Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not to sit Shiva for Dad? Sorry this is a bit Jewish!

86 replies

DistrictAndCircle · 12/11/2023 19:46

My Dad may die soon. He is a secular Jew. I am an even more secular Jew.

When he dies there will be an expectation that we sit Shiva for him. For those who don’t know - this means prayers every night for a week, at his house, with my sister, his siblings and his wife (who isn’t my mum). Friends and family attend, there’s a bit of food, the Rabbi comes etc. It’s meant to send him on his way and be a comfort to the mourners.

This is a big deal even for the most secular Jews.

But I don’t want to do it! It is genuinely stressing me out, and I fear it will make my grief quite a bit worse. It wouldn’t be a comfort to me in the least. It would be the exact opposite.

Dad lives 3hrs drive away. I don’t want to stay at his wife’s house, or in a hotel, for a week. I don’t want to say prayers in a language I don’t know, to a God I don’t believe in, in a room full of strangers and long-lost relatives who I’ve no real wish to re-find. I don’t even want to do it for a day let alone a week.

I want to be in my own house, with my own family, grieving in my own way, whatever that turns out to be. To be honest forcing me to be away from my spouse and kids doing that seems cruel to me. Yet I know it would be seen as unbelievably disrespectful to not do it, and possibly people will think I’m trying to make a point about religion or make it ‘all about me’ etc when actually I just want to be left alone to choose.

I don’t want to disrespect my dad. We’re not particularly close but he’s a decent guy. But… he’ll be dead! So does it matter?! I am much less close to his wife but don’t want to upset her. I suspect this would though. Not for any logical reason. Nobody actually believes in it. It would upset her just because it’s not the done thing and would be a talking point.

Perhaps this is more pertinent to the Jewish contingent but I’d value anyone’s views on whether I’d be being unreasonable to opt out, or whether I should suck it up for the sake of not upsetting people.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NalafromtheLionKing · 13/11/2023 22:27

marvelousmarmite · 12/11/2023 20:41

Go for a couple of days, mention a lot on the second day about not feeling well. Very shivery all of a sudden etc. Leave at the end of the second day. Bad bout of Covid and sit out the rest - devastated you can't be there etc. Or cry off the whole thing with 'Covid'. It's not something where people will pressure you to just come anyway.

Exactly what I was thinking (but Covid the whole time).

Mylobsterteapot · 13/11/2023 20:52

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 13/11/2023 04:19

Do something nice before heading home? OP's Dad will have just died, she'll be on the throws of grief! JFC. Hmm

I meant a gentle thing like a walk somewhere scenic, rather than a trip to Alton Towers. It would also give the children something to do and a chance to let off steam after a long journey, an afternoons at quietly, and before another long spell in the car.

OP asked what I would do, and this is what I would do.

sashh · 13/11/2023 09:36

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 13/11/2023 04:24

That's awful! I can’t imagine not attending my own grandparents funeral and likewise if my DC have kids I'd be devastated at the thought of them not attending my service when I die. Wow 💔 Grandparents aren't a distant relative and an hour's drive shouldn't require a hotel

Re read what she put, she said, "hours" as in a multiple of an hour not one hour.

Herecomesdehotstepper · 13/11/2023 09:11

OK, it's a week out of your life (as someone once said to me) but shiva is there for a reason and I think if you don't sit, you will regret it later.

Pennina · 13/11/2023 07:08

Namechangeagain2023 · 12/11/2023 20:06

I would do one night. Secular as i am I simply don’t think I could do nothing, equally a week is too much and too intense. I compromised when i was the mourner on 3 nights but would have preferred 2. Much as i really really didn’t want to do it, i did get a lot of comfort from it and totally dind’t expect to.

would your husband and kids not be with you?

The service is very short, you can even go out the room when they do it and if you’re really uncomfortable don’t do the chairs and don’t hang around for the tea and cake.

