Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect dd to tolerate her brothers playing while she's trying to sleep?

332 replies

Mastmw7g · 13/11/2023 05:39

My 10 year old likes to sleep late, but her brothers wake up early and play in the mornings. They make noise when they play. I think it's a good thing because they're spending time together and not on screens. But dd keeps getting upset that they wake her up. Then she comes out of her room and it starts a fight and dh gets upset because that wakes him up and he also likes to sleep late.

OP posts:
ManateeFair · 13/11/2023 15:02

I see the people who think getting up at 10 means you've 'wasted half the day' have arrived.

If I get up at 10am I haven't 'wasted half the day' any more than you have 'wasted half the evening' by going to bed significantly earlier than I do.

Some people are night owls, some people are larks. Neither one is superior.

OP's DD should be able to lie in for as long as she likes, although she can't expect the house to be silent, of course. Her brothers can obviously get up earlier if they prefer and should be allowed to play, but encouraged to do that fairly quietly until, eg, 9ish.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 13/11/2023 14:13

I can see both sides here.

Some people are owls and don’t find early this bed, early to rise very restful or refreshing.

I find the pressure to “have an early night” quite stressful.

That said I think you’re DH should suck it up as he’s a parent.

Can you Dd wear earplugs? That sees me through the general “living in London” noise in the weekend mornings?

The boys should maybe keep it down a bit before 9 as it’s important they learn to consider others too.

Itwasafterallallaboutme · 13/11/2023 14:07

Mastmw7g · 13/11/2023 10:42

@Itwasafterallallaboutme I have no idea what time I would be getting up if I was on my own. I'm dealing with my own hormone fluctuations that bring me out of sleep at odd times. DH actually does a lot of the housework despite sleeping so late, so I have a great deal of free time in the mornings and look forward to my boys waking up, though my 12 year old basically acts like I'm intruding on his alone time by talking to him and asking if he's hungry so long before he wants to eat. My 6 year old is far more enthusiastic about me saying "Good morning."

Thank you for answering my questions @Mastmw7g I am very glad that you enjoy getting up with your boys, and that you are happy that your husband does his fair share towards making your family a family.

I couldn't help but smile at your 12 year old's behaviour as it brought back many memories of my children at that age! Mine were probably in their early 20's when they realised that it was ok to give mum a hug and a kiss without me even asking!

I am not going to add my two tuppence worth into your childrens waking up and going to sleep times, I think you have had enough conflicting advice on that. But I do hope that you can pick out any of the bits of advice that resonate with you. You are obviously a very loving Mum with your children's best interests at heart, so I don't think that whatever you decide will harm them, as long as you don't get talked into going strongly against your own beliefs. 🫖 or ☕️ and 🥞 😊

jannier · 13/11/2023 13:18

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 13/11/2023 13:10

That doesn’t mean 8am is the crack of dawn though!

Well, in much of the UK, in winter, 8am pretty much is the crack of dawn!

I'm on the dd's side here. I'm an owl and used to hate being woken by people who thought that just because they were up, everyone should be up. There's nothing especially virtuous about being an early riser.

One of the benefits of living alone is that I can please myself unless I have to be up and out somewhere in the morning. I'll often be doing something productive into the early hours, and sleep later in the morning.

And I don't see why everyone has to rush around every weekend doing 'activities '. Everyone should take more time to chill.

And calling her a princess is just nasty.

But if you read the post on dad's schedule he gets up at 7am puts food out goes back to bed for an hour does school run has a meeting then goes back to bed that's a pretty wacky weekday routine

jannier · 13/11/2023 13:16

ShineBright1209 · 13/11/2023 11:29

Absolutely not, once my younger 2 are asleep they will sleep through anything. My 13 year old sits in the same bedroom as 7 year playing on his PlayStation talking (not particularly quietly) to his friends on the headset whilst my 7 year old is sleeping.
I was never a ssh the babies sleeping kind of parent when they were small so maybe that’s why they are the way they are now.

