Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed they used the exact name

233 replies

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 19:53

Just found out that DH's cousin has had a baby (they are quite a close knit family). Had a text to say they had named the baby the exact same first and middle name as our son. DS is 4 and they were both at the christening and have seen him since so they were fully aware of the name. It's not a massively common name so it's not something you expect lots of people to have. I just feel really angry, like they've taken away part of his identity which I know is probably ridiculous. But why copy his first and middle name? His middle name we chose to honour his grandad and they have no family connection to it so I just can't understand it! Just feel like I need to vent somewhere

OP posts:
LookingforMaryPoppins · 12/11/2023 21:41

Its an odd situation, I totally understand why you are not happy. A family member of ours, closer than a cousin, named their child a name that is the same as my child's other than a different starting letter. I thought it odd at the time but didn't say anything, numerous people mention it to me and my child is upset by it...... I try to take it as a compliment!

SemperIdem · 12/11/2023 21:35

I’m not close to my cousins at all, no particular reason just drifted apart as we got older.

I’m currently the only one on my paternal side with a child. My child doesn’t have an overly common first or middle name, though both are well known.

For the reason that both are well known names, even if relatively uncommonly used, I’d probably not think much of one or the other being used. I’d think it very odd if both were used though!

Wanttobefree2 · 12/11/2023 21:31

Really weird but it’s not worth falling out over either.

supernoodletrain · 12/11/2023 21:29

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 21:02

@Mari9999 I will definitely be keeping my distance now because I feel strongly that I don't want my child to have confusion over the situation.

Your son might quite like it! I can't imagine what would be confusing though

DinaofCloud9 · 12/11/2023 21:26

It's definitely weird and shows a lack of imagination. There's a million names out there, why pick exactly the same two as a relative?

Isthisexpected · 12/11/2023 21:26

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 21:02

@Mari9999 I will definitely be keeping my distance now because I feel strongly that I don't want my child to have confusion over the situation.

There will be no confusion. Your child will say "oh that's just like my name" once. Then carry on playing!

surreygirl1987 · 12/11/2023 21:25

That's really weird.

PeppermintMandy · 12/11/2023 21:25

BreatheAndFocus · 12/11/2023 21:18

I’d ask why they’d named their child after your grandad. You’re right to be pissed off. So many names out there and they purposely chose the same, including choosing a middle name that means nothing to them. Your best hope is that they at least change the middle name.

I don’t understand why people do this with relatives and close friends. It’s rude.

  1. OP doesn’t know that the middles name “doesn’t mean anything to them”

  2. OP doesn’t know that they purposefully chose the same name.

Most people don’t know/can’t remember their cousins kids middle names. Especially if it’s a common old fashioned grandad name since that’s where most middle names come from is grandparents.

FlissyPaps · 12/11/2023 21:23

00100001 · 12/11/2023 21:04

Couldn't tell you my dad's cousins name,😐 let alone their kids

And that’s absolutely fine.

But myself, the OP and many other people here will know their parents cousins names. And their child’s names. It’s common in some families to have close relationships with their cousins.

So the OP is 100% entitled to feel how she does.

Drfosters · 12/11/2023 21:22

YANBU- you will get the whole ‘you don’t own a name’ but with regards to close family you absolutely do. a name could be one you just randomly picked out of a book but it could also hold immense sentimental attachment. I had close family members copy how we chose to name our children and it upset me immensely and still upsets me all these years later. They didn’t even use the exact same names but used a lot of research I had done for our own benefit. So I don’t think you are overreacting but ultimately nothing you can do except think they are weird.

PeppermintMandy · 12/11/2023 21:22

You really need to take a step back and think what this actually means for your DS.

His Dad’s Cousin’s Son has the same name as him. What are the chances of him having a close relationship throughout his life with this kid?

Stealing his identity? Honestly a 4 year old is not going to give a shit, but if his mother decides to be eaten up with resentment over it for the next 30 years like some PP have experienced that might get pretty tiresome. God I wish this was the biggest concern I had involving family dynamics…my husband’s cousin’s child’s name.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 12/11/2023 21:21

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 20:55

@Mari9999 there's a few people in this thread who this has happened to with their own names. Most say that it annoys them. I think a name affects a lot about who you are, it's part of your identity. We put a lot of thought and effort in to our DCs names, we wanted it to be something they love and are proud of. If someone in your close family has the exact same now it could make you feel a sense of loss of identity.

