Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed they used the exact name

233 replies

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 19:53

Just found out that DH's cousin has had a baby (they are quite a close knit family). Had a text to say they had named the baby the exact same first and middle name as our son. DS is 4 and they were both at the christening and have seen him since so they were fully aware of the name. It's not a massively common name so it's not something you expect lots of people to have. I just feel really angry, like they've taken away part of his identity which I know is probably ridiculous. But why copy his first and middle name? His middle name we chose to honour his grandad and they have no family connection to it so I just can't understand it! Just feel like I need to vent somewhere

OP posts:
bookworm60 · 12/11/2023 20:51

My dads brother gave his daughter the same first name as me and very nearly the same middle name ( think Julie and Julia) plus we had the same surname. She was just a year younger and I still resent it now, over 60 years on! Caused a lot of confusion in the family over which one of us was being referred to

Totaly · 12/11/2023 20:51

Things like this cause rifts in families. Awful behaviour.

Id have to say something.

Freefree · 12/11/2023 20:49

My dhs brother named his son almost exactly the same name as ours, and this was after they told us they didn't like our sons name.
So basically, if we called our son zack- James, they called theirs james-jack and we call our sons by the two names they're not just known by first name only.
(These aren't the actual names but they're as common as the ones above.)

So I get your anger and think it's just really weird.

Sellingbedtime · 12/11/2023 20:49

Using both names seems a bit lazy of them!

Mari9999 · 12/11/2023 20:49

@holeymoleymacaroli
As stated , you don't own the names. In my opinion it is not uncommon for names to repeat in families. How do you imagine that you son will be negatively impacted by having the same name as another family member? During the course of his educational experience he will likely encounter this more than once.

I have seen several complaints about this on MN , but never once have the complaining parents ever stated what they think that the actual resulting harm or damage will be.

TeaGinandFags · 12/11/2023 20:48

I think this happens a lot.

I was supposed to be a boy and the two alternatives for my name were used by Dad's cousin for her two boys.

Mum is still annoyed and that was decades ago.

KaiserChefs · 12/11/2023 20:48

This is the third thread on this "relative used my child's exact name for theirs" situation in a week.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 12/11/2023 20:47

CharingX976 · 12/11/2023 20:21

Come on. Imagine you are part of a small, close knit family, just a few siblings and cousins, and you called your child Hazel Susanna, and then your cousin just announced their daughter was also being called Hazel Susanna. It's WEIRD.

OP doesn’t say they’re close knit. She says they see each other a couple of times a year. I don’t need to imagine being part of a close family. I am. I am genuinely struggling to remember DH’s niece’s middle name.

I said it was odd but thinking they stole his identity is overreacting.

Tarantella6 · 12/11/2023 20:46

It would be difficult to resist saying how nice of them to honour their Uncle Raymond like you did, he's a lucky guy to have multiple kids carry his name forward. Hope their parents aren't offended that they didn't use any of their names 😉

jazzhands84 · 12/11/2023 20:46

My brother and cousin have exactly the same first and middle names and it's really never been an issue. We just think it's quirky and unusual.

whatausername · 12/11/2023 20:45

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 20:33

Luckily it's a different surname. I know I don't own a name but it's just so odd that they would use the exact name. They are close enough that we see them a few times a year at family gatherings and speak a lot over text, social media etc. The first name is not a common name, the second is common for older generations (hence our son is named after his grandad) but not for a younger generation. I don't want to say the name as it's outing but it would be something similar to someone being called Carter Raymond.

'Grandad' names are everywhere and have been for years now, for both first and middle names. Maybe the names are more common than you realise? It's like when people say that they named their DC something special and then "suddenly the name is everywhere". Various cultural and social phenomena quietly slip names on to many people's radars and what people think is unusual, special, original, ahead of the curve turns out to be just a trend the parents are following. If the first name is in the same occupation/surname/American vein as "Carter" (your example) then, again, these are all current long-standing trends.

HolidayHolllie · 12/11/2023 20:45

I think it is odd OP.

People have different levels of closeness OP but no way would they not know that's your son's name.

