Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to sit Shiva for Dad? Sorry this is a bit Jewish!

86 replies

DistrictAndCircle · 12/11/2023 19:46

My Dad may die soon. He is a secular Jew. I am an even more secular Jew.

When he dies there will be an expectation that we sit Shiva for him. For those who don’t know - this means prayers every night for a week, at his house, with my sister, his siblings and his wife (who isn’t my mum). Friends and family attend, there’s a bit of food, the Rabbi comes etc. It’s meant to send him on his way and be a comfort to the mourners.

This is a big deal even for the most secular Jews.

But I don’t want to do it! It is genuinely stressing me out, and I fear it will make my grief quite a bit worse. It wouldn’t be a comfort to me in the least. It would be the exact opposite.

Dad lives 3hrs drive away. I don’t want to stay at his wife’s house, or in a hotel, for a week. I don’t want to say prayers in a language I don’t know, to a God I don’t believe in, in a room full of strangers and long-lost relatives who I’ve no real wish to re-find. I don’t even want to do it for a day let alone a week.

I want to be in my own house, with my own family, grieving in my own way, whatever that turns out to be. To be honest forcing me to be away from my spouse and kids doing that seems cruel to me. Yet I know it would be seen as unbelievably disrespectful to not do it, and possibly people will think I’m trying to make a point about religion or make it ‘all about me’ etc when actually I just want to be left alone to choose.

I don’t want to disrespect my dad. We’re not particularly close but he’s a decent guy. But… he’ll be dead! So does it matter?! I am much less close to his wife but don’t want to upset her. I suspect this would though. Not for any logical reason. Nobody actually believes in it. It would upset her just because it’s not the done thing and would be a talking point.

Perhaps this is more pertinent to the Jewish contingent but I’d value anyone’s views on whether I’d be being unreasonable to opt out, or whether I should suck it up for the sake of not upsetting people.

OP posts:
NewtonPulsifer · 12/11/2023 23:11

i am an atheist from a long line of atheists. We have had no cultural or religious expectations on us so relating it to other cultural expectations is hard.

However, when my Dad died 30 years ago, he was only 49, and he had a lot of colleagues and friends coming round to check in on us, talk about him and memories etc. That brought me a lot of comfort at the time, when I think if I had been asked ahead of time if I wanted people around, I would’ve said no.

I think a good range of perspectives has been given. I’d be tempted to decide when the time comes, but equally to have a good reason why you can’t do it that will be acceptable to others judgements, which can be hard at times of grief. Covid, or stomach flu would be reason enough to stay home and grieve quietly.

Jewnicorn · 12/11/2023 23:05

I’m coming at this from an Orthodox perspective but when my dad’s death was approaching I dreaded sitting Shiva. For so many reasons (leaving my family and young children at home, having difficult relationships with many family members, the idea of talking about my dad who I loved more than anyone with random folk I barely knew - it all just seemed awful). I very nearly didn’t go, I was ready to make up excuses about missing my flight or whatever.
With that said I’m glad I did go. It wasn’t anything like I’d built it up to be in my head. As his daughter I was in control over who I spoke to and what I did and ultimately it was a really comforting experience for me.

No judgement here if you decide you can’t manage it, grief is a big, scary, personal thing and I hope it all goes as well as it possibly can for you all 💜

Moooooooooooooooooo · 12/11/2023 22:54

Although I agree you’ll be doing this for your dad, whether it’s 1/2/3 or however many nights. You’ll be doing it for yourself too.

Trust me. Once everything’s settled down you’ll be going through it all in your head, what you did/didn’t do. What you said/didn’t say.

Don’t leave yourself with any regrets, you may not think you’ll have them but if you don’t try for your dad it will play on your mind.

ToDamp0rNotToDamp · 12/11/2023 22:26

OP - I’m so sorry for your pending loss. The death of one of my own (also secular) dad is not long away. The wait is unbearable. What we haven’t been able to discuss as a family yet is his wishes for when he passes, and this very issue looms on my own mind.

I could thousands of words on this - the monologue of the internal debate I have in my mind daily. Im not religious, how hypocritical of me would it be? How could I face a Rabbi, would
I be able to say the prayers? But deep down I know what I’ll do, and that’s whatever my dad wants me to. He’ll physically have passed but a wistful part of me hopes really he’ll never truly
leave, and so I’ll respect his wishes.

