Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Treating adult children different but fairly

66 replies

Keepitrealnomists · 13/11/2023 08:06

What does that actually mean in your experience?
I feel I am treated massively different, my brother is clearly favoured amd always has been, but it's because he needs help apparently. 🙄 38 year old married man with 3DC who can't manage his finances, in a huge amount of debt which is wife doesn't know about which in my mind is financial abuse but it's fine for my divorced parents to give him a second car they pay for, swimming lessons, holidays, food shopping.....
I feel they have created massive divide and I am LC with all 3 of them!
I have a good career, married, 2DC, enough money to pay for everything we need with ittle debt. I just feel massively, well....annoyed and hurt that they give him everything allowing him to facilitate his wreckless behaviour, so AIBU ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MilkChocolateCookie · 27/11/2023 09:20

The way my parents deal with it is that they've financially supported both me and my brother (him more than me) at different times, according to need, but made a note if it so that it will be corrected for before the inheritance is shared between us (they don't have much savings but do own their house having paid off the mortgage). They've explained this to both of us.

I think that's a good way of approaching it.

TotalOverhaul · 27/11/2023 09:12

To me, it means giving them what they need at a given time - whether that's time, emotional support, a nudge in the right direction or some financial or practical help. But always with an eye to how that makes the other child feel.

E.g. DS2 usually gets way more of my headspace as he has additional needs. He flourishes, living unassisted, but that is partly because of the hours and hours and hours of support he was givenwhile transitioning to adulthood, to help him find his feet. DS1 had none of this and at times, I think, resented it.

But recently DS1 moved into an unfurnished, decrepit flat. We spent two weeks deep cleaning, mending, restoring and decorating it, helping him choose furniture from ebay and junk shops, restoring that furniture, giving him some things from home that he loved and buying him some expensive white goods. He was clearly bowled over by all this attention, time and love spent on him. Maybe he is not used to being the focus of our undivided attention. But this was when he needed it, and his brother is happy in his own life right now and needs less support.

One thing I am pretty careful about is not giving more money to one than the other. We've spent a fair bit on DS1 recently. When DS2 eventually finds a place of his own, rather than a rented room in shared place, we'll do the same for him.

pickledandpuzzled · 27/11/2023 09:04

I’m sorry, @Keepitrealnomists

It isn’t going to change. The only thing you can change is how you respond to it- how you feel. If you can acknowledge it’s totally unfair, totally unjustified, and totally not your fault/not about you… you’ll feel a lot better. It’s an active choice you can make.

MereDintofPandiculation · 27/11/2023 08:58

I try to keep the monetary value in line, but for one that's a contribution to mortgage and wedding, for the other it's a similar amount for a car.

romdowa · 27/11/2023 08:55

You're the scape goat and he's the golden child. It's a similar dynamic in my family. Brother spent 10 years drinking every penny he had , stealing from others to fund his drinking and raking up debt. My parents bank rolled him through out these 10 years, paying off his debts every time, buying him hundreds of euros worth of clothes and shoes. One Christmas he got 500 euro worth of gear and I got a dressing gown From primark . Also during this 10 years he distroyed their house, broke windows, doors , furniture . I was the dutiful one who was helpful and went above and beyond. Even now when he's sober he does nothing to help. My mother has been diagnosed as terminally ill and I was expected to run around after her but I finally said enough. He can do his bit now while I concentrate on my young child.
So I understand how you feel op but my advice is to leave them to it and get on with your own life.

CurlewKate · 27/11/2023 08:19

It's difficult. We have two adult children, and while we do try to treat them fairly, one of them needed a lot of support at one stage-she was in a violent relationship and needed a lot of practical and financial help. We made very sure that her sibling understood what was going on and he was very supportive of her sister too. But the fact remained that at one stage in his life he had to take a back seat in a way that can never be made up.

Keepitrealnomists · 27/11/2023 08:07

It goes from bad to worse, car repairs worth over 1k, new tele, food, extras for his kids. I get a bottle of wine and a card for my birthdays.

OP posts:
Keepitrealnomists · 13/11/2023 16:14

pickledandpuzzled · 13/11/2023 13:47

Bless you OP.

It’s not about the money- they enable your brother which does him no favours. One day the chickens will come home to roost. They’ll run out of money and be no use to him, or need care that he won’t provide.

