Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed they used the exact name

233 replies

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 19:53

Just found out that DH's cousin has had a baby (they are quite a close knit family). Had a text to say they had named the baby the exact same first and middle name as our son. DS is 4 and they were both at the christening and have seen him since so they were fully aware of the name. It's not a massively common name so it's not something you expect lots of people to have. I just feel really angry, like they've taken away part of his identity which I know is probably ridiculous. But why copy his first and middle name? His middle name we chose to honour his grandad and they have no family connection to it so I just can't understand it! Just feel like I need to vent somewhere

OP posts:
Verbena17 · 12/11/2023 22:58

It is a bit strange but as the children will be 1st cousins once removed, they maybe won’t have much of a relationship growing up.

Also, although unlikely, there is a small chance that the parents had already chosen their baby names prior to you having you son. Although if that had happened, you’d have thought they might have altered it a bit or swapped out the middle name.

Hibye23289 · 12/11/2023 22:57

No that is so weird! Like how did they have the guts to message you with the same name??? Did they not feel awkward? It's really weird, I'd imagine they have abit of an obsession and compare alot to you. Keep away!

LightDrizzle · 12/11/2023 22:56

Both names is odd and I wouldn’t do it myself. I personally wouldn’t fall out with them about it though; they are highly unlikely to have named their own child for life with the intention of pissing you off, I suppose they must just really like those names and be thick skinned. I can’t see how jealousy would come into it as a motivator as suggested above, that’s a strange suggestion. It definitely won’t rob your boy of his identity either, so please don’t give that a second thought.

I'm ancient and only had girls but from being about 13, I wanted to call any son George, - at the time an old man name before old man names first came into vogue. If a friend or relative other than a sibling had had a George, I’d probably have said something about loving the name and calling any son of mine George if I had one. I don’t think I’d have shelved it. Similarly I wouldn’t have taken the hump if a friend or relative used one of my girls names.

Choosing the same middle name too takes it more into the bizarre category but I’d class it as odd, but not horrible.

With time you’ll probably get used to it; DD2 has a name that became very popular when she was about four and remains so, albeit usually spelled differently, but when I hear people taking to or about their own Fahanabananahammocks, it just doesn’t register that they have the same name as my own Fahanabananahammock. It doesn’t conjure the same picture and emotions.

Jenasaurus · 12/11/2023 22:44

Same thing happened in my family. My son was 3 when my cousin had her DS and gave him the same first and second name. I found out a family reunion. All the cousins and children were there and my cousin had just had her DS. She came over and said she forgot my DS had the same names. We don't see each other very often as not close. It didn't really bother me but it might if we had a lot of contact. I just think they were nice names x

JSB16 · 12/11/2023 22:39

First and middle name the same feels like an odd choice.
My bil named his dd the same first name as his cousins dd, a fairly common name though and they aren’t overly close. I’m not actually sure he knew when they named her, I am intrigued now so might have to ask. It does really confuse the great grandparents.

JANEY205 · 12/11/2023 22:38

Alopeciabop · 12/11/2023 22:34

PLEASE, for the love of mumsnet can you just ask them?! Whenever I see one of these posts (which seems to be pretty regularly weirdly enough) the op never confronts the crazy name stealers?! It’s like just ASK them! It’s freaking weird and rude. Even if you pretend it isn’t rude and “no one owns a name” blah blah blah it’s definitely weird! Please ask. They then report back. Why would anyone do this?!! I neeeeeed to know their excuse?!!!

I doubt they remember the other child’s middle name and probably feel a cousin is a distant enough relative to not care. These children aren’t cousins, their parents are, which is pretty distant. And if the middle name is James it’s stupid because so many boys are given that middle name. I have 2 Grandads with that name and my husband has 1 Grandad with that name 😂

LavendersBlueeee · 12/11/2023 22:38

Have you spoken to them since the name announcement? What did you say?

Mari9999 · 12/11/2023 22:37

So once again , other than annoyance on the part of parents who readily admit that no one owns a name, what damage is done to the child by sharing a name with an extended family member?

Does anyone have an answer to that question? In terms of identification for legal or business purposes, all of these people have different Dates of Birth so there is no confusion in those terms.

JANEY205 · 12/11/2023 22:36

If the middle name is James you are definitely unreasonable as I know a crazy amount of people including my own family with that name. I also know 3 children called Teddy James and I don’t know many children, so please tell me it’s that name 😂

Alopeciabop · 12/11/2023 22:34

PLEASE, for the love of mumsnet can you just ask them?! Whenever I see one of these posts (which seems to be pretty regularly weirdly enough) the op never confronts the crazy name stealers?! It’s like just ASK them! It’s freaking weird and rude. Even if you pretend it isn’t rude and “no one owns a name” blah blah blah it’s definitely weird! Please ask. They then report back. Why would anyone do this?!! I neeeeeed to know their excuse?!!!

