Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed they used the exact name

233 replies

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 19:53

Just found out that DH's cousin has had a baby (they are quite a close knit family). Had a text to say they had named the baby the exact same first and middle name as our son. DS is 4 and they were both at the christening and have seen him since so they were fully aware of the name. It's not a massively common name so it's not something you expect lots of people to have. I just feel really angry, like they've taken away part of his identity which I know is probably ridiculous. But why copy his first and middle name? His middle name we chose to honour his grandad and they have no family connection to it so I just can't understand it! Just feel like I need to vent somewhere

OP posts:
momonpurpose · 13/11/2023 18:23

Donald Trump's daughter gave her hild my child's name . First and middle not a common first name at all and the middle name my mother's nickname for me as a child. My mother was furious and wanted to sue 😆

housethatbuiltme · 13/11/2023 18:13

ironorchids · 13/11/2023 17:11

@MargotBamborough they do need to answer the question of why they have their child those names.

What an odd thing to say that they don't.

If they want to remain close with OP then they need to pain why they've given their child the same first and middle name as OP's DC.

No one owes you an explanation of their parenting choice... my god how entitled are you.

Believe it or not you (or OP) are not the center of anyone elses universes. No one 'steals' names because you are just 'too cool'. They just liked the same name (no explanation needed just obvious common sense). Maybe for longer than you even did but struggled to get pregnant, maybe its after a dead loved one, maybe it was the name she has loved since calling her dolly that at 2 year old, maybe its the only name both liked... who the fuck cares, they deemed it the best option for THEIR child and that all that matters.

Imagine thinking someone should give up their favorite baby name because as a distant cousin you feel precious over being unique.

DontJumpInTheFountain · 13/11/2023 18:07

We had a traditional but not particularly common name we had always wanted to use but a good friend used it first, so when DS was born a year or so later we took it off our list. But we couldn't settle on a name - poor DS had us trying out a different name every day for a week. Then we mentioned the original name to someone, they said 'but it suits him', and it just felt right. When we explained to my friend they told us not to be stupid and to just use it. So that's his name. It was only years later that they let slip that they have the same second name as well. They must have told us both names when their child was born but we genuinely hadn't remembered otherwise we wouldn't have chosen that too. We see them fairly regularly and it doesn't seem to be an issue for anyone (unless they're very good at hiding a grudge).

TenderDandelions · 13/11/2023 17:58

Some people have very little imagination! A friend of mine gave her daughter the same name as her sister, which I found very strange!

At least your child is obviously older OP - it'll be obvious that they've copied you!

tameimpalas · 13/11/2023 17:51

Agree - very strange

Iwasafool · 13/11/2023 17:36

I think that expecting someone to explain why they chose a name is weirder than choosing the same name as someone else. No one has ever asked me for an explanation of my name choices and I've never asked anyone to explain their choices. They really don't owe anyone an explanation.

ironorchids · 13/11/2023 17:33

They so do

MargotBamborough · 13/11/2023 17:13

ironorchids · 13/11/2023 17:11

@MargotBamborough they do need to answer the question of why they have their child those names.

What an odd thing to say that they don't.

If they want to remain close with OP then they need to pain why they've given their child the same first and middle name as OP's DC.

No, they really don't.

They can name their own child whatever the hell they like and they are not answerable to anyone, least of all a cousin and his wife, i.e. not even a particularly close relative.

ironorchids · 13/11/2023 17:11

@MargotBamborough they do need to answer the question of why they have their child those names.

What an odd thing to say that they don't.

If they want to remain close with OP then they need to pain why they've given their child the same first and middle name as OP's DC.

PumpkinSly · 13/11/2023 17:08

My cousin has just named their daughter with the same name as my DD. I couldn't give a shit. It's a great name, and the kids won't really know each other very much so it doesn't make any difference to me. If the kids were going to be in each others lives a lot then I might feel differently. If they are only going to see each other a couple of times a year I wouldn't let it wind me up. When you're with them you should start referring to your child as The Original 'insert name here'

ZupZapZop · 13/11/2023 16:52

I dunno, yous cant be that close if you have only just found out about the baby and theres a 4 year age gap so unlikely theyll be playing together for confusion to happen ect

My DS and his cousin have the same first name. Theres around a 7 year age gap.

Cousin is named after his uncle ( my DC father ) and my son is named after his dad so has same name as cousin. She might of been angry about it at the time, but my DS is almost 7 now and has met his cousin twice so it's a non issue

SerafinasGoose · 13/11/2023 16:35

TrishIsMySpiritAnimal · 12/11/2023 20:41

YABU .

His identity is not in his name

Unless it’s two names you made up yourself, they arent ‘yours’ to keep

Of course a person's name is their identity. What else is it?

@holeymoleymacaroli - my DH's sister did precisely the same thing to her cousin. Yes, to coin the descriptive used many times throughout this thread (and with good reason), it is 'fucking weird'.

Pointless saying anything of course, they're not going to change their kid's name, and if you speak unfortunately you'll be the one who comes across as strange. But it's a distinctly odd thing to do, which is why you're best off letting others come to their own conclusions.

In DH's sister's case, the one whose behaviour came off as weird was said sister. As indeed it would. Because just why would you?

HalebiHabibti · 13/11/2023 16:34

I'd be replying with "David Taylor Evans says hello to David Taylor Smith!" with a picture of your happy child waving :D makes the point!