Mine always been like this I could go in their room lights on put stuff away. Hoover the stairs etc.

jannier · 13/11/2023 13:13

Mastmw7g · 13/11/2023 11:05

@jannier DH does most of the housework and cooking. He does his share of childcare, too. On weekdays he gets up at 7 to give our 12 year old breakfast before he takes his morning medicine and then DH goes back to bed until it's time for our 12 year old to go to school. Then I mostly handle the morning routine of getting the younger two up, which is mostly me telling my 10 year old what she has to do while she protests and says school should never have been invented. I get my 6 year old dressed and feed the two of them. Then DH gets back up and gives my 6 year old his morning medicine and takes them to school. He has a morning meeting he calls into and then he goes back to bed until he wakes up later and starts really working.

That's an odd routine surely 7 is when most school kids are up and not that early.....many arrive at mine for 7.30 having had breakfast and head to school at 8.15.
Has your oh asked a GP why he needs to sleep so much and looked at things like sleep apnopea or depression?
Some people do turn their day into night by bad sleep habits the odd cat napping isn't going to allow a proper sleep cycle so he won't be refreshed.

HonoriaLucastaDelagardie · 13/11/2023 13:10

That doesn’t mean 8am is the crack of dawn though!

Well, in much of the UK, in winter, 8am pretty much is the crack of dawn!

I'm on the dd's side here. I'm an owl and used to hate being woken by people who thought that just because they were up, everyone should be up. There's nothing especially virtuous about being an early riser.

One of the benefits of living alone is that I can please myself unless I have to be up and out somewhere in the morning. I'll often be doing something productive into the early hours, and sleep later in the morning.

And I don't see why everyone has to rush around every weekend doing 'activities '. Everyone should take more time to chill.

And calling her a princess is just nasty.

Celebrationsnakes · 13/11/2023 13:07

3WildOnes · 13/11/2023 12:46

I sleep in until 10am almost every Sunday and 10am half of the time on Saturdays. I don't expect the children to be quiet.
I certainly don't feel like I've wasted half of the day!
Those of you who feel like half of the day is wasted, are you out of the house 8am-5pm all weekend?

I would have lost 3 hours of study time if I got up at 10am on a weekend so it would be time wasted for me.

3WildOnes · 13/11/2023 12:46

I sleep in until 10am almost every Sunday and 10am half of the time on Saturdays. I don't expect the children to be quiet.
I certainly don't feel like I've wasted half of the day!
Those of you who feel like half of the day is wasted, are you out of the house 8am-5pm all weekend?

AppropriateAdult · 13/11/2023 12:44

When do you get your lie-in, OP?

The boys don't need to tiptoe around or be silent or anything else - they just need not to play right outside her bedroom door when she's asleep. 10am is not very late, my similar-aged daughter has started sleeping noticeably later in the last few weeks.

Dutch1e · 13/11/2023 12:10

I think your idea of moving the toys downstairs is really the most logical solution.

I feel for your DD, she is in her room with books at 8PM, quietly respecting the sleep time of her brothers when I imagine she'd much prefer to be bouncing off the walls until midnight as owls do.

Surely the natural flipside of this is that they sit quietly with books in the morning to respect her sleep time, rather than bouncing off the walls as larks do.

Tbh I think that your DH needs to take a Saturday (or a Sunday) and leave the house early with the boys, especially the eldest who is awake so early that his day truly is half-gone. DHs sleep is crappy anyway, may as well be exhausted and useful than just exhausted.

PhantomUnicorn · 13/11/2023 12:06

Mastmw7g · 13/11/2023 11:57

@PhantomUnicorn I think they play in the space outside their rooms because that's where the toys are. My 6 year old shares a wall with my 10 year old so his room is right next to hers. I think the obvious solution I previously didn't consider is that the toys they play with together should be downstairs.

I'd encourage them to play in the 12yos room. I'm with you on downstairs being 'adult' space.

I have 2 older kids, but the youngest was 10 when we moved here and i stopped them having toys downstairs.. they have their own bedrooms each and a play room and they get my room to play in as well once i'm up. The only space i get that is entirely mine as a play free zone is my living room.

The dining room is shared space for hobbies and gaming.

I know that set up isn't for everyone, and with one 6yo it could be argued you might have to tolerate it a bit longer, but don't let people tell you you're not allowed to designate your lounge a toy free zone, you are.