That comes from having a truly wonderful relationship with my parents though, they are my world. You mention you are not particularly close with your dad, so I appreciate you might not feel the same.

All things considered, do one night. I doubt you will regret just one night. And if you do regret it, that’s ok because it is literally just one night and the next day will come and you will grieve in your own way back with your family. What would not be ok is not doing at least the one night and then regretting that in the future.

caringcarer · 12/11/2023 22:20

If you don't want to do it then don't....but it's probably the last thing your Dad has asked of you and it will probably cause a breakdown of your family as an aftermath. Do you want to keep in touch with your stepmum and siblings? If you're not bothered then don't do it. If you want future contact and to be included in family rituals then you know if you don't go you'll get upset if you're excluded. I'm not Jewish but when my Mum died my siblings and I all went to her house and stayed together for about a week whilst we arranged her funeral and grieved together. I'd have been upset if one of my siblings refused to be with the rest of us.

Rocknrollstar · 12/11/2023 22:09

I think your best option would be to go and sit shiva for a night or two. You could then say you are going home to sit shiva. As has been said, the service is short and you might be surprised at who you meet and talk to. We only sat one night for my father. However, my mother died six months and we made a deliberate choice not to sit shiva at all. It was what she wanted. People came back to our house and stayed late into the evening and it felt the right thing to do. Finally, you say dad wants ‘the full week’ but at the most that will only be five nights and maybe even less depending on Jewish holidays. Don’t forget that if you upset your family over the shiva you are going to have to deal with them when it comes to the Stone Setting.

KeepingTrying · 12/11/2023 22:05

Hi OP,

I would feel really weird about this too. I find emotions complicated and having to go through an intense emotional experience with no privacy would be impossible for me I think.

I find death very complicated too. I've only been to one funeral and the old lady who had died was a lovely person with the best sense of humour. All I could think about all the way through the funeral was how I could hear the sound system in the church picking up a local radio station electric guitar performance and thinking how much the lady would have giggled to hear it. I really had to try hard not to laugh all the way through, because I knew she would have laughed.

Going to the funeral didn't change for me my perception of her having died. For me she is still alive and still a friend, and I still laugh when I see something that she would have liked.

I'm not sure how rituals help, but maybe I have never been taught.

Can you do it on zoom?

therealcookiemonster · 12/11/2023 21:59

Hi OP, really sorry you are going through this... I think you will know what the right course of action is when the time comes...
personally I would approach it in the sense that if its my parent's last wish, I would want to do that for them and also for myself so that looking back, I won't have any regrets....

but only you know what is right for you

SeethroughDress · 12/11/2023 21:59

I’m Catholic and while Irish Catholic funerals aren’t really any equivalent to sitting shiva in terms of length, the first part of the funeral/wake will usually take place the night after the person dies, with the removal the day after and the funeral the day after that, hence a lot of very intense grieving while also meeting people and catering for them. God, the sandwich making. I’m contentedly atheist, and don’t believe my relatives exist in some afterlife where they can be comforted by me engaging in a certain ritual, but I have actually found the traditional funeral cathartic, thinking about it in purely selfish terms.

Having said that, I don’t think anyone should do real violence to themselves in terms of observing a ritual that is intolerable to them. Be kind to yourself whatever you decide, OP.

frazzledasarock · 12/11/2023 21:56

I’m not Jewish. I’m Muslim. We also have prayers when people pass away, usually the house has mourners paying their respect for a week of so.

Will you regret not sitting shiva?

Will it upset you to look back on this period and not have participated?

Are you able to speak to your SM and explain your reasoning to her and tell her bring away from your own family will make the grieving process so much harder for you?

can you do a few days if not the full week, end of the week so you observe shiva for the last few days to the end of the week.

I’m so sorry you’re going through this, losing a parent is so hard.

lisalisa · 12/11/2023 21:52

Hi @DistrictAndCircle i am orthodox so have tried to answer your post . First of all im
so sorry thst you’re in this position ; anticipating losing a parent is always so painful no matter how old we are and how unwell they were .
I understand that the rituals of shiva can feel intrusive and alien at a very sensitive time . However they are designed for our benefit , not for the benefit of those around us . The rituals around mourning go further than 7 days and are designed to help us cope with the loss and to mourn in a healthy way which will enable us to emerge the other side healed and hopefully able to move on. The first seven days are the start of it ( shiva is from the word seven ).
This intense period when the mourners effectively remove themsekves from normal life ( not working , cooking , shopping ) but allow themselves to pray ( however they want ) , talk about the person who’s passed away with visitors and rest is very important to the grieving and healing process.
Many people find the days after shiva ends the hardest as the formalities and structure of the seven days ends as does the visits by people and the prayers and they feel the loss more acutely ; the shiva tends , if not to cushion the loss, then to keep its intensity at bay .
I would say you might find the experience more cathartic than you think although I get the logistics are difficult.