I'd be really pissed off if my cousin named their child the exact name of my child. Even just the first name is odd but first and middle!

I would also be saying something as PP days like "Wow you've given your Ds the exact same name as ours!"

ABCXYZ17 · 12/11/2023 20:44

You’re overreacting, they likely can’t remember the middle name. I can’t remember my cousin’s son’s middle name and I was at his christening and have seen him several times since. I can’t remember any of my friend’s kids’ middle names either and I see them loads!

FlissyPaps · 12/11/2023 20:43

00100001 · 12/11/2023 19:59

So their dads cousins child has the same name....?

Who the fuck cares?

Obviously the OP. Because she has made this thread.

And rightly so, because it’s weird behaviour.

Supergirl1958 · 12/11/2023 20:43

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 19:53

Just found out that DH's cousin has had a baby (they are quite a close knit family). Had a text to say they had named the baby the exact same first and middle name as our son. DS is 4 and they were both at the christening and have seen him since so they were fully aware of the name. It's not a massively common name so it's not something you expect lots of people to have. I just feel really angry, like they've taken away part of his identity which I know is probably ridiculous. But why copy his first and middle name? His middle name we chose to honour his grandad and they have no family connection to it so I just can't understand it! Just feel like I need to vent somewhere

YANBU. It’s not on at all :(

RandomQuestionOfTheDay · 12/11/2023 20:41

If the middle name is an
older-generation name of the Raymond type era, it’s likely to be a family name from DH’s cousin’s partner?

I don’t remember my cousins’ children’s’ middle names, but using the same first name is odd, unless one side is a huge family.

carddino · 12/11/2023 20:41

I would reply something like

Oh wow, congratulations.

Is baby named after DS? He is asking. ( my four year olds would)

Can pass you down all our personalised clothes now!

Passive aggressive perhaps but gets the point across.

Yes very weird.

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 12/11/2023 20:41

YABU .

His identity is not in his name

Unless it’s two names you made up yourself, they arent ‘yours’ to keep

Tistheseason17 · 12/11/2023 20:39

I would congratulate them and say how flattered you are they chose the exact name and say how you all have amazing taste - and mean it. They are not at school together and imitation is the sincerest form of flattery. I've certainly cared less about others copying me over time.

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 20:38

LylaLee · 12/11/2023 20:34

If I heard of two cousins with the same name, I would think either the younger child had a copied name OR that the parent of younger child at one point confided a 'dream name' which was 'stolen' and used for the older child, but still used for the younger child as a matter of principle.

Did the cousin ever say - my dream baby name is 'Carmelita Andie', and you thought, 'yeah, I love it' and used it yourself?

No the name was never mentioned. Me and DH chose the name based on something we both loved about 10 years before we had DS and never told anybody about it.

OP posts:
QWERTYoutside · 12/11/2023 20:37

Omg … 😏taken his identity !

Santaiswashinghissleigh · 12/11/2023 20:35

Send the whole family a family photo with your ds's name emblazoned across it. Make them look like copying cunts.

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 20:35

SkySecret · 12/11/2023 20:09

It’s definitely weird. But it looks odd on their part not yours, clearly your life and choices are so desirable they’ve had to copy you, I’d be laughing at them tbh. What do the rest of the family say about it?

This is how I'm trying to look at it. My DHs parents are quite offended as he was named after DH's dad, they just think it's weird and will make things a bit strange.

OP posts:
LylaLee · 12/11/2023 20:34

If I heard of two cousins with the same name, I would think either the younger child had a copied name OR that the parent of younger child at one point confided a 'dream name' which was 'stolen' and used for the older child, but still used for the younger child as a matter of principle.

Did the cousin ever say - my dream baby name is 'Carmelita Andie', and you thought, 'yeah, I love it' and used it yourself?

Hibambinos · 12/11/2023 20:33

I would laugh and question it in a humorous way. Throw them into the ridiculous light they have created for themselves. It’s weird, it’s seriously weird, so reframe it and find it funny that they are so bloody odd. Your child is a few years older, so everyone in the family will find it odd too.