LuckySantangelo35 · 13/11/2023 12:02

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 13/11/2023 11:15

And if you go to bed later, you will wake up leater. Naturally.

could you please explain what you are trying to say?

@Islandparadise

also some people can’t just make themselves fall
asleep earlier.

PhantomUnicorn · 13/11/2023 11:59

Whiteday · 13/11/2023 11:31

I'm not sure that the people in the OP have a sleep disorder? Obviously, if they had such a thing then measures would be taken? They don't appear too, so therefore it's not relevant.

depends, a lot of people suffer from a delayed circadian rhythm, is called Delayed Sleep Phase Syndrome.. its a more 'extreme' version of what makes an owl an owl.

I have DSPS and i literally CANNOT fall asleep before 1am at the absolutely earliest, if i do its out of sheer exhaustion because i average about 4hrs sleep most nights, and 6hrs is an amazing night for me, but if i do fall asleep early, i wake up at something like 3/4am and can't get back to sleep.

It was thought i had insomnia or i was causing my own issues by not 'choosing' to sleep earlier for years until we found out it was DSPS.

People on here insisting there is some virtue in early to bed, early to rise, and there isn't, there is no moral failing in sleeping in.

Whatever the reason for being a lark or an owl, everyones sleep pattern should be respected.

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 13/11/2023 11:57

Mastmw7g · 13/11/2023 11:50

@honeylulu You knew better than me! I had no idea it was so controversial for dd to have a lie in. I was just frustrated by the fighting. We only moved recently, so we're still getting used to this house. I think it was a mistake to make the area they play right off of the bedrooms, though dh liked this house for that respect as it gave us the opportunity to have an adult space downstairs. I think that dream isn't going to work for our family. I need to find toy storage that doesn't scream kids where magnetic tiles and legos can be kept and easily cleaned up. I also think the problem will solve itself shortly as I can't imagine my 12 year old will want to play much longer, so I should facilitate that for as long as it lasts in a way that disturbs others the least.

Can’t think offhand or link as don’t know where they got it from but DB and SIL have nice storage for magnetic tiles and Lego (they’re in a 2 bedroom flat currently).

Mastmw7g · 13/11/2023 11:57

@PhantomUnicorn I think they play in the space outside their rooms because that's where the toys are. My 6 year old shares a wall with my 10 year old so his room is right next to hers. I think the obvious solution I previously didn't consider is that the toys they play with together should be downstairs.

OP posts:
PhantomUnicorn · 13/11/2023 11:53

OP, you still haven't explained why they can't play in their rooms rather than outside DD's door?

Mastmw7g · 13/11/2023 11:50

@honeylulu You knew better than me! I had no idea it was so controversial for dd to have a lie in. I was just frustrated by the fighting. We only moved recently, so we're still getting used to this house. I think it was a mistake to make the area they play right off of the bedrooms, though dh liked this house for that respect as it gave us the opportunity to have an adult space downstairs. I think that dream isn't going to work for our family. I need to find toy storage that doesn't scream kids where magnetic tiles and legos can be kept and easily cleaned up. I also think the problem will solve itself shortly as I can't imagine my 12 year old will want to play much longer, so I should facilitate that for as long as it lasts in a way that disturbs others the least.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 13/11/2023 11:50

Sleep phones with white noise app. My 12 year old uses them as his brothers wake him and he likes a snooze. Or get her foam earplugs

TimetoPour · 13/11/2023 11:49

Come on OP, it’s not difficult. Everyone needs to learn to compromise a bit here and you need to step up and teach them.

It’s not ok to run around making a racket while others are sleeping. It’s also not ok to expect the whole house to tip toe around a 10 year old that wants to sleep till 10am. The fighting is unacceptable for all of them.

You don’t have to take all toys down but can’t you keep a small selection of quiet games/toys downstairs? If you are up why can’t you take the younger one down with you? Have a quiet breakfast together, make a cake, write a shopping list, play a game. Otherwise take a cup of tea up to the play room and sit with them there. When they are playing together and the noise starts, step in before the fight breaks out.