DarkDarkNight · 13/11/2023 16:32

And I would be really petty and put your child’s first and middle name in the congratulations card 😅

DarkDarkNight · 13/11/2023 16:31

How weird and stalkerish of them. They’ve just announced to the whole family that they have no original thoughts or imagination of their own and I’m sure everyone finds it just as weird as you.

All these people saying ‘you don’t own a name’ really? First and middle name? I could just about see if they really loved your child’s name sneaking it in as a middle name but this is just out and out copying.

MargotBamborough · 13/11/2023 16:31

ironorchids · 13/11/2023 16:11

Say
"Congratulations. What made you choose these names?"
and wait.

They need to answer this.

No they don't.

What an odd thing to say.

What they choose to name their child is literally none of anybody else's business.

MrsB74 · 13/11/2023 16:26

MrsRachelDanvers · 12/11/2023 21:16

Things like this causes rifts in families? People would be fuming? Really? Get a grip people. This is a lot of fetishising about names. It used to be very common to have people with the same name in families-in my own, there are lots of Elizabeths and James. No one has a problem with their identity or gets confused! I can understand a bit of bemusement and maybe annoyance over identical first and middle names but only fleeting. You named your son because you liked it-it really doesn’t matter that people you rarely see names their kid the same does it?

I agree - weird, but just try to put it behind you. They won’t change it. We actively avoided any names the same as family/friends, but not everyone does (obviously). Our neighbour used the same quite unusual name as our granddaughter within weeks - all they said was “I knew we’d heard it somewhere” - we weren’t bothered at all, but within family I might have been more surprised.

I also think like PP that they maybe forgot your child’s middle name? I couldn’t tell you my family’s middle names apart from very close family - certainly not cousin’s children. They don’t generally stick in people’s memories.

I always had someone with my first name at school, college, friendship group etc. - never bothered me. There was another girl at school with the same full name as me, first middle and surname!

MaturingCheeseball · 13/11/2023 16:24

@Emotionalsupportviper - perhaps we have the same name! There heaps at school, in my road and as for when I started work… mayhem 😬

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 13/11/2023 16:18

holeymoleymacaroli · 12/11/2023 21:02

@Mari9999 I will definitely be keeping my distance now because I feel strongly that I don't want my child to have confusion over the situation.

Honestly, your child won’t be confused unless you make it a big deal.

it’s less common now, but cousins with the same name, and they’re not even as close as that, was very very common until recently.

If the middle name is common in the older generation then it’s highly likely to be a family name for them too.

ironorchids · 13/11/2023 16:11

Say
"Congratulations. What made you choose these names?"
and wait.

They need to answer this.

MargotBamborough · 13/11/2023 16:09

This baby is, what, a second cousin to your child? Really, who cares?

I have a second cousin with the same first and last name as me and it is a non issue.

Even if they do see each other more often than most people see their second cousins, can't it just be a funny thing between them?

GotMooMilk · 13/11/2023 15:42

My friend had a similar situation- her mums friend likes her name so much they called her child her whole name and surname.
So friend is Claire Taylor and child is Claire Taylor Jones.

Not real names but friend was a bit weirded out!

Iwasafool · 13/11/2023 15:37

Totaly · 12/11/2023 23:33

im going to buck the trend and take it was a compliment

Not a compliment when your child is now know as ‘big’ Jack and ‘little’ Jack - takes away a lot from the name.

Could be worse, I used to suppress a laugh at a 2nd cousin who was named after his father. Father was Big Willy, son was Wee Willy. I would imagine that would be a hard name to cope with but I did grow up and stopped wanting to laugh.

housethatbuiltme · 13/11/2023 15:34

JoanOfAllTrades · 13/11/2023 15:25

I bought a product and had a lady call from the after sales team.

Anyway, before hanging up, lady said "I just want to ask you what joanofalltrades means, as it's so pretty".

After correcting her pronunciation of my name for the seemed like 100th time, I explained the origin and meaning of my name.

She said she'd never heard the name before and her daughter was pregnant, so if it's a girl, can she tell her daughter to use my name 😳.

Well, yeah, people don't own a name but lady, you can't even pronounce it properly!

I ended up saying that as long as she was happy having her DGD correcting people on how to pronounce her name, constantly and forever, then yeah, she should have at it!

Because joanofalltrades may well look easy to pronounce and spell, but trust me, it's a curse!

I had similar too.

I have a very unusual name, its simple and phonic but CONSTANTLY misspelled/mispronounced. A friend of a friend who was pregnant made a huge deal of telling me she chose my name for her kid... I think she expected me to be honored. It was weird especially given she didn't say it right.

I full accept I don't own my name and anyone can use it, if I met another with my name I would be quite excited as I never have in real life before however the utterly creepy pomp and circumstance of a stranger announcing at a party in front of loads of people that she was 'honoring' me by naming their kid specifically 'after' me was so surreal and unsettling.

If she had had a kid and names it my name without saying anything I wouldn't have given too hoots but she went full bunny boiler... in the end she didn't use my name anyway and went with Scarlet Olivia (possibly as far from my name as possible).

People are odd in their behaviors.

muckymayhem · 13/11/2023 15:32

I think it's really weird and ridiculous of them. DHs cousin gave their daughter the same name as his firstborn (SDD) and I always thought that was odd enough. She was known as something akin to "little Lizzie" to differentiate between which was which. DHs brother gave his dog the same name as our son. I thought about retaliating when we got a dog, but both his sons have ugly names, so I didn't. 😬😂