Theokaycokey · 12/11/2023 22:31

I would be highly surprised if they could remember your son's middle name! I struggle to remember all my cousin's kids' first names. And how do you know that it's of no significance to them on either side of the family. It is annoying but I doubt that copying the middle name was deliberate.

Saffrom · 12/11/2023 22:30

Wow what weirdos. They must be very jealous of you guys to have done that.

Not much you can do except give their kid a nickname / keep your distance.

Itsbritneybitch22 · 12/11/2023 22:28

Usually I say it’s just a name but this is really strange… think I would say did you not realise not all children have to have the same name.

Blinkityblonk · 12/11/2023 22:22

I have first cousins who are friendly but not that close and I think the second family forgot that one name was used by the first family, so now we have two baby 'X's, one about a year younger than the other. No big deal. The middle name thing is quite odd though.

GirlOfTudor · 12/11/2023 22:20

That is really odd. Have you asked why they e named the same as your child? What was their response? You have to bring it up with them or it'll forever be the elephant in the room.

Iwasafool · 12/11/2023 22:15

So second cousins have the same name? I honestly can't see that is a big issue. I have first cousins who have the same name and no one has ever had a problem with it and it doesn't seem to have caused any sort of identity crisis. I think it would only be an issue for the children if the adults make it an issue.

Whoopy · 12/11/2023 22:12

When I was expecting my first child, I was convinced I was having a boy and we knew exactly what we were going to call him. It turned out I had a girl (so had to quickly think about girl’s names). Dh wasn’t particularly close to his cousin, but we saw him at a family occasion, where dh told him about this. His cousin asked what we had been going to call a boy, so he told him.

The following year I was pregnant again and found out dh’s cousins wife was as well. Their child was born first. It was a boy and they gave him the name my dh had told him we were going to use. Dh messaged him asking why he had decided to call his son by that name. The response was that they hadn’t thought of that name, but liked it when dh mentioned it. This was followed by “oops have we one upped you” with laughing emojis!

I didn’t use the name when my ds was born, as it would have looked like we had copied them, instead of the other way round…..but I haven’t spoken to the copying bastards them since. And no I don’t think I over reacted!

ladymuckofthemanor · 12/11/2023 22:12

Reply to the text 'haha, funny joke, there's no way you've named him the same as his cousin / our son. What have you really named him??'

JustMarriedBecca · 12/11/2023 22:08

In my experience, using a name usually leads to bigger issues. BIL used our personally written vows and name choice. The kids have been "pitched" and compared their whole lives by grandparents. Ours get bought things their cousins will like even though they are COMPLETELY different humans with different interests. At least your son is four years older.

I find as your kids get older you spend less time with cousins. And your son will have nicknames etc from school which will be wholly different from family names.

fuzzystar · 12/11/2023 22:06

Vet73 · 12/11/2023 21:56

I’d refer to them as ‘name the 2nd’ to make it clear

I have a friend that sadly lost their baby at 3 months old. Their sibling named their child the exact same name with the same two middle names as they “loved the name”. Unsurprisingly that relationship broke down in an instant

Oh my goodness. That's awful

IlonaRN · 12/11/2023 22:01

Tell them that their baby's nickname will have to be "Copycat" - or maybe "Copy" for short! 😆

KatBurglar · 12/11/2023 22:01

Jill23 · 12/11/2023 20:23

So one set of grandparents has two grandsons with exactly the same name? That is bizarre! Are they planning to use a shortening at least? Otherwise, the GPs will have to use “little Mike” or whatever into eternity…..

No, one set of great-grandparents have two great grandsons with the same name but different surnames.

This baby is a second cousin once removed from OP's son. My children barely know my cousin's children. There are three Joes in the extended family and noone is confused. Nobody remembers middle names.

It's a bit weird of them, but I wouldn't stress about it.

CanIGoHomeNowPlease · 12/11/2023 21:58

Just refer to the new baby by its surname - say that’s the only way to differentiate between the two children

Vet73 · 12/11/2023 21:56

I’d refer to them as ‘name the 2nd’ to make it clear

I have a friend that sadly lost their baby at 3 months old. Their sibling named their child the exact same name with the same two middle names as they “loved the name”. Unsurprisingly that relationship broke down in an instant

Livingoncaffeine · 12/11/2023 21:46

I think first name is fine, I almost called DS2 a name that my DP’s cousin has since called her little boy. Not because I was stealing it from her or she stole it from me, I just love it and when we were talking about names she once said she loved it, not realising it was high on my list (and she wasn’t pregnant at the time). First and middle name is weird though.

Swipe left for the next trending thread