Honestly, it’s your dad, if his wish is for a shiva I think that you should do the one night and then go home and have your time to yourself

I was going to suggest something like this. Perhaps 2 nights though? Day of levoyah and the next one. I've known observant families where a close mourner is a) not so observant and b) lives distant, do this. Depending on when he dies this might work anyway if Shabbat is a couple of days after levoyah. Either way, wishing you strength in the coming days (did you know there's a Jewish section on Mumsnet?)

JenniferJupiterVenusandMars · 13/11/2023 06:56

How judgemental @PabloandGustheGreySquirrels 😵‍💫.
OP I wouldn’t lie about your feelings, that won’t help at all.
I would have a word with your stepmother about how you feel and do whatever you feel best.
I lost both my parents during Covid, I didn’t go to my father’s funeral, I sat with my mother who was too poorly to attend it.
My mother’s funeral was awful, restricted numbers, no hymns and it gave me no comfort at all. In fact I haven’t grieved for either of them for various reasons.
I’m sorry that you’re going through such a difficult time that’s being compounded by others’ expectations.

Noicant · 13/11/2023 04:24

Not Jewish but an atheist from a minority religion who’s passing away tradition sounds similar. I’d go for a few days if it were me but it would be purely to be around for my siblings. I imagine theres a lot of non praying stuff to be done as well and I would probably be pitching in with that part (teas, food, washing up etc). I think though while you may resent having to do it there may come a point in your life where you may really regret not doing it at all.

I think funerals are for the living not the dead so I get exactly where you are coming from but theres also the family aspect. When my grandmother died I saw some cousins I hadn’t see for a while and I was able to catch up with them, we told jokes which were in poor taste and then drank a bit too much. It was actually ok and I had been dreading it.

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 13/11/2023 04:24

CaramelMac · 12/11/2023 20:14

If you don’t want to do it then don’t do it, I didn’t go to either of my grandparents funerals, they were hours drive away and I had young children and couldn’t really afford a hotel stay. No one got angry with me and if they disapproved they didn’t tell me. It didn’t mean I wasn’t sad or loved them any less. Sometimes you just have to do what’s best for you.

That's awful! I can’t imagine not attending my own grandparents funeral and likewise if my DC have kids I'd be devastated at the thought of them not attending my service when I die. Wow 💔 Grandparents aren't a distant relative and an hour's drive shouldn't require a hotel

PabloandGustheGreySquirrels · 13/11/2023 04:19

Mylobsterteapot · 12/11/2023 19:50

Disclaimer, I am not Jewish, so what I am about to suggest may not fit with the traditional expectations.
Could you, your DH and the children go up on a Saturday morning, be with your dad’s wife and visitor until after dinner, then have stay in a hotel. Have breakfast and then have a morning out doing something nice before heading home.
That feels like a compromise in that you get some time to mourn your dad in the way that you feel most comfortable, but also honouring the traditional process.

Do something nice before heading home? OP's Dad will have just died, she'll be on the throws of grief! JFC. Hmm

SunRainStorm · 13/11/2023 03:57

Say you have Covid.

Send some food to be delivered to those observing with a note about how wretched the timing is.

Your step mother then has something to tell people that explains your absence and no one will want you there if you're sick.

sashh · 13/11/2023 03:26

I'm not Jewish.

Can you do one day? The day / evening of the funeral?

Does shiva have to be in one place? Can you spend one day at your father's and then say you will sit the rest at home? And then mourn in any way you want.

And it will be you in mourning, no one should tell you what you have to do. My grandmother was a wise woman. She used to say not to drink champagne to celebrate but when you feel down because it is a 'pick up'.

The day she died I went to the pub with a friend and we drank champagne and talked about her.

ironedcurtain · 13/11/2023 03:13

@Muddybooties yes I know what a shiva is, but thank you for the explanation anyway :) my question was more directed at whether the wider circle/visitors or the hosts/immediate family felt that way, which would change the options open to OP imo

Muddybooties · 13/11/2023 01:53

ironedcurtain · 13/11/2023 01:21

Yet I know it would be seen as unbelievably disrespectful to not do it, and possibly people will think I’m trying to make a point about religion or make it ‘all about me’ etc when actually I just want to be left alone to choose.