SIL and I have exactly the same name. I am the exact same person I have always been because my identity isn’t linked to me having a totally unique name. Almost no one has. The only confusion it causes is wondering which one of us people are calling for which is a non-issue.

BreatheAndFocus · 12/11/2023 21:18

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 21:02

@Mari9999 I will definitely be keeping my distance now because I feel strongly that I don't want my child to have confusion over the situation.

I’d ask why they’d named their child after your grandad. You’re right to be pissed off. So many names out there and they purposely chose the same, including choosing a middle name that means nothing to them. Your best hope is that they at least change the middle name.

I don’t understand why people do this with relatives and close friends. It’s rude.

tillytoodles1 · 12/11/2023 21:18

My great, great grandad and all the first born sons have the same first name.
It's a very common name among Irish Catholics so it not unusual for first cousins to have the same first names, lots of my aunties married men with the same name .

grumpycow1 · 12/11/2023 21:18

Also, it doesn’t matter how far removed the cousin is if they are close enough to you to be invited to your christening or vice versa. If they are in your life for whatever reason, it’s weird!

fuzzystar · 12/11/2023 21:16

BitofaStramash · 12/11/2023 21:10

Middle names are only ever used or heard at birth christenings weddings and funerals.

And close knit or not these children are second cousins.

It's really not worth getting worked up about.

They are also written on family trees

MrsRachelDanvers · 12/11/2023 21:16

Things like this causes rifts in families? People would be fuming? Really? Get a grip people. This is a lot of fetishising about names. It used to be very common to have people with the same name in families-in my own, there are lots of Elizabeths and James. No one has a problem with their identity or gets confused! I can understand a bit of bemusement and maybe annoyance over identical first and middle names but only fleeting. You named your son because you liked it-it really doesn’t matter that people you rarely see names their kid the same does it?

fuzzystar · 12/11/2023 21:15

If its something like Fox because you liked the x files then it's probably more common than you think and they might also like the x files.

But anyway yeah it's a bit odd but I'd just assume theu genuinely had forgotten your child's middle name.

obje · 12/11/2023 21:15

I don't think the same middle name is weird, especially if it's a fabulous name on dh side of the family:

The same first name as well as the middle name is VERY weird. Particularly if it's not a common name.

When I was picking Dds name, I ruled out a few names I loved as friends or relatives had already named their dc that

grumpycow1 · 12/11/2023 21:15

That’s so weird!! I would have to say with a totally straight face ‘Love the names, did you find it hard to choose them?’ 😂

NovemberRain23 · 12/11/2023 21:14

Mari9999 · 12/11/2023 20:49

@holeymoleymacaroli
As stated , you don't own the names. In my opinion it is not uncommon for names to repeat in families. How do you imagine that you son will be negatively impacted by having the same name as another family member? During the course of his educational experience he will likely encounter this more than once.

I have seen several complaints about this on MN , but never once have the complaining parents ever stated what they think that the actual resulting harm or damage will be.

Well most people introduced to the wider family will think it means something? Two "Carter Raymond's" isn't an accident.
Both kids will grow up with this as a family name as opposed to one that's theirs.
The cousin will also have to come to terms with his parents being either unoriginal or a bit thick.

BitofaStramash · 12/11/2023 21:14

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 21:02

@Mari9999 I will definitely be keeping my distance now because I feel strongly that I don't want my child to have confusion over the situation.

Child won't be confused. You are being a drama llama

wesurecouldstandgladioli · 12/11/2023 21:12

YANBU. I would decline the christening with an excuse, if there is one.

TheresaCrowd · 12/11/2023 21:12

The baby's your husband's second cousin, so I can't see anything wrong with the baby having the same first name at all.

Same middle name too is a bit weird though.

SecondUsername4me · 12/11/2023 21:10

I'd probably message back "congrats! Obvs we adore that name combo as we have it too, great taste. Let us know when you are settled and ready for visitors"

Nice and amenable.