Motheranddaughtertotwo · 12/11/2023 21:48

I’m not Jewish but I am from a culture who observe similar traditions after a death. I think you should see how you feel when that awful time comes. I’m very loosely religious when my dad died that those traditions and rituals were quite comforting; I loved being around people who loved him too and I felt proud to be carrying out his last wishes. I also felt supported and safe to scream, cry or whatever. Don’t put pressure on yourself but if you go to at least one, you may see you could find it helpful.
Whatever you do, I hope it brings you some comfort and that your dads passing will Br as peaceful as it can.

Vinrouge4 · 12/11/2023 21:44

For what it’s worth I found the week I sat with my 3 siblings around my mum’s bed when she was dying really comforting. We bonded in a way that we hadn’t before. Talked about our childhoods, our parents, laughed and cried. Don’t rule it out completely. It might give you some closure

sunnydayhereandnow · 12/11/2023 21:32

I'm Jewish and observant. It's definitely ok for shiva to be in multiple locations - it's not weird not to stay for the whole week if you're not super close. I once hosted an afternoon of shiva for a friend with a similar family situation whose father's house was very far from where she was currently living and she wanted to have the opportunity to have her own shiva with people meaningful to her. And even if you are sitting shiva but you are not religious, plenty of people sit shiva but without prayers and certainly no need for rabbis etc. The tradition of shiva is simply that you sit at home and people come to visit and comfort you, which usually means that you specify when visitors are welcome, and often people choose to get out some photos and share reminiscences with the visitors. And you're not supposed to need to "host" people - the opposite! The guests typically bring some biscuits, fruit or whatever.

Fine to sit out the prayers, and in most communities you won't even be really expected to participate if you're a woman ;)

All that is to say: you're not religious so you don't need to be bound by tradition! I think it would respect your father's wishes if you're able to do a night or two at his home. If it's any comfort, I found when I sat shiva that actually some of the potentially annoying people brought reminiscences that I was happy to hear. I was also glad to have shiva at my own house for a day (mine was in 2 locations) so I could invite "my people", because I really find shiva a fantastic tradition, even if only that it breaks the ice after a bereavement so that the next time you see people you can talk about something normal rather than being awkward. But that's just me, and you can decide what works for you.

Ginmonkeyagain · 12/11/2023 21:28

@NoraLuka A Wake. Mr Monkey is an atheist but with an Irish Catholic background. He sat a wake for his dad the night he died. He wasn't sure he was going to do it as he and his dad did not have the best of relationships and he is not a believer However he found it a helpful thing to do in the end.

legrandcolbert · 12/11/2023 21:22

I am Jewish, as was my dad (and whole family for that matter). He wasn't particularly religious although he he is buried in a Jewish cemetery. We just sat shiva for one night for him, and IIRC, just two nights for my mum.

Do what suits you best, and what you feel is most appropriate. It is not for anyone else to judge you or even have an opinion.

I have rediscovered Judaism, and proudly observe any of the high holidays. However, have made it clear that when I die, I don't want anyone to sit shiva for me, or to be buried in a Jewish cemetery, I want to be cremated and scattered.

I wish you a long life.

HobnobsChoice · 12/11/2023 21:01

My mother in law died recently. She wasn't observant at all and neither is her son or daughter. We couldn't have the shiva at her house as it wasn't suitable to be have people there and we didn't want it in the space offered at a different shul to the one she was a nominal member of. In the end we did one night at her sister's, more for the benefit of those who couldn't come to the funeral. My husband found just one night very tiring as he had to then drive back home.

Everyone then got Covid as well which was fun when we started clearing the house.