I’d stay LC, and do not get drawn in to caring.

Have you had therapy? That accident, and their response to your pay out must have been traumatic.

It’s never easy trying to understand why one child gets generous and affectionate treatment while the other is expected to suck it up and thrive on neglect. I suspect if you fawned over your brother things would be easier with your parents.

Best to understand that it’s not about you, it’s about them, and it isn’t something you can fix.

And enjoy your in laws!

I've thought about therapy and I think its something that would definitely benefit me. I will have another look into it.
There has been a fair amount of trauma in my life that I could do with sorting out.

OP posts:
pickledandpuzzled · 13/11/2023 13:47

Bless you OP.

It’s not about the money- they enable your brother which does him no favours. One day the chickens will come home to roost. They’ll run out of money and be no use to him, or need care that he won’t provide.

I’d stay LC, and do not get drawn in to caring.

Have you had therapy? That accident, and their response to your pay out must have been traumatic.

It’s never easy trying to understand why one child gets generous and affectionate treatment while the other is expected to suck it up and thrive on neglect. I suspect if you fawned over your brother things would be easier with your parents.

Best to understand that it’s not about you, it’s about them, and it isn’t something you can fix.

And enjoy your in laws!

Afteropening · 13/11/2023 13:37

Keepitrealnomists · 13/11/2023 10:55

It's the main issue yes, in my 40s I have come to realise that I am very different to them and don't have much in common. On mothers/fathers day I always see SM posts about how they have amazing parents, I just don't have that which makes me sad. I do have wonderful in laws who treat me like a daughter who I am lucky to have.

i can’t fathom an otherwise loving relationship between parents and an adult child being low contact on the grounds that I felt peeved that my parents offered more support to my sibling - when their grandchildren clearly benefit and would lose out if they did not.

So I suspect that it is one of a number of “main issues”

icallshade · 13/11/2023 12:56

I can understand the comments made by lots of posters here but I understand how you feel OP.
It isn't about money, it isn't about 'is that the only reason you're low contact' as people have suggested. It's about feeling second best to a sibling, and almost feeling punished for having your shit together.
For example, my sibling and I both have a child under 3.
My mother does 3 days per week of childcare for my sibling for free (they are about equivelent to us financially), and invites her, her husband and her son for dinner every Sunday.
My mother does no childcare for my daughter, who came along after my siblings son. My sibling and I both work the same number of days per week, however we pay for my.daughter to go to nursery 3 days per week. We were last invited for a meal at my mums on 6th January.

There are no 'issues' between my mum and I to suggest why she favours my sibling, however I have recently gone low contact because the resentment is getting too much. And before anyone says anything, sometimes raising the issue just gets you nowhere/is brushed off.

Desecratedcoconut · 13/11/2023 12:23

The op isn't looking to improve the quality of her brother's life through some useful tough love. Fairness seems to be the prevailing theme of the op.

Elsiebear90 · 13/11/2023 12:15

If they’re just paying for things for him which allows him to hide the debt from his wife they’re not helping they’re enabling. My brother and sister in law were in a mess financially, all their own doing, and my parents were clear that any help was a loan that they had to pay back, so I get where OP is coming from. Paying for things all the time isn’t helping him, he needs to be honest and learn how to manage his money better, not just keep getting bailed out by mum and dad.

unsync · 13/11/2023 11:59

Keepitrealnomists · 13/11/2023 08:10

I've thought about that so many times, but the other half of me thinks that's she's blind and stupid not to realise!

You said you thought she was being financially abused, then you call her blind and stupid? If he is abusing her financially, he may well be abusing her in other ways too. Abuse is complex and she may need help, not victim blaming.

Desecratedcoconut · 13/11/2023 11:52

So, you don't think they should bail him out and they should allow him to descend into a pit of his own making so that he is, and his family, is properly punished for his bad choices and the world can fully appreciate the full thrust of how shit he is and then, what? What outcome are you imagining....your parents might like you better?

RosePetals86 · 13/11/2023 11:45

I think it’s quite common OP and I agree it doesn’t feel great to be the one who is constantly overlooked despite having your own life in order. There is always one adult sibling who monopolises parents be it for childcare, money, attention etc. Other siblings have to take a step back to preserve their own sanity and their feelings from being hurt.
From my own experience, parents and grandparents are rubbish at treating children and grandchildren equally. All you can take from the situation is you intend to treat your own better in the future.

