHCHQ - The Walter Mitty Hunters Club HQ

TWMHCHQ - The Walter Mitty Hunters Club HQ are a non-governmental organisation that investigates and exposes Walter Mittys within the United Kingdom. We also investigate instances where someone inflates their Military service, (serving in 1 Para when t...

https://thewaltermittyhuntersclubhq.com

OP posts:
Intelligenthair · 13/11/2023 14:05

Ask your MIL to keep it to herself while you recover.

Then go and see a solicitor, get some advice and make a proper plan.

Don’t rush into anything.

Ponderingwindow · 13/11/2023 14:02

If you are worried about his reaction you shouldn’t be confronting him at all, even with assistance.

you should bide your time, gather your documents and anything of your possessions you can’t stand losing, open a bank account, and rent someplace to live. Then at the very last minute, transfer half of any joint assets into your new bank account and leave. You can most likely get the rest of your things later, but they are just things.

Whoopy · 13/11/2023 14:00

Baffledandalarmed · 13/11/2023 13:46

Oh, OP. This is very sad.

Unfortunately, the one thing you can count on is that the people who have seen action/danger (even if they’re not military but something like MSF) will never talk about it.
But until you know someone who’s been in those situations it’s not something you know (if that makes sense). So people up thread berating you are being a bit ridiculous.

I would personally speak to a solicitor before you do anything else - you might be able to secure your house without having to ‘buy him out.’

Not true. Prince Harry did talk about his service action and gave a total of his “kills.” This wasn’t just speaking to someone, he wrote about it for anyone in the World to know! If he can, others can.

fingerguns · 13/11/2023 13:59

I'm sorry OP, that sounds terrible. If you're worried about your safety, especially as you're still recovering, could you ask any friends - maybe get three of them together - to be with you? More witnesses, and he'll be outnumbered. Or bring it up in a public place?

I hope everything works out for you!

forgotname · 13/11/2023 13:57

Charge ring camera in same room as you and set to live record so have recording of anything. Stay safe

JudgeJ · 13/11/2023 13:55

He constantly talks about the violent side of it, killing kids, etc, that have weapons/bombs. Highlights his kill count

Someone who has served in the most secretive units will not talk about what he's done or seen.

Duckingella · 13/11/2023 13:54

In my circle men who pretend to have been in the army are known as Walts (Walter Mitty).

Unfortunately I know at least two walts;one was identified and his secret came out;the other is a friends partner who has actually been in the armed forces but has lied about where he's been and what he's done;he was discharged due to a court marshal not medical like he told my friend;I have no intention of telling her as it's not my responsibility to do so.

GrimDamnFanjo · 13/11/2023 13:53

I'd give yourself a bit of time to get physically stronger and your ducks in a row. You've a plausible reason for separate rooms.
Get the paperwork together before you say anything.

ClawedButler · 13/11/2023 13:50

Is there somewhere you can go in the short term while you're recuperating from your operation and have a think about how to proceed?

Mymilkshakebringsallthepapstomycar · 13/11/2023 13:47

CinnamonSwirl82 · 13/11/2023 13:14

So reasons I think he would get violent:

  • He constantly talks about the violent side of it, killing kids, etc, that have weapons/bombs. Highlights his kill count
  • Always says 'one more wouldn't make a difference' in terms of kill count
  • Punched a door through once when he got angry
  • Has a very short temper. I can't raise things with him like asking if he'd like to go somewhere on holiday without first asking him not to get angry with me for suggesting something.
  • Told me how he broke the arm of his ex girlfriend's boyfriend when he got angry because he tried to start a fight

Is this new since you married him? Or was he alway like this?

Did you get any independent legal advice when you used your money on the house deposit? Did he put anything in? Who pays the mortgage?

Fionaville · 13/11/2023 13:47

I have a friend who tells big dramatic lies and small everyday lies for no reason whatsoever. It's very strange. Some people are compulsive liars. It's doesn't necessarily mean he's dangerous, just that he can't be trusted.
I had a very short fling with a compulsive liar when I was younger. I realised he always had a dramatic story to tell, then his cousin warned me. She said he's harmless, but take his stories with a pinch of salt. I couldn't stay with him because I felt like everything he said was a lie, even compliments.
I would definitely get rid of him, a marriage is nothing without trust. If you have a trusted friend or relative get them round while you tell him. You need the support.

Baffledandalarmed · 13/11/2023 13:46

Oh, OP. This is very sad.

Unfortunately, the one thing you can count on is that the people who have seen action/danger (even if they’re not military but something like MSF) will never talk about it.
But until you know someone who’s been in those situations it’s not something you know (if that makes sense). So people up thread berating you are being a bit ridiculous.

I would personally speak to a solicitor before you do anything else - you might be able to secure your house without having to ‘buy him out.’