My father in law dealt with the issue of sitting shiva by dying two days before Pesach meaning we just had to do one afternoon.

andmeandmeandme · 12/11/2023 21:00

I don't think anyone can really advise what's best here, you need to do what's right for you, although if you can, I would at least try the first night after the funeral. Do you think it’s possible in the future you might regret having not gone? And what kind of impact might that have on your relationship with your family?

Like you, I'm atheist and secular and the Shiva makes me feel so far out my comfort zone that I just don't want to be present at it. The nosey 'long lost' relatives drive me round the bend at them (especially the not-so-secular ones who always have something to say about having a non-Jewish DH and kids). But having said that, Jewish funerals are pretty bleak and spartan affairs - and I don't agree with PP that it's something we do well - so the Shiva and rituals might bring a certain comfort that's missing from the funeral. You might not think it will now, but it may actually help with the rawness and grief when the time comes.

DistrictAndCircle · 12/11/2023 20:53

Thanks for everyone’s advice and kind words. I have read them all, and will take on board what people have said. Plenty to think about.

Thank you all x

OP posts:
NoraLuka · 12/11/2023 20:52

Think about what you’ll be happy with. Years from now, do you think you’d regret not doing it, even if you didn’t want to at the time? Or would you be at peace with not doing it?

FWIW I’m an atheist with a Catholic family, not sure what the English word is but they expected me to sit with my Mum’s body the night after she died and pray etc. I said no, mainly because it was the absolute last thing I wanted to do at that point. I have never regretted it because I don’t believe in any of it anyway.

Aethelberht · 12/11/2023 20:49

I'm sorry you are losing your Dad, but please never be embarrassed about being Jewish, observant or not. Pps have some good suggestions for you and I hope you find something that works for you.

bellac11 · 12/11/2023 20:48

Its really hard for people who dont have cultural or religious (or semi religious) expectations of certain events to give advice

Becuase most of us would say 'grieve as you need to' but is there going to be fall out from that decision which would be worse than the grief and distress of Shiva for you?

The most similar thing I can think of is all the threads on here (not involving death or religion) where people suggest you must stay over at family/hold xmas/see people on their birthdays etc in order to save something worse happening if that doesnt happen

On the other hand lots of people say dont do any of those things if you dont want to

MeinKraft · 12/11/2023 20:45

Not Jewish sorry, but where I live visitors will start arriving at the house a couple of hours after someone has died and you're expected to make them tea and cater for them (although most people do bring stuff) it does last a good few days...I hate hate hate it but it carries you through OP, it serves the purpose it needs to serve. It's about support and feeling you've done everything the right way for your dad. The first week is so shit that sometimes the distraction of the random faces and the laughs and stories of the old days and just general weirdness helps you get through it.

GladWhere · 12/11/2023 20:41

TopicalNameChange · 12/11/2023 20:24

I'm an atheist secular Jew.

Sitting shiva for my dad really helped me, although I don't think I recognised it at the time. I did it because that's what you do, because it was expected of me, blah blah... Those sorts of reasons. But being connected to such a significant rite of passage was really important in helping me process the grief and move on from being the daughter of a living father to someone who had experienced a loss. I'm not explaining myself well, but in those days I didn't know where to put my feelings and my grief. Shiva gave me a ritual to follow: this is what we do when we grieve. This is how we gather. This is how we honour. This is how we support.

When my (not Jewish) husband lost his dad I realised even further how important it is to have that structure at times when you feel lost and alone.

That's good that you found comfort in sitting shiva even though you are an atheist. It's hard to know what's the best thing to do without having gone through it. Grief is such a complicated feeling. When my much loved Dad died we arranged a direct-to-crem funeral which we didn't attend. We also had no service or memorial at all. The crematorium dealt with the ashes. For our family it was the right thing to do. None of us are religious or spiritual. We believe when you die you are no more. My siblings, children and my Mum are all glad that we did it like we did. We have no regrets at all. We can reminisce and chat about our Dad easily. Sometimes I wonder if it's easier to remember my Dad when he was alive because we sort of ignored the bit where he died.

My siblings, my Mum and I all want the same type of non-funeral. It's the cheapest option too.

marvelousmarmite · 12/11/2023 20:41

Go for a couple of days, mention a lot on the second day about not feeling well. Very shivery all of a sudden etc. Leave at the end of the second day. Bad bout of Covid and sit out the rest - devastated you can't be there etc. Or cry off the whole thing with 'Covid'. It's not something where people will pressure you to just come anyway.