Keepitrealnomists · 13/11/2023 10:55

Afteropening · 13/11/2023 10:43

Is the only reason you are LC because of this issue?

It's the main issue yes, in my 40s I have come to realise that I am very different to them and don't have much in common. On mothers/fathers day I always see SM posts about how they have amazing parents, I just don't have that which makes me sad. I do have wonderful in laws who treat me like a daughter who I am lucky to have.

OP posts:
ChateauMargaux · 13/11/2023 10:48

I get it... I remember being told that my parents couldn't help me when I was struggling to survive on a really low wage while at work placement during my studies. Someone else's parents invited me for lunch every Sunday so I could have a great meal and some company. When I was moving between placements, two other people's parents helped me move and helped me find a place to live.

I sat and howled at the kindness and support shown to me my strangers which my parents were unable to show me. They now say.. oh you were so independent Chateaux, you didn't need us.

They offered very different support to my siblings. There have been times they could and should have supported my sister but choose not to while they have given a huge amount of financial support to my brother. Yet they insist tehy treat us equally. When I point it out.. they say, 'we are sorry you feel that way'.

It's not about the money... it's about how they express their love and what they expect in return.

TeenDivided · 13/11/2023 10:45

OP, your parents are doing 'differently AND unfairly'.

Differently but fairly means to me some level of 'according to need'. e.g. We will pay medical bills for our DC as needed, but won't try to balance out spending if one has much greater medical needs than the other. Similarly maybe also nursery costs.

it does not mean enabling repeated profligate spending and being in debt.

Afteropening · 13/11/2023 10:43

Is the only reason you are LC because of this issue?

unfairornot · 13/11/2023 10:39

@Sisterpita possibly yes. We suspect the younger has adhd and has always needed a lot of attention/support from being a toddler. (She was in her teens when we realised) Their dad and I split when they were young and elder dd was always more for her dad but unfortunately he's useless so she would ask him for support but inevitably be let down. It has altered abit in adulthood as older dd has got better at asking/showing and younger has become more mature. But teen years were a nightmare.

PostItInABook · 13/11/2023 10:32

Harbouring resentment about who gets what and when only hurts and eats away at you. Let it go.

Sisterpita · 13/11/2023 10:27

unfairornot · 13/11/2023 08:35

I have 2 dd, one definitely needs more support than the other. Not financially but more emotional/practical. The elder one also rarely asks for help because I would help if needed.

I've said to her on the past her reward is being more independent/able to succeed /less reliant on others.

Genuine question has the one child always required more from you so your second child has learnt/been conditioned not to ask because you have always expected them to be the bigger person?

Keepitrealnomists · 13/11/2023 10:13

It's not about inheritance, they don't have much so it's not an expectation. It's not even about the money they continue to give him, that he and his family benefit from. To me It's a feeling of one child being favoured more than the other and allowing it to continue.
This goes far deeper than what I have mentioned, DB has always been favoured, he had his first car bought for him, deposit paid on a rental, moving costs given, so many examples but with me it's been far harder, I've struggled at times and been told to get on with it. When I was a teenager I was involved in a car accident and received a pay out, my mother counted uo everything she had bought me including a car (as did my brother get a car) and wanted over half my pay out. There is alot to unpick. I see my parents as much as I can bear which is not alot and when I do see them it's all about my DB, I saw her yesterday which left me feeling flat which triggered this post.
I have offered my brother financial advice, debt charity help but he's not interested. Having my own children has made me see that I would never favour one over the other.

OP posts:
BaublesAndGlitter · 13/11/2023 10:01

Similar situation here. Dsis is in a worse financial position than me so I understand the urge to help her (and I have done so in the past) however, she is also making absolutely no attempt to cut back or stay within a budget.
She continues living the life she wants to have and just turns to parents when her money runs out.
She also lets admin type things become absolutely urgent knowing it stresses my dm out so it's done for her.

I find it frustrating because while I don't need the money now, I did in the past but it wasn't available because they were paying for things for her.

OP you can have the conversation with your parents but don't expect things to change too much. Your options realistically are to either accept things the way they are or back right off (as you say you have done)

Swipe left for the next trending thread