Who do you mean? Wider circle or the people who will be "holding" the shiva (your sister, your aunts/uncles, his wife)? If the former, can the latter cover for you sort of?

When my family member died, it was helpful for my peace of mind to see others doing the full Buddhist traditions for them (without my having to do it). I participated a tiny bit which also gave me some peace of mind, but any more than that would have been scary (I know Buddhism is trendy in the West but the hipsters would run a mile from most real Buddhist traditions!)

@ironedcurtain

This might explain it
https://www.kveller.com/article/what-to-expect-at-a-shiva/

It’s sort of like when an Catholic dies and they announce people are welcome at the house for the three days before the funeral culminating in the wake (though this doesn’t always happen and some only have people in the evenings, just at the wake or no wake at all).

For Jews it is extended to 7 days, the house is open and people visit, though for the wider community or people doing the prayers it may be just during the prayer time. Mourners are not permitted to wash their body (save for hands and face with cold water) and wear a piece of torn clothing near their heart.

If any of that is wrong please forgive me. Attended Shiva when a dear friend had passed. We talked, we laughed, remembered and cried, and there was an abundance of food. The whole community was literally organising feeding everyone. Kids weren’t around for prayers, but then neither was I, the rest of the time it seemed ok though.

L0bstersLass · 13/11/2023 01:45

DistrictAndCircle · 12/11/2023 20:03

Thanks for those first few replies.

Dad wants the full week. It’s as important to him as I’ve seen Christenings be to non-believing ‘Christian’ friends of mine. They want to do it for reasons that even they can’t define. But they know they definitely want to do it.

But he’ll be dead! So it’s not like he can get upset if it doesn’t happen.

Going for one or two days is obviously a potential compromise. I can see this happening. But I fear that I’ll find it very hard to leave without causing upset.

There’s no way I can get out of it by lying and saying that something more important has come up. People would rightly ask what’s more important than my dad dying.

@DistrictAndCircle
I predict that after the first two days you may "test positive for covid" which means that regrettably you can't participate any more.

ragrugger · 13/11/2023 01:23

So difficult OP. My DP made it easy by saying he didn’t want us to sit for him or to have a stone setting, as he didn’t want anyone standing about ‘clogging and vaning’ . I think he remembered the distress that those rituals caused us all after DM died. For the whole family the stone setting was much harder than the funeral as her death had really had time to sink in and hit us by then.

What do you think your family’s reaction to not sitting would be? If you know it won’t cause division, resentment or make your and their grief more difficult- I would do what is right for you. We are all different. For some sitting is helpful and the support comforting. For others it may be the total opposite. Our family is orthodox but we are all atheists. All the family who would have been distressed by our decision have long since passed, so we knew we wouldn’t upset anyone. I hope when the time comes you’ll know what is best for you to do. I’m so sorry about your DF 💐

ironedcurtain · 13/11/2023 01:21

Yet I know it would be seen as unbelievably disrespectful to not do it, and possibly people will think I’m trying to make a point about religion or make it ‘all about me’ etc when actually I just want to be left alone to choose.

Who do you mean? Wider circle or the people who will be "holding" the shiva (your sister, your aunts/uncles, his wife)? If the former, can the latter cover for you sort of?

When my family member died, it was helpful for my peace of mind to see others doing the full Buddhist traditions for them (without my having to do it). I participated a tiny bit which also gave me some peace of mind, but any more than that would have been scary (I know Buddhism is trendy in the West but the hipsters would run a mile from most real Buddhist traditions!)

YoKookoY · 13/11/2023 01:06

It's crazy how some posters think there is a correct way to grieve and that the OP isn't capable of making the decision about what is best for her herself.

Everyone processes grief differently. Funerals and morning rituals might be right for some people but they aren't right for everyone. Like I mentioned in my earlier post we didn't have any funeral service, ceremony or wake for my Dad at all. We literally did nothing. We didn't have his ashes and we've no special place where we remember him.