The boys need to learn to keep it down and if the 10 year old is feeling cranky about sleep, she could try going to bed earlier. A 10 year old needs roughly 10-11 hours sleep. If she woke at 9am, that would be going to bed between 10 & 11pm which is certainly late enough for a 10 year old.

honeylulu · 13/11/2023 11:39

As a defensive owl, I knew this thread would descend into an early riser v late riser spat! Aggravating that larks are seen as virtuous and worthy and owls as lazy and slovenly even though we get the same amount of stuff done in the day so what's the problem?

I love sleeping later at the weekend and then enjoying a cup of tea and book in bed before I have to get up and "do stuff". I'm happy to be busy into the evening as that is when my energy and imagination is at its peak, long after the larks have gone to bed at 9pm like overgrown toddlers.

My father constantly berated us (me and sibling), both owls, when we lived at home for "wasting the day". He'd get up at 6am and mow the lawn and stuff. I bet the neighbours hated him. After lunch though he'd go for a 2-3 hour nap ... in daylight! We'd ask why that wasn't "wasting the day" but it was different apparently.

Luckily my husband and kids are all owls too!

Persephonegoddess · 13/11/2023 11:32

FFS why is your problem to solve, you are a family. Sit down and discuss. Agree quiet hours for example 10pm to 8am outside of that time ppl need to be considerate but not mice. Your DH needs to man up and sleep at a reasonable times and maybe parent his kids, basically he misses maybe four hours of his 6 yr old each day each weekend..... he is Shit dad

Whiteday · 13/11/2023 11:31

PhantomUnicorn · 13/11/2023 11:30

well, i'm a single mum with a sleeping disorder, i sleep best between 2am and 9am, so my kids are told to keep it down before 9am on a weekend (they wake up about 6am), as i need to sleep having only got 4hrs sleep most nights in the week with having to be up to get DD to school.

I'm not 'wasting half the day' by not getting up before 9.30, i'm recouping essential rest.

OP.. i think 9am is a decent compromise, but i dont think its fair having to deal with someone playing OUTSIDE your bedroom door, can't the boys play in one of their rooms?

Not even commenting on your DH, mine slept until 2pm some days and i learned not to disturb him (one of myriad reasons i'm single)

I'm not sure that the people in the OP have a sleep disorder? Obviously, if they had such a thing then measures would be taken? They don't appear too, so therefore it's not relevant.

phoenixrosehere · 13/11/2023 11:30

StockpotSoup · 13/11/2023 11:04

But why do they have to wait for their dad and their other sibling? If they want to go out, leave them behind and let them sleep in. I can see it would be a problem if both parents were raring to go and one child was holding everything up, but you have one parent happy to get up earlier, one not so who can look after the child who feels the same - where’s the problem?

Do the “But half the day is gone!” crowd never take their kids to things like soft play, the cinema, bowling, swimming - activities where it doesn’t matter what it’s like outside? Does every activity have to be outdoors in daylight? Do none of their kids want to go to a bonfire, trick or treating or to the Christmas markets at this time of year?

Plus, I can’t believe everyone wants EVERY Saturday to be a hotbed of activity. There must be times when even the most active families just want to watch telly with the duvet cover over them.

Agree.

My dad is one of those people and then asks “what did you do today”? and it drove me mad as a kid and still annoys me now. Why does one have to get up early if they don’t have to, especially on a weekend. Why must I be out of bed before noon if I have nothing pressing to do?

The whole sunlight thing is perplexing even more so when it does get dark earlier.

PhantomUnicorn · 13/11/2023 11:30

well, i'm a single mum with a sleeping disorder, i sleep best between 2am and 9am, so my kids are told to keep it down before 9am on a weekend (they wake up about 6am), as i need to sleep having only got 4hrs sleep most nights in the week with having to be up to get DD to school.

I'm not 'wasting half the day' by not getting up before 9.30, i'm recouping essential rest.

OP.. i think 9am is a decent compromise, but i dont think its fair having to deal with someone playing OUTSIDE your bedroom door, can't the boys play in one of their rooms?

Not even commenting on your DH, mine slept until 2pm some days and i learned not to disturb him (one of myriad reasons i'm single)

Swipe left for the next trending thread