It was 100% the right thing to do. We miss him obviously but we can talk about him and reminisce comfortably. I like the fact our memories are about his life and not his death. Not having a funeral or wake made our grieving easier. It's now been a few years since he died and we have no regrets at all.
I understand that other people want to have funerals and do more traditional morning and that they get a lot of comfort from it. However it's ignorant and even a little insulting to suggest that people that want to do something different are making a mistake,

Muddybooties · 13/11/2023 00:45

So sorry for your loss 💐

Not Jew but have Jewish friends.

And have lost a parent.

I think you need to do it and that if you don’t it will actually compound your grief and make it worse.

Part of the reason you don’t want to go is because you don’t want to face the full scale of the grief.

Nobody does.

And it would be much easier to sit at home in pjs eating ice cream with all the home comforts.

But it won’t help you process the grief at all.

I think you need to do this for your Dad. But also for yourself as going through the process, supporting him in this (even though he is dead, he is still your Dad), it will help you physically and mentally acknowledge the loss and prevent you from developing complicated grief.

Dilbertian · 13/11/2023 00:12

Sorry, I put dh, but now realise you said spouse.

Dilbertian · 13/11/2023 00:10

Shiva is for the mourners. You do not have to be a host. You do not have to be stoic. If you want to sit in silence or to cry you go ahead and do so. All you have to do is acknowledge those who come to grieve with you. Beyond that, it's up to you how you deal with the Shiva, and how many days you sit. Why cannot your dh and children be with you at your dad's house?

Shiva is a strange experience. Not easy, by any means. I can't say I wanted to meet strangers or distant relatives who knew my name but who I didn't remember. Yet when I understood that they were making no demands on me, they were there for me to lean on, and to honour my loved one, their presence turned out to be surprisingly comforting.

I hope you find the way to mourn that works for you and yours.

Elieza · 12/11/2023 23:55

Disclaimer - I’m not Jewish.

How was shiva done during lockdown? Is there any way you could do some time in person and some time via Teams or whatever was used during covid? That way you and your wife and children could participate from the comfort of your own home.

That may suit others too, and allow them to attend when they otherwise couldn’t manage?

Or perhaps I’m missing the point and it has to be done in person, forgive my ignorance.

Copperoliverbear · 12/11/2023 23:43

I think you should do it for your father.

AbbeyGailsParty · 12/11/2023 23:42

Disclaimer. I’m not Jewish and my knowledge of the faith is patchy.
But I did learn a lot about grief and grieving after DH died.
I learnt grief is individual, no two people grieve in exactly the same way and how you grieve affects how you pass through the process and learn to live without the person alongside living with their loss.
If at all possible could you join the family for one evening and say then you prefer to pray or think about your father alone?
Or would this be more appropriate on the last night, which I assume is the night before the funeral?
My personal opinion is if anyone is offended by that they’d just have to be offended.

hopsalong · 12/11/2023 23:24

Very sorry for your impending loss. I'm not Jewish, but if your dad wants you to do it then you don't reasonably have a choice. If you don't do it, you'll always feel guilty about it. And it's not going to happen again.

FWIW, I have been to Shiva prayers as a sort of guest and they do seem to do something that Christian/ secular funeral rites fail to achieve, in terms of surrounding the mourner with the presence of life. A mere funeral can be a very lonely place. I remember my mum at home scrubbing the kitchen floor in tears (lots of muddy shoes from the graveyard) only a few hours after my dad was buried.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 12/11/2023 23:18

Gently,
sometimes it's these end of life rituals that help us process and make peace with loss as well as make sense of the meaning of life and where we all fit it. It helps us connect to others and , really, we need that.
In this most difficult time I encourage you to sit shiva in a way you can manage and allow others to offer support.

I am so very sorry your dad has passed and I wish you peace and hope you will find comfort remembering happier times. May his memory be a blessing. 💐

Swipe